{ Philosophical Methods Exploring some ways people go about “thinking about thinking”.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Socratic Seminar. Debate and Dialogue Dialogue is collaborative: multiple sides work toward shared understanding. Debate is oppositional: two opposing.
Advertisements

By Anthony Campanaro & Dennis Hernandez
Value conflicts and assumptions - 1 While an author usually offers explicit reasons why he comes to a certain conclusion, he also makes (implicit) assumptions.
12 Things To Avoid Move Your Life Forward.
Personal Identity. CAUSAL EFFICACY OF CONTENT Breaking Glass o.
Unlocking the mind to critical thinking. “Thinking about Thinking”
‘Love your neighbour’ Making it happen... Cafe Church 2 nd November 2014.
Why Critical Thinking Is Important Critical thinking is a skill. It is active interpretation and evaluation of observation, communication, information.
Critical Thinking. Definition: Evaluating whether we should be convinced that a claim is true or that an argument is good. It’s also about formulating.
Definitions – John Dewey
Misconceptions of Philosophy
Perceptions of the Role of Feedback in Supporting 1 st Yr Learning Jon Scott, Ruth Bevan, Jo Badge & Alan Cann School of Biological Sciences.
Types of Essays... and why we write them.. Why do we write essays? Hint: The answer is NOT ‘because sir/miss told me to’
Basic Debating Skills.
See no evil Learning Objectives for today : 1. Understand how Religious education is different. 2. Identify what Religion is. 3. Have an understanding.
Why Critical Thinking Is Important Critical thinking is skilled and active interpretation and evaluation of observations and communications, information.
The Philosophy of Exotischism Ignorance Is No Excuse 1 Most of us have heard the old expression "ignorance is no excuse for breaking the law". If courts.
Critical Thinking Skills for all Subjects
Critical Thinking in Education. Defining Critical Thinking Asking pertinent questions Evaluates statements & arguments Admits a lack of knowledge & understanding.
Learning to Think Critically
Learning to Think Critically pages Objectives Define thinking & reflection Identify 3 functions of the brain Describe how thinking impacts decision.
The Cosmological Argument (Causation or ‘first cause’ theory)
Introduction to Moral Philosophy Moral philosophy is about making moral choices – about how people decide what is moral / immoral. Morality is concerned.
What does Socratic mean? Socratic comes from the name Socrates Socrates Classical Greek philosopher who developed a Theory of Knowledge.
HZB301 Philosophy Room 158 Mr. Baker.
Copyright © by Holt, Rinehart and Winston. All rights reserved. Chapter 2: Skills for a Healthy Life 1.I review all of my choices before I make a decision.
The Problem of Knowledge 2 Pages Table of Contents Certainty p – Radical doubt p Radical doubt Relativism p Relativism What should.
Healthy Relationships Interpersonal Communication I Block Feb 12, 2013.
Or what you always wish your math teachers had told you.
ToK - Emotion What do you think of when you hear the word ‘Emotion’?
Responsible Engineers Framing the Problem. How do we address a problem? When addressing an ethical dilemma, we usually experience moral disagreement and.
Reflection: TOPIC: Are people naturally “good” or are they forced to be “good” by social rules and legal institutions? INTRODUCE EVIDENCE: Why