TOK Camp 2013 – TOK Presentation Preparation Part 1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The only thing all about you is the grade:-]. Critical Analysis Addressing two fundamental questions: What it is I claim to know? How valid are the methods.
Advertisements

By Anthony Campanaro & Dennis Hernandez
Division of Youth Services Oct 26, 2012 Common Core & the Content Areas.
Chapter Twelve: The Fact-Value Problem Chapter Twelve: The Fact-Value Problem Metaethics ► Philosophizing about the very terms of ethics ► Considering.
© Cambridge International Examinations 2013 Component/Paper 1.
Why study Logic?. Logic is of the greatest importance. Logic is one of the most important courses in a classical education. It is the only course that.
The Heart of ToK Knowledge Questions.
 Three examples of Knowledge Issues that could be addressed in this title: ◦ To what extent do our senses give us the truth? ◦ To what extent do reason,
IB THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE An Overview.
VCE Religion and Society Revised Study
Michael Lacewing Emotivism Michael Lacewing
Principles of High Quality Assessment
Research problem, Purpose, question
Philosophy and The Search for Truth. Philosophy is perhaps the most “open” of all subjects. Its primary goals are clarity of expression and thought, and.
MORAL THEORY: INTRODUCTION PHILOSOPHY 224. THE ROLE OF REASONS A fundamental feature of philosophy's contribution to our understanding of the contested.
Science Inquiry Minds-on Hands-on.
TOK Camp 2013 – TOK Presentation Preparation Part 2.
Critical Thinking in Education. Defining Critical Thinking Asking pertinent questions Evaluates statements & arguments Admits a lack of knowledge & understanding.
Theory of Knowledge An Introduction. Language How reliable is the information? How reliable are our senses? Are we being logical? How strong are the.
UNIT 1 PERIOD STUDY FROM OVERVIEW OF THE PERIOD STUDY PROVISION FOR 2015 SOME SPECIFIC ISSUES STRUCTURE OF THIS SESSION.
or, how to improve your answers Recognising Command Words.
To Think Or Not To Think: That Is The Question Abstract Year after year, teachers recognize that many of their students lack critical thinking skills or.
STRUCTURE OF TOK Working guide to terms, concepts, etc.
Easy steps to writing THE ESSAY. Writing an essay means: Creating ideas from information Creating arguments from ideas Creating academic discourse to.
From the last lesson: Ducks, Jimi Hendrix and Knowledge Questions open-ended questions that admit more than one possible answer explicitly about knowledge.
Active Listening Listening carefully to what the speaker is saying, without judgment or evaluation. Listening to both the content of the message as well.
STOP DOING MATH LONG ENOUGH TO LEARN IT How to Study Math –Short Version Delano P. Wegener, Ph.D. Spring 2005.
MY E-PORFOLIO. ¨Evaluation¨… What I know…What I want to know…What I learned… -Process/formative vs product/summative evaluation -Necessary to make changes.
Highlights from Educational Research: Its Nature and Rules of Operation Charles and Mertler (2002)
ToK ESSAY The instructions tell you to: Remember to centre your essay on knowledge issues and,where appropriate, refer to other parts of your IB programme.
Environmental Science
AIT, Comp. Sci. & Info. Mgmt AT02.98 Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues in Computing September Term, Objectives of these slides: l What ethics is,
READING #1: “What This Book is About” Chapter One from The Ethics of Teaching.
Introduction to Critical Thinking Developing Critical Thinking Skills.
CHAPTER 1 Understanding RESEARCH
Philosophy 224 Moral Theory: Introduction. The Role of Reasons A fundamental feature of philosophy's contribution to our understanding of the contested.
Philosophy 2803 – Health Ethics Andrew Latus. Introduction Ethics Study of right and wrong/good and bad A Branch of Philosophy Central Question = “How.
Virtual Canada 2.0. » Knowledge is not just information » Knowledge is not philosophy (but it can be approached through philosophical inquiry) » There.
What is Ethics? Ethics is the philosophical study of what is right or wrong, good or bad, in that part of human conduct for which we are responsible, excluding.
ToK March 2013 Understanding Knowledge Questions..
Welcome to Psychology International Baccalaureate Group 3: Psychology Course Guide September May 2012.
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?. SCIENTIFIC WORLD VIEW 1.The Universe Is Understandable. 2.The Universe Is a Vast Single System In Which the Basic Rules.
Knowledge issues are questions that explicitly address knowledge. Knowledge issues are best expressed in terms of ToK vocabulary. For example, When is.
Lecture 3: The nature of epistemic justification.
Formulating & Developing Knowledge Question (KQ) Theory of Knowledge.
Writing a Critical Review
Academic Vocabulary. Analysis The process or result of identifying the parts of a whole and their relationships to one another.
Focus Education Assessing Reading: Exceeding Year 1 Expectations Year 1 Exceeding Expectations: Reading Read accurately and confidently words of.
Debate 101 Brand. Class Rules We are respectful We are considerate We listen the first time We will be present We are responsible What are some of the.
Knowledge Questions An Introduction. What is a “Knowledge Question” Questions about knowledge. Apply to any aspect of knowledge  Acquisition  Production.
Knowledge Questions The Good, the Bad and The Ugly.
What is TaK? Looking back … Looking forward …
Subject-specific content: A Generic scoring guide for information-based topics 4 The student has a complete and detailed understanding of the information.
How to Pass General Studies An Idiots’ guide (for idiots)
Philosophy An introduction. What is philosophy? Ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle said that philosophy is ‘the science which considers truth’
Your ToK presentation …does not involve dressing in a banana outfit. Phew.
Introducing Ethical Capability Focus on F-6. Objectives  an overview of the Ethical Capability curriculum  introduction of an ethical issue planning.
Applying and extending analytical skills Chapter 8.
ETHICS Shawnna Burchfield HU Table of Contents Analytical Skill Building  Critical Reading Skills  Writing Skills  Thinking Skills Knowledge.
Philosophy 224 Moral Theory: Introduction. The Role of Reasons A fundamental feature of philosophy ' s contribution to our understanding of the contested.
Writing Test September 27, 2011 All Juniors must take and pass in order to receive a diploma.
KNOWLEDGE QUESTIONS THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY.
PHI 208 Course Extraordinary Success tutorialrank.com
KNOWLEDGE QUESTIONS (KQs)
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?
Ethics and the Examined Life
Jez Echevarría 6th September 2013
Philosophical Methods
Personal and shared knowledge
Presentation transcript:

TOK Camp 2013 – TOK Presentation Preparation Part 1

The presentation The presentation is the first of the two assessments for TOK. You can do your presentation as an individual, or in a group of 2. Either way, each speaker has to speak for 10 minutes. The presentation involves skills, knowledge and understandings that will be directly applicable to the second assessment: the essay. The presentation is internally assessed (assessed by your TOK teachers) whereas the essay will be externally assessed.

The basic structure of the presentation

Topic for the rest of this presentation: How to get from a real-life situation to a high quality knowledge issue.

What is a knowledge issue? A knowledge issue is essentially a question regarding knowledge. Here are some examples of knowledge issues, not all of which are of the same quality: Is belief in God really justifiable? What is it about a scientific explanation that makes it convincing or unconvincing? What reasons might we have for adopting capital punishment?

How to tell a high quality knowledge issue from a lower quality knowledge issue Here are some criteria to help you tell the difference: (1) Open-ended questions are better than closed questions. (2) Questions that are explicitly about knowledge are better than ones that are only implicitly about knowledge (or not about knowledge at all). (3) Questions that are expressed in terms of TOK vocabulary and concepts are better than questions that are not.

Criterion 1: open-ended versus closed questions Closed questions can be answered with a “yes”, a “no” or some other short phrase: Examples of closed questions: Do you know the time? Is scientific knowledge possible? Is there such a thing as progress in the arts?

Criterion 1: open-ended versus closed questions Open-ended questions are ones that cannot be given a brief answer. In order to answer an open-ended question it will be usually necessary to answer a set of sub-questions, some of which will be closed questions. Examples of open-ended questions: What are the differences and similarities between the methods of inquiry used in the physical and human sciences? How has the scientific method evolved over time? What methods of inquiry should be used to decide ethical questions?

Criterion 2: Is the question explicitly about knowledge? For TOK assessment purposes, it is better to have a question that is explicitly about knowledge itself than one that focuses on a subject-specific claim. Here are some examples of questions that focus on subject specific claims: What are the causes of mental illness? What are the fundamental principles of mathematics? Will stem-cell research really lead to significant medical breakthroughs?

Criterion 2: Is the question explicitly about knowledge? Here are some examples of questions that do explicitly focus on knowledge: What role does sense-perception play in justifying our beliefs about morality? What is the difference between a valid and an invalid inference? Can a scientist ever really know that one of theories is correct?

Criterion 3: Is the question expressed using TOK terminology? By expressing your question in terms of TOK terminology, you can make clear to your teachers, and ultimately to your external examiner, how your question relates to the content of the TOK course.

Criterion 3: Is the question expressed using TOK terminology? Non-TOK-vocab: What makes an argument good or bad? TOK-vocab: What is the difference between a valid and an invalid inference? Non-TOK-vocab: Can a scientist ever really know that one of their theories is correct? TOK-vocab: Is it possible to conclusively verify the truth of a scientific theory? Non-TOK-vocab: Is it OK for me to go on my gut-instinct when deciding whether to support capital punishment? TOK-vocab: What role should intuition play in justifying capital punishment?

Getting a feel for good knowledge issue The criteria laid out in this presentation should be treated as a guide rather than as a set of hard and fast rule. As you practice applying these criteria, you will start to get a feel for the difference between good and bad knowledge issues.

Extracting a knowledge issue from a real-life situation Example 1: The centre is home to the Cunningham Dax Collection, 15,000 works of art by people who have experienced mental health issues and/or trauma. It is one of the few heritage-listed art collections in Australia. Read more: ny4d.html#ixzz2Vm7kYgiFhttp:// ny4d.html#ixzz2Vm7kYgiF First attempt: Can art be used as therapy for the mentally ill? Second attempt: How can we know if art is a good form of therapy for the mentally ill? Third attempt: Are there aspects of our lives that can be expressed through art and not through other modes of communication? Fourth attempt: Can the study of art reveal truths about human psychology that cannot be uncovered through the human or physical sciences?

Extracting a knowledge issue from a real-life situation Example 2: Do you find people often ask you ‘what’s wrong?’ when there’s really nothing wrong. Do strangers seem to take an immediate dislike to you? Then perhaps you have the heavy brows, pouty mouth, or angular features that contribute to ‘b*tchy resting face’. Sure, people are designed to be able to read each other’s emotions. It’s what stops us from wanting to strangle each other. But sometimes, your face just naturally sits in a way that indicates mild displeasure nyuq.html#ixzz2Vm6ErQ8chttp:// nyuq.html#ixzz2Vm6ErQ8c First attempt: What kinds of facial features make a person look b*tchy? Second attempt: Is it possible to draw inaccurate conclusions about someone’s mental state based on their facial expressions? Third attempt: What role do sense-perception and reason play in our judgments regarding the emotional states of others?

Extracting a knowledge issue from a real-life situation Example 3: America's top intelligence official has angrily defended the government's secret monitoring of internet users, insisting the vast operation is legal and vital to national security. National intelligence director James Clapper said the activities were ''conducted under authorities widely known and discussed, and fully debated and authorised by Congress'’. over-esurveillance nxvo.html#ixzz2VmAsC37Q’ over-esurveillance nxvo.html#ixzz2VmAsC37Q First attempt: What methods do governments use to spy on their citizens? Second attempt: Under what circumstances is it ethical for governments to spy on their citizens? Third attempt: Should all knowledge be freely accessible to everyone at all times? Or, are their ethical reasons for restricting access to certain kinds of knowledge?