Conference Introduction Duncan Forbes Swinburne University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Conference Summary Richard Ellis (Caltech) 51 talks × 30 slides = 1530 slides AND 54 posters All carefully digested, rationalized, inter- compared with.
Advertisements

Star formation histories and environment Bianca M. Poggianti INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova WE ARE ALL AFTER THE BIG PICTURE: 1)To what extent,
Galaxy groups Michael Balogh Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Waterloo.
Malaysia 2009 Sugata Kaviraj Oxford/UCL Collaborators: Sukyoung Yi, Kevin Schawinski, Eric Gawiser, Pieter van Dokkum, Richard Ellis Malaysia 2009 Early-type.
arvard.edu/phot o/2007/m51/. Confronting Stellar Feedback Simulations with Observations of Hot Gas in Elliptical Galaxies Q. Daniel Wang,
Galaxy Formation and Evolution, Mo, van den Bosch & White, 2010 Galactic Dynamics, Binney & Tremaine 2008.
Subaru UM 2009/01/15 1 Extended ionized gas regions around the Coma cluster galaxies Michitoshi YOSHIDA Okayama Astrophysical Observatory, NAOJ with Masafumi.
Formation of intergroup and intragroup objects Kenji Bekki (UNSW) Origin of isolated massive clouds, intergalactic HII regions, intragroup GCs etc….
Stellar Populations in Galaxies as traced by Globular Clusters Markus Kissler-Patig.
18 July Monte Carlo Markov Chain Parameter Estimation in Semi-Analytic Models Bruno Henriques Peter Thomas Sussex Survey Science Centre.
Observations of the evolution of HI in galaxies across different environments. D.J. Pisano (West Virginia University)
An introduction to Galaxies. The World of Galaxies Spirals barred unbarred Ellipticals Irregulars.
Formation of Globular Clusters in  CDM Cosmology Oleg Gnedin (University of Michigan)
1 Mechanisms of Galaxy Evolution Things that happen to galaxies… Galaxy merging Things that happen to galaxies… Galaxy merging.
AGN in hierarchical galaxy formation models Nikos Fanidakis and C.M. Baugh, R.G. Bower, S. Cole, C. Done, C. S. Frenk Accretion and ejection in AGN, Como,
Kevin Bundy, Caltech The Mass Assembly History of Field Galaxies: Detection of an Evolving Mass Limit for Star-Forming Galaxies Kevin Bundy R. S. Ellis,
The ages and metallicities of Hickson Compact Group galaxies. Rob Proctor Swinburne University of Technology May 2005 Rob Proctor Swinburne University.
Dark Halos of Fossil Groups and Clusters Observations and Simulations Ali Dariush, Trevor Ponman Graham Smith University of Birmingham, UK Frazer Pearce.
Galaxies and their Environments Nick Cowan UW Astronomy January 26, 2007 Nick Cowan UW Astronomy January 26, 2007.
Dark Matter and Galaxy Formation Section 4: Semi-Analytic Models of Galaxy Formation Joel R. Primack 2009, eprint arXiv: Presented by: Michael.
Extragalactic Globular Clusters: Insights into Galaxy Formation Jean P. Brodie UCO/Lick Observatory University of California Santa Cruz S tudy of A strophysics.
“ Testing the predictive power of semi-analytic models using the Sloan Digital Sky Survey” Juan Esteban González Birmingham, 24/06/08 Collaborators: Cedric.
Clustering of QSOs and X-ray AGN at z=1 Alison Coil Hubble Fellow University of Arizona October 2007 Collaborators: Jeff Newman, Joe Hennawi, Marc Davis,
Cosmological formation of elliptical galaxies * Thorsten Naab & Jeremiah P. Ostriker (Munich, Princeton) T.Naab (USM), P. Johannson (USM), J.P. Ostriker.
Observational Properties of Extragalactic Globular Cluster Systems
Galactic Metamorphoses: Role of Structure Christopher J. Conselice.
Star Clusters and their stars Open clusters and globular clusters General characteristics of globular clusters Globular cluster stars in the H-R diagram.
Conference “Summary” Alice Shapley (Princeton). Overview Multitude of new observational, multi-wavelength results on massive galaxies from z~0 to z>5:
Dwarf LSB galaxies in the Virgo cluster Jonathan Davies.
Understanding formation of galaxies from their environments Yipeng Jing Shanghai Astronomical Observatory.
After decoupling, overdense regions collapse IF Collapse timefor all sizes. More small ripples than large waves. --> Universe dominated by globular clusters.
Galactic Astronomy 銀河物理学特論 I Lecture 1-5: Dependence of Galaxy Properties on Environment Seminar: Park et al. 2007, ApJ, 658, 898 Lecture: 2011/11/07.
Galaxy Growth: The role of environment Simone Weinmann (MPA Garching) Collaborators: Guinevere Kauffmann, Frank van den Bosch, Anna Pasquali, Dan McIntosh,
