It’s an Information Jungle Out There!

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Evaluating Electronic Information
Advertisements

Evaluating Websites. Why is it so important to evaluate websites ? Think about these differences… Print Books or Magazine Articles  Checked for accuracy.
Beyond GoogleGoogle Research Quality Web Searching, Part 2 Joe Barker jbarker at library.berkeley.edu John Kupersmith jkupersm at library.berkeley.edu.
 Most books you find in library nonfiction are credible.  Most large newspapers are credible. ◦ New York Times ◦ Washington Post  Scholarly journals.
John Kupersmith jkupersm [at] library.berkeley.edu A “Know Your Library” Workshop Teaching Library, University of California, Berkeley Spring 2009 Research-quality.
Frankenstorm 2012 Hurricane Sandy. A horrific environmental disaster...
Evaluating Web Sites The Internet is a great place to find information. But, has anyone ever told you not to believe everything you read? Web Sites are.
Websites vs. Databases Glenforest Secondary School Library Resource Centre Primary Source: M. Rosettis, St. Augustine.
Website Evaluation Using the internet for research.
Evaluating Websites Using the 5 W’s. What is the Internet? The internet is a vast source of information from around the WORLD. REMEMBER : You can’t always.
SEARCHING FOR TRUTH Defining Student Research Skills Bonnie McCormick, Librarian Ronny Crownover Middle School Denton ISD.
1 Internet Detective Searching for Clues Evaluating Web Sites C. Johnson.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Website Evaluation Using the internet for research.
Evaluating Web Sources West Fargo School District.
Have You Evaluated??? Is that site good enough to cite???
English 115 Web Site Evaluation Hudson Valley Community College Marvin Library Learning Commons 1.
Website Evaluations Good stuff vs Bad stuff History 2d1.
An IMPORTANT Skill!. CCurrency RReliability AAuthority/Accuracy PPurpose/Point of View.
World Wide Web Resources What Do the Experts Say About Web Pages? February, 2001.
 As you research, you will use print, database and internet resources for information.  The print and database resources in the library (such as online.
QUESTIONS ABOUT WEBSITES. But, how do you know if the information is good, accurate and reliable ? Websites from the Internet can be fast and easy to.
Evaluating the Internet. Why is the internet (the free web) both a “good” and “bad” place to find information for a scholarly paper? “Good” Source “Bad”
Evaluating Websites Do you trust everyone to tell you the truth? Osama bin Laden, Terrorist Was one of FBI’s 10 Most Wanted Fugitives Reward:
Evaluating Websites… The truth is out there - but so is the lie..
CRITICAL EVALUATION Why Evaluate What You Find on the Web? Anyone can put up a Web page about anything for pennies in minutes Many pages not kept up-to-date.
Evaluating Web Pages Techniques to apply and questions to ask.
Purdue University Writing Lab Research and the Internet Adapted from the Purdue University Writing Lab by Dr. K.
Evaluating Websites Do you trust everyone to tell you the truth? Osama bin Laden, Terrorist Was one of FBI’s 10 Most Wanted Fugitives Reward:
4 Criteria for Web Evaluation ELEMENTARY (BASIC) This is an easy way to teach students how to evaluate web resources: 1.Content 2.Authority/Reliability.
NATIONAL AGENCY FOR EDUCATION Check the Source! - Web Evaluation
 Think about your favorite movie.  Think, specifically, about why you thought it was good. › What did you look for? › What made it your favorite? 
Web Research Guide Evaluating Websites Mrs. Roesler September 2012.
Lesson 6, Unit 3 Using the Internet for Research Based on the Plan Ahead educational materials made available by Gap Inc. at and.
“But I read it On the Internet!” Evaluating Websites Lisa C. Wallin.
Internet Literacy Evaluating Web Sites. Objective The Student will be able to evaluate internet web sites for accuracy and reliability The Student will.
Research Finding good information. How do you search for information? Internet Wikipedia Print resources (books, magazines, encyclopedias, etc.) Databases.
Evaluating Web Pages Techniques to apply and questions to ask.
ONLINE RESOURCES. 5W+H RULE Anyone (professionals, students, idiots, terrorists, etc.) can post something online for the world to read, which makes it.
1 NAME_________________________________ LIBRARY ORIENTATION--DAY EIGHT CRITICAL EVALUATION OF SOURCES “All researchers, students as well as professional.
WALT use the internet to find information. WILF Use safe internet surfing skills How to narrow a search What to do if your find something inappropriate.
 Take out the following materials: 1. Your research links if you did not turn them in yesterday 2. Signed Movie Permission Forms 3. Your ALWG text 4.
The Research Paper Finding Valid, Credible, and Accurate Sources.
Research Skills for Your Essay Where to begin…. Starting the search task for real Finding and selecting the best resources are the key to any project.
Your Social Studies teacher wants you to learn about Egypt. You choose to research mummies. Where would you start?
GET “R.E.A.L.” Website Evaluation in 4 easy steps.
Hudson Valley Community College Marvin Library Web Site Evaluation
Reliable and UNRELIABLE Sources
Marvin Library Web Page
Evaluating Websites.
Reliable vs. Unreliable Web Sources
EVALUATING WEB BASED INFORMATION
EVALUATING WEB BASED INFORMATION
Internet Literacy Evaluating Web Sites.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
ABCs of Website Evaluation
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Is it a Good Web Site to use?
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Credible Sources.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
HMMMMMM….. So Many Resources, So Little Time! By: Mrs. Papiano.
Why is there CRAAP in my classroom?
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Evaluating Internet Resources
Presentation transcript:

It’s an Information Jungle Out There!

