How TSOs can further contribute to efficient competition GIE ANNUAL CONFERENCE ATHENS 2005.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

4th Poverty Reduction Strategies Forum Athens, June 27 th, 2007 Regional Energy market in Southeast Europe: Prospects and challenges for the SEE countries.

Advertisements

1 st GRG meeting, Zagreb, 30 September 2005 Gas Regulatory Group Main issues to be addressed.

Madrid, 7 th February th SG Meeting South Gas Regional Initiative.

Draft Framework Guidelines on Capacity Allocation Mechanisms for the European Gas Transmission Network Benoît Esnault, CRE Presentation Workshop Ljubljana,

Heinz Hilbrecht Director "Security of Supply and Energy Markets" European Commission - DG TREN , GRI NW, Amsterdam Regional Cooperation Role of.

Baltic Energy Strategy Einari Kisel Director of Energy Department.

7 th IG meeting, South Gas Regional Initiative Madrid, 10 th July 2008 Consultation on Requirements for Gas Interconnection Capacity between Spain and.

World Forum on Energy Regulation IV Athens, Greece October , 2009 Regulating EU Gas Supply Security in a Global Gas Market P Jacques de Jong Clingendael.

3 November 2005 GIE Conference Gas Market Developments in SEE Balázs SÁNDOR Chairman GIE ECSEE Study Group Athens - 3 November 2005.

Update on GSE Activities Klaus-Dieter Barbknecht GSE President GIE General Assembly Madrid 21 November 2007.

Rocío PRIETO – Comisión Nacional de Energía Benoît ESNAULT – Commission de Régulation de l’Energie LNG TF chairs 18th Madrid Forum Madrid, 27/28 September.

David Halldearn, ERGEG Conference on Implementing the 3 rd Package 11 th December 2008 Implementating the 3rd Package: An ERGEG Consultation paper.

1 The Regulatory Approach to Fostering Investment David Halldearn Ofgem 28 September 2006.

XV Madrid Forum, 6 and 7 November 2008 Capacity Allocation and Congestion Management Rules for Storage Mr. Walter Boltz ERGEG’s Gas Focus Group (GFG)

Classification: Internal Status: Draft ERGEG GRI NW Investment Workstream Shippers’ contribution Helga FRANSE, Jerome DUROYON,

3-4 November 2005GIE Annual Conference 2005, Athens1 The increasing importance of storage Klaus-Dieter Barbknecht GSE President GIE Annual Conference 2005,

EG pfa-sb Athen_November2005.ppt GIE Annual Conference The View of the Users of Gas Infrastructures Presented by Dieter Pfaff E.ON Ruhrgas AG Chairman.

Directorate General for Energy and Transport Johannes ENZMANN European Commission DG Energy and Transport Unit Electricity and Gas GIE Annual Conference.

Achieving a sound investment climate – the role of regulators Boaz Moselle Joint-Chair, CEER Gas Working Group Managing Director – Corporate Strategy Ofgem.

1 Dublin 23/24 April 2007Autor Jacques Guldenmundt EFET, input for discussion on ‘day-ahead-auctions’, Dublin, 23/24 April 2007.

David Halldearn, ERGEG Conference on Implementing the 3 rd Package Brussels, 11 th December 2008 Co-ordination of Decisions at Regional and European level.

The Regional Initiatives: Progress and Prospects Conference Brussels, 28 March 2007 Mr Walter Boltz ERGEG Gas Focus Group Chair Status Report of the Gas.

Gas Regional Initiative North-West Transmission System Operators Page 1 Investment work stream GRI North-West Operators‘ Group Investment Work Stream SG.

Sound Investment Climate? Jacques Laurelut GTE President CEO of GRTgaz Bratislava, 28 September 2006.

The 3rd package for the internal energy market Key proposals EUROPEAN COMMISSION Heinz Hilbrecht Directorate C - Security of supply and energy markets.

Directorate General for Energy and Transport Nina Grall Directorate General – Energy and Transport European Forum Gas 2007 – Paris Towards one.

