An Introductory Lecture to Environmental Epidemiology Part 3. Issues in Design. Mark S. Goldberg INRS-Institut Armand-Frappier, University of Quebec, and.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Sources and effects of bias in investigating links between adverse health outcomes and environmental hazards Frank Dunstan University of Wales College.
Advertisements

TRP Chapter Chapter 2.3 Environmental impacts and health risks.
CONCEPTS UNDERLYING STUDY DESIGN
CHEMICAL CARCINOGENS CHEMICAL CARCINOGENS. What is a Chemical Carcinogen?  Any chemical compound which has been shown to cause cancer in humans or in.
STUDY DESIGN CASE SERIES AND CROSS-SECTIONAL
Introduction to Cancer Epidemiology Epidemiology and Molecular Pathology of Cancer: Bootcamp course Tuesday, 3 January 2012.
Adverse Health Effects of Air Pollution in India JN Pande Sitaram Bhartia Institute of Science and Research, New Delhi.
What is a sample? Epidemiology matters: a new introduction to methodological foundations Chapter 4.
Biomarkers and Risk Assessment for Chromium(VI) Qingshan Qu, MD (PI) Roy Shore, PhD (Co-I) Dept. of Environmental Med. NYU School of Medicine.
Exposure Assessment Thanks to Marc Rigas, PhD for an earlier version of this lecture Much of the materials is drawn from Paustenbach, DJ. (2000) The practice.
Environmental Health III. Epidemiology Shu-Chi Chang, Ph.D., P.E., P.A. Assistant Professor 1 and Division Chief 2 1 Department of Environmental Engineering.
Gene-Environment Interaction: Definitions and Study Designs
Environmental Health XIV. Standards and Monitoring Shu-Chi Chang, Ph.D., P.E., P.A. Assistant Professor 1 and Division Chief 2 1 Department of Environmental.
Copyright 2002 Marc Rigas Issues in Exposure Assessment Marc L. Rigas, Ph.D. National Exposure Research Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
GIS in Spatial Epidemiology: small area studies of exposure- outcome relationships Robert Haining Department of Geography University of Cambridge.
Introduction of Cancer Molecular Epidemiology Zuo-Feng Zhang, MD, PhD University of California Los Angeles.
Study Design and Measures of Disease Frequency Intermediate Epidemiology.
IMPACTS OF CRITERIA AIR POLLUTANTS ON THE RESPIRATORY HEALTH OF CHILDREN John R. Balmes, MD UCSF.
Principles of Epidemiology Lecture 9 Dona Schneider, PhD, MPH, FACE
COHORT STUDY DR. A.A.TRIVEDI (M.D., D.I.H.) ASSISTANT PROFESSOR
How do cancer rates in your area compare to those in other areas?
Environmental Hazards, Risk, & Human Health. Leading Causes of Mortality.
Supercourse Environmental Exposure Assessment And Biomarkers Wael Al-Delaimy, MD, PhD.
Zuo-Feng Zhang, MD, PhD Epi242, Prospective:  Cohort Studies: Observational studies  Intervention Studies, Clinical Trials  Nested Case-Control.
Proposed Identification of Environmental Tobacco Smoke as a Toxic Air Contaminant Public Workshop Cal/EPA Headquarters Building Sierra Hearing Room Sacramento,
ATSDR’s approach to site assessment and epidemiologic considerations for multisite studies Steve Dearwent, PhD, MPH Chief, Health Investigations Branch.
Epidemiology The Basics Only… Adapted with permission from a class presentation developed by Dr. Charles Lynch – University of Iowa, Iowa City.
A short introduction to epidemiology Chapter 5: Measurement of exposure and health status Neil Pearce Centre for Public Health Research Massey University.
CHP400: Community Health Program- lI Research Methodology STUDY DESIGNS Observational / Analytical Studies Case Control Studies Present: Disease Past:
TRAINING FOR THE HEALTH SECTOR
Chapter 15 Environmental Health, Pollution and Toxicology.
Environmental Hazards & Human Health
Epidemiological Study designs
A short introduction to epidemiology Chapter 4: More complex study designs Neil Pearce Centre for Public Health Research Massey University Wellington,
PARTICLE EMISSIONS FROM TYRE AND BRAKE WEAR OPEN QUESTIONS Sustainable Transport Unit Institute for Energy and Transport Joint Research Centre 8 January.
An Introductory Lecture to Environmental Epidemiology Part 5. Ecological Studies. Mark S. Goldberg INRS-Institut Armand-Frappier, University of Quebec,
