Targeted Interventions in Health Care: The case of PROMIN Sebastian Galiani Mercedes Fernandez Ernesto Schargrodsky.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys Survey Design Workshop
Advertisements

World Study on Poverty and Disparities in Childhood Panama, June 30 th and July 1 st, Childhood and Poverty in Brazil Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica.
Laurin Kasehagen, MA, PhD MCH Epidemiologist / CDC Assignee to CityMatCH Maternal & Child Health Epidemiology Program Applied Sciences Branch, Division.
HEALTH EQUITY: THE INDIAN CONTEXT Subodh S Gupta.
STATISTICS FOR MANAGERS LECTURE 2: SURVEY DESIGN.
Housing and Health Care Programs and Financing that Integrate Health Care and Housing Housing California Institute April 15, 2014 John Shen Long-Term Care.
FOOD INSECURITY IN PAKISTAN. Pakistan is the seventh most populous country in the world PAKISTAN – A PREVIEW Total Population – million Male : Female.
1.2.2 Geographical Targeting of Poverty Alleviation Programs 1 MEASUREMENT AND POVERTY MAPPING UPA Package 1, Module 2.
Assessing the impact of a policy on universal coverage on financial risk protection, health care finance, and benefit incidence of the Thai health care.
Displacement and forced sex: Haiti’s experience since the 2010 earthquake Nicholas Thomas, MPH, PhD candidate Department of Global Health Systems and Development,
Dr. Chris L. S. Coryn Spring 2012
Issues in Sampling and Sample Design – A Managerial Perspective CHAPTER 12 Research Methodologies.
Global Health Challenges Social Analysis 76: Lecture 6
Sampling and Sampling Procedures.  In most epidemiologic studies, we deal with a sample of the population  The study population may be:  An entire.
Performance of Community- based Management of Acute Malnutrition programme and its impact on nutritional status of children under five years of age in.
Sampling Concepts Population: Population refers to any group of people or objects that form the subject of study in a particular survey and are similar.
The Role of Consumer Knowledge on the Demand for Preventive Health Care Among the Elderly Stephen T. Parente, Ph.D., Project HOPE Center for Health Affairs.
12 th Global Conference on Ageing June 11-13, 2014 The Economic Support System for Senior Citizens in India: Restating the Obvious K S James Institute.
Aspects of the National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) Chris Moriarity National Conference on Health Statistics August 16, 2010
Is Free Care Truly Free and Equitable? The Case of Liberia CHALLENGES & LESSONS LEARNED S. Tornorlah Varpilah Tesfaye Dereje Chris Atim.
Impact Evaluation of Health Insurance for Children: Evidence from Vietnam Proposal Presentation PEP-AusAid Policy Impact Evaluation Research Initiative.
1 Rachel Torres, MPH, CHES Department of Health & Behavior Studies Teachers College, Columbia University Relationships between Health Literacy, Self- efficacy.
RESEARCH A systematic quest for undiscovered truth A way of thinking
Matching Methods. Matching: Overview  The ideal comparison group is selected such that matches the treatment group using either a comprehensive baseline.
Wealth, Education and Demand for Medical Care ___ Evidence from Rural China Feng Jin Qin Bei Yu Yangyang.
Health Indicators Mortality indicators Morbidity indicators
Ruralhealth.und.edu/research Social Determinates of Health: Rural Inequalities and Health Disparities.
Health Programme Evaluation by Propensity Score Matching: Accounting for Treatment Intensity and Health Externalities with an Application to Brazil (HEDG.
Health & Welfare Council of Long Island May 12, 2010.
Adjustment of benefit Size and composition of transfer in Kenya’s CT-OVC program Carlo Azzarri & Ana Paula de la O Food and Agriculture Organization.
 Health insurance is a significant part of the Vietnamese health care system.  The percentage of people who had health insurance in 2007 was 49% and.
Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys Survey Design Workshop Sampling: Overview MICS Survey Design Workshop.
Measuring Equality of Opportunity in Latin America: a new agenda Washington DC January, 2009 Jaime Saavedra Poverty Reduction and Gender Group Latin America.
1 South Carolina Medicaid Coordinated Care and Enrollment Counselors Programs.
1 Targeting and Calibrating Educational Grants: Focus on Poverty or on Risk of Non-Enrollment? Elisabeth Sadoulet and Alain de Janvry University of California.
Has Public Health Insurance for Older Children Reduced Disparities in Access to Care and Health Outcomes? Janet Currie, Sandra Decker, and Wanchuan Lin.
1 Sources of gender statistics Angela Me UNECE Statistics Division.
United Nations Economic Commission for Europe Statistical Division Sources of gender statistics Angela Me UNECE Statistics Division.
Name Institution Date. Description of the Target Population The target population for this study are the African- American population aged between
Family Health Program Brazil Coverage and access Aluísio J D Barros Andréa D Bertoldi Juraci Cesar Cesar G Victora Epidemiologic Research Center, UFPel.
Screen 1 of 23 Targeting Introduction to Targeting LEARNING OBJECTIVES Explain the key principles of targeting. Understand the steps of the targeting process.
Public Social Expenditures Education (2.3 percent of GDP) Health (1 percent of GDP) Social protection (1 percent of GDP) -- equal to $12 per capita and.
World Bank’s Thematic Group on Health, Nutrition and Population and Poverty REACHING THE POOR CONFERENCE, February, 2004 ASSESSING CHANGES IN TARGETING.
LEVELS OF HEALTH CARE VINITA VANDANA.
SAMPLING TECHNIQUES AND METHODS ‘CHAR’ FMCB SEMINAR PRESENTER: DR KAYODE. A. ONAWOLA 03/07/2013.
MDG data at the sub-national level: relevance, challenges and IAEG recommendations Workshop on MDG Monitoring United Nations Statistics Division Kampala,
Things that May Affect the Estimates from the American Community Survey Updated February 2013.
University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Effect of Parental Depression on School Attendance and Emergency.
Overview of targeting in Sub- Saharan Africa - the ongoing debate in the region Cash Transfers Workshop 21 st September 2010.
Dr. Miguel Székely, Deputy Minister for Social Developement Cape Town, South Africa, 2005.
The courage to make every life count Murwa Bhatti Program Manager, Maternal & Child Health Program, IRD Oct 14, HANIF meeting, Nathiagali.
Targeting of Public Spending Menno Pradhan Senior Poverty Economist The World Bank office, Jakarta.
BENEFIT INCIDENCE ANALYSIS FOR PUBLIC CHILD HEALTH AND NUTRITION PROGRAMS IN PERU Martín Valdivia Group of Analysis for Development February 2004.
Targeting Outcomes, Redux Coady, Grosh, and Hoddinott (forthcoming in World Bank Research Observer) Presentation at Reaching the Poor Conference Washington,
STATISTICAL DATA GATHERING: Sampling a Population.
International SBCC Summit
Concepts of Primary health care Ass.Prof:Dr:Essmat Gemaey
International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work (FPRW) Branch.
Evaluating Social Funds: A Cross- Country Analysis of Community Investments February 2004 Laura Rawlings, Lynne Sherburne-Benz, Julie Van Domelen.
© Plan International Xu Jian, Country Health Advisor, Plan China Piloting Children’s Medical Insurance in Rural China: The Experience of Plan China.
Immunization Coverage of Vulnerable Children: A Comparison of Health Center and National Rates Ashley Schempf, BS Robert Politzer, ScD Shannon Stokley,
1 TARGETING HEALTH INSURANCE TO THE POOR IN COLOMBIA By Tarsicio Castañeda Reaching the Poor Conference The World Bank, February 18-20, 2004.
At a glance Health access and utilization survey among non-camp refugees in Lebanon UNHCR November 2015.
The Income Divide in Health Care:
GSRHR course 2010 The Three Delays Model Pauline Binder, PhD student
Matching Methods & Propensity Scores
Matching Methods & Propensity Scores
Sampling Distributions
How the Affordable Care Act Has Improved Americans’ Ability to Buy Health Insurance on Their Own Findings from the Commonwealth Fund Biennial Health Insurance.
Presentation transcript:

Targeted Interventions in Health Care: The case of PROMIN Sebastian Galiani Mercedes Fernandez Ernesto Schargrodsky

State policies should expand access of the poor to social services (basic education, healthcare) Feasible alternative: targeting resources to the poor Benefits: Saves resources and increases efficiency. Costs: Identification of potential beneficiaries, disincentive effects, loss of political support. We study the targeting of PROMIN (Programa Materno Infantil y Nutrición), a program which attempts to improve infant and child health, reproductive health, and nutrition.

PROMIN targeting is a two-stage procedure: 1.In the first stage, poor localities are identified based on poverty levels. PROMIN centers are located in these areas. 2.In the second stage, households self-select into the program by deciding on their use of PROMIN centers We consider first geographical targeting and then, targeting at the household level, conditional on the geographical allocation of the program.

PROMIN and primary health care PROMIN seeks to improve primary medical attention in Argentina. The first Argentine experiences in this matter date to the decade of the 1940s. Primary health centers were created to: –treat ailments and diseases which could be tended without attending a hospital, and –foster the prevention of avoidable diseases by means of healthcare education programs.

A widespread view was that in Argentina, primary health centers did not take adequate account of the particular needs of the community in which they functioned. The PROMIN intervention was designed to improve and strengthen these centers, by implementing a three-level structure for medical attention 1. The community 2. The primary health center 3. The local hospital

The program’s goal was to improve medical attention at local centers. This did not imply building new centers. The quantity and distribution of health centers was considered to be “more than acceptable”, and the centers were thought to be appropriately located. Instead, its aim was to improve existing constructions and properly adapt them so as to adequately provide medical services.

There are several targeting mechanisms. They can be classified into –Individual assessment mechanisms –Group (or geographic) targeting mechanisms –Self-targeting mechanisms We now study PROMIN’s two-stage mechanism

Geographical Targeting Is PROMIN in fact located in the poorest localities? Proportion of Localities covered by PROMIN, by UBN UBN Range (%) Localities (%) 0 to to to More than PROMIN tends to be placed in localities where there are more poor people even though it may not be concentrated in the poorest localities.

Conditional Targeting In the areas where it operates, are the families that use its centers the poorest ones in the population? That is, where are the households that benefit from the program located in the local distribution of family income?

Conditional Targeting We need comparable information on earnings and family structure for both the population and PROMIN beneficiaries’ households. The information for the population is gathered from the ongoing household survey. For PROMIN users, we conducted a survey at a random sample of centers in 3 localities where the household survey is conducted – Rosario, Mar del Plata and La Rioja.

Conditional Targeting The families that use PROMIN centers are not the richest ones, and tend to be more concentrated among the bottom 5 deciles of the relevant population income distribution, with more weight in the deciles 2 to 4. Thus, although the targeting can be judged as satisfactory, it can certainly be improved by reducing some of the leakage presently existent.

Self-Selection: The Role of Distance We explore the determinants of self-selection into PROMIN. For this purpose, we rely on a second survey conducted to a random sample of households stratified by distance to the PROMIN centers where we conducted our first survey. For each household, we have information about the utilization of the PROMIN center for each child under 5 and any pregnant woman who is head or spouse of the head of household, or the daughter of the head or his spouse.

Self-Selection: The Role of Distance We estimate a discrete choice model where the endogenous decision is the utilization of the PROMIN center. We are interested in estimating the probability that a household with a given set of observed characteristics self-selects into a PROMIN center.

Table XIII: Logit model for children under 5 years old. Dependent variable: 1 if child uses PROMIN Independent variable Coefficient (Standard Error) Marginal Effect Coefficient (Standard Error) Marginal Effect Square root of family per capita income *** (0.034) *** (0.005) *** (0.037) *** (0.005) Sex of head of household (0.331) (0.059) 0.677** (0.346) 0.101* (0.059) Distance *** (0.299) 0.114*** (0.038) 1.110*** (0.326) 0.128*** (0.034) Distance (0.289) (0.042) (0.313) (0.038) Child is between 3 months and 1 year old 1.072* (0.619) 0.120** (0.051) (0.654) 0.091* (0.051) Child is between 1 and 2 years old 1.995*** (0.608) 0.194*** (0.041) 1.832*** (0.644) 0.158*** (0.038) Child is between 2 and 5 years old (0.509) (0.085) (0.543) (0.080) Child was sick in the past month 0.563** (0.264) 0.071** (0.034) Child has a chronic condition (0.410) (0.070)

Conclusions PROMIN coverage is concentrated in the large, high density municipalities where there are more poor people, although it does not reach many of the poorest localities. Within these localities, most of the households that use the program come from the poorest five deciles of the relevant income distribution, although there is non negligible leakage to higher income groups. Looking at measures of structural income other than current income leads to essentially similar conclusions. Thus, we believe that while targeting is certainly satisfactory, there is still room for improvement.

Conclusions Regarding self-selection, we find that a key issue in determining PROMIN utilization is location. Households living near the center are substantially more likely to use it than households further away. This points to the importance of the placement of the centers within the localities selected at the first stage.