1 GIE Annual Conference Madrid, November 2007 Investing in Europe‘s Future – the Role of Regulators David Halldearn Senior Adviser, European Affairs.

GIE Annual Conference, Athens, 3 November 2005 Prospects of a Regional Gas Regulatory Framework Fostering a Sustainable Market-Based Investment Climate.

1 Gas Regional Investment Plan North West Europe GRI Meeting, November 25 th 2011.

Bucharest, 24 October 2008 Making the third package work in practice Wolfgang Urbantschitsch, E-Control.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION Heinrich Hick, DG TREN C 2 3rd IEM Package and relevance of GRI GRI NW stakeholder Conference, London, 14 November 2008.

Benoît Esnault Commission de Régulation de l’Energie (CRE) - ERGEG 19th Madrid Forum, March 2011 Energy Infrastructure Package ERGEG preliminary.

Directorate General for Energy and Transport1 Ana Arana Antelo Head of Unit Electricty & Gas – European Commission/DG TREN GIE Annual Conference, ,

GIE Annual Conference Bratislava, September 28-29, 2006 Author:Milan Sedlacek, SPP-preprava, a.s. TRANSIT IN CENTRAL EUROPE.

Directorate General for Energy and Transport European Commission Directorate General for Energy and Transport Regulation of electricity markets in the.

European Federation of Energy Traders GIE annual conference 2008 Bukarest, October Needs of the market participants with respect to creating an integrated.

Madrid, 15th June rd SG Meeting South Gas Regional Initiative.

XVI th Madrid Forum Madrid, 28 May 2009 Walter Boltz (Gas Working Group Chair) Transparency guidelines and GRI transparency work.

Does the Third Package provide the European TSO associations with the tools necessary to find solutions to the European energy challenge ? Nigel Sisman,

Benoît Esnault Commission de Régulation de l’Energie (CRE) - ERGEG 19th Madrid Forum, March 2011 Preparatory work for Framework Guideline Tariffs.

The industrial consumer’s view IFIEC EUROPE 1 GTE 2 nd Annual Conference September 2004 Copenhagen Barriers to competition in the view of a consumer.

The Energy Community C hrissa Argyriou – European Commission – DG Transport and Energy Electricity and Gas

Benoît Esnault (CRE) 17 th Madrid Forum 14 January 2010 Pilot framework guideline on capacity allocation mechanisms.

The Central Role of the Network Operators 28 March 2007 ERGEG-GTE Meeting.

Vienna, 24 november GRI SSE: work done so far 1. Assessment summary on selected transportation routes ongoing 2. Preliminary paper on hubs as regional.

1 The Spanish Gas Industry and the 3 rd Package Antoni Peris Mingot – Sedigas President GIE Annual Conference – Madrid.

Pamela Taylor, Head of European Strategy, Ofgem Madrid Forum, March 2011 ERGEG’s draft framework guideline for gas balancing.

1 ERGEG Customer Focus Group Workshop October 11, 2005, Helsinki CEDEC Gert De Block Secretary General.

22 – 23 November 2007 GIE Annual Conference How the Third Package might encourage investment.

Gas Roads & GTE Colin Hamilton (European Policy) 2 nd July 2009.

Gas Regional Initiative North West Region - Draft Framework Guidelines Capacity Allocation Mechanisms BNetzA/CRE Pre-Comitology Meeting Bonn – 26 May 2011.

23 September 2004GTE Annual Conference1 Review of the Madrid Forum VIII July 2004 Geert E.H. Joosten GTE President GTE Annual Conference September.

28-29 September 2006 GIE Annual Conference 2006, Bratislava1 Role of storage for SoS / Necessary signals for investing in new storage Klaus-Dieter Barbknecht.

Gas Regional Initiative Impact of the 3rd package & creation of RIG Benoît Esnault (CRE), GRI TF co-chair NW GRI – RCC and ministerial meeting Paris, 8.

Michael Schmoeltzer Member of ERGEG Gas Working Group GIE Annual Conference, 6/7 May 2009, Groningen ACER & ENTSOG and their interaction.

