Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, 2008 1 Index Introduction Outline of the scheme Step 1. Individual weights Step 2. Preference aggregation Step.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
International Initiative
Advertisements

Natural Capital: Working Towards Local-Level Indicators for the NRE2 Sharmalene Mendis, Ingrid Brueckner, and Diane Martz Centre for Rural Studies and.
Section 3/6/2009  VSL  Static vs. Dynamic Efficiency (Example: optimal extraction of a non-renewable resource)  Defining/ measuring scarcity  Definitions.
T172 Tutorial 3. Environmental Impacts Energy Use CO2 emissions – global warming Resource depletion Waste Pollution (land, water, air) Land use CO2 emissions.
SUSTAINABLE PRODUCT & PROCESS DEVELOPMENT ISQA 511 Dr. Mellie Pullman 1.
Focusing on Life Cycle Cost (LCC) and Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) in GPP Green Public Procurement (GPP) - Lead the change National Conference George Jadoun,
The Impacts of Packaging on the Environment Birgitte Kjær, Ph.D. Household Waste Division.
Environment and Business Course Overview Instructor: Jerry Patchell; Office Hours: Tuesday 12:00-14:00 Room 2352A TA: Kaxton Siu;
An Empirical Environmental Sustainability Index derived solely from Nighttime Satellite Imagery and Ecosystem Service Valuation Paul Sutton
Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)
Life Cycle Assessment (LCA): Connections with Sustainability Scott Matthews Green Design Institute.
Ecology and Engineering CE 3 Introduction to Civil and Environmental Engineering.
Sustainable Development Managing for a healthy economy and healthy ecosystems UAU 101 Seminar 1.
Life Cycle Analysis and Resource Management Dr. Forbes McDougall Procter & Gamble UK.
GREEN BUILDING.
16469 Low Energy Building Design Sustainability – an overview
Clara María Mollá Muñoz. PFG_T31 17-July, Introduction. Sustainable architecture The strategies are focused on energy efficiency. Reduce environmental.
Nirmala Menikpura Institute of Global Environmental Strategies (IGES) Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions and other impacts from recycling activities:
The OECD sustainable manufacturing toolkit Sustainability and US Competitiveness Summit October 8, 2009 Michael Bordt Structural Policy Division Directorate.
Life Cycle Analysis. Topics  Definition  Use  Process  Limitations.
Prioritization of sub-watersheds for the application of environmental policies in the Basin of Lake Cuitzeo D. González. and M. Mendoza CIGA CENTRO DE.
4-7 June 2006NATO-CCMS Pilot Study, Athens Contaminated Land in Greece Recent Developments Nymphodora Papassiopi NATO-CCMS Pilot Study Tour de Table -
Juan Pablo Gómez Jáuregui Abdó Department of Ecosystems and Environmental Informatics Brandenburg University of Technology at Cottbus 1 Lehrstuhl Ökosysteme.
CSM 2006, Laxenburg, August Hierarchical reference approach to multi-criteria analysis of discrete alternatives JANUSZ GRANAT National Institute.
Life Cycle of Products Source: Melanen et al Metals flows and recycling of scrap in Finland. The Finnish Environment 401. Finnish Environment Institute,
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: A Challenge for Engineers Ata M. Khan March 2002.
Environmental Economics Class 6. Concepts Static efficiency Dynamic efficiency Static efficiency allows us to evaluate those circumstances where time.
Lecture nu 9 Presented by: Dr. Zainab O.Saeed The way in which an individual perceives the environment; the process of evaluating and storing information.
Sustainable City Management and the Urban Ecological Footprint.
Mel Cossette Executive Director & Principal Investigator National Resource Center for Materials Technology Education 1 This center is sponsored by the.
16469 Low Energy Building Design Sustainability – an overview Dr Nick Kelly ESRU.
Sustainable Development, Energy and Environment Lecture 05 Paulo Ferrão Full Professor Tiago Domingos Assistant Professor Rui Mota Researcher IN+, Centre.
Ecology is the scientific study of the relation of living organisms to each other and their surroundings. Ecology includes the study of plant and animal.
MATERIAL BALANCE METHODOLOGY Julia Brown Manager, Process Development.
UN ECE CEP Working Group on Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 7th Session Geneva 27 – 29 November 2006 Item 5(a) Guidelines for the Application of.
ERT 319 Industrial Waste Treatment Semester /2013 Huzairy Hassan School of Bioprocess Engineering UniMAP.
Picture Port Elgin Action Planning Tuesday, March 1, 2011 Port Elgin Village Chambers.
1 Sustainable Development Assessment: A formalized approach initiated in Tunisia Rafik MISSAOUI (APEX-ALCOR)
The Science of Sustainability NEW SCIENCE, OLD CONCERNS
AP Environmental Science Intro Sustainability and Ethics.
Advanced Science and Technology Letters Vol.32 (Architecture and Civil Engineering 2013), pp Development.
Danny O’CallaghanKingdown School Warminster Ecological Footprints.
T172 Tutorial 2. Maths Day school for Technology Students Saturday 27 March Regional Centre, Manchester (Details to be sent in post) The day school clashes.
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT (LCA). As corporations seek to improve their environmental performance they require new methods and tools. LCA is one such tool.
The City as a System and Sustainability
LCA Thinking in Hampshire’s Material Resources Strategy
Green Accounting. EU Policy Context Lisbon (economic and social) Gothenburg (environment) Climate change Sustainable transport Public health Resource.
The City as a System and Sustainability IB Geography II.
1 Meeting Agenda. Part I : Provide Information Presentation. Part II : Get your Comments Main Question Survey. Part.
CEU/UNDP Summer school on Stainable Human Development Human development and sustainability Dr. Andrey Ivanov Human Development Advisor United Nations Development.
Sustainability Development Indicators Created By : Ali Alghazwi, Saif Alsayed IS 459 Dr. Paul Safonov.
Page 1 Environmental Mainstreaming in Development Projects Cairo, March
Chapter 11 Life-Cycle Concepts, Product Stewardship and Green Engineering.
Overview of Sustainability Policy Issues CMAP Board of Directors October 10, 2007.
Water Sustainability in Cities Unit 1: Module Introduction (Photos and Graphics by Steve Burian)
Environment : Physical environment surrounding us: Air Water: Fresh water, rivers, oceans, etc. Soil: Lands, forests. Broader definition includes urban.
Sustainable development
Conceptual Landfill Design and Energy Recovery Potential for Greater Dammam Area AbdulRahman Al-Blooshi Umar I. Ahmed Wasi Ul.
Clean Technology (PB382) Click to edit Master title style Numfon Eaktasang, Ph.D.
Reality of Highway Construction Equipment in Palestine
Green Building and Sustainable Architecture
Multidisciplinary nature of environmental studies Lecture #1
ESCM – Chapter 1.
Sustainable City Management and the Urban Ecological Footprint
BIOL 315 Environmental Biology
BIOL 104 The Environment, Society, and Conservation
Green Building and Sustainable Architecture
Unit 1 Powerpoint Chapters 1 & 2 What do you think. What is Capital…
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY SUPPLY
Ecological Economics Lecture 03 25th March 2010
Presentation transcript:

