Emre Ergungor Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Foreclosures In Ohio: Does Lender Type Matter?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Economics Chapter 10 Section 2 & 3 Notes
Advertisements

Chapter 8 Federal Housing Policies: Part One. Chapter 8 Learning Objectives Understand how federal legislation has affected the mortgage and housing markets.
Depository Institutions
Depository Institutions
The demolition-foreclosure-equity connection Michael Schramm Research Associate, Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development, Case Western Reserve.
Virginia Foreclosure Prevention Task Force The Foreclosure Crisis: A Regional Perspective June 19, 2008 Presented by: Bill Shelton, Director Virginia Department.
Depository Institutions Take Charge of Your Finances.
Subprime Crisis By: Brad, Mario, Andrew, Matt April 30, 2008.
1 The Role of Mortgage Brokers in the Latino Community Janis Bowdler Senior Policy Analyst National Council of La Raza
Banks & Other Financial Institutions Ch PoB 2011.
Lender Behavior During Credit Cycles Giovanni Dell'Ariccia Deniz Igan Luc Laeven Comments: Alejandro Micco.
THE IMPACT OF GOVERNMENT POLICY AND REGULATION ON BANKING
Understand the role of finance in business Understand the banking system.
J. K. Dietrich - FBE Fall, 2005 Deposit-Taking Institutions Week 2 – August 31, 2005.
Chapter 2: An Overview of the Financial System Classifying Financial Markets Financial Market Instruments Financial Intermediaries Regulation Classifying.
Copyright © 2004 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill /Irwin 12-1 Chapter Twelve Thrift Institutions.
1.7.3.G1 © Family Economics & Financial Education – Revised March 2008 – Financial Institutions Unit – Depository Institutions Funded by a grant from Take.
FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS Bank : A business that sells services such as savings accounts, loans, and investments Regulated more strictly than most other.
1 Money, Finance,and the Crisis of Outline of money section 1.Essence of financial markets 2.Balance sheets 3.Introduction to the supply and.
Chapter  A bank is business just like a store or factory  Sells services such as checking, and payment accounts, savings accounts, loans, and.
Chapter 7 Federal Regulations and Financial Institutions Related to the Mortgage Market © OnCourse Learning.
 Savings and Savings Products Unit 3. Federal Reserve Bank  Federal Reserve Bank – is part of the central banking system in the United States  Services.
The Last Word: Ch 10 Review due next Tuesday; quiz next Tuesday.
Chapter 4 – Depository Institutions BA 543 Financial Markets and Institutions.
The Federal Reserve What is the Fed? How does the Fed help shape the economic conditions in the US? How does the Fed implement monetary policy?
©2007, The McGraw-Hill Companies, All Rights Reserved 14-1 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chapter Fourteen Other Lending Institutions: Savings Institutions, Credit.
1 Distance and Information Asymmetries in Lending Decisions by Sumit Agarwal and Robert Hauswald (& sons) Discussant Hans Degryse CentER – Tilburg University,
The Effect of the Foreclosure Crisis on Asset-Building in Minority Communities Paul Leonard November 13, 2008 Insight.
© Oklahoma State Department of Education. All rights reserved.1 Housing Alternatives Standard Renting vs. Buying.
1.7.3.G1 © Family Economics & Financial Education – Revised March 2008 – Financial Institutions Unit – Depository Institutions Funded by a grant from Take.
Federal Reserve System (ch7 & 8) -- Fin331 1 Federal Reserve System Overview of Federal Reserve System (central banking) Structure of Federal Reserve Fed.
Part II: Business Environment Introduction to Business 3e 4 Copyright © 2004 South-Western. All rights reserved. Assessing Economic Conditions.
How Bank Regulation, Supervision and Lender Identity Impact Loan Pricing: A Cross- Country Comparison Li Hao Debarshi K. Nandy Gordon S. Roberts Schulich.
Econ 350: October 15  Chapter 8: Economic Analysis of Financial Structure  CRA  Newly posted article.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2006 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 23 Monetary Policy, Output, and Inflation in the Short.
PowerPoint Presentation by Charlie Cook Copyright © 2004 South-Western. All rights reserved. Chapter 13 Depository Institution Management and Performance.
Does the market discipline banks? New evidence from bank capital mix October 27, 2006 Adam B. Ashcraft Federal Reserve Bank of NY.
Shadow Banking.
Essential Standard 4.00 Understand the role of finance in business.
©2013 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. Business Management, 13e Financial Services Financial Institutions Common Financial Services.
ESSENTIAL STANDARD 4.00 Understand the role of finance in business.
4.01, 4.02 Bluff
Essential Standard 4.00 Understand the role of finance in business.
FDIC Perspective on Environmental Risk Presented by: Gordon Stoner Legal Division Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation May 6, 2008.
20-1 The Money Supply and Banking Systems Chapter 20.
BANKING & FINANCE NOTES. THE UNITED STATES BANKING SYSTEM  Banks are businesses too!  Owned and operated like most corporations  Sells services : checking.
Fri. 4/15. Ch. 10 Money and Banking 10.3 Notes “Banking Today”
Financial Sector Integrity and Emerging Risks in Banking FDIC Conference 2005 João A.C. Santos Federal Reserve Bank of New York The views expressed here.
Small Banks and Deposit Insurance: The U.S. Experience Small Banks and Deposit Insurance: The U.S. Experience Christine E. Blair, Ph.D. Sr. Financial Economist.
Essential Standard 4.00 Understand the role of finance in business.
Essential Standard 4.00 Understand the role of finance in business.
LENDERS FOR A HOME LOAN MORTGAGE IN JACKSONVILLE.
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall.1 CHAPTER 3 Depository Institutions.
Economics and the Global Economy
Federal Housing Policies:
Chapter 13 Money and Banks.
Home Mortgage Loan Defaults In the US and EU
Understand the role of finance in business
Managing Nondeposit Liabilities
Monetary Policy & Politics
Disruptive Potential of Madden v. Midland Funding
Economics Chapter 10 Section 2 & 3 Notes
Tools of Monetary Policy
Depository Institutions
Chapter 17 The Financial System.
Depository Institutions
Understand the role of finance in business
Understand the role of finance in business
Understand the role of finance in business
Presentation transcript:

Emre Ergungor Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Foreclosures In Ohio: Does Lender Type Matter?

What is the Main Issue? “Deceptive lending practices [are common among] minority homeowners who lack access to traditional banking services and rely disproportionately on finance companies and other less regulated lenders.” National Consumer Law Center

The Question Does the way lenders are regulated matter for delinquency and foreclosure rates? How does the paper define “the way lenders are regulated”? Local Depositories Non-local Depositories Less-Regulated Entities For example: Ameriquest, Ameritrust, etc Why Ohio? I have the number of foreclosure filings in each county. Regulated by FED, OCC, OTS, FDIC, or NCUA

Why should lender type matter? Federal regulation and supervision matter. The difference in delinquency/foreclosure rates among counties is not about the way lenders are regulated. It could be about which lender is better informed about the neighborhood and uses that information in its lending decision. It could be about which lender depends upon third parties (brokers) who may have neglected their due diligence in order to generate volume.

The Alternative Hypothesis Suggests a Special Role for Local Depository Institutions Local depository institutions may know their neighborhoods better than out-of-town lenders and less-regulated mortgage lenders because they constantly interact with consumers and businesses on both sides of their balance sheets by making loans and taking deposits. Even in the absence of any informational advantage, local lenders may be less likely to foreclose on properties because of their ties to the community. Caution: I cannot measure any of this but these could be factors affecting the significance of the results.

Testable Hypotheses If regulation matters, I expect to see delinquencies and foreclosures increase with increasing market share of less- regulated entities. There should be no difference between local and non-local depositories If being a local lender matters, I expect to see delinquencies and foreclosures increase with increasing market share of less-regulated entities and non-local depositories. There should be no difference between less-regulated entities and non-local depositories

Method I Cross-sectional analysis (2SLS) t: 1999 to 2004 Caution: Some variables are ‘problematic’

Method II Arellano-Bond first-differenced GMM

Estimation Two methods Dynamic panel allows control of unobserved county-specific effects accounts for auto-regressive dynamics allows for explanatory variables that are not strictly exogenous Cross-sectional analysis potential bias in the dynamic panel that arises from the large number of instruments relative to the number of cross sections

Results When non-local depositories and less-regulated entities gain market share at the expense of local depositories, foreclosure rates tend to go up. The negative economic impact of non-local depositories is larger than that of less-regulated entities but the difference is statistically insignificant in most years.

Summary The type of the financial institutions lending in a county is a factor that influences the foreclosure rates. The evidence does not support the view that federal regulation/supervision is important. This result could mean many things, which I don’t address in this paper Less regulated lenders and non-local depositories may have depended upon third parties (brokers) who may have neglected their due diligence in order to generate volume. They may be more realistic about the deteriorating conditions in the housing market and more inclined to foreclose on the property to prevent it from falling into disrepair.