Observational and model evidence for positive low-level cloud feedback Robert J. Burgman and Amy C. Clement Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Robin Hogan, Andrew Barrett
Advertisements

Trends in Water Cycle meeting, Paris, November 2004 Cloud and water vapour variability: models, reanalyses and observations Richard P. Allan and Tony Slingo.
1 Preliminary Simulation of the Regional Coupled Atmosphere-Ocean Model in the Southern California Coastal Regions (Santa Ana Winds and Air-Sea Interaction)
Impacts of Large-scale Controls and Internal Processes on Low Clouds
Scaling Laws, Scale Invariance, and Climate Prediction
Climate change in the Antarctic. Turner et al, Significant warming of the Antarctic Winter Troposphere. Science, vol 311, pp Radiosonde.
Observed Tropical Expansion: Impact on the Hydrological and Energy Cycles New Investigator Research Summary Joel Norris (Lead PI, UC San Diego) Robert.
Water Vapor and Cloud Feedbacks Dennis L. Hartmann in collaboration with Mark Zelinka Department of Atmospheric Sciences University of Washington PCC Summer.
Understanding climate model biases in Southern Hemisphere mid-latitude variability Isla Simpson 1 Ted Shepherd 2, Peter Hitchcock 3, John Scinocca 4 (1)
1 Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Review June 30 - July 2, 2009.
Climate modeling Current state of climate knowledge – What does the historical data (temperature, CO 2, etc) tell us – What are trends in the current observational.
Response of the Atmosphere to Climate Variability in the Tropical Atlantic By Alfredo Ruiz–Barradas 1, James A. Carton, and Sumant Nigam University of.
Richard P. Allan 1 | Brian J. Soden 2 | Viju O. John 3 | Igor I. Zveryaev 4 Department of Meteorology Click to edit Master title style Water Vapour (%)
Clouds and Climate: Cloud Response to Climate Change ENVI3410 : Lecture 11 Ken Carslaw Lecture 5 of a series of 5 on clouds and climate Properties and.
Subseasonal variability of North American wintertime surface air temperature Hai Lin RPN, Environment Canada August 19, 2014 WWOSC, Montreal.
Modes of Pacific Climate Variability: ENSO and the PDO Michael Alexander Earth System Research Lab michael.alexander/publications/
Climate Feedbacks Brian Soden Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science University of Miami.
Clouds and climate change
Towards stability metrics for cloud cover variation under climate change Rob Wood, Chris Bretherton, Matt Wyant, Peter Blossey University of Washington.
Sub-Saharan rainfall variability as simulated by the ARPEGE AGCM, associated teleconnection mechanisms and future changes. Global Change and Climate modelling.
The speaker took this picture on 11 December, 2012 over the ocean near Japan. 2014/07/29 AOGS 11th Annual Meeting in Sapporo.
ISCCP at 30, April 2013 Concurrent Study of a) 22 – year reanalysis and extension of global water vapor over both land and ocean (NVAP–M) and b) the matching.
Atlantic Multidecadal Variability and Its Climate Impacts in CMIP3 Models and Observations Mingfang Ting With Yochanan Kushnir, Richard Seager, Cuihua.
A Comparison of the Northern American Regional Reanalysis (NARR) to an Ensemble of Analyses Including CFSR Wesley Ebisuzaki 1, Fedor Mesinger 2, Li Zhang.
Cloud Feedbacks on Climate: A Challenging Scientific Problem Joel Norris Scripps Institution of Oceanography Fermilab Colloquium May 12, 2010.
Part II: Where are we going? Like an ocean... The waves crash down... Introducing OCEAN ATMOSPHERE INTERACTION.
The effects of solar variability on the Earth’s climate Joanna D. Haigh 2010/03/09 Pei-Yu Chueh.
Variability of Pacific Pycnocline Overturning in a Coupled GCM Bill Merryfield and George Boer Gu, D. and S.G.H. Philander, 1997: Inter- decadal climate.
C20C Workshop ICTP Trieste 2004 The Influence of the Ocean on the North Atlantic Climate Variability in C20C simulations with CSRIO AGCM Hodson.
Interannual Variabilities of High Clouds Seen by AIRS and Comparison with CAM5 simulations Yuk Yung, Hui Su, Katie, Hazel et al.
Volcanic Climate Impacts and ENSO Interaction Georgiy Stenchikov Department of Environmental Sciences, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ Thomas Delworth.
(Mt/Ag/EnSc/EnSt 404/504 - Global Change) Climate Models (from IPCC WG-I, Chapter 10) Projected Future Changes Primary Source: IPCC WG-I Chapter 10 - Global.
Evaluation of climate models, Attribution of climate change IPCC Chpts 7,8 and 12. John F B Mitchell Hadley Centre How well do models simulate present.
