Pro-competitive EU Framework delivered a success story: affordability, higher speeds, more investment 2.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CoE/ARB Workshop On Infrastructure Sharing and LLU Session 4 Infrastructure Sharing Drivers and Blocks By: Isabelle Gross Khartoum – Sudan, 27 – 29 March.
Advertisements

1 FITCE 2008 London September 23th, 2008 Next Generation Access Networks: Perspectives and regulatory options.
Introducing Piers Daniell Managing Director
Unbundling the incumbent: Evidence from UK broadband M. Nardotto (ParisTech), T. Valletti (Imperial and ParisTech) and F. Verboven (KU Leuven)
1. Your ADSL broadband comes from the BT exchange, on your copper telephone wires to your premises Copper 3.5Km 1.5Km 2. The broadband equipment is based.
Telecoms: a trendy investment target again? The way forward Can regulation help? Budapest, December 4th 2013.
National Broadband Network: Some Big Policy Issues.
LLU and Broadband Regulation in France July 2005 Autorité de Régulation des Communications Electroniques et des Postes.
Christian Berg Fibre deployment by utility companies in Denmark EU Digital Agenda Assembly event Workshop 5: Facilitating wide-scale broadband.
Broadband to everybody!? Torstein Olsen Director Norwegian Post and Telecommunications Authority LLU Conference, Bucharest, 5 July 2005.
0 The Economics of Next Generation Access Results of a study for ECTA Dieter Elixmann Dragan Ilic Karl-Heinz Neumann Thomas Plückebaum Brussels, June 25,
Ireland’s Broadband Performance and Policy Actions January 2010.
Telecoms Regulation in the New Millennium David Edmonds Director General OFTEL.
Regulatory issues raised by access upgrade investment: where we are in the UK debate Richard Budd Senior Regulatory, Economist, BT 16 September 2008
ACN Product Overview Australia
1 Access regulation and incentives for investment in alternative broadband infrastructure* Harald Gruber Presentation for REGULATION AND COMPETITION SEMINAR.
ITS Berlin, September 7th, 2004 Polish Telecommunications Market Overview Grzegorz Stanisławski Department of Business Development and Strategic Analyses.
ITS Regional Conference in Rome, September 2008 Martin Lundborg SBR Juconomy Consulting AG Lessons learned from the regulation of LLU for the future regulation.
Retail Competition and Electricity Contracts Richard Green University of Hull and CEPR.
Connectivity as raw material of Digital Economy 'Challenges for telecoms in the new Internet ecosystem' BEREC-EMERG-REGULATEL-EaPeReg Summit Barcelona,
Development of BB markets Access markets (M4 & M5) and remedies applied Linda Paršova 10 TH BALTIC ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATIONS AND POSTAL SERVICES REGULATORS’
Next Generation Access: A Global / Policy Perspective Maury D. Shenk 27 June 2007.
CoE/ARB Workshop On “Infrastructure Sharing and LLU” Session 9: Infrastructure Sharing Potentials in Developing Countries By: Isabelle Gross Khartoum –
UK Broadband Regulatory Framework David Clarkson 16 th November 2011 NextGen 11 Conference, Bristol, November.
Cost sharing models of NGN rollout in rural or remote areas BEREC-EaPeReg-REGULATEL-EMERG Summit Barcelona, 2-3 July 2015.
Broadband Development in the Republic of Moldova July 2015, Spain, Barcelona BEREC-EMERG-REGULATEL-EaPeReg Joint Summit CRISTINA LUCHITA Chief of.
Delivering Better Broadband. Broadband Programme Update Broader Picture – Why is broadband important nationally? BDUK and DEFRA explained The Picture.
Commercial in confidence The economic challenges of reaching broadband ubiquity Speeding up NGN ubiquity: a pillar for digital growth Athens, 13 February.
Qualifying, Quantifying and Meeting the Challenge of Internet Costs Dr. Olfat Abd El Monsef NTRA.
Investment in next generation networks A competitive approach to stimulating Europe’s broadband future - CEPS 22 February 2007.
Broadband Internet Current and future challenges for regulators: a selection Athens – June 1, 2007 Philippe Defraigne Cullen International
Accessing Fixed Networks and Facilities to Speed Up Broadband Rollout Presented by Andrew Gorton CANTO 29th Annual Conference & Trade Exhibition 14 th.