S. Mazloomzadeh MD, PhD COHORT STUDIES Learning Objectives To develop an understanding of: - What is a cohort study? - What types of cohort studies are.
Chapter 2 Nature of the evidence. Chapter overview Introduction What is epidemiology? Measuring physical activity and fitness in population studies Laboratory-based.
Department of Municipal Hygiene and Occupational Health Lecture on communal hygiene for 4th year Topic: "The influence of air pollution on the health of.
1 Basic epidemiological study designs and its role in measuring disease exposure association M. A. Yushuf Sharker Assistant Scientist Center for Communicable.
Integrating a gender perspective into environment statistics Workshop on Integrating a Gender Perspective into National Statistics, Kampala, Uganda 4 -
Organization of statistical research. The role of Biostatisticians Biostatisticians play essential roles in designing studies, analyzing data and.
Case-Control Studies Abdualziz BinSaeed. Case-Control Studies Type of analytic study Unit of observation and analysis: Individual (not group)
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Steven Markowitz, Problem-Based Exercises for Environmental Epidemiology, Office of Global and Integrated Environmental.
Part 1d: Exposure Assessment and Modeling Thomas Robins, MD, MPH.
EHS 507 Potential dose: the amount of chemical that is ingested or inhaled, or the amount of chemical contained in material applied to skin. Applied dose:
CHP400: Community Health Program - lI Research Methodology STUDY DESIGNS Observational / Analytical Studies Cohort Study Present: Disease Past: Exposure.
Timing of exposure assessment in relation to exposure occurrence:  Historical or retrospective: i.e., exposure reconstruction; an attempt to identify.
Air Pollution Research Group Analysis of 1999 TRI Data to Identify High Environmental Risk Areas of Ohio by Amit Joshi.
Descriptive study design
An Introductory Lecture to Environmental Epidemiology Part 1. Introductory Examples. Mark S. Goldberg INRS-Institut Armand-Frappier, University of Quebec,
NUATRC/TCEQ Air Toxics Workshop October Air Toxics Air Toxics: What We Know, What we Don’t Know, and What We Need to Know Human Health Effects –
BIOSTATISTICS Lecture 2. The role of Biostatisticians Biostatisticians play essential roles in designing studies, analyzing data and creating methods.
RISK DUE TO AIR POLLUTANTS
A short introduction to epidemiology Chapter 2: Incidence studies Neil Pearce Centre for Public Health Research Massey University Wellington, New Zealand.
(RWB / The Road to PM Understanding / November 2004) ExxonMobil Biomedical Sciences, Inc. 1 Adapted from Dan Greenbaum Health Effects Institute US EPA.
Hss4303b – Intro to Epidemiology March22, 2010 – Environmental Epidemiology.
Headlines Introduction General concepts
Body or Tissue Burden. Some Toxicants With Very Slow Elimination.
An Introductory Lecture to Environmental Epidemiology Part 4. Some Issues in Exposure Assessment Mark S. Goldberg INRS-Institut Armand-Frappier, University.
Case control & cohort studies
Exposure Prediction and Measurement Error in Air Pollution and Health Studies Lianne Sheppard Adam A. Szpiro, Sun-Young Kim University of Washington CMAS.
N Engl J Med Jun 29;376(26): doi: 10
Lecture 4: Risk Analysis
Present: Disease Past: Exposure
Biologic Monitoring A. H. Mehrparvar, MD
Which method is most appropriate for assessing exposure?
Lecture 1: Fundamentals of epidemiologic study design and analysis
George Washington University
Presentation transcript:

An Introductory Lecture to Environmental Epidemiology Part 3. Issues in Design. Mark S. Goldberg INRS-Institut Armand-Frappier, University of Quebec, and McGill University July 2000

In Part 1 we discussed examples of ecological studies used to investigate environmental hazards. In Part 2, I presented an example of a study design (time series) used to investigate daily fluctuations of mortality in relation to changes in air pollution. In this Part, we shall survey the standard designs used in environmental epidemiology and will discuss some important issues.

Types of Studies Ecological studies –Pure ecological studies –Mixed ecological/individual studies Cluster investigations –“’Unusual’ aggregation in time, space, or both of occurrences of disease(s)” Cyclical and other temporal patterns –Time series studies (see Part 2 of this lecture)

Longitudinal trends –Age-period-cohort models of rates Case-control studies Cross-sectional studies Prospective and retrospective cohort studies

Spatially-Related Analyses Mapping of rates –Definition of geographic regions e.g., using postal or zip code areas versus the smaller enumeration areas –Sparse data  extreme values Two-stage analyses (e.g., empirical Bayes)

–Errors in numerators and denominators Migration to and from study regions Incomplete ascertainment of cases Conversion between different geographic identifiers

Tradeoffs in defining geographic areas –Large areas: increased variability of exposure between subjects fewer problems with mobility reduced errors in estimating numerators and denominators less extreme values

bias from aggregation of variables at smaller levels of geography (e.g., from enumeration areas to census tracts) –Small areas: reduced variability of exposure between subjects high variability and extreme values for outcomes between areas difficulties with mobility and estimating numerators and denominators

Example: Cluster Investigation in Reprocessed Textile Workers Observation of unusually high lung cancer mortality rates in 1979 in Prato, Italy High rates of malignant mesothelioma found among rag sorters in Prato A case-control study in Prato ( ) showed a 50% excess of lung cancer in textiles workers See Quinn et al., Am J Ind Med 1987;11:255-66; Paci et al., Am J Ind Med 1987;11:267-73

Major industry in Prato is recycling of old clothes Industrial hygiene survey of rag sorters working in small shops Clothing and rags from all over the world Clothes arrived in plastic bags or in bales Rags sorted by hand by men sitting on the floor Rags then baled and shipped to other processing plants

It was found that bags from Canada, the US, the Soviet Union, South Africa, and Australia contained large quantities of asbestos These bags were ripped open by workers to be used as recycled bale covers Asbestos fibers identified in breathing air zones of these workers

Components of an Environmental Epidemiologic Study What is the problem? –Accidents –Perception of a hazard Clusters in space and time –Investigator’s imagination Precise study objectives

Precise definition of target population –Who is exposed? –Which population can serve as “unexposed” or reference group? –Effect of patterns in mobility of the target population?

Outcomes Definition of potential confounding variables Definition of variables that may indicate biologic interactions Statistical power –Size of target population and expected level of effects

Key Issues Expected response rates Migration Measurement of exposures Measurement of potential confounders Interactions? Biases Pilot studies

Outcomes Acute versus chronic effects (latency) Precise definitions –Cancer Histological confirmation –Respiratory Chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases –ATS standardized questionnaire Asthma Lung function –Standardization to expected values (age, height, gender)

Confounding Variables Definitions and effects differ depending on whether study is ecological or individual- based Individual studies: causally associated with outcome and associated with exposure –Effects must be estimated on same scale (e.g., correlation coefficients do not reflect level of association in case-control studies (odds ratios))

Biological Interactions –Not in causal pathway –Variables can also be used to adjust for selection biases Susceptible subgroups –Fewer subjects, perhaps greater effects (effect on power??) –Gene-environment interactions

Environmental Exposure Assessment Exposure –Amount of a contaminant that a person may come into physical contact with over a specified period of time Dose –Amount of a contaminant that is absorbed or deposited in an organism over a specified period of time –Usually measured as mass per unit volume or per unit mass of affected tissue (e.g., blood lead levels in µgm per deci-liter)

EXPOSURE ANALYSIS APPROACHES INDIRECT METHODS DIRECT METHODS PERSONAL MONITORING BIOLOGICAL MARKERS ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING MODELS DIARIES QUESTIONNAIRES EXPOSURE MODELS FACTORS SCHEMATIC OF APPROACHES TO ESTIMATE ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURES PHARMACOKINETIC AND PHARMACODYNAMIC MODELS MITIGATION MEASURES

Exposures versus dose –Distribution in the body –Chemical and physical properties of agents (e.g., solubility in water, lipid tissues) –Metabolic processes, detoxification => metabolites –Body burdens (sojourn times, interactions with other organs, feedback mechanisms)

Action of chemicals: Examples Genotoxic –Mutagens and carcinogens (e.g., ionizing radiation; benzene) Organ-specific toxicity –Ethylene glycol (aircraft de-icing) causes kidney dysfunction and serious irreversible damage in sufficiently high doses Immunological/neurological effects –E.g.; Volatile organic compounds may induce neurogenic inflammation mediated through chemical receptors on slow velocity neural C-fibers. (See Meggs, 1993.)

Examples of Measurement of Dose Serum carboxyhemoglobin as a marker both for exposure to CO (for a study of cardiovascular diseases) Blood lead levels in children living near major traffic arteries (for a study of intellectual functioning)

Example: Organ-specific Doses of Ionizing Radiation from Diagnostic X-rays Energy and distribution of flux of photons at skin estimated from: –Geometry of radiograph (view, distance to x-ray tube) –Parameters of x-ray tube (voltage, amperage, integrated time) –Shielding –Age and gender of subject

Organ-specific doses estimated from Monte-Carlo calculations of photon flux through simulated body –Validated using standard phantom Doses estimated for members of a cohort of Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis Excess risks projected into time using dose-response models and lifetables

Methods of Estimating Exposure Questionnaires –Information on physical properties of an environment E.g., standardized questionnaire on indoor air quality (see Lebowitz et al., 1988) “Are you exposed to ….?” “Do you use a wood stove…?”

Simple categorization of potential exposure –“Do you smell odours around your home…?” –“How many members of your family smoke cigarettes in your home?” “Approximately how many per day?” etc…. Activity patterns –“How much time do you spend doing…?”

Direct Measures of Exposure Personal monitoring –In breathing zone –Through dosimeters and other active or passive samplers worn by subjects –Response rates very important –Development of prediction models comparing personal measures with area measures –Be wary of longitudinal versus cross- sectional studies

Indirect Measures of Exposure Microenvironmental monitoring –Long-term samples or grab samples to determine spatial-temporal distribution (active or passive samplers) –Ambient air monitors for ozone, sulfur dioxide, particles –Measurement of methane & volatile organic compounds in air, soil, and ground water around municipal solid waste landfill sites

Statistical modelling (prediction models) using questionnaires, area measures, and personal monitoring –Spatial interpolation techniques (Kriging) Other methods –Proximity to source –Distance from source

References Lebowitz M.D., Quackenboss J.J., Kollander M., Soczek M.L., Colome S. The new standard environmental inventory questionnaire for estimation of indoor concentrations. JAPCA 1988;39: Ryan P.B., Soczek M.L., Treitman R.D., Spengler J.D., Billick I.H. The Boston residential NO 2 characterization study - II. Survey methodology and population concentration estimates. Atmos Environ 1988; 22:2115-.

Meggs WJ. Neurogenic inflammation and sensitivity to environmental chemicals. Environ Health Perspect 1993:101: “Human Exposure Assessment for Airborne Pollutants: Advances and Opportunities”. National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC 1991 Hertz-Piccioto, I. “Environmental Epidemiology”, in Rothman and Greenland: Modern Epidemiology, Second edition, Lippincott-Raven Publishers, 1998, Philadelphia, Chapter 28, pages