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Index Introduction Outline of the scheme Step 1. Individual weights Step 2. Preference aggregation Step 3. Determination of the indicators Step 4. Final aggregation Conclusions End

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Introduction Sustainable development (Brundtland Commision, 1987): development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. This is, by nature, a multicriteria concept.

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Introduction Sustainability Social EconomicEnvironmental

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Introduction Natural capital vs. Man-made capital. Weak sustainability. Total capital constant. Substitutability paradigm. Strong sustainability. Natural capital and man-made capital are (at the most) complementary. Non substitutability paradigm.

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Introduction Life cycle assesment. Environmental performance of production and services through all phases of their life cycle (from craddle to tomb): Extracting and processing raw materials; manufacturing; transportation and distribution; use, reuse and maintainance; recycling; final disposal. How to measure sustainability?

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Introduction Ecological footprint. Estimate of the ammount of land area a human population, given prevailing technology, would need if the current resource consumption and pollution by the population is matched by the sustainable (renewable) resource production and waste asimilation by such a land area. How to measure sustainability?

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Introduction (Urban) Indicators. A set of magnitudes measuring different concrete aspects of sustainability. Over 200 indicators are presently used. Still to be done: –To define a full common framework (meningful and comparable), –To actually measure them, –To develop synthetic urban sustainability indicators. How to measure sustainability?

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Introduction... define a methodology, based on the reference point approach, to develop a pair of urban synthetic sustainability indicators (weak and strong) for a set of municipalities of Andalucía, based on a pre-defined set of indicators. In this work, we...

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Outline of the scheme Data selection 0 Determination of individual weights 1 Preference aggregation 2 Synthetic indicators within each class 3 Final aggregation 4 -Municipalities -Indicators -Criteria -Experts Haldi (1995)Meta-Goal Programming Rodríguez et al. (2000) Reference Point Wierzbicki (1986) Strong and Weak Indicator

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Municipalities. 18 (M) Andalusian municipalities, over 55,000 inhabitants. Indicators. 4 classes: –Environmental (13) –Urban development (12) –Demographic (16) –Economic (22) (I - number of indicators in a given class) Outline of the scheme

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Outline of the scheme ENVIRONMENTAL CLASS WATER CYCLE % of water losses in the pipe line Water consumption (per inhabitant) Km of water supply line Km of drainage line ENERGY Electricity consumption (per inhabitant) MATERIALS CYCLE Volume of waste (per inhabitant) Paper containers (per inhabitant) Volume of glass recycled (per inhabitant) NOISE Day noise Night noise ATMOSPHERE Atmospheric inmissions Greenhouse efect emissions Global emissions

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Criteria. The indicators are to be maximized or minimized –Some are clear (e.g. % of water loss) –Others are not so clear (e.g. Paper containers/inhabitant, electricity consumption) Panel of experts. 6 experts (ND): –2 Environmental –2 Social –2 Economic Outline of the scheme

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Individual Weights Each expert k (k = 1,..., ND) assigns weights to the indicators in the following way: Assume a class of indicators is chosen, which contains I indicators. The expert classifies the indicators into L sets (VI, CI, I, NVI, NI is suggested)

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Individual Weights For each l = 2,..., L-1, the expert is asked to place set l between sets l-1 and l+1. l - 1 l set l alkalk

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Individual Weights The following system of equations is solved: The weights are assigned:

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Individual Weights ENVIRONMENTAL CLASS I1I2I3I4I5I6I7I8I9I10I11I12I13 DM DM DM DM DM DM Weights for the environmental class:

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Preference Aggregation We establish the following set of goals: The achievement function takes the form:

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Best maximum deviation: 2. Preference Aggregation (AP1) d*, s max

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Best total deviation: 2. Preference Aggregation (AP2) s*, d max

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Pay-off matrix: 2. Preference Aggregation BestWorst Max. dev.d*d*d max Agg. dev.s*s*s max Meta-Goals: we choose values

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Meta-Goal Programming Problem: 2. Preference Aggregation

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, An auxiliary problem is solved. The process can continue until we achieve a satisfactory solution. The final result gives the group weights for each class of indicators. 2. Preference Aggregation

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Preference Aggregation BestWorst Max. dev Agg. dev Group weights for the environmental class:

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Preference Aggregation ENVIRONMENTAL CLASS I1I2I3I4I5I6I7I8I9I10I11I12I13 DM DM DM DM DM DM Group Group weights for the environmental class:

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Determination of Indicators For a given class of indicators, is the value of indicator i for municipality j

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Aspiration and reservation levels: 3. Determination of Indicators

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Individual achievement functions: 3. Determination of Indicators 0 1 2

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Determination of Indicators Mun Individual Achievement Functions Weight Norm

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Construction of the synthetic indicators (  i are the normalized group weigths) 3. Determination of Indicators

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Graphical representation: 3. Determination of Indicators

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Final aggregation Let us denote by the strong and weak indicators corresponding to municipality j and to the indicator class h (h = 1, 2, 3, 4) Let us assume that the weights are assigned to the four classes of indicators

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Global indicators: 4. Final aggregation Weights: –Environmental: 0.4 –Economic: 0.3 –Urban development: 0.15 –Demographic: 0.15

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Graphical representation: 4. Final aggregation

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Weights: two options –Give the weights ourselves and carry out a sensitivity analysis. –Determine the weights in a group decision making process like the one carried out in step 2 4. Final aggregation

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Conclusions Urban indicators have been designed to measure concrete aspects of sustainability, but there is a lack of a unified measure. We have developed a full methodology to build synthetic urban indicators. Both strong and weak sustainability indicators are built and taken into account. The pair of indicators and their graphical representation allows a more in depth analysis of the data.

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Conclusions The methodology developed comprises several different schemes, among which we can point out: –Meta-Goal Programming, for the determination of the group weights. –Reference point technique (objective ranking) for the construction of the indicators. The scheme can be adapted to any number of indicators and/or municipalities.

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Conclusions Future Research Lines: –To carry out a wider study: Broader range (national?), higher number of municipalities. Refine the panel of experts. More reliable data. –Final aggregation: Full systematic sensitivity analysis. Classification scheme.

Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 22 July, Conclusions Future Research Lines: –Group weights: Full group decision making process. Different penalizations for n and p. –Reference point scheme: Interval criteria. Different slopes for the branches of the achievement functions. Different aspiration and reservation values.