Not All Web Sites are Equal How do you sort the good ones from the bad? How do you sort the good ones from the bad?

Let’s Imagine that Your Assignment is to… Write a report about Egyptian mummies Write a report about Egyptian mummies

How Will You Find Information? Many students use the Internet first because it’s fast!

Web Sites on Egyptian Mummies….. With a few mouse clicks on a search engine, you’ll find hundreds or thousands of web sites With a few mouse clicks on a search engine, you’ll find hundreds or thousands of web sites

How Will You Know Which Web Sites are the Best? Which web sites do I trust? How can I tell if the Web Site has accurate information?

For Reliable Searching on the Internet… Use reputable search engines that are owned and managed by professional librarians, such as They are custom safe Google search engines that only search web sites recommended by librarians, teachers, and educational consortia

For Reliable Searching on the Internet… Use Internet directories sponsored by educators or librarians such as… Use Internet directories sponsored by educators or librarians such as… Internet Public Library (ipl.org) Internet Public Library (ipl.org) Best Info on the Net Best Info on the Net(

For Reliable Searching on the Internet… Use databases that your school library subscribes to Ask your librarian how to access them at school AND at home

Why Aren’t all Web Sites Equal? Remember that anyone can build a web site I create web sites in my spare time!

Why Aren’t all Web Sites Equal? Some web sites have information that is wrong or misleading Some web sites have information that is wrong or misleading Hey dude, that web site says there’s no school today!

Why Aren’t all Web Sites Equal? Some web sites are more interested in selling something—a product or a point of view—than providing the straight facts Some web sites are more interested in selling something—a product or a point of view—than providing the straight facts This water has been proven to be the best for your health!

When You’re On Your Own… Use these eight critical research skills to distinguish good web sites from the bad

Eight Critical Research Skills 1.Who sponsors the Web site? The name of the person or group in charge of the site should be on their home page. The name of the person or group in charge of the site should be on their home page. Is the sponsor trying to sell a product or promote a political view? Is the sponsor trying to sell a product or promote a political view?

Critical Research Skills 2.Who wrote the material? If no one takes responsibility for the content, don’t trust the information. Is the author an expert in the subject? If so, the content is likely to be good.

Critical Research Skills 3. How much information does the site provide? The site is really helpful if it is rich in content. Is the information complete?

Critical Research Skills 4.Is the information balanced? Beware of sites that give only one side of a controversial issue or that try to persuade you to accept one point of view. Beware of sites that give only one side of a controversial issue or that try to persuade you to accept one point of view.

Critical Research Skills 5. Is the material well written? Are the pages full of misspelled words and bad grammar? The facts may be inaccurate as well. Are the pages full of misspelled words and bad grammar? The facts may be inaccurate as well. Didn’t they use a spell- checker???

Critical Research Skills 6. When was the Web Page last updated? Look for dates on the page. A page that hasn’t been updated may contain outdated information. Last Updated June 1,

Critical Research Skills 7. Does the site list reliable sources for the information it provides? Where did the information come from? My web site doesn’t need any sources!

Good Web Sites… A good site will give you a way to check the information A good site will give you a way to check the information A good site will have updated links to other sources of information on the Web A good site will have updated links to other sources of information on the Web

Critical Research Skills 8. Is the site easy to use? Can you go to any place on the site from one page? This is so easy to use!

Use these eight critical research skills…. 1) Who sponsors the Web site? 2) Who wrote the material? 3) How much information does the site provide? Is it complete? 4) Is the information balanced?

Use these eight critical research skills…. 5) Is the material well written? 6) When was the Web Page last updated? Is it current? 7) Does the site list reliable sources for the information it provides? 8) Is the site easy to use?

Use these eight research skills… and you’ll be a successful Internet user!

Presentation by: Dr. Michael Bell and Carole Bell, Librarians/teachers for over 35 years! Dr. Michael Bell and Carole Bell, Librarians/teachers for over 35 years! Webmasters and Owners of Webmasters and Owners of Contact us at:

Citations Clipart from Microsoft Clip Art Gallery Clipart from Microsoft Clip Art Gallery Original music produced from Apple’s GarageBand Original music produced from Apple’s GarageBand It's an Information Jungle Out There! by Carole and Michael Bell is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Based on a work at It's an Information Jungle Out There! by Carole and Michael Bell is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Based on a work at and Michael BellCreative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported Licensewww.infotopia.infoCarole and Michael BellCreative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported Licensewww.infotopia.info Contact us at: