NuFact 05 Revisiting the optimum PMT size for water-Cherenkov megaton detectors Esso Flyckt, Christophe Fontaine, Pascal Lavoute and Carole Marmonier Photonis,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Large Area, Low Cost PMTs Neutrinos and Arms Control Workshop Paul Hink 6 February 2004 BURLE INDUSTRIES.
Advertisements

Picosecond Timing Workshop 18 November Sales meeting 2005 Discovering the Future.
Jan 2009 U. Katz: Astroparticle Physics 1 What is KM3NeT – the Vision  Future cubic-kilometre sized neutrino telescope in the Mediterranean Sea  Exceeds.
The Multi-PMT Optical Module P.Kooijman, University of Amsterdam University of Utrecht Nikhef.
6 April 2005Aussois, France BURLE INDUSTRIES Next Generation Large Area Low Cost PMT UNO Collaboration Robert Caracciolo and Richard Leclercq 6 April 2005.
The Pierre-Auger PMT Test Stand Chris Jillings Feb 6, 2002.
Peter Križan, Ljubljana Peter Križan University of Ljubljana and J. Stefan Institute The HERA-B RICH counter.
Robert Cooper L. Garrison, L. Rebenitsch, R. Tayloe, R. Thornton.
Detector R&D: status and priorities Paolo Strolin NUFACT05 June 26, 2005 Low-Z Tracking Calorimetry Magnetised Iron Spectrometers Water Čerenkov Liquid.
1 A Design of PET detector using Microchannel Plate PMT with Transmission Line Readout Heejong Kim 1, Chien-Min Kao 1, Chin-Tu Chen 1, Jean-Francois Genat.
Working Concepts for a very near detector Preliminary discussions involving SNL/LLNL, ANL, Saclay and Brazil Goals –Work towards a compact detector design.
February 8 th, 2001 Status Report: SciFi for MICE Edward McKigney Imperial College London.
Update on Electronics Activities Jim Pilcher University of Chicago 20-Jan-2006.
Revisiting the optimum PMT size for water-Cherenkov megaton detectors
P. Karchin – PMTs for Scintillator Based Muon Systempage 11/7/2004 January 7, 2004 American Linear Collider Physics Group 2004 Workshop Stanford Linear.
Scintillation Detectors
Lecture 11  Production of Positron Emitters, Continued  The Positron Tomograph.
Prototype string for a km3 Baikal neutrino telescope Roma International Conference on Astroparticle Physics V.Aynutdinov, INR RAS for the Baikal Collaboration.
10 Picosecond Timing Workshop 28 April PLANACON MCP-PMT for use in Ultra-High Speed Applications.
Copyright © Hamamatsu Photonics K.K. All Rights Reserved. Oct at NNN07 Workshop Hamamatsu Photonics Electron Tube Division Recent Progress in PMTs.
Xiaodong Wang ( 王晓冬 ) School of Nuclear Science and Technology Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, China MPGD activities at Lanzhou University July 5, 2013.
Hamamatsu R7525 HA: outer conductive coating with insulating sleeve CC: convex-concave window mm thick (standard plano-concave: 1mm center, 6.1.
B.K.Lubsandorzhiev, MSU 16 May Nuclear Photonics Methods in EAS Cherenkov Arrays Bayarto Lubsandorzhiev Institute for Nuclear Research RAS Moscow.
Latest developments in Hamamatsu Large Format PMTs
T. Sumiyoshi (TMU) 30, Nov del Carmen 1 Development of HPD (HAP D) Photon-detector for the Aerogel RICH Photon-detector for the Aerogel.
1 The X-HPD: Development of a large spherical hybrid photodetector A.Braem +, C. Joram +, J. Séguinot +, L. Pierre *, P. Lavoute * + CERN, Geneva (CH)
Large Photodetector Developments in Europe
TOF for ATLAS Forward Proton Upgrade AFP concept: adds new ATLAS sub-detectors at 220 and 420 m upstream and downstream of central detector to precisely.
Fast Detectors for Medical and Particle Physics Applications Wilfried Vogel Hamamatsu Photonics France March 8, 2007.
Department of Radiology UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA 1 Investigation of LaBr 3 Detector Timing Resolution A.Kuhn 1, S. Surti 1, K.S. Shah 2, and J.S. Karp.
P.Vincent LPNHE-Paris for H.E.S.S. collaboraton28 th ICRC - Tsukuba - Japan - 5, August 2003 Performance of the H.E.S.S. cameras Pascal Vincent (LPNHE.
July 29, 2004 American Linear Collider Physics Group Victoria Linear Collider Workshop Muon Detector MAPMT Tests - Calibration R&D Scintillator Based Muon.
A detector design for the Daya Bay reactor neutrino experiment Yifang Wang Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing Jan. 18, 2004.
Developments in hemispherical tubes for underwater Neutrinos detection. Bruno Combettes PHOTONIS Group Product Manager PHOTONIS-Brive, France CPPM Meeting.
Tests WLS - Readout axial PET - Bari - Janvier 2007 AXIAL PET - HPD AXIAL COORDINATE RECONSTRUCTION WITH WLS STRIPS
J.T. White Texas A&M University SIGN (Scintillation and Ionization in Gaseous Neon) A High-Pressure, Room- Temperature, Gaseous-Neon-Based Underground.
Bbbbb 1.Introduction to ET Enterprises Ltd 2.Brief History 3.Product Range 4.Main Applications 5.Recent Developments 6.Current and Past projects 7.Summary.
Development of TOP counter for Super B factory K. Inami (Nagoya university) 2007/10/ th International Workshop on Ring Imaging Cherenkov Counters.
Optimization of Detectors for Time of Flight PET Marek Moszyński, Tomasz Szczęśniak, Soltan Institute for Nuclear Studies, Otwock-Świerk, Poland.
Andy Cormack Sensor Development Director Graham Sperrin European Sales Manager ET Enterprises Limited 45 Riverside Way Uxbridge UB8 2YF United Kingdom.
Hyper-Kamiokande project and R&D status Hyper-K project Motivation Detector Physics potential study photo-sensor development Summary Kamioka.
Timing properties of MCP-PMT K.Inami (Nagoya university, Japan) - Time resolution - Lifetime - Rate dependence Photon Detector Workshop at Kobe,
Techniques for Nuclear and Particle Physics Experiments By W.R. Leo Chapter Eight:
Barrel PID upgrade K. Inami (Nagoya) Ljubljana, Hawaii, Cincinnati and PID group - R&D status - Structure design - Prototype study - Beam test - Photon.
Tunka Experiment: Towards 1км 2 EAS Cherenkov Array B.K.Lubsandorzhiev for TUNKA Collaboration.
Gigaton Volume Detector in Lake Baikal: status of the project Zh.-A. Dzhilkibaev (INR, Moscow) Zh.-A. Dzhilkibaev (INR, Moscow) for the Baikal Collaboration.
Lecture 3-Building a Detector (cont’d) George K. Parks Space Sciences Laboratory UC Berkeley, Berkeley, CA.
October 2002Sienna, JL. Faure, DAPNIA/SPP In 8th Topical Seminar on Innovative Particle and Radiation Detectors Jean-louis Faure CEA-DAPNIA-SPP Progress.
Jean-François Genat Fast Timing Workshop June 8-10th 2015 FZU Prague Timing Methods with Fast Integrated Technologies 1.
Characterization of the QUartz Photon Intensifying Detector (QUPID) Artin Teymourian UCLA Dark Matter Group Dept. of Physics and Astronomy.
Lecture 12  Last Week Summary  Sources of Image Degradation  Quality Control  The Sinogram  Introduction to Image Processing.
Nuclear Medicine Instrumentation 242 NMT 1 Dr. Abdo Mansour Assistant Professor of radiology
Three inch PMTs. Manufacturers ETEL 72 mm photocathode tube ready Passes all specifications (has higher than wished afterpulse rate: this is being fixed.
1 CPPM Test bench for photon detectors Imen Al Samarai*, Jose Busto, Anne-Gaelle Dehaine (Photonis),Greg Hallewell Pascale Keller & Thierry LeGou Developed.
M.Teshima (MPP, U-Tokyo) M.Pimenta (LIP) T.Schweizer (MPP)
1 Development of a Large Area Photodetector with a Fast Phosphor Anode Toru Iijima Kobayashi-Maskawa Institute Nagoya University Open Meeting for the Hyper-Kamiokande.
Efficiency, Dark noise, and Baseline fluctuations with Burle-Photonis MCP-PMT's Jean-Francois Genat and Edward May Dec 2009 –Jan 2010.
The prototype string for the km3 scale Baikal neutrino telescope VLVnT April 2008 Vladimir Aynutdinov, INR RAS for the Baikal Collaboration for.
Multi-PMT DOM P.Kooijman University of Amsterdam-GRAPPA Presentation for SSC.
Neutron Imaging and Tomography with MCPs
The Electromagnetic Calorimetry of the PANDA Detector at FAIR
Gamma Camera.
Revisiting the optimum PMT size for water-Cherenkov megaton detectors
Large Photodetector Developments in Europe
Department of Physics and Astronomy,
Measured baseline fluctuations and dark counts with Burle-Photonis MCP-PMT's Jean-Francois Genat and Edward May Dec 2009 –Jan 2010.
Recent Progress in Large Format PMTs
Development of hybrid photomultiplier for Hyper-Kamiokande
Design Requirements for Jinping Underground Neutrino Experiment
Presentation transcript:

NuFact 05 Revisiting the optimum PMT size for water-Cherenkov megaton detectors Esso Flyckt, Christophe Fontaine, Pascal Lavoute and Carole Marmonier Photonis, Brive, France NuFact 05 Frascati

NuFact 05 Overview PHOTONIS Physics is challenging Traditional PMTs Optimal size cost Capacity & investments Sub-conclusions Discussion/outlook R&D reminder/prospects

NuFact 05 Brive

NuFact 05 PHOTONIS Photomultipliers Image intensifiers (also DEP tubes) Streak tubes Microchannel plates Single-channel electron multipliers Neutron detectors

NuFact 05 PMTs Nuclear medicine (~80%) gamma cameras PET scanners Analytics/industrial (~10%) Physics (~10%)

NuFact 05 H.E.S.S. in Namibia ( very-low after-pulse PMT)

NuFact 05 Veritas in Arizona

NuFact 05 Auger in Argentina

NuFact 05 Traditional PMTs Hemispherical 5“, 8“, 9“, “, 12“, 15“

NuFact 05 Very many PMTs Example: UNO >50,000x 20“ PMT size cost Embedded inside water volume Sensitivity Timing SE pulse-height resolution Granularity

NuFact 05 PMT size cost Diameter 20“ (20“)17“ 12“ Projected area cm² QE(typ) % CE % Cost € Cost/ cm² per useful PE U = cost /( cm² x QE x CE) €/ PE U / cm²

NuFact 05 Timing Size20“17“12“ Rise time (ns) Jitter (ns)

NuFact 05 Weight Size 20‘‘17‘‘12“ Weight (kg)

NuFact 05 Single-electron resolution Need good P/V for exact gain calibration: 20“ difficult? (P/V = :1) 17“ P/V = :1 (reality better) 12“ P/V = :1 (reality better)

NuFact 05 Quantities and total cost 20“ 50,000 x € 2500 = € 125M 17“ 57,200 x € 2500 = € 143M 12“ 135,000 x € 800 = € 108M

NuFact 05 New pump capacity needed? Delivery over 6 years 300 working days/year 20“ tube 50,000/6/300 => 28 good tubes x yield 0.7 = 40 starts/day (1 start/pump/day) => 40 pumps ( € 7M or so) 12“ tube 135,000/6/300 => 75 good tubes x yield 0.7 = 110 starts/day. A multi-array computerised pump at Photonis handles 20 starts/day => 6 pumps ( € 2M or so)

NuFact 05 + Sub-conclusions 12“ seems much better than 20“/17“ cost per useful photoelectron & total PMT cost timing single-electron resolution (17“ equal) granularity weight and handling implosion risk investments and start-up

NuFact 05 - Sub-conclusions cost of more cables and electronics 12“ tubes may also need a shield at 60 m depth (or thicker glass?)

NuFact 05 Discussion The 12“ tube is a cost-optimum for Photonis pumping systems - maybe other cost-optima in 8“ - 15“ for other suppliers? Can be made by at least 4 suppliers - without major R&D! Photonis is willing, able and prepared up to 15“ However, non-industry investments needed!

NuFact 05 Optimise! Cost/cm² per useful PE U = cost/(cm²xQExCE)

NuFact 05 Invest in QE now! Instead of investing € 7M (or so) for 20“ it is better to invest € 2M (or so) for 12“ and another € 0.5M in getting the QE up to > 30 % Photonis has such a QE programme Characterisation with French institutes

NuFact 05 „Smart“ PMTs so far „smart“ => PHR => elimination of single PE noise (for DUMANDs) Patented by Philips (Photonis) Copied (faster mushroom shape) by INR, Moscow, into the „QUASAR“ Philips (spherical)

NuFact 05 anode target was YSO single-crystal at kV => photocathode at ground potential! partly sensitive from the back

NuFact 05 Pulse-height resolution S/N 8 & 10 deployed in Lake Baikal

NuFact 05 Status „smart“ PMTs Philips/Photonis made ~ 30; invested 1M €! 200 QUASARs operating for many years in Lake Baikal => proof of concept as to life time! No ongoing production! Could be made (and improved) again!

NuFact 05 Possible „smart“ PMTs Reproduce and improve former tubes Redesign (target) Better scintillator (LSO, ZnO:Ga,...) Si diode/Si diode array APD/APD array Multianode multiplier Quadrant PMT (inside/outside) ??

NuFact 05 On-going R&D „smart“ 8 => 12“ tubes with: electron-bombarded scintillator in a preamplifier tube, read-out by a small, fast PMT electron-bombarded Si diode as the anode Both will resolve 1, 2, 3, several photoelectrons but - need to stand > kV Is such „smartness“ worth a factor 2-3 in cost?

NuFact 05 Photonis has all the technical capability needed! R&D cooperation: detailed & intensive talks are going on with the MEMPHYS collaboration to define a balanced programme Workshop planned in the spring