Contesting Sociology as a Science. Interpretivism  Interpretivists argue that society cannot be studied in the same way as objects in natural science.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
TASK: The comparison between basic and applied research.
Advertisements

What is research methodology
PY226: Philosophy of Science The structure of scientific revolutions “The transfer of allegiance from paradigm to paradigm is a conversion experience”
Weber ‘Objective Possibility and Adequate Causation in Historical Explanation’.
Sociology as a Science. Natural Sciences  Biology and Chemistry are probably the first subjects which spring to mind when considering “what is science”
NORBERT ELIAS What is Sociology? Chapters One and Two.
Theories and Philosophies for Social Research Schutt Chapter 2.
The tripartite theory of knowledge
 Many scientists claim there is a clear distinction between science and the supernatural. A good recent example is Richard.
The Empiricists on Cause Locke: powers in material objects cause our ideas; ideas of primary qualities represent external things Berkeley: the concept.
Interpretivism: The research problem  Impact of Information Technology on gambling behaviour  Under-researched phenomena (minimal.
G544:DEBATES IS PSYCHOLOGY A SCIENCE?
CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH TRADITIONS.
Research Methods and Design
RSBM Business School Research in the real world: the users dilemma Dr Gill Green.
Nature of Politics Politics: Science or Art?. The scientific approach Generally described as a process in which investigators move from observations to.
3 rd Doctoral Colloquium Trinity College Dublin 6 th November 2012.
Sociological Research Methods and Techniques
Chapter 1 The Sociological Point of View. Chapter 1 The Sociological Point of View sociology surrounds us sociology surrounds us sociology- the study.
Lecture 3: Criticisms of Positivism; and the Interpretivist Approach
Objectivity & Subjectivity
INTRODUCTION TO SOCIOLOGY Duško Sekulić. Sociology is the scientific study of human society or the study of human behavior as shaped by group life. Including.
Nature of Politics Politics: Science or Art?.  Political science as a discipline involves the study of political ideas, institutions, processes and events.
Interpretivist Methods What is Interpretivism? It refers to the range of theoretical perspectives which assert that there is.
+ Research Paradigms Research Seminar (1/2 of book complete with this PP)
 To explain what is meant by the ‘scientific approach’  To discuss whether or not psychology is a science  To apply the scientific approach to the.
THEORY AND METHODS POSITIVISM Positivists see sociology as a science They seek to discover the objective social laws which cause.
Philosophical Aspects of Science Soraj Hongladarom Department of Philosophy Faculty of Arts.
Contrasting views of science: Popper vs. Kuhn. Sir Karl Popper Sir Karl Popper was a member of the Vienna Circle in the earlier part of the 20th century.
Paradigm Shifts S. Redden. The work of T. S. Khun The idea of the paradigm shift was developed by T. S. Khun in his PhD thesis, which was later published.
SCIENCE The aim of this tutorial is to help you learn to identify and evaluate scientific methods and assumptions.
Thomas Kuhn The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962)
The Sciences Natural and Human (Social) Sciences as Areas of Knowledge
AF1.1 L1-2 Using models for and in explanations Compare features or parts of objects, living things or events.
G544:DEBATES IS PSYCHOLOGY A SCIENCE?. Is Psychology a Science? Where do you stand and why? Yes No Justify!!!
G544:DEBATES IS PSYCHOLOGY A SCIENCE?. Is Psychology a Science? Where do you stand and why? Yes No Justify!!!
What Is Science?. 1. Science is limited to studying only the natural world. 2. The natural world are those phenomena that can be investigated, discovered,
What is Science? If some was ask to you: What is science? How would you respond? Body of Knowledge Method/Process A Way of Thinking or Constructing Reality.
Today we will discuss on - Scientific Method Scientific method is the systematic study through prearranged steps that ensures utmost objectivity and.
AREA STUDIES, RATIONAL CHOICE CULTURE AND THE THIRD WORLD Is It Possible to Explain Without Understand? By Nuno Magalhães SOGANG UNIVERSITY – THEORIES.
What is science?. Formal Systematic Rigorous Empirical (based on observation not personal opinion) Consistent Proven knowledge.
Science Have your say! Student Consultation on the Background Paper for Science.
The Sociological Imagination
Objectives The objectives of this lecture is to:
Sociology and science essay plan
The Sociological Imagination
Sociology as a Science.
Values in Sociology.
What is science?.
SCIENCE & KNOWLEDGE OF THE WORLD
Positivism: is sociology value free/should it be
Your homework question Due next Thursday
Sociology and science: interpretivism
Is sociology value free essay plan
Criticisms of Sociology as a Science:
Psychology as a science
IS Psychology A Science?
The Empiricists on Cause
Interpretivism (Sociology cannot be a Science):
Define the terms science and social science.
Sociology & Science: Sociology is often referred to as a ‘Social Science’ but can it truly be classified as a science? Scientific methodology can be used.
IS Psychology A Science?
Perspectives on Methodology: Positivism vs. Interpretivism:
Science of Biology
Philosophy of science is as useful to scientists as ornithology is to birds.
Criticisms of Sociology as a Science:
How do we start research?
Science Review Game.
CHAPTER 1 Review.
1) Positivism (Structural Theory) (Positivist Research)
Presentation transcript:

Contesting Sociology as a Science

Interpretivism  Interpretivists argue that society cannot be studied in the same way as objects in natural science  Drawing from Weber’s concept of VERSTEHEN or empathetic understanding, Sociologists should place themselves in the position of others  In this way they can understand social behaviour from the viewpoint of the individual.

Subjectivity  One of the difficulties with this approach is that verstehen explanations are subjective.  Different researchers may interpret the same event in different ways.  Some sociologists would claim that the only way to study aspects of society is to immerse oneself into it  The objectivity of natural science then appears irrelevant to developing understanding

Thomas Khun – the structure of scientific revolutions  Khun’s work on the development of natural science has been related to the development of social science  Khun states that science does not change gradually but goes through scientific revolutions where a “paradigm shift” takes place.  A paradigm is a way of viewing the world through the theories and methodology of science in a particular period of time

Paradigm shifts  A scientific revolution occurs when a contradiction in the old paradigm becomes apparent  One way of thinking is swept away by another  E.g. the discovery by Copernicus that the Earth revolves around the Sun – not the other way round  “Normal” science then returns until the next scientific revolution  Some sociologists would use Khun’s idea, arguing that it justifies Sociology as a science  If normal science is dependent on paradigm shifts then sociology may be more like normal science.

The Social context of science  Khun’s work suggests that it may not be possible to achieve an objective truth  As paradigms shift, the truth shifts.  This position has been developed to argue that science is not necessarily the objective pursuit of knowledge  Science studied within a social context, may lead to harm

The Realist view  Scientific enquiry demands the investigation of observable phenomena  Realists would argue that explanations in natural science and social science must involve an understanding of underlying and unobservable processes  Science must go under the surface and beyond the obvious  Much of sociology aims to uncover underlying structures and mechanisms in society such as patriarchy or labelling in order to understand society and human behaviour

Summary  There are those who say that Sociology is like the natural sciences (POSITIVISTS)  There are those who say it could be a science (POPPER)  Those who say it cannot be a science (INTERPRETIVISTS)  And those who analyse the nature of science and compare it to Sociology (KHUN & REALISTS)  If science is the use of systematic methods of empirical research and the logical assessment of theories, then Sociology is scientific  However, Sociology cannot be neutral, because it influences the very behaviour it attempts to explain