BT Transformation Working with the CWU. Defend Traditional Calls decline - 5 main factors Dial IP - Market declines, driven by Broadband Price - Market.
The European way to think the Digital World Multiplay on Broadband IDATE International Conference Montpellier (France), 23 November 2005.
9 March 2001 Page 1 Broadband in Australia Vicki MacLeod Manager Public Policy and International Regulatory Legal & Regulatory
DG Information Society 1 Liberalisation and regulation in Electronic Communications in the EU 2nd ICT Summit Istanbul, 3-6 September 2002 Hans-Peter Gebhardt.
1 Investment incentives in an environment of dwindling voice revenues* Harald Gruber Presentation for Conference “The Future of Voice” Geneva January.
Broadband for All through Universal Service? 17 June 2010, Lisbon.
Tim Martienssen, Regeneration Manager, Wiltshire Council Broadband.
Infrastructure for eInclusion – Regulation and Policy Initiatives Marianne Røgeberg Ministry of Transport and Communication Norway.
VoIP: New regulatory paradigm or more plain old telephony? Will VoIP change the regulatory landscape?
Local Loop Unbundling PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE 6 th JUNE 2007.
Telecommunications competition - a new entrant’s perspective on the UK experience Rickard Granberg 2 December 2008.
Community Broadband Delivering Next Gen Infrastructure.
1 Telecommunications in Wales Where we are and what we need Mike Tedd Chairman Welsh Advisory Committee on Telecommunications (WACT)
Digital Agenda Scoreboard 2013: Lithuania. Standard fixed broadband* availability Basic broadband for all by 2013 adding wireless, EU coverage is 99.97%
Telecoms Review Institutional aspects European Parliament, 5 March 2008.
Connectivity Broadband market developments in the EU Digital Agenda Scoreboard 2015.
1 TINF 2010 Tuesday 30 November 2010 Present and Future Regulation of Electronic Communications Vesa Terävä European Commission Information Society & Media.
Presentation to Joint Oireachtas Committee [27/01/2016] Jeremy Godfrey, Chairperson Kevin O’Brien, Commissioner Gerry Fahy, Commissioner.
Harmonisation in progress: the telecom regulation example Andrzej Chrzanowski Office of Telecommunications and Post Regulation URTiP, Poland November 2004.
Ahlan Wa Sahlan – welcome to Jordan Opening session note SAMENA – Convergence to Jordan Mickael Ghossein – Chief Executive Officer- Orange Jordan.
Finnish NGA state-aid scheme Antti Kohtala Ministry of Transport and Communications Finland Digital Agenda Assembly, Brussels, 16th June 2011.
Inês Nolasco Senior Regulatory Affairs Manager European Competitive Telecommunications Association.
Super-fast Fibre Access Angharad Davies, Policy and Public Affairs, Openreach Openreach makes every effort to ensure the information in this presentation.
October Penetración de principales servicios finales | Penetration rates for final services (lines/100 inhabitants) 2.
FTTH: the European update Introduction
1 European sector regulation and investment incentives for NGA to meet objectives for Digital Agenda Harald Gruber Project Directorate, European Investment.
Welcome to Northamptonshire. Current Situation Parts of Northampton can receive 50mb/s 12% of Northants only able to receive under 2mb/s (based on line.
Broadband Workshop Facilitating Broadband Investment French regulatory framework Bertrand Vandeputte ARCEP European Commission – DG INFSO March 23rd, 2011.
Broadband regulation in Denmark 24. September 2009 TRIS workshop Tomas Skov Lauridsen National IT and Telecom Agency, Denmark.
Infrastructure sharing and its contribution to the development of the infrastructure- based competition in Lithuania TAIEX Multi-beneficiary Workshop on.
International Telecommunication Union 1 The views expressed in this paper are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the ITU.
Regulation of NGA networks – the EU experience
Business customers connected
European Week of Regions and Cities, 10 October 2018, Brussels
Workshop on price statistics The Hague – 20th and 21st of June 2013
FTTH IN LUXEMBOURG INSIGHTS FOR A CONNECTED COUNTRY
Very High Capacity and 5G Networks: from the EU code to the EU market
The Past, Present and Future of Connectivity in Shropshire and Beyond.
Presentation transcript:

Pro-competitive EU Framework delivered a success story: affordability, higher speeds, more investment 2

Financial performance consistent: incumbents more profitable than entrants (Source: Webb Henderson & SPC Network) 3 Deutsche Bank forecasts incumbents’ weighted average EBIT margins to be 14.6% and 16.8% in 2013 and 2014 respectively, whilst entrants’ EBIT margin will be 11.0% and 11.9% in the same period Entrants have been investing more as percentage of sales in all of past five years. Incumbents have higher absolute investment due to larger size.

Telecoms shares are overall not underperforming (Source: Bloomberg & JP Morgan Cazenove) 4

NGA investments are increasing and on par with US 54% NGA coverage according to DAE Scoreboard (up from 49%) Comparable FTTC & FTTH coverage in EU & US (Source: FTTH Council & BCE by Telage) 5

100% NGA coverage is affordable (FTTC by Point Topic) Urban149 mn homes 71% population EUR 8 bn Semi- rural 31.4 mn homes 15% population EUR 22 bn Rural29.3 mn homes 14% population EUR 52 bn 6

Fast & superfast BB take-up is low & stagnating 7

Competition on NGA limited – hard-won liberalisation benefits at risk Entrant share of incumbent NGA lines minimal even where regulation applies (where data available) Compares with shares of 30%+ for copper lines Fibre LLU and fibre WBA in % of SMP operator’s FTTH lines Copper SLU and VDSL WBA in % of SMP operator’s FTTN lines Copper LLU and ADSL WBA in % of SMP operator’s copper lines AT0,0% 20,0% BE0,0%1,0% 4 4,9% CH0,0% no data DE0,0%<5%42,9% DKno data 24,8% ES0,0% 37,8% FR0,0%No FTTN/VDSL roll-out54,6% HU0,0%no data17,1% IE0,0% 33,5% IT0,0%No FTTN/VDSL roll-out45,7% NL5-10%0-5%26,8% PL0,0%no data22,0% PT0,0%no data21,4% RO0,0% 0,1% SEno data 33,6% TR0,0%no data UK<1%no data47,4% 8

Affordability & speed are the most important factors when choosing a BB subscription 9

Competition necessary to drive take-up of NGA networks (cf. historic development of DSL) All major leading broadband countries including Germany, France, UK and Nordics have benefited from ‘unbundling’ of the copper network Competition brought lower prices and new services (€30 triple play in France) 10

High market shares and low customer satisfaction in business services Results of end-user survey data (WIK – Jan 2013) 69% business users prefer to use a single supplier for all sites (within and cross country) and services, but only 53% of those preferring a single supplier found this was normally a practical option More than 50% of respondents cite problems sourcing fixed and mobile telephony or data from same supplier. More than 40% cite problems finding single supplier able to cover all sites or offer a consistent service across all relevant countries In 46% cases, respondents claimed it was rare to have more than 1 or 2 suppliers able to make a suitable offer Survey results consistent with 2009 end-user survey for European Regulators Group (ERG) Retail business market shares >50% - higher for multi-site business Available market share data in retail business services (eg CMT 2011) show incumbents retain >50% in most segments, with higher market shares for larger multi-site businesses 11

Market shares for multi-site business Example: Telefonica’s market share depending on number of sites and customer bill Customer Bill1 site2-5 sites6-10 sites 11 and more sites Total Less than % 1-5%<1%45-60% From 600 to %>75%5-15%<1%45-60% From to %>75%45-60%5-15%45-60% From – %>75% 25-35%45-60% From – %60-75%>75%45-60% From to %35-45%60-75% 45-60% From to %15-25%45-60%60-75%45-60% More than %15-25%25-35%>75%60-75% Total35-45%60-75% >75%45-60% Source: CMT (2011) 12