ETSO-GTE Supporting a secure and liberalized European energy market A Joint Presentation by Mr Geert Joosten, GTE Mr Juha Kekkonen, ETSO 22 January 2003.

Directorate-General for Energy and Transport Mark van Stiphout – C2 Electricity and Gas GSE Workshop on storage investment 24 May 2007 Policy framework.

Scoping the Framework Guidelines on Interoperability Rules for European Gas Transmission Geert Van Hauwermeiren 20 th Madrid Forum, 26 Sept 2011.

The Role of TSO. Madrid, 7-8 Feb The Role of TSO2 The roles of industry players First vision of role of TSO in GTE position paper Industry players.

1 XVI Madrid Forum, 29 May 2009 XVI Madrid Forum Jose Sierra Madrid, 29 May 2009 Chair, RIG ERGEG Gas Regional Initiative Update & Progress.

10 year investment plan ERGEG approach and contribution

New transparency guidelines

Background and Process

ERGEG South Gas Regional Initiative

Achieving the Internal Gas Market The view of gas suppliers

GIE Annual Conference Bratislava, September 2006

XIIIth Madrid Forum (16th/17th October 2007)

Meinhard Janssen GIE Board Member

ERGEG’s reaction on DGTREN LNG study results and policy conclusions

NDPHS Work Plan for 2012 NDPHS 8th Partnership Annual Conference

Presentation transcript:

How TSOs can further contribute to efficient competition GIE ANNUAL CONFERENCE ATHENS 2005

3-4 November MAIN ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE 2001 Separation of transmission companies (management unbundling) Progressive implementation of Directives and GGP Transparency and non-discrimination Various contributions of TSOs made within GTE Efforts made to manage a high technical complexity Virtual tariff offering versus physical constraints, investments in metering and measuring equipments, IT systems …

3-4 November But there is another question which we have to face. It is the question of large infrastructure investments within Europe

3-4 November TOWARDS UPSTREAM COMPETITION… EU more and more dependent on external gas sources Each supply source on the upstream market influences a regional price on the downstream market Competition among the different supply sources is necessary to create an efficient market U. K. Russia LNG North Sea Norway

3-4 November VISION FOR A EUROPEAN ECONOMIC MODEL U. K. Hub South-West Hub South-East Hub North Hub East Hub UK Hub West P1 P2 P3 P4P5 P6 The price differential between two hubs reflects the lack of available capacity between these two hubs The market will be efficient if the price differentials between hubs are low enough, so that competition among supply sources is effective Therefore, investments in transnational inter- hub links are necessary for an efficient market

3-4 November HOW TO DECIDE ON SUCH INVESTMENTS … (1/2) … while high investments in transmission infrastructures are needed, … and while inter-hub links require transnational investments between interconnected networks ? ERGEG roadmap objective covers “regional hubs” subject, but does not emphasize the question of the interconnection of the hubs Use of “Art. 22” is still limited to the creation of new entry points only on the edge of the European gas market Hub 1Hub 2 ?

3-4 November HOW TO DECIDE ON SUCH INVESTMENTS ? (2/2) TSOs or shippers (especially in case of transit) may take the initiative If TSOs are financing, the price differentials will be reduced, but : Problem of cost allocation of transnational investments (such an investment has different consequences on each concerned national market) No regulatory framework exists for a transnational link  need for a supranational supervision ? Decision cannot be based on market price signals, as they do not exist yet If shippers are financing (as often in the past) : Except for transit, shippers objective is to capture the price differential value and to maintain the price differential between hubs However, this may incite new competing investments Therefore shippers have very low visibility on the value of such investments and only major operators may be able to take such risks Mixed financing (TSOs with shippers) will cumulate all the drawbacks

3-4 November What action should be taken now ? Need to build up a supranational vision, shared by all the actors - via voluntary agreements (Madrid Forum) The urgent issue to be addressed now : The priority is to focus on transnational investment programs and the needed conditions for investments in inter-hub links