Arbitrator Challenges at ICSID: Why a Different Standard?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
GRAF & PITKOWITZ RECHTSANWÄLTE GMBH ATTORNEYS AT LAW REVISION / ANNULMENT OF INVESTMENT TREATY AWARDS Dr. Nikolaus Pitkowitz M.B.L.-HSG Vienna June 21,
Advertisements

COMMENCEMENT OF ARBITRATION PROFESSOR JOSEPH MBADUGHA.
The View of European Business Stuart Popham 14 March 2008 Survey Results.
PARTNERSHIPS, CORPORATIONS AND THE VARIANTS PROF. BRUCE MCCANN SPRING SEMESTER LECTURE 1 DUTY OF LOYALTY PP Business Organizations Lectures.
© Allen & Overy Costs of International Arbitration.
The Court of Justice European Law in the Making. Terminology Jurisdiction Jurisdiction Venue Venue Standing Standing Chambers Chambers Plenary Session.
Annulment of ICSID Awards Christina Knahr. Dr. Christina Knahr, MPA2 Overview Jurisdiction of Annulment Committees Grounds for Annulment Recent Annulment.
ARBITRATION Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot.
1 “For Better or For Worse” State Bar of Arizona American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers January 28, 2010 Rules Update Arizona Rules of Family Law Procedure,
© Allen & Overy Yacine Francis The 10 Point Guide to International Arbitration in Cyprus.
Conflict Resolution.
Attorney-Client Privilege in International Disputes “Groundhog Day – Episode III” Ian Meredith Partner, International Arbitration Practice Group Co-ordinator,
International Commercial Arbitration and Australia Professor Doug Jones AM Head of Clayton Utz International Arbitration Group 2 March 2007.
WTO FORUM: ARTICLE 25 OF THE DSU Christian Albanesi Managing Counsel ICC International Court of Arbitration.
September 23, 2011 World Bank Annual Meetings International Law Institute CSO Forum ICSID Arbitration Paul-Jean Le Cannu Counsel - ICSID.
Arbitration For Projects in Brazil From the Perspective of a U. S
Ukrainian Bar Association Cyprus Companies September 2009 Presentation during 2009 UBA Conference, Limassol, Cyprus Use of Jurisdictions for structuring.
ALEKSANDRE TSULADZE HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT OF THE COURT STATISTICS AND ANALYSIS Georgian Practice of Arbitration March 2014 Supreme Court of Georgia.
Understanding decision making - Prosecuting complaints Karen Mobbs Director of Proceedings Health Care Complaints Commission Patrick Griffin Barrister.
London I September 2012 I Dr. Reinhard Dallmayr 1 1 The Bias of Arbitrators in Reinsurance Arbitration - The German Perspective Dr. Reinhard Dallmayr.
Scope of Domestic Review of Investment Awards Investment Treaty Forum, 9 May 2008 Anthony Wilson King & Spalding International LLP v1.
The Board of Directors Corporate Governance Chapter 4.
Practising open procurement of IT Thomas Vinje, Partner, Clifford Chance LLP, Brussels 10 June 2010.
Austrian Polish Twin Conference Warsaw, 17 June 2011 VIAC VIENNA INTERNATIONAL ARBITRAL CENTRE Arbitration Landscape in Austria The Vienna Rules Austrian/Polish.
Prof. Andrea Moja Academic year 2011/2012 LIUC University – Castellanza 1.
BRIEFING & ROUNDTABLE FRAMEWORK OF INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION Marie Stoyanov, YIAG Co-chair – Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP, Paris Warsaw, Poland –
Local Assessment of Code of Conduct Complaints. 2 Background  On 08 May 2008 – the local assessment of Code of Conduct complaints was implemented due.
New rights for people complaining about adult social care providers – an introduction.
4th CIS Local Counsel Forum, Kiev, Ukraine June 24 – 26, 2009 Dr. Thomas Rihm, Partner Thouvenin Attorneys - at - Law Klausstrasse Zurich, Switzerland.
International Commercial Arbitration The arbitral tribunal University of Oslo Giuditta Cordero-Moss, Ph.D., Dr.Juris Professor, Oslo University.
Towards improvement: Institution of appeal in public procurement – topical procedural and evidentiary issues Kyiv, April , 2012 Oleksandr Voznyuk.
Taking of Evidence Disclosure in Investment Treaty Arbitration Sarita Woolhouse Seventh Investment Forum 8th September BIICL.
Part Eleven Reporting on Financial Statements 1. 2 Structure of Seminar 1.Standards of Reporting 2.Types of Audit Opinions 3.Other Reporting Considerations.
© 2010 Tribunal Invitations to Comment on Legal Authority, Argument and Draft Awards Alejandro A. Escobar Fifteenth Public Conference, Investment Treaty.
1 A decade of revisions at UNCITRAL Special Course 6 – James Castello Lecture 3 Arbitration Academy PA R I S SUMMER COURSES
1 AIDA REINSURANCE WORKING PARTY London 13 September 2012 THE BIAS OF ARBITRATORS IN REINSURANCE ARBITRATIONS.
11/21/2015Name of Footer1 December 9, 2013 Arbitrators in International Arbitration.
1 DISPUTE SETTLEMENT THROUGH ADJUDICATION N D Sharma.
AN ABCD of Post-Award Remedies Investment Treaty Forum, 9 May 2008 Matthew Weiniger, Head of Public International Law, Herbert Smith LLP
1 A decade of revisions at UNCITRAL Special Course 6 – James Castello Lecture 5 Arbitration Academy PA R I S SUMMER COURSES
Two Case Studies involving intra-EU BITs Christer Söderlund, Vinge, Stockholm, Sweden London, 4 December 2008 EUROPEAN LAW AND INVESTMENT TREATIES: EXPLORING.
Security for costs in investment treaty arbitration Jakob Ragnwaldh Mannheimer Swartling, Stockholm 10 September 2010.
The Swiss Rules of International Arbitration Roots, Revision and Experiences in a Nutshell Dr. Philipp Habegger LL.M., LALIVE.
Workshop II: THE ICSID ANNULMENT MECHANISM 1 © 2012 by International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes. Content may be reproduced for educational.
Institut für Österreichisches und Internationales Steuerrecht How Final are Arbitration Decisions? Prof. Dr. Alexander Rust, LL.M.
European Union 8 Judicial Protection
KEY ISSUES IN INVESTOR- STATE ARBITRATION Lessons for a Young Practitioner Presented by Isaiah Bozimo, FCIArb.
Fall Conference Ethics Presentation November 13, 2015.
Is Past Performance a Guide to Future Performance – Precedent in Treaty Arbitration Matthew Weiniger Partner, Herbert Smith LLP BIICL Investment Treaty.
ICC Dispute Resolution Services The ICC Court powers under Article 6(2) of the Rules Alina Leoveanu Deputy Counsel, ICC International Court of Arbitration.
Emmanuelle Cabrol, Partner Herbert Smith LLP Provisional measures in ICSID arbitration 15th Investment Treaty Forum, 10 September 2010.
The UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration: 25 Years 4 June 2010 “The Influence of the UNCITRAL Model Law in Hong Kong and China”
Karel Daele - Mkono & Co. Advocates, Tanzania and Burundi MOST FAVORED NATION TREATMENT OF SUBSTANTIVE RIGHTS & INVESTMENT ARBITRATION IN CHINA.
Setting aside for apparent bias Brian Doctor QC Fountain Court Chambers.
LECTURE 11 ICJ INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE The statute of the ICJ consists of 70 articles and is annexed to the UN Charter. A UN member is an automatic.
Legal Foundations of European Union Law II Tutorials Karima Amellal.
“Court Review of Arbitral Awards for excès de pouvoir” June 4, 2010 Dirk Pulkowski - Legal Counsel -
Disputants may use mediation in a variety of disputes, such as:
Introduction to International Commercial Arbitration
Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot
International Commercial Arbitration
Recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments and arbitral awards in Russia Roman Zaitsev, PhD, Partner 05/09/2018.
Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments and Arbitral Awards
International Business Law Sciences Po Paris Spring 2017
Function of the International Court of Justice (ICJ):
Amicus Participation in Investment Arbitration
Summary Disposition of Claims
Conflicts of Interest In Arbitrations
Introduction to International Commercial Arbitration
LECTURE No 6 - THE EUROPEAN UNION’s JUDICIAL SYSTEM I (courts)
Presentation transcript:

Arbitrator Challenges at ICSID: Why a Different Standard? Audley Sheppard 11 September 09 BIICL 13th Investment Treaty Forum Conference

Summary Procedure for challenging an ICSID arbitrator Time limits ICSID test for arbitrator conflict of interests Notable ICSID challenges Recommended changes BIICL 13th Investment Treaty Forum Conference September 09

Procedure for challenging an ICSID arbitrator Article 58 ICSID Convention: The decision on any proposal to disqualify a[n] arbitrator shall be taken by the other members of the Tribunal Provided that where those members are equally divided, or in the case of a proposal to disqualify a sole arbitrator, or a majority of the arbitrators, the Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council shall take that decision.

Procedure for challenging an ICSID arbitrator (cont.) Contrast: UNCITRAL: Appointing Authority ICC: ICC Court LCIA: LCIA Court With right to challenge under national law ICJ: unanimous decision of other Judges

Comment “It’s the remaining arbitrators on the tribunal who generally have to decide whether the challenged colleague lacks independence or impartiality.  This is not the way it is done in the ICC or the AAA.  It is not the way it is done in the LCIA.  There is, I think, an understandable fear of cronyism.  I am not saying that there is cronyism, but there is a perception of cronyism.” (Rusty Park, Fordham University Law School, 2009)

Time limit for challenge Rule 9(1) Arbitration Rules: Challenge must be brought “promptly and in any event before the proceedings are closed” Contrast: UNCITRAL: 15 days from appointment or discovery of facts ICC: 30 days LCIA: 15 days

ICSID test for arbitrator conflict of interests Article 14(1) ICSID Convention: “Persons designated to serve on the Panels shall be persons of high moral character and recognized competence in the fields of law, commerce, industry or finance, who may be relied upon to exercise independent judgment. …” Article 40(2) of the Convention states: “Arbitrators appointed from outside the Panel of Arbitrators shall possess the qualities stated in paragraph (1) of Article 14.”

ICSID test (cont.) Rule 6(2) Arbitration Rules: Arbitrator declaration disclosing: past and present professional, business and other relationships (if any) with the parties any other circumstances which might cause the arbitrator’s reliability for independent judgment to be questioned by a party

ICSID test (cont.) Article 57 ICSID Convention Party may propose that an arbitrator is disqualified on the basis “of any fact indicating a manifest lack of the qualities required by Article 14(1)”

ICSID test (cont.) Articulation of test: Vivendi v Argentina Manifest “imposes a relatively heavy burden of proof on the party making the proposal” The test is “whether a real risk of lack of impartiality based upon those facts (and not upon any mere speculation of inference) could reasonably be apprehended by either party [...] That is to say, the circumstances actually established (and not merely supposed or inferred) must negate or place in clear doubt the appearance of impartiality.” Suez v Argentina “It is important to emphasise that the language of Article 57 places a heavy burden of proof on the Respondent to establish facts that make it obvious and highly probable, not just possible, that Professor Kaufmann-Kohler is a person who may not be relied upon to exercise independent and impartial judgement.”

Non-ICSID test Contrast disclosure requirements and grounds for challenge: UNCITRAL: “circumstances exist that give rise to justifiable doubts as to the arbitrator’s impartiality or independence” ICC: “lack of independence or otherwise” LCIA: same as UNCITRAL

Non-ICSID test (cont.) Contrast disclosure requirements and grounds for challenge: ICJ: “independent judges, elected .. from among persons of high moral character” ECHR: “independent and impartial tribunal” IBA Guidelines: “impartial and independent of the parties”

Non-ICSID test (cont.) Test: ECHR/English law: IBA Guidelines: “question is whether a fair-minded and informed observer, having considered the facts, would conclude that there was a real possibility that the tribunal was biased” (Porter v Magill) IBA Guidelines: “doubts are justifiable if a reasonable and informed third party would reach the conclusion that there was a likelihood that the arbitrator may be influenced by factors other than the merits of the case as presented by the parties in reaching his or her decision”

Notable ICSID challenges: 1. Arbitrator and a Party Holiday Inn SA/ Occidental Petroleum v. Morocco Arbitrator appointed non-exec director of Occidental Permitted to resign Amco Asia Corp v. Indonesia Arbitrator given tax advice to controlling claimant Test included impartiality Part appointment assumes some acquaintance Appearance of partiality must be manifest = highly probable Challenge rejected Zhinvali Development Ltd v. Republic of Georgia Occasional social contacts Suggestion that judgement affected purely speculative BIICL 13th Investment Treaty Forum Conference September 09

Notable ICSID challenges: 1. Arbitrator and a Party (cont.) Vivendi v. Argentina Arbitrator’s firm instructed on tax matter by party connected to Vivendi Work unrelated and arbitrator not involved Challenge rejected Suez v. Argentina Arbitrator non-exec director of UBS, minor shareholder in Suez Spanish version of Art. 14(1) refers to person “who inspires full confidence in his impartiality of judgement” Considered four criteria: proximity; intensity; dependence; materiality EDF v. Argentina Same grounds Failure to disclose did not indicate manifest lack of independence

Notable ICSID challenges: 1. Arbitrator and a Party (cont.) Lemire v. Ukraine Arbitrator’s law firm instructed by Ukraine in unrelated investment arbitration Challenge rejected

Notable ICSID challenges: 2. Arbitrator and Counsel Amco Asia Corp v. Indonesia Arbitrator’s firm and claimant’s counsel had had joint office and profit sharing arrangements Continued to share premises and administrative services Lack of independence must be manifest Challenge rejected SGS v. Pakistan Arbitrator has appointed/agreed counsel to be arbitrator in other cases Must establish facts, inference from facts must be reasonable Azurix v. Argentina Arbitrator’s law firm appointed counsel as arbitrator in other arbitrations Hrvatska Electroprivreda v. Slovenia Chairman and counsel from same barristers’ Chambers Counsel not allowed to appear

Notable ICSID challenges: 3. Issue and subject matter conflict Suez v. Argentina Arbitrator’s involvement in Vivendi Award “so flawed” Must show fact indicating manifest lack of impartiality or independence Challenge rejected Electrabel v. Hungary Arbitrator appointed by Hungary in parallel arbitration against Hungary raising same issues Saba Fakes v. Turkey Arbitrator appointed by Turkey in another arbitration raising similar issues

Most recent ICSID Cases S & T Oil Equipment v. Romania Arbitrator’s firm was representing an investor in a case against Romania Arbitrator resigned PIP SARL v. Gabon Arbitrator previously chairman of an ICSID tribunal which made award against Gabon Awaiting decision Azurix Corp v. Argentina – annulment Improper constitution of the Tribunal (Art 52(1)(a)) Challenge had been heard in accordance with procedures and rejected, tribunal properly constituted Only annul if did not comply with procedure for challenge 19 BIICL 13th Investment Treaty Forum Conference September 09

Some non-ICSID (BIT) cases AWG v. Argentina (UNCITRAL) National Grid Plc v. Argentina (UNCITRAL) Eureko v. Poland (UNCITRAL) Canfor Corporation v. United States (UNCITRAL) Grand River Enterprises v. United States of America (UNCITRAL) Ghana v. Telekom Malaysia Berhad (UNCITRAL, heard by Dutch courts) BG Group v. Argentina (ICC) BIICL 13th Investment Treaty Forum Conference September 09

Reform? 2006 proposed amendment: Amend Rule 6(2), disclosure requirement, to include – “any circumstances likely to give rise to justifiable doubts as to the arbitrator’s reliability for independent judgment” Not adopted Note approach to appointments to annulment committees

Recommendations Challenges decided by an independent ad hoc committee Time limit of 30 days from appointment or discovery of facts Requirement of independence and impartiality

Recommendations (cont.) Test for disqualification: justifiable doubts as to independence and impartiality Doubts justified if a fair-minded and informed observer, if having considered the facts, would conclude that there was a real possibility that the arbitrator was not independent or not impartial

BIICL 13th Investment Treaty Forum Conference Audley Sheppard