Germany and Scotland November 2010. Germany – another complex story! Commitment to planning, with good planning being done all over, above all at local.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Health Doing Business with the World - The new role of corporate leadership in global development Geneva, September 2007 World Business Council for Sustainable.
Advertisements

The Future of the CECA Rail Forum Infrastructure – the state of the market Alasdair Reisner Director of external affairs CECA.
Workshop on National Platforms 23 – 29 August 2008, Davos Switzerland Federal Department of Foreign Affairs FDFA Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation.
Task Force Fostering and Building Human Capital Opportunities for Regional Cooperation in South Eastern Europe Sofia, 4 April 2008.
The Africa Action Plan An IEG Evaluation CSO Forum April 15, 2011.
Forschungszentrum Jülich in der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft IEF – Systems Analysis and Technology Evaluation (STE) J.-F. Hake Facing the truth: EU energy policy.
1 EU Strategy for the Baltic Sea Region as a tool to implement the EU2020 European Commission Directorate General Regional Policy Territorial Cooperation.
Implications for the Regions EU-Regional Policy 1 Governance White Paper Introduction Adoption of White Paper on European Governance, July 25, 2001 Aim:
Istanbul October 2010: EastAgri Annual Meeting – RT4 – Investing across borders: The way forward for agriculture and rural development in the Balkan.
FTA-Approaches integrated in the broader SPI Context Improving Regional RTDI Policies & Investments *G. Clar, **H. Acheson, *S. Hafner-Zimmermann, *B.
Lifelong Guidance: A Key to Lifelong Learning – EU Policy Perspective John McCarthy European Commission DG EAC Vocational Training Policy Unit.
1 Macro-regions a new test of the integrated approach territorial cohesion: improving policy coherence on the ground.
Open Days 2007 – 10 Oct. Territorial Impacts of EU Sector Policies Dr Kai Böhme Origin of Territorial Impact Assesssments (TIA) TIA experience and results.
Perspectives on Regulation in Transport in BiH Presentation at Conference on Regulatory Governance and Network Industries Richard Westler, Secretary General,
Transport Policy And The Environment Professor David Gray The Centre for Transport Policy The Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen.
Infrastructure investment in international comparison.
1 SDC Climate Change Event Dr Keith MacLean Head of Policy and Public Affairs.
Scotlands Third National Planning Framework Proposed Framework Ambition Opportunity Place.
A Multimodal Goods Movement Strategy for Ontario Canada-United States Transportation Border Working Group Fall Plenary November 7 – 8, 2012 James Perttula.
Policy related outputs from GILDED: the Aberdeen City and Shire context Keith Marshall.
Land use for bioenergy production – assessing the production potentials and the assumptions of EU bioenergy policy Trends and Future of Sustainable Development.
South Africa’s S&T partnership with the European Union From FP4 to Horizon 2020 Daan du Toit Senior S&T Representative to the EU.
Energy Efficiency Strategy. THE ENERGY WHITE PAPER Energy White Paper sets out four key goals for energy policy to: Cut the UK’s carbon dioxide emission.
N.Vakalis, MEP, ITRE “Greek experiences in using Structural funds for regional development” Conference "Research and Innovation - an Opportunity for Convergence.
ESPON Gateway Workshop 27 November 2013, Brussels Dr Kai Böhme Spatial Foresight Potentials to strengthen Europe’s gateway cities and regions.
1 SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORT AL. 2 The White Paper 2001  The 2001 White paper proposed almost 60 measures designed to implement a transport system capable.
Workshop on Transportation Corridor Evaluation With a focus on Economic and Community Development.
Location conditions and locations factors Location conditions and factors define characteristics which vary from place to place and directly (indirectly)
Connections and the Third Sector
System of Environmental-Economic Accounting SEEA Implementation Guide and Diagnostic Tool Alessandra Alfieri UNSD.
UN-Water Water Country Briefs Introduction & Background Frederik Pischke Interagency Water Advisory UN-Water Frederik Pischke Interagency Water Advisory.
ECONOMIC SYSTEMS. Different Economic Systems – Economic Questions  WHAT IS ECONOMICS? The study of how resources are managed in the production, exchange,
System of Environmental-Economic Accounting SEEA Implementation Guide and Diagnostic Tool and Suggested Structure for Assessment United Nations Statistics.
TOPIC INTRO TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE Courtesy of Katie Gjerpen, Niles North Head Debate Coach.
Challenges and Opportunities in Developing Rural Regions Dr Patricia O’Hara.
Transport Sustainable Mobility and Integrated Planning in Urban Areas: Trade Union Dialogue with Local Authorities Day 2: 5th February 2013, SESSION 1:
The Role of Infrastructure in Development Cooperation a Norad Perspective Bergen 14 June 2005 Morten Svelle, Director Department for Environment and Private.
QER SMT Scenario Planning Workshop by Professor Ron Johnston 28 April 2009 Brisbane.
Rome Energy Meeting 2008 Rome, November 2008 Investments Opportunities and Project Finance in the Energy Market Luigi Marsullo President Finpublic.
Infrastructure and spatial planning – general recommendations November 2010.
Impact of Liberalization of the Electricity Market on Energy Efficiency, Quality of Supply and Environmental Performance Eric BONNEVILLE ECI Webconference.
Green Paper on National Strategic Planning The Presidency November 2009.
Strategic Priorities of the NWE INTERREG IVB Programme Harry Knottley, UK representative in the International Working Party Lille, 5th March 2007.
Trade liberalisation in Chile: How can sustainable development be safeguarded? Nicola Borregaard Workshop Brasilia, 29-30th March 2004 Organised by Tufts.
Connecting England The Report of the TCPA Commission for the Vision of England Professor Sir Peter Hall National Planning Forum 20 June 2006.
EUROPEAN SOCIAL FUND EQUAL - The European Perspective EQUAL Initiative EQUAL The European Perspective Dublin - 25 September 2003 Ian Livingstone European.
Canada’s Asia-Pacific Gateway and Corridor Initiative 2006.
Regulatory and development framework: the key role of TSO cooperation Sopot, November 28 th, 2011 Hervé MIGNON RTE (France)
The Regional Transport Strategy Transport for Regional Growth Conference Edinburgh 5 November 2015 John Saunders SEStran.
E u r o p e a n C o m m i s s i o nCommunity Research Global Change and Ecosystems EU environmental research : Part B Policy objectives  Lisbon strategy.
Waikato Mayoral Forum Progress on a Waikato Spatial Plan.
NS4054 Fall Term 2015 North America Energy Trilemma.
Infrastructure planning in the UK – old and new stories November 2010.
Labour law in contemporary world: discussion of selected issues in light of European experiences Corinne Vargha International Labour.
Europe 2020: A Connected Continent Gerard de Graaf European Commission DG Connect Director ‘Coordination’ NGN Conference Athens, 13 February 2014.
European integration, domestic interest associations A Comparative Perspective Prof. Dr. Jan Beyers ACIM.
Aid for Trade Progress on the Initiative in 2007 and Report on the Mandate to ECA Stephen N. Karingi Chief, Trade and International Negotiations Section,
SEMINAR THE EMPLOYMENT IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE POLICIES CASE STUDY 2, SPAIN Joint Study of the European Social Partners Brussels June, 29 th 2010 SECRETARÍA.
Transport Integration of cross-border transport infrastructure TEN-T strategy on large cross- border cooperation projects Gudrun Schulze, Team leader,
Key factors in the transport policy to encourage better integration Sixty-Third Session of UNECE, Geneva, 30th March 2009 "Economic Integration in the.
The Manchester City Region Karen Tierney, Greater Manchester Strategy Coordinator.
Supporting Growth in the South East Midlands Philip Cox, Director Local Economies, Regeneration and European Programmes, Department for Communities and.
Convention of the Protection and Use of Transboundary Watercourses and International Lakes Developing a guidance on water and climate adaptation for the.
One of the EU’s success stories
GBM 380 Competitive Success-- snaptutorial.com
EUSALP EU Strategy for the Alpine Region and macro-regional strategies
ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION PROJECTS IN THE BSEC REGION
WHAT IS AN ECONOMY? Today’s presentation is on the economy. We are going to look at the different components that make up an economy.
One of the EU’s success stories
WHAT IS AN ECONOMY? Today’s presentation is on the economy. We are going to look at the different components that make up an economy.
Presentation transcript:

Germany and Scotland November 2010

Germany – another complex story! Commitment to planning, with good planning being done all over, above all at local level. Other parts of system progressively less impressive as go upwards. Federal state planning still some force, important in some cases for wind energy planning, strong on water framework directive plans.

German federal planning 1 Though not overall terribly impressive, there are messages. Great value of data and research, with well resourced national bodies like BBSR and ARL, continuing intelligence on what is happening to the country, especially on overall central European developments.

German federal planning 2 Also that even in soft form, some national framework making can have value – use to frame debates, to encourage pilot projects, spread good practice, link to the intelligence function (Leitbilder approaches of 1993, 1995 and 2006). Worthy of study, as the German soft mode is the maximum plausible in most countries.

Spatial trends

Transport Leitbild 1993

2006 economy Leitbild

North Sea German plan 2009

German federal planning 3 BUT – real weaknesses are apparent, and can infect any soft national approach. Federalism and federal weakness has torpedoed much chance of stronger transport and energy spatial policy making. Competitive regionalism often rules. Liberalisation compounds this – energy and transport companies left as the core powers.

Large scale energy change No real forces guiding change beyond the four large energy corporations who control electricity transmission in Germany. No explicit federal level energy planning, though plenty of non spatial strategies for each sector. Makes long term linking up of generation and transmission, alongside renewable sources, very problematic.

Energy company zones

Germany energy generation

Renewables variation

Transmission lines development suggestions 2005

German transport industry structure Rail run mainly by vertically integrated but private company, DB AG, which has majority of its profits now outside rail. Roads system run mainly by federal government, with historically high investment and planning. Ports and airports run by states and privately, with limited effective federal steering.

German transport planning Bundesverkehrswegeplan is main instrument – federal transport plan, covering high level road and rail investment. But though allows expert and public overview every few years (last one 2003), has many drawbacks, and has often served as a machine for road building, with weak intermodal approach overall.

Scotland – a fresh approach NPF1 in 2004 and NPF2 in 2009 show new thinking on national planning. Remains mostly light touch, to allow other actors lots of scope. But because is effectively at regional level, and with significant collective powers, can work as effective dialogue, not top down.

NPF2 strategy diagram

NPF2 economic development and community regeneration

NPF2 transmission system reinforcements

Scotland – NPF2 and the national designations NPF2 was statutory, and incorporates the projects seen as of national significance. 14 designated, on essentially political (cabinet) criteria. A novel way of deciding on major projects. But where a consensus does not exist, will still be problematic – example of campaign on coal fired Hunterston power station.

Scotland national designations

Judgement on new Scottish system Developing nicely, though a thin line as to whether is an effective guide to lower level planning – probably works because all so close – only 46 councils in Scotland. National designations not totally convincing, whether can be seen to be logically linked to the strategy. Whether the Dutch key national decision system might not be better, for the few genuinely national projects – e.g. second Forth crossing.

Germany and Scotland Absolutely different contexts, but each has interesting features, one for the big country situation, one for the more regional scale. Scotland impressive on energy, which is high Scottish government priority. Scotland starting to show the value of national level planning, though plenty of scope for development.