Evaluating Healthy Food Retail in Low-Income Urban Neighbourhoods L.M. Minaker, C. L. Mah, B.E. Cook May 29, 2014 CPHA 2014.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Program Evaluation: What is it?
Advertisements

Developing Organizational Commitment to Cultural Competence
An impact evaluation of Ethiopias Food Security Program John Hoddinott, IFPRI (in collaboration with Dan Gilligan, Alemayehu Seyoum and Samson Dejene)
Conducting monitoring and evaluation FACTSHEET 13 Food and Garden Organics Best Practice Collection Manual.
Does a community-based practical food skills intervention (CookWell) assist weight reduction W.L. Wrieden 1, A.S. Anderson 2, E. Dowler 3, K. Valentine.
Diet Matters: Approaches and Indicators to Assess Agriculture's Role in Nutrition Diego Rose, Brian Luckett, and Adrienne Mundorf School of Public Health.
Health Trainer Champions in a Category A Prison in England: Lessons Learned for Health Improvement of Offenders Di Bailey Nottingham Trent University.
Impact of reduced in-home secondhand smoke exposure on low birth weight prevalence and neonate health PEER Health Research Project Dr. Yayi Suryo Prabandari.
Food Accessibility in Wisconsin: Comparison of Self-Report, Direct Observation, and Mapping Data ResultsKey Findings Results Conclusions Background Results.
Assessing the Engaged Student: Using Evaluation Tools to Reexamine and Strengthen Civic Engagement Programs Ethan A. Kolek, Associate Director of Institutional.
Who was there and how many were there? Did they learning something? Will they change behavior? Inputs: Time, Money, Materials Numbers Reached, Frequency.
Using data to tailor a school-based worksite wellness program Stephanie Vecchiarelli, Judith Siegel, Michael Prelip University of California Los Angeles,
ARQ part II data management Training pack 2: Monitoring drug abuse for policy and practice.
1 Selecting A Research Method. 2 Selecting research methods How do we answer our research questions? Methodology depends on question, budget, timing,
Evaluating Physical Activity Intervention Programs Thomas Schmid, PhD Physical Activity and Health Branch CDC Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
Founded by: Flavoured tobacco use among Canadian Youth: the role of surveillance in policy development and framing Leia Minaker, PhD | May 28, 2014 CPHA.
Bay Area Region Nutrition Network. The Network The Bay Area Region Nutrition Network is one of 11 Regional Nutrition Networks that together provide services.
The Oxford Health Alliance The Oxford Health Alliance Community Interventions for Health: Methodology Confronting the Epidemic.
Purpose The National Physical Activity Guidelines Dimensions of Physical Activity Methods used to Measure Physical Activity Appropriate instruments for.
Designing Learning.
Impact of a public education program on promoting rational use of medicines: a household survey in south district of Tehran, Darbooy SH, Hosseini.
Interactive Notebooks in the middle school Social Studies classroom EDSS 8420 Lindsey Banos.
Skunk Works Evaluation Tools: How do we know if we are having an impact?
How qualitative research contributes to evaluation Professor Alicia O’Cathain ScHARR University of Sheffield 22 June 2015.
The role of local libraries in improving access to health- related information in rural settings Emanuela Marton-Vasarhelyi, MA Center for Health Policy.
Climate Change Council November 2011 draft ACT Planning Strategy.
Program Fidelity Influencing Training Program Functioning and Effectiveness Cheryl J. Woods, CSW.
Evaluation Tools & Approaches for Engaging Stakeholders: The AREA Approach Presentation at the Canadian Evaluation Society Dr. Mariam Manley, Principal.
Barbara Resnick, PhD, CRNP, FAAN, FAANP
EILS_NSF Program Assessment Strategies for obtaining meaningful & comparable results.
Understanding Your Community And Assessing Your Community Health Assets & Needs Folakemi T. Odedina, PhD Professor, College of Pharmacy Director, UFPDC.
Assessing the Feasibility of Continuous Net Distribution in Kenya using Community Based Approach.
1 Research on Effects of Urban Forestry Work Experiences on Inner City, Underserved Adolescents Trees & Positive Youth Development.
Methods for the evaluation of the Abstinence and Faithfulness among Youth (ABY) interventions in South Africa Dr Geoff Setswe, Dr Mark Ottenweller & Roger.
Identify a Health Problem Qualitative Quantitative Develop Program -theory -objectives -format -content Determine Evaluation -design -sampling -measures.
Impact of a Community-based Participatory Program on Socioeconomic Disadvantage in Youth Reproductive Health Outcomes in Nepal Anju Malhotra Sanyukta Mathur.
Glaucoma in Ealing Where have we been? qualitative and quantitative work suggested poor public health knowledge of glaucoma Public Patients Professionals.
Performance Indicators Table for Youth Substance Abuse & Use Prevention September 15, 2005 Ottawa, Ontario Wanda Jamieson & Tullio Caputo.
[ADD TITLE] Field Experience Culminating Presentation [ADD YOUR NANE] [ADD DATE]
The impact of effective community engagement in implementing prevention of blindness interventions. The impact of effective community engagement in implementing.
 Getting Outside of the Box: Designing and Implementing Innovative Ways to Prevent Infection Willo Pequegnat, Ph.D., Salix Health Consulting/USAID Susan.
Natural Experiments Versus RCTs Steven Gortmaker, Ph.D. Harvard School of Public Health /Harvard Prevention Research Center.
Evaluating Multilingual Education Programs Seminar on Multilingual Education Kabul, March 2010 Dennis Malone, Ph.D.
THE RD PARENT EMPOWERMENT PROGRAM CREATES MEASURABLE CHANGE IN THE BEHAVIORS OF LOW- INCOME FAMILIES AND CHILDREN: AN INTERVENTION DESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION.
SCHOOL COUNSELING INTERVENTIONS Adrienne WatkinsBall State University.
Knowledge of Canada’s Food Guide to Healthy Eating and Serving Size Awareness Understanding Healthy Lifestyles: Measuring & Monitoring Behavioural Risk.
 2013 Cengage-Wadsworth A National Nutrition Agenda for the Public’s Health.
Starting down a NEWPATH Nutrition, Environment in Waterloo Region, Physical Activity, Transportation and Health Andrew Devlin, University of British Columbia.
This action-based research study used a descriptive triangulation process, which included quantitative and qualitative methods to analyze nursing students’
Decent Food for All: What we are researching and why ? Orla Walsh Public Health Development Officer Institute of Public Health in Ireland.
The Starting Point Things to consider include Defining the overarching aim(s) of the event/activity Deciding the type of event you wish to undertake Defining.
Social Cooking Project Evaluation Proposal Dr. Haider Ali & Dr. Andrew Lindridge Open University.
INTRODUCING THE PSBA-GTO ACT FOR YOUTH CENTER OF EXCELLENCE IN CONSULTATION WITH HEALTHY TEEN NETWORK Planning for Evidence-Based Programming.
This course focuses on guidelines for making nutritious food choices. Students will investigate factors that influence food choices, including beliefs,
Are we there yet? Evaluating your graduation SiMR.
Diversified Agriculture for a balanced nutrition: Constraints and drivers for consumption of diversified diets in rural households - Morogoro and Dodoma.
Neighbourhood Markets Evaluating our Efforts Building Healthy and Supportive Communities CHNET – Works! Fireside chat May 7, 2009.
Welcome to the (ENTER YOUR SYSTEM/SCHOOL NAME) Data Dig 1.
4 th Biennial SAMEA Conference Meaningful Evaluation: Improving Use and Results Evaluation of Teacher-Directed ICT Initiatives Presenter Mokete Mokone.
Evaluation. “Anatomy” of a Campaign Topic Audience and Behavior Audience 1 Audience 2Audience 3 Strategy Tactic A Tactic B Tactic C Outcome A Outcome.
Evaluation Nicola Bowtell. Some myths about evaluation 2Presentation title - edit in Header and Footer always involves extensive questionnaires means.
1 Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Most Vulnerable Children Quality Improvement Trainings in five Regions of Tanzania Author: Flora Nyagawa 1 ; Kusekwa.
Culturally appropriate training for remote Australian Aboriginal Health Workers: Evaluation of an early child development training intervention Dr Anita.
Evaluating the Quality and Impact of Community Benefit Programs
MESAS: Evaluation of minimum unit pricing (MUP) for alcohol
MESAS: Evaluation of minimum unit pricing (MUP) for alcohol
14 Cultural Competence Training, Assessment, and Evaluation of Cultural Competence, and Evidence-Based Practices in Culturally Competent Agencies.
Program Evaluation Essentials-- Part 2
as a determinate of health
Internal Assessment (IA)
Presentation transcript:

Evaluating Healthy Food Retail in Low-Income Urban Neighbourhoods L.M. Minaker, C. L. Mah, B.E. Cook May 29, 2014 CPHA 2014

Background Food environments are (probably) important for health Healthy food retail interventions may hold promise for improving diet

Over 500 measures exist!

Intervention

Study design OXOOOOXOOOO O O O

Evaluation Components Process evaluation Impact evaluation (environmental impact) Impact evaluation (individual/ household impact) Dose and reach of interventions Fidelity of HCS and MGFM implementation (including formative adaptations) Neighbourhood and municipal policy context Change in neighbourhood food environments Change in diets, attitudes, and purchasing patterns of community residents

Evaluation Design Sample: – low-income, adult apartment residents in Toronto. Predominantly newcomers. Mixed-methods: 3 neighbourhoods – Qualitative Pre-intervention focus groups with residents Post-intervention interviews with stakeholders – Quantitative Pre-post, controlled, quasi-experimental design Questionnaires and Web-based 24-diet recalls at Pre and Post Sales data (Point-of-Sale) throughout Neighbourhood food retail quality

Individual-level Assessment ASA24 Food Insecurity Food Purchasing Food environment perceptions Socio- demographic Food preferences & skills

Store-level Assessment

Neighbourhood-level Assessment Promotoras

Additional Observations Qualitative Observations – Focus groups – Interviews with stakeholders

Conclusions Population health intervention research is fairly new Interdisciplinary approaches are crucial for understanding the unanticipated outcomes and diverse impacts It’s time to move beyond assessment in public health

Acknowledgements Dr. Catherine Mah Dr. Brian Cook

The Propel Centre for Population Health Impact was founded by the Canadian Cancer Society and the University of Waterloo.