Outcomes Data 1. LOWER READMISSIONS 2. LESS ER USE 3. SATISFACTION Patient Staff 4. IMPROVED BIOMETRICS Diabetes Blood Pressure Weight Loss 5. BEHAVIOR.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
A Call for Partnerships Between Adult Literacy, Public Health, and Medicine Dean Schillinger, MD UCSF Associate Professor of Medicine Community Engagement.
Advertisements

PROVIDENCE CENTRALIA HOSPITAL EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT COMMUNITY ACCESS PROJECT Cindy Mayo, Chief Executive.
Multi-Payer Reimbursement Pilot Overview of Risk/Benefit to Practices L Gordon Moore MD.
Care Coordination Program for Heart Failure Susan Levine RN Director Clinical Resource Management Carolyn Timmons BSN,RN Lead Clinical Care Coordinator.
Integrated Disease Management at HealthPartners Health Care Transformation Task Force Meeting August 16, 2007 N. Marcus Thygeson, MD Associate Medical.
MAMSI Health Plans 2003 (c)1 Evaluating Disease Management Return on Investment “Lessons Learned” Sally J. Duran Disease Management Summit May 11, 2003.
Consumer Health Self-Care. Purposes of Self-Care Health Promotion Self-Diagnosis Home Medical Tests Self-Treatment of Chronic Diseases Organizations Self-Help.
It’s A Success! Achieving Cost-Effective Disease Management in CHF Sherry Shults, RN BSN CIO South Carolina Heart Center.
1 Care Kits The Proven Transition-of-Care Solution.
Care Kits 1 Focus on the Patient to Improve Care and Reduce Health Care Costs.
Access Health Closing the Gap Between Public and Private Insurance Coverage.
Care Coordination What is it? How Do We Get Started?
PREVENTING READMISSIONS OF CONGESTIVE HEART FAILURE PATIENTS Daidreanna Whiteman Senior Project Columbus State University Summer 2014.
Saeed A. Khan MD, MBA, FACP © CureMD Healthcare ACOs and Requirements for Reporting Quality Measures © CureMD Healthcare Saeed A. Khan MD, MBA, FACP.
2 AMERIGROUP Community Care Entered Maryland market in 1999 Largest MCO in Maryland Serving over 143,000 members in Baltimore City and 20 counties in.
Robert Margolis, M.D. Chairman & CEO HealthCare Partners ACO’s – Getting from Here to There Benefits / Risks / Opportunities.
... a KAISER PERMANENTE Innovation IndiGO: Tailoring Guidelines to Individuals David M Eddy MD PhD Founder and Chief Medical Officer Emeritus Archimedes.
Memorial Hermann Healthcare System Clinical Integration & Disease Management Dan Wolterman April 15, 2010.
Measuring the Quality of Pennsylvania’s Commercial HMOs Joe Martin Director of Communications and Education Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council.
Lifestyles in Malta 2007 A Survey Study Judith Rocchiccioloi, PhD., RN Karen Jagiello, RN, MSN James Madison Univesity.
Home Health Education, Special Meal Provision, and the Heart Failure Patient Christine A. Rovinski, ARNP, MSN OEF OIF Program Manager Veteran Affairs Medical.
* The Asheville Project * An Ounce of Prevention Really IS Worth a Pound of Cure Barry A. Bunting, Pharm.D. Clinical Manager of Pharmacy Services Mission.
1 Care Kits The Proven Transition-of-Care Solution.
Community Oncology Conference Thursday April 23 rd, 2015.
What Are You Worth? Demonstrating the Value of Your Program to Your Community and Potential Investors Ethan Joselow, MPH.
James Schuster, MD, MBA VP, Behavioral Integration May 21, 2015 Using data to engage members with complex medical conditions.
The Significance of Outcome Data at The FREE Foundation.
Connected Health: Using patient-centric technologies to change behavior and improve outcomes Joseph C. Kvedar, MD Director Center for Connected Health.
PUTTING THE PIECES TOGETHER: REDUCING AVOIDABLE READMISSIONS.
Diabetes Free Zone ™ Diabetes Wellness Can Help Prevent a $35,000 Amputation or a $100,000 Heart Attack. That’s Wellness that Makes Financial Sense.
A Unique Health Care Empowerment Solution. Care Kits Drive Results! Improve Care & Drive Down Costs Provides the curriculum, tools and devices for successful.
American Institute for Preventive Medicine
T H E A C T I V A T E D P A T I E N T Integrating Self-Direction with Provider Support Shirley Grey RN MSN RESULTS.
Steps for Success in EHR Planning Bill French, VP eHealth Strategies Wisconsin Office of Rural Health HIT Implementation Workshop Stevens Point, WI August.
CMS as a Public Health Agency: Effective Health Care Research Barry M. Straube, M.D. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services January 11, 2006.
Where there is valid and reliable literature evidence regarding “best practice”, use it Premier Demo/ Hospital Quality Metrics/ Core Measures HCHAPS for.
The Santa Barbara County Care Data Exchange Ronald A. Paulus, M.D., M.B.A. President, CareScience.
Creating Value for Health IFA 2012 Global Conference on Aging Dr. John Tarrant 118 Old Lafayette Ave Lexington, Kentucky USA
Internet-based Telemedicine for Cardiovascular Disease Management Alfred A. Bove, MD, PhD Cardiology Section Temple University Medical Center.
One Health Information Exchange’s experience in responding to the changing landscape Funding: AHRQ Contract ; State of Tennessee; Vanderbilt.
1 Paul McGann, MD CMS Chief Medical Officer for Quality Improvement Dennis Wagner, MPA Director, Quality Improvement & Innovation Group U.S. Department.
Population Health Janet Appel, RN, MSN Director of Informatics and Population Health.
Community Paramedic Payment Reform December 2 nd,2015 Terrace Mall- North Memorial.
Quality Improvement and Care Transitions in a Medical Home Maryland Learning Collaborative May 21, 2014 Stephanie Garrity, M.S., Cecil County Health Officer.
Emanuel Medical Center Case Management By: Deadre Hadden, RN.
Redefining Care for Seniors and the Chronically Ill Gary German President & CEO New York, NY
Remote Monitoring and Chronic Care Management: A Community Health Center Model of Care Kim A. Schwartz CEO Roanoke Chowan Community Health Center November.
Can Nurses Assist Older CHF Patients With Self-Care? Sallie A. Alvarez NGR 5800 American Heart Association.
The Role of Health Information Technology in Implementing Disease Management Programs Donald F. Wilson, MD Medical Director Quality Insights of Pennsylvania.
Early patient returns trigger fines up to $1 million for 7 metro Detroit hospitals Patricia Anstett Detroit Free Press August 27, 2012
Chronic disease management: Doctor’s office to remote patient monitoring November 2, 2015 Presenters: Rusty Williams - Vice President and Chief Information.
PREVENTION OF READMISSIONS By Michael Burns Widener University.
Community Paramedic Primary Care Project.
“My Life, My Health” The Stanford University Chronic Disease Self-Management Program.
Managed Care Nursing Facility Quality Initiatives February 2, 2015.
Cindy Tumbarello, RN, MSN, DHA September 22, 2011.
Conference 2009 Nurse 2.0 Engaging the Healthcare Consumer Remote Patient Monitoring Debbie Schmidt RN, MCSE.
Sea View Hospital Rehabilitation Center & Home Nancy Endozo, R.N., B.S.N. Marian McNamara, R.N. M.S.N. Reduction of Antipsychotic Medication in the Long.
Characteristics of Health Activation Solutions
MRSA Regina Livshits RN MSN NYU Langone Medical Center
Kagman Community Health Center
Home Health Remote Patient Monitoring For Heart Failure
Grand-Aides: Transitional/ Chronic Care Management S
The Trust and MiPCT Partnerships in Health Care Innovation
Sometimes it’s a knock on the door that can make all the difference.
Bending the Cost Curve A Case for Integration.
Using the SafeMed model for transitions of care approach
Using the SafeMed model for transitions of care approach
Structures, Process and Outcome
Presentation transcript:

Outcomes Data 1. LOWER READMISSIONS 2. LESS ER USE 3. SATISFACTION Patient Staff 4. IMPROVED BIOMETRICS Diabetes Blood Pressure Weight Loss 5. BEHAVIOR CHANGE 6. STAFF PRODUCTIVITY 7. COST SAVINGS Seven parameters tested in Care Kit studies to date

Statistical reliability: The probability that the results were due to chance is less than 1% An improvement greater than 15%. The American Society of Quality Control says this level of change is breakthrough innovation A validated measurement. When you measure one way, then measure another way and get the same result, your initial measurement is valid. Success where others have failed. If you achieve results where national authorities say results are hardest to achieve What Makes an Outcome Compelling? Results are replicated. When you not only do it once, but over and over and over and over and… >99 % > 15 % ✔ On the outcomes report slides that follow, watch for a Ribbon Symbol to see which of these 5 reasons make that outcome compelling

95% 0 7.4% BEFORE: Vitas Medical Center NJ had used books from the American Lung Association, so clinical accuracy was assured. WITH CARE KITS: Distributing the Care Kits, with no other changes or interventions, More than doubled adherence Eliminated readmissions Reduced ER use by 72% Persistence 6 mo 44% Readmissions 16% Use of the ER 26% Asthma Care Kits alone Eliminated Readmissions BEFORE AFTER EVIDENCE that CLINCAL ACCURACY by itself is not adequate for effective PATIENT COMMUNICATION The probability that the outcome was chance is less than 1%. That means if you adopt Care Kits, it’s 99% likely you’ll see comparable results See Appendix for calculations >99 %

Data collected from each group at 6 months Study designed & conducted by hospital staff BEFORE: Northwest Community Medical Center had failed to change behavior with a year-long Disease Management program Heart Failure Care Kits Changed Behavior Weighing Daily Taking Blood Pressure Medication Compliance 27% 14% 77% 86% 14% 59% BEFORE AFTER IMPROVEMENT 514% 321% 185% EVIDENCE: CARE KITS ARE MORE EFFECTIVE AT ENGAGEMENT BEFORE AFTER The probability that the outcome was chance is less than 1%. That means if you adopt Care Kits, it’s 99% likely you’ll see comparable results See Appendix for calculations >99 %

J Reeves, MD Director Nevada State QIO J Ambulatory Care Management V36, No. 2, pp March 2013 Multiple Conditions in a Medical Home Care Kits saved $1.5 million TOTAL MEDICAL COST Blood pressure Cholesterol Blood sugar Emergency Room visits In-hospital days Health Plan net savings exceeded $56 PMPM $1.5 million / 1000 members Member savings = 30% lower out-of-pocket cost than the alternate PPO plan 54% “Breakthrough Innovation” says the American Society for Quality > 15 % 712 participants 24 months 85% better scores 23% lower 16% fewer visits Imaging services 35% lower use fewer days COMPARED TO BASELINE YEAR Prescription cost per member 18% lower cost

Discharge Teaching Time Care Kits Improve Quality & Productivity 144% improvement in standardization of time spent at discharge “Breakthrough Innovation” says the American Society for Quality > 15 % Care Kits

BEFORE AFTER 17% 0% 92% ER Returns Readmissions in less than 31 days After Prostate Surgery Care Kits eliminated ER Returns and Readmits Control and Intervention Groups were concurrent BEFORE AFTER in less than 31 days St. Joseph Mercy Hospital Ann Arbor Michigan “Breakthrough Innovation” says the American Society for Quality > 15 %

TIME OUT! “These results are not credible. They’re too good.” “There must be flaws in the study designs.” Communication Science researchers shadow hundreds of patients at home, in the workplace and around the community. For each condition, they find the problem preventing adherence and they fix it just as the consumer products industry has done for decades. Observational research increases consumer products sales by giant proportions. Why not health care? The model for fixing adherence is not clinical, where a new treatment may improve a condition by a small percentage. The model is mechanical, where you take a broken machine to the mechanics and they fix it. But let’s not argue. Set up your own study for Care Kits. See for yourself, on your own terms

AFTER BEFORE XX CSI Over 140/90 88% Below 140/80 12% Employer Wellness Initiative: Prior year home visit program had failed Home visit outcome: 12% in control Care Kit outcome: 88% in control All readings confirmed at clinic after six months 6% 88% Hypertension Care Kits performed 6 X better than face-to-face visits Results were measured one way, then confirmed by measuring a different way = valid results ✔

We took them on in South Carolina using outcomes analysis software CMS: “Truckers are the most difficult employee group to effect behavior change.” Multiple Conditions Care Kits are the first to achieve ROI with Truckers Return on Investment For every $1 the trucking company invested, they received $1.79 in savings --to our knowledge, the first successful trucker health intervention Success exceeding levels previously achieved by all others

Diabetes Care Kits could serve well as curriculum for classes P= 97% CARE KIT CLASSES New York City Cleveland, OH Readmissions in 30 days 10.4% <1% 9.6% 5.9% Emergency in 30 days Head-to-Head with Diabetic Education Classes CARE KIT CLASSES Impact after three months A1c Score Care Kits were >90% better at preventing readmits 39% better at preventing ER returns Care Kits brought down A1C numbers after classes had not impacted population Success exceeding levels previously achieved by all others

Success exceeding levels previously achieved by all others Patient Satisfaction Care Kits achieved 33% higher scores “Were you satisfied with the materials for self care?” “Did they help you manage your condition?” Hypertension Yes – 94.9% No – 2.9% Diabetes Yes – 93.6% No – 6.4% CAD Yes –100% University of Pittsburgh Health Plan Press-Ganey national 5-year average = 72% Care Kit UPMC 5-year average = 96% Heart Failure Yes – 97.3% No – 1.8% Asthma Yes – 92.5% No – 2.5%

AMA said getting >33% of the population to comprehend = impossible 154 Patients from Orthopedic and Abdominal Surgery Nurses called one week after discharge, “Were you able to follow your instructions without asking anyone for help or calling back the doctor or the hospital?” Before Care Kits After Care Kits “How satisfied were you with discharge?” Before Care Kits After Care Kits 35% 100% 92% 4% RUSH Medical Center “ Patient Satisfaction” Hospital Peer Review Journal September 2000 Post Surgical Dressings Care Kits outperformed Education Committee Success exceeding levels previously achieved by all others

St. Joseph, Lexington KY St. Joseph, Elgin IL NWC, Arlington Hts. IL DRG 127 ONLY NWC, Arlington Hts. IL ALL CHF-RELATED DRGs Aurora, Milwaukee WI Great Plains, Elk City OK Mercy Hospital, Chicago VA, Ann Arbor MI BEFORE AFTER REDUCED BY 6.4% 4.0% 38% 16.7% 7.7% 54% 13.2% 8.7% 34% 22.2% 6.3% 72% 8.6% 2.2% 73% 23.4% 6.9% 74% >28% 0% 100% 90 days Thompson-Reuters Statistical Analysis Heart Failure Care Kits Reduce or Eliminate Readmissions 58.2% 35.5% 39% 30 days 60 days When you achieve outcomes over and over and over and over again

Summary: Compelling Results Statistical Reliability Breakthrough Innovation Validated Measurement Exceeded authorities’ threshholds for success We have achieved >99% reliability in Diabetes, Hypertension, HF, Asthma, Post-Surgery, et.al. Our worst performance, 34% = more than double the “breakthrough” definition. Many outcomes >70%, even 100% Self-reported confirmed by clinic measurement Self-reported confirmed by software analysis Self-reported confirmed by Thompson-Reuters CMS: Truckers most resistant; achieved ROI National average 72%; Care Kit average 96% AMA prediction = 66%; Care Kit result = 92% “If you were a drug, you’d be approved” --F. I. Orkin, former Corporate Director of Quality and Regulatory, Baxter Healthcare Replicated Results Dozens of studies, all with breakthrough results >99 % > 15 % ✔

√ READMISSIONS P >99% USE OF THE ER Appendix: Statistical Reliability P >99% PERSISTENCE at 6 MONTHS As many times as you repeat a study, statistics says 99% of the outcomes will fall within + or – 3 standard deviations of the initial result. The chance of a result outside ±3Σ is less than 1%

1550 Barclay Boulevard Buffalo Grove IL Michael Weiss President Shirley Grey RN MSN VP Health Plans Carol Outland RN MSN VP Home Care Judith Farah Director of Operations Sylvia Aruffo PhD Chief Content Officer