Past and Future Changes in Southern Hemisphere Tropospheric Circulation and the Impact of Stratospheric Chemistry-Climate Coupling Collaborators: Steven.
Update on stratocumulus simulations by the UCLA AGCM C. R. Mechoso, I. Richter, G. Cazes, and R. Terra University of California, Los Angeles OUTLINE 1.Sensitivity.
Mechanisms of drought in present and future climate Gerald A. Meehl and Aixue Hu.
An evaluation of satellite derived air-sea fluxes through use in ocean general circulation model Vijay K Agarwal, Rashmi Sharma, Neeraj Agarwal Meteorology.
Radiative Impacts of Cirrus on the Properties of Marine Stratocumulus M. Christensen 1,2, G. Carrió 1, G. Stephens 2, W. Cotton 1 Department of Atmospheric.
Trends in Tropical Water Vapor ( ): Satellite and GCM Comparison Satellite Observed ---- Model Simulated __ Held and Soden 2006: Robust Responses.
Trends in Tropical Water Vapor ( ): Satellite and GCM Comparison Satellite Observed ---- Model Simulated __ Held and Soden 2006: Robust Responses.
Ocean Surface heat fluxes Lisan Yu and Robert Weller
Lazaros Oreopoulos (NASA-GSFC)
Effects of trends in anthropogenic aerosols on drought risk in the Central United States Dan H. Cusworth Eric M. Leibensperger, Loretta J. Mickley Corn.
Indo-Pacific Sea Surface Temperature Influences on Failed Consecutive Rainy Seasons over Eastern Africa** Andy Hoell 1 and Chris Funk 1,2 Contact:
The ENSO Signal in Stratospheric Temperatures from Radiosonde Observations Melissa Free NOAA Air Resources Lab Silver Spring 1.
Sources of global warming of the upper ocean on decadal period scales Warren B. White 2010/05/18 Pei-yu Chueh.
Stratocumulus-topped Boundary Layer
Discussions  Observationally, the two leading principal modes of ISCCP high clouds are highly correlated with MEI and EMI (Fig 3) and the spatial patterns.
Lecture 9: Air-Sea Interactions EarthsClimate_Web_Chapter.pdfEarthsClimate_Web_Chapter.pdf, p ; Ch. 16, p ; Ch. 17, p
On the instantaneous linkages between cloud vertical structure and large-scale climate Ying Li Colorado State University.
Evidence in ISCCP for regional patterns of cloud response to climate change Joel Norris Scripps Institution of Oceanography ISCCP at 30 Workshop City College.
Michael J. McPhaden & Dongxiao Zhang NOAA/PMEL Decadal Variability and Trends of the Pacific Shallow Meridional Overturning Circulation and Their Relation.
MICHAEL A. ALEXANDER, ILEANA BLADE, MATTHEW NEWMAN, JOHN R. LANZANTE AND NGAR-CHEUNG LAU, JAMES D. SCOTT Mike Groenke (Atmospheric Sciences Major)
Sea Ice, Solar Radiation, and SH High-latitude Climate Sensitivity Alex Hall UCLA Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences SOWG meeting January 13-14,
ENSO Influence on Atlantic Hurricanes via Tropospheric Warming Brian Tang* and David Neelin Dept. of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences, UCLA Institute of.
Cooperative Research Programs (CoRP) Satellite Climate Studies Branch (SCSB) 1 1 Reconstruction of Near-Global Precipitation Variations Based on Gauges.
Important data of cloud properties for assessing the response of GCM clouds in climate change simulations Yoko Tsushima JAMSTEC/Frontier Research Center.
Studies of the tropical upper troposphere using MODIS data A. E. Dessler Earth System Science Interdisciplinary Center University of Maryland S. Sherwood,
Cooperative Research Programs (CoRP) Satellite Climate Studies Branch (SCSB) 1 1 Reconstruction of Near-Global Precipitation Variations Based on Gauges.
Marcel Rodney McGill University Department of Oceanic and Atmospheric Sciences Supervisors: Dr. Hai Lin, Prof. Jacques Derome, Prof. Seok-Woo Son.
Improved Historical Reconstructions of SST and Marine Precipitation Variations Thomas M. Smith1 Richard W. Reynolds2 Phillip A. Arkin3 Viva Banzon2 1.
Spatial Modes of Salinity and Temperature Comparison with PDO index
Dave Winker1 and Helene Chepfer2
Influence of climate variability and
Impact of the vertical resolution on Climate Simulation using CESM
Observed and Simulated Decadal Variability in Clouds and Water Vapour Richard Allan, Tony Slingo Environmental Systems Science Centre, University of Reading.
Current global and regional changes in atmospheric water vapour
Project Title: The Sensitivity of the Global Water and Energy Cycles:
New energy budget estimates at top of Earth’s atmosphere and surface
Korea Ocean Research & Development Institute, Ansan, Republic of Korea
Presentation transcript:

Observational and model evidence for positive low-level cloud feedback Robert J. Burgman and Amy C. Clement Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Miami Joel R. Norris Scripps Institution of Oceanography University of California, San Diego

“Cloud feedbacks remain the largest source of uncertainty [of equilibrium climate sensitivity].” -Summary for Policy Makers, IPCC AR4 WG1 “…simulation of the sensitivity of marine boundary layer clouds to changing environmental conditions constitutes, currently, the main source of uncertainty in tropical cloud feedbacks simulated by GCMs.” -Bony and Dufresne, GRL (2005) Here we address this issue by (1) Examining low-frequency fluctuations in observations of low-level cloud and regional meteorology, and (2) Using these observations to evaluate climate models.

Atmospheric response to Pacific Decadal Variability Burgman et al (2008) use multiple EOF (9.6% variance) of 5 NCEP/NCAR reanalysis variables (t, u, v, omega, and sh) for the lowest 8 pressure levels (1000 hPa–300 hPa) in the 60S-60N region over the time period 1970 to ENSO signal is ‘‘removed’’ by extreme cross correlation at least lag (+/- 12 months). Recent shift to cooler tropical Pacific in late 1990’s allows incorporation of satellite observations to study atmospheric response to decadal changes in SST. Passive Microwave era

Atmospheric response to Pacific Decadal Variability 1990’s shift strengthening in the overturning circulation –increased subsidence –drying in the upper and middle troposphere in NE Subtropical Pacific –shoaling of the marine boundary layer –increased lower tropospheric stability. Co-location of increased cloud with persistent cool SSTs indicate a possible feedback between Sc and the underlying SST on decadal timescales. mb/stdv Wm^2/stdv mm/stdv okta/stdv C/stdv

Black- total cloud Bars- low cloud Trend noted by Stevens et al. (2007) ISCCP cloud data corrected for satellite view angle, and inter-calibration errors (Norris, personal communication) NESP (145W-115W, 15N-25N)

Black- total cloud Bars- low cloud Trend noted by Stevens et al. (2007) COADS surface based total cloud ( ) and marine stratiform cloud ( ) from Hahn and Warren (1999) NESP (145W-115W, 15N-25N) HW99 msc comprises ordinary stratocumulus, cumulus under stratocumulus, fair- weather stratus, and bad-weather stratus

Black- total cloud Bars- low cloud Cloud fluctuations coincide with known climate shifts (1976, and late 1990’s) When SST is high, cloud cover is reduced NESP (145W-115W, 15N-25N)

Spatial structure of decadal cloud changes SURFACE OBS Hahn and Warren data available from ( ) Dominated by 1976 shift SATELLITE RETRIEVAL + ALGORTIHM Available from Dominated by 1990’s shift Regression of low clouds on NE Pacific SST

Regional changes are related to large-scale: Regression of meteorology on NE Pacific SST SSTSLP (colors); Surface winds 500 mb subsidenceLower tropospheric stability (t700-tsurf) Both thermal structure and circulation changes are consistent with weaker stratus deck (Klein and Hartmann 1993; Norris and Leovy 1994; Klein et al. 1995; Norris and Klein 2000; Stevens et al. 2007) Familiar PDV pattern

Regression of ISCCP ‘cloud radiative effect’ on NE Pacific SST 8 W/m2 cloud shortwave ~balances the upward IR due to 1K increase in SST Cloud change maintains SST anomaly

When SST is high, LTS is weak, SLP is low, surface winds and subsidence are weak  Reduced low level cloud Reduced low level cloud maintains SST Observations show that:

Models that simulate the wrong sign r(cloud,SST) Wrong sign or no r(cloud,LTS) Wrong sign or no r(cloud,SLP) Wrong sign r(cloud,w500) Is this feedback present in IPCC AR4 models? Physically-based parameterization & correct correlations Observed correlation between NE Pacific cloud and meteorology 20c3m

Is this feedback present in IPCC AR4 models? The INM-CM3.0 adopts a more empirical approach that parameterizes low-level cloud cover as a linear function of relative humidity with coefficients that depend on temperature, altitude, land/ocean, and stratification HadGEM1 has higher spatial resolution, more explicit cloud microphysics, interactive parameterization of cloudiness as a function of local variability in humidity, and a sophisticated planetary boundary layer mixing scheme

HADGEM1 simulates reduced NE Pacific cloud cover under doubled CO2 change

WHY? Model simulates regional changes in SST (increase) and LTS (increase) that are consistent with all other models Circulation changes are also consistent with the multi- model average Weaker overturning circulation (Held and Soden 2006, Vecchi and Soden 2007) Already observed (Zhang and Song 2006)

Conclusions It is possible to identify decadal fluctuations in low-level cloud in the NE Pacific in multiple, independent cloud datasets. Cloud changes are physically consistent with local meteorology changes: Cloud cover decreases when SST is high, LTS is weak, SLP is low, and meridional advection and subsidence are weak. When put to the test of simulating the relationship between cloud and thermal structure as well as circulation, only one of the current state of the art model with a physically-based parameterization of clouds passes Under doubled CO2, that model simulates a decrease in cloud cover in the NE Pacific along with robust changes in thermal structure and circulation  Observed decadal variability in low-level clouds as an analogue to how these clouds will change with global warming

ISCCP Correction Satellite view angle changes removed by linearly regressing out that portion of cloud variability associated with local changes in satellite view angle. Satellite intercalibration error removed by regressing out from each individual grid box time series the time series of standardized cloud cover anomalies averaged over the entire view area of successive satellites. This procedure will remove any real cloud cover variability occurring on near- hemispheric spatial scales but should have little impact on our regression patterns that focus on differences between regions.

Global context

Decadal Cloud Changes

Changes in CRE

SLP Changes