Scaling relations of spheroids over cosmic time: Tommaso Treu (UCSB)
The interaction between galaxies and their environment Trevor Ponman University of Birmingham Jesper Rasmussen Carnegie Observatories.
A Supergroup in 6dFGS Sarah Brough, Swinburne University Virginia Kilborn, Duncan Forbes, Swinburne University Warrick Couch, UNSW Heath Jones, Mount Stromlo.
The coordinated growth of stars, haloes and large-scale structure since z=1 Michael Balogh Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Waterloo.
The Evolution of Groups and Clusters " Richard Bower, ICC, Durham " With thanks to the collaborators that have shaped my views Mike Balogh, Dave Wilman,
The Environmental Effect on the UV Color-Magnitude Relation of Early-type Galaxies Hwihyun Kim Journal Club 10/24/2008 Schawinski et al. 2007, ApJS 173,
Constraining formation scenarios for S0 galaxies through their Globular Cluster systems Rubén Sánchez-Janssen VII Workshop Estallidos Madrid, 26 Enero.
Revealing Elliptical Galaxy Halos Duncan Forbes, Swinburne University.
Modeling the dependence of galaxy clustering on stellar mass and SEDs Lan Wang Collaborators: Guinevere Kauffmann (MPA) Cheng Li (MPA/SHAO, USTC) Gabriella.
Globular Cluters in Dwarf Galaxies. But first, a digression regarding tides... Leo I.
MNRAS, submitted. Galaxy evolution Evolution in global properties reasonably well established What drives this evolution? How does it depend on environment?
Galaxies with Active Nuclei Chapter 14:. Active Galaxies Galaxies with extremely violent energy release in their nuclei (pl. of nucleus).  “active galactic.
The GEMS Project and Collapsed Groups Duncan Forbes Swinburne University.
Driving Downsizing with groups of galaxies Michael Balogh Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Waterloo.
Myung Gyoon Lee With Hong Soo Park & In Sung Jang Seoul National University, Korea Multiwavelength surveys: Formation and Evolution of Galaxies from the.
Myung Gyoon Lee Seoul National University, Korea The 6 th KIAS Workshop on Cosmology and Structure Formation, Nov 4-7, 2014, KIAS, Seoul 1.
Major dry-merger rate and extremely massive major dry-mergers of BCGs Deng Zugan June 31st Taiwan.
E. K. Grebel Globular Clusters: The Dwarf Galaxy Contribution1 Globular Clusters: The Dwarf Galaxy Contribution Eva K. Grebel Astronomisches Rechen-Institut.
Subaru Wide-Field Survey of M87 Globular Cluster Populations N.Arimoto (NAOJ) N.Tamura, R.Sharples (Durham) M.Onodera (Tokyo, NAOJ), K.Ohta(Kyoto) J.-C.Cuillandre.
Models & Observations galaxy clusters Gabriella De Lucia Max-Planck Institut für Astrophysik Ringberg - October 28, 2005.
Gas Accretion and Secular Processes 1  How much mass assembled in mergers?  How much through gas accretion and secular evolution? Keres et al 2005, Dekel.
The Star Formation- Density Relation …and the Cluster Abell 901/2 in COMBO-17 Christian Wolf (Oxford) Eric Bell, Anna Gallazzi, Klaus Meisenheimer (MPIA.
Semi-analytical model of galaxy formation Xi Kang Purple Mountain Observatory, CAS.
AGN Demographics Christine Black 3/1/12
How are galaxies influenced by their environment? rachel somerville STScI Predictions & insights from hierarchical models with thanks to Eric Bell the.
Speaker: Dave Wilman (MPE) Collaborators: Mike Balogh (Waterloo), George Hau, Richard Bower (Durham); John Mulchaey, Gus Oemler (Carnegie); Ray Carlberg.
Interpreting the relationship between galaxy luminosity, color, and environment. Andreas Berlind (NYU, CCPP) SPH predictions: Michael Blanton (NYU) David.
Maracalagonis, 24/05/ Semi-Analytic Modeling of Galaxy Formation PhD student: Elena Ricciardelli Supervisor: prof. Alberto Franceschini.
BULGE FRACTION AND DISTRIBUTION OF STAR FORMATION IN SAMI GALAXIES Greg Goldstein PhD student, Dept of Physics and Astronomy, Macquarie University Supervisors:
Galaxies in LowDensity Environments
Extragalactic Globular Clusters: Insights into Galaxy Formation
The X-ray Evolution of Young Post-Merger
The SAURON Survey - The stellar populations of early-type galaxies
Rubén Sánchez-Janssen (IAC) J.Alfonso L. Aguerri Casiana Muñoz-Tuñón
Henry Ferguson STScI August 28, 2008
Quenching of the star formation activity in cluster galaxies
Ages, Metallicities and Abundances of Dwarf Early-Type Galaxies in the Coma Cluster by Ana Matković (STScI) Rafael Guzmán (U. of Florida) Patricia Sánchez-Blázquez (U.
Presentation transcript:

Conference Introduction Duncan Forbes Swinburne University

Conference Introduction Thanks to Meghan, Frazer and Mike Preview the upcoming conference (ie Ill give the least accurate talk) Personal and biased view (ie Ill forget to mention your seminal paper on environment) Lets have a clean and open discussion (no plutos)…

This conference aims to…disentangle the complex interplay between nature and nurture. Malaysia, March 2009

SOC chair: Lourdes Verdes Montenegro

Defining Environment Field, Group and Cluster Projected local number density of nearby galaxies (volume density better) Cluster-centric distance (which centric?)

Defining Environment Halo, subhalo, satellite Halo mass 3D dark matter density

Morphology-Density Relation Dressler 1980 Clusters Field With time, spirals are replaced by S0s - Dressler et al. 1997

Morphology-SF-Density Relation for Dwarf galaxies Forbes et al dI -> dE -> dSph Einasto et al Mayer et al. 2006

In the extreme… Environmental trends due to: Nature: everything due to initial conditions, eg massive galaxies form early in the highest overdensities. OR Nurture: everything due to environment, eg galaxy-galaxy, galaxy-ICM, galaxy-dark matter interactions.

What supresses star formation? Hopkins et al. 2004

Environmental Madau plot Crain et al. 2009

Gray et al dFGRS (Lewis et al. 2002) and SDSS (Gomez et al. 2003) => pre-processing in Groups ? The low density Field includes some quiescent galaxies (Gray et al. 2004) Supression at (group-like) densities

What supresses star formation? Haines et al Observation Lower density, less SF suppressed 100% star forming

What supresses star formation? Croton et al Model Haines et al Observation

Environmental Processes Steady gas accretion Ram pressure stripping (gas removal) Strangulation (turnoff gas supply) Interactions & Harassment (high ) Mergers (low ) Review by Boselli & Gavazzi 2006

Kacprzak et al High redshift gas accretion Stream-fed galaxies Dekel et al. 2009

Rasmussen et al Stripping in a Group

Sun et al. 2005

=> Formation of dark-matter free Tidal Dwarf Galaxies ? Interactions and Mergers

Globular Cluster tidal stripping/accretion Bekki etal. 2003

Peng etal GC/L V

Environmental Processes Ram pressure stripping (gas removal) Strangulation (turnoff gas supply) Steady gas accretion Interactions & Harassment (high ) Mergers (low ) Are their timescales and any feedback processes consistent with the observed Red sequence, green valley and blue cloud ?

The Dearth of Environment Dependence Van den Bosch et al. 2008

M V < -20 High density Low density Redshift Red galaxy fraction Evolution of the red sequence (Bell et al. 2004) Butcher-Oemler effect in place at medium redshift and in the field.

Formation vs Assembly De Lucia 2007

~13 Gyrs old dissipative rapid burst NGC1400 M B = -20 E/S0 Spolaor et al % See poster by Foster et al.

NGC 4649 Globular Clusters Pierce et al. 2006

Cluster-centric predictions Caution: global vs central values Caution: physical vs projected radii Caution: splashback De Lucia 2007

No X-ray Halo Stripping in Groups Helsdon et al Isolated BGGs Non-BGGs

Luminosity Functions Miles et al Low L X groups Low sigma Lots of spirals Current merging Pre-virialised

Isolated Elliptical Galaxies A `control sample unaffected by the group/cluster environment Reda, Forbes et al. (2004) Early-type galaxy, V < 9,000 km/s, B < 14 No neighbours within: 700 km/s 0.67 Mpc in plane of the sky 2 B mags (factor of 6 in mass) => 36 ellipticals

Colour-magnitude relation

Fundamental Plane Deviant galaxies have young stellar populations and/or disturbed morphology Reda, Forbes & Hau 2005

FP – Kappa style

Radial Kinematics Hau & Forbes 2005

NGC the nearest isolated elliptical galaxy ?

Radial Ages - NGC 821 Proctor,Forbes etal. 2005

Multi- GC systems Strader et al Both red and blue sub- pops are coeval at ~12 Gyr old. Most GC formation in massive ellipticals happened at z > 2, not in recent mergers. BlueRed Old age isochrones

Galaxy Bimodality M V ~ -20, M ~3x10 10 M o, M halo ~6x10 11 M o Luminosity function, Colour-magnitude, Star formation rates, bulge/disk ratio, X-ray emission, stellar age, AGN emission, M/L ratio Globular Cluster Specific Frequency Transition from hot accretion flows to cold accretion plus AGN/SN feedback (see Dekel, Keres, Croton etc)

Relative GC numbers versus host galaxy stellar mass GC T N -parameter M * = galaxy stellar mass computed from 2MASS K-band mag Problem: Star formation histories vary Transition at M * ~few x M sun (Forbes 2005)

globular clusters are ~0.007% of a halos mass Galaxy Halo Mass Globular Cluster System Mass

globular clusters are ~0.007% of a halos mass Galaxy Halo Mass Globular Cluster System Mass MW & M31 halo masses from Xue et al & Lee et al. 2008

Galaxy Halo Mass Globular Cluster System Mass Spitler & Forbes 2009 No clear environment trend

Globular Clusters in Galaxy Clusters Where are the GCs in the Virgo galaxy cluster? 25% in M87 46% satellites 29% intracluster 100% The GC mass of a cluster-sized halo should include these 3 components. (Bekki et al. 2006)

globular clusters are ~0.007% of a halos mass Galaxy Halo Mass Globular Cluster System Mass

Galaxy Halo Mass Globular Cluster System Mass globular clusters are ~0.007% of a halos mass

Galaxy Halo Mass Globular Cluster System Mass globular clusters are ~0.007% of a halos mass LG total masses from Mateo 1998 Fornax Sag. N147 N185 N205

Potential method for determining Halo Masses… GC formation appears to be directly proportional to the host halo mass 0.007% of Halo Mass = (Globular Cluster System Mass)

Conclusions Massive isolated galaxies can be quiescent Environment influences greater for dwarfs Galaxy (and GC) properties are bimodal Consider formation vs assembly times Galaxies have (strong) mass trends Some isolated galaxies show signs of a merger Globular clusters provide an alternative probe of galaxy formation and assembly And finally…

…Not Nature vs Nurture but Nature AND Nurture Have a great conference…