Requirements for Standardization on the Service Registries ISO/IEC JTC1 SC32 2015/10/161 A comment to WSSG, JTC1 SC32WG2 N1209 2008.11.10.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
UDDI v3.0 (Universal Description, Discovery and Integration)
Advertisements

Status Report of the Study Group on MDR/MFI Implemenations ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32/WG2 Interim Meeting Santa Fe, NM, USA, November 11~15, 2013 Dongwon Jeong,
Road Map of WG2 New Project on “Framework for Registering Business Objects” Hajime Horiuchi Tokyo International University SC32 NXXX.
MMF reference model figures. PDES/STEP Registry Manufacturing ebXML Registry UDDI Component Registry GCI Registry EAN Registry CPFR Registry RosettaNet.
Interactive Systems Technical Design Seminar work: Web Services Janne Ojanaho.
1 Introduction to XML. XML eXtensible implies that users define tag content Markup implies it is a coded document Language implies it is a metalanguage.
Study Period Report: Metamodel for On Demand Model Selection (ODMS) Wang Jian, He Keqing, He Yangfan, Wang Chong State Key Lab of Software Engineering,
EbXML Registry Technical Committee n Defining and managing interoperable registries and repositories n The OASIS ebXML Registry TC develops specifications.
ebXML Registry Technical Committee Defining and managing interoperable registries and repositories Kathryn Breininger (TC Chair)The.
Processing of structured documents Spring 2003, Part 6 Helena Ahonen-Myka.
Introduction to UDDI From: OASIS, Introduction to UDDI: Important Features and Functional Concepts.
Introduction to ebXML Mike Rawlins ebXML Requirements Team Project Leader.
OASIS and Web Services Karl Best OASIS Director of Technical Operations.
Future of MDR - ISO/IEC Metadata Registries (MDR) Larry Fitzwater, SC 32 WG 2 Convener Computer Scientist U.S. Environmental Protection Agency May.
RGPS Metamodel Framework for Interaction between cloud and client HE Yangfan, HE Keqing, WANG Jian, WANG Chong SKLSE(WHU), P.R.China 32N1891.
Final Report on MFI & MDR Harmonization Hajime Horiuchi May 2010 SC32WG2 N1425.
Introduction of Registry Service Integration Architecture ~RSIA~ 22-August-2009 NEC Corporation.
SC32 Liaison report to SC Sept Plenary Denise Warzel JTC 1/SC 32/WG 2 Convenor SC 32 Liaison to SC 38.
WG2 Tutorial ISO/JTC1/SC32 Larry Fitzwater (202) SDC JE-4029.
Scenario for the Integration of MDR&MFI Ad-hoc Meeting, Wuhan H. Horiuchi Study Period on the Integration of MDR/MFI.
SC32 WG2 Metadata Standards Tutorial Metadata Registries and Big Data WG2 N1945 June 9, 2014 Beijing, China.
MFI Part-1: Reference Model 2 nd Edition Overview Co-editor: Hajime HORIUCHI Co-editor Keith GORDON For the discussion at Krakow: SC32WG2.
© 2010 TASC, Inc. | TASC Proprietary Laura J. Reece, Ph.D. for SOCoP workshop Dec 3, 2010 Standards Activities in Semantics and Ontologies.
Environmental Terminology Research in China HE Keqing, HE Yangfan, WANG Chong State Key Lab. Of Software Engineering
Final Report on Harmonization of MFI & MDR Hajime Horiuchi May SC32WG2 N 1533 OpenForum 2011 & SC32WG2 Meeting, May 2011, Kona, Hawaii.
OASIS ebXML Registry Standard Open Forum 2003 on Metadata Registries 10:30 – 11:15 January 20, 2003 Kathryn Breininger The Boeing Company Chair, OASIS.
Study Period Interim Report of RoR. - Registry Service Integration Architecture /11/12 SC32/WG2 Japan.
UDDI ebXML(?) and such Essential Web Services Directory and Discovery.
Classification and the Metadata Registry Judith Newton NIST IRS XML Stakeholders/ XML Working Group May 18, 2004.
ebXML Registry Technical Committee Defining and managing interoperable registries and repositories Voting members Kathryn Breininger.
Dr. Bhavani Thuraisingham October 2006 Trustworthy Semantic Webs Lecture #16: Web Services and Security.
1 MFI-5: Metamodel for Process models registration HE Keqing, WANG Chong State Key Lab. Of Software Engineering, Wuhan University
Interfacing Registry Systems December 2000.
Road Map of WG2 New Project on “Framework for Registering Business Objects” Hajime Horiuchi Tokyo International University SC32 NXXX.
Cooperating Registries Draft Content for OASIS/ebXML Reg/Rep f2f November 1, 2001 Bruce Bargmeyer (510)
The Final Study Period Report on MFI 6: Model registration procedure SC32WG2 Meeting, Sydney May 26, 2008 H. Horiuchi, Keqing He, Doo-Kwon Baik SC32WG2.
Study Period Report on Registration Procedure SC32WG2 Interim Meeting, Seoul H. Horiuchi SC32WG2 N1070.
Extensible Markup Language (XML) Extensible Markup Language (XML) is a simple, very flexible text format derived from SGML (ISO 8879).ISO 8879 XML is a.
MFI-6: Registration procedure SC32WG2 Meeting, Vilamoura, Portugal H. Horiuchi 1 SC32WG2 NXXXX.
1 The overview of NWI “Framework for Identification and Classification of Enterprise Objects” Hajime Horiuchi Masaharu Obayashi (Japan) ISO/IEC JTC1/SC32/WG2.
9 th Open Forum on Metadata Registries Harmonization of Terminology, Ontology and Metadata 20th – 22nd March, 2006, Kobe Japan. Presentation Title: Day:
Potential standardization items for the cloud computing in SC32 1 WG2 N1665 ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Plenary Meeting, Berlin, Germany, June 2012 Sungjoon Lim,
OASIS Symposium 4/04 Registry : Reliable Infrastructure Role of Registry : Reliable Infrastructure Carl Mattocks CEO CHECKMi Infrastructure Project Background.
Scope and Objectives of MFI family Hajime Horiuchi.
Study Report on ROR (Registry Of Registries) Hajime Horiuchi MFI Project Leader SC32WG2 N 1263.
EbXML (Electronic Business XML) Kanda Runapongsa Dept of Computer Engineering Khon Kaen University.
ISO/IEC JTC1 SC 32 WG1 eBusiness. WG 1 scope Standardization in the field of generic information technology standards for open electronic data interchange.
"Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?” "That depends a good deal on where you want to get to," said the Cat. -Lewis Carroll: Alice’s.
Final Study Report on ROR May 2010 SC32WG2 Kunming, China Hajime Horiuchi SC32WG2-N1423.
Overview of SC 32/WG 2 Standards Projects Supporting Semantics Management Open Forum 2005 on Metadata Registries 14:45 to 15:30 13 April 2005 Larry Fitzwater.
Copyright © Open Applications Group, Inc. All rights reserved Open Applications Group OAGIS Core Components WG Tax Component
Extending the MDR for Semantic Web November 20, 2008 SC32/WG32 Interim Meeting Vilamoura, Portugal - Procedure for the Specification of Web Ontology -
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Plenary and WGs Meetings Jeju, Korea, June 25, 2009 Jeong-Dong Kim, Doo-Kwon Baik, Dongwon Jeong {kjd4u,
Standards Development Organizations: Stakeholders Perspectives 16 September 2008 Mark Palmer UN/CEFACT Vice Chair U NITED N ATIONS C ENTRE F OR T RADE.
ebXML Registry Technical Committee Defining and managing interoperable registries and repositories Voting members Kathryn Breininger.
Concept of MFI-6: Registry Summary Hajime Horiuchi May SC32WG2 N 1543 SC32WG2 Meeting, May 2011, Kona, Hawaii.
ISO TC37/SC4 N435 Nov 12, 2007 Presented by Miran Choi/ETRI Written by Jae Sung Lee/Chungbuk National Univ.
Concept Proposal Sixth Open Forum on Metadata Registries Semantic Interoperability between Registries To be held January 20-24, 2003 Bruce Bargmeyer
July 11, 2008OASIS SET TC OASIS Semantic Support for Electronic Business Document Interoperability (SET) TC Overview.
EbXML Semantic Content Management Mark Crawford Logistics Management Institute
OASIS ebXML Registry Standard Open Forum 2003 on Metadata Registries 10:30 – 11:15 January 20, 2003 Kathryn Breininger The Boeing Company Chair, OASIS.
International/Interagency Collaboration – IT for Environmental Information & Environmental Data Exchange Network Copenhagen, Denmark April 25, 2002 Bruce.
WG2 Roadmap Discussion Denise Warzel May 25, 2010 WG2 Convenor SC32 WG2N1424SC32 WG2N1424.
Final Report on Harmonization of MFI & MDR and Disposition Hajime Horiuchi May18, 2011 SC32WG2 N1533-R1 SC32WG2.
Concept Presentation Sixth Open Forum on Metadata Registries To be held January 20-24, 2003 Bruce Bargmeyer
Report on Eighth Open Forum on Metadata Registries, Berlin, April 2005
XML Based Interoperability Components
Scope and Objectives of MFI family
Wsdl.
ISO/IEC (MFI-6) Scope definition & Document Structure
Presentation transcript:

Requirements for Standardization on the Service Registries ISO/IEC JTC1 SC /10/161 A comment to WSSG, JTC1 SC32WG2 N

SC32 perspectives to the registry Standardization SC32 recognize that there are so many different registry or metadata standard activities in both ISO or outside of ISO. To clarify requirements to the Service Registry standards, A taxonomy of registry type should be investigated in the discussion of the those standardizations. 2015/10/162

OAGIS Registry or Metadata related Standard Activities UN/CEFACT OMG ISO TC 37 ISO TC 204 Metadata or Registry Standards OASIS Intelligent Transportation Systems ISO/IEC MDR ISO/IEC19763 MFI UDDI.org W3C TC154 E-Commerce metadata XML, WSA,WSDL, SOAP Terminology UDDI SQL Catalog ISO TC 215 Health Informatics ISO TC127 Earth Moving machine ebXML RIM, RS SAML UBL Dublin Core ISO TC 46 Library metadata ISO TC211 Geographical data HL7 ISO/IEC JTC1 SC36 Topic map ebXML MOF, CWM, ODM ISO TC184 PLIB, CDD GS1 CCTS, UMM, UCM SIL, Products Catalog NATO ECCMA ISO8000 Learning Metadata ISO/IEC JTC1 SC32 ISO/IEC JTC1 SC34 EPC-G Rosseta Net 2015/10/163

An Idea for Taxonomy of Registry Types 4 Domain Specialty Diversity of Stakeholder Type-1 ProcessContents Type-3 Among Experts High (Narrow) Type-2 Cross Industries (BtoB) Metadata Dependent (Non Structural) Model Dependent (Structural) Low (Generic) High Target of the Standardizations System of Systems Registry Of Registries Cross Individuals Service registry 2015/10/16

Type-1 Registry Dedicated Registries for specialized closed domains such as Space & Air, Defense, Automobile or Medical industries to support high skilled engineer/experts like SOSE (System of Systems Engineering) Sharing models and process by domain experts. Registry User: limited experts. Example: – TC184: ISO13584 (IEC ) : Parts Library – TC184: ISO OTD ( Open Technical Dictionary ) – TC184: ISO29002: Concept dictionaries — Resolution services 2015/10/165

Registries to support cross industries B to B business information sharing in the e-business such as the Supply Chain or Traceability. ebXML RIM & RS is a typical standard in this type. But, different registry standards or non standardized registries were implemented in each industry domains (Heterogeneous Registries) Registry User: various different business domain experts ROR (Registry of Registries) standard might be needed Type-2 Registry 2015/10/166

ROR(Registry Of Registries) concept Heterogeneous RegistriesRegistry Interoperation Registry ROR ManufacturingLogisticRetails Registry ROR: Registry of Registry SC32 Seoul PDES/STEP Registry Manufacturing ebXML Registry UDDI Component Registry GCI Registry EAN Registry CPFR Registry RosettaNet Registry Business Negotiation Vender Catalog Shipper Catalog Business Category Shipping Customer Support Consumer Profile CALS Production Planning & Procurement System Development Registry The UDDI 3.0 specification is addressing this ROR concept as Multi-Registries Environment featuring Root & Affiliate registries. ISO/IEC (MFI: Metamodel Framework for Interoperability) in SC32 is also addressing the ROR concept. 2015/10/167

Registry for discovery of services and orchestration of services. the UDDI is typical registry in this type. Registry User: Unlimited Problems: – Who should be responsible in the contents maintenance – How to segregate from Google or Yahoo Type-3 Registry 2015/10/168

Comparison of Registry Types Registry TypeType-1Type-2Type-3 Typical Example PLIB Registry ebXML RIM & RS UDDI Purpose of Registry Integration of products in a specific industry Cross Industries information interchange (BtoB) Discovery of Service Major Contents Models & Products Specification Process & Regulations Metadata Business Information (MSG) Metadata Definitions of Service URL/IRI Access Protocols Maintenance Responsibility Covered by Integrator Agencies Covered by Agency in each industries ?? Diversity of Stakeholder ~4 10 8~9 Problems to be Considered MDA/SOC capability Complexity of contents Inharmonic registries ROR needed Justification of registering 2015/10/169

Risk at Type-2 & Type-3 Concentration of Maintenance efforts Concentration of RA(Registration Authority ) Difficulty on the tracking changes or versions Difficulty on assurance of ID or URI persistency Small returns on the registration efforts at users How to differentiate from Google or Yahoo Summary of comparison 2015/10/1610 Needs for standards of registry content definitions that enable Automatic Syndication without any central maintenances.

11 An Image for Automatic Syndication of Service Definitions Web service Saas Web Service Saas SD 2015/10/16 RaaS SD Saas SD Saas SD SD: Service Definition RaaS RaaS: Registry as a Service

SC32 Perspective SOAP/REST WSDL UDDI-X Automatic Syndication Service Definition Registration Metadata /model Registration Ontology Registration Service Registries Scope of SC /10/1612 ROR

Recommendations for WSSG The Service Registry should be considered as a type of the registries It should be investigated that Registry Standards for type-2 still needed to ensure the integrity and the security in Business domains (BtoB) or not. To promote standardization by the PAS procedure at this area, it is needed to organize and coordinate SDOs in both ISO & Industrial consortia more widely. SC32 initiated study projects on ROR and Metamodel for Service Definition, then,SC32 appreciates to share study results with the WSSG. 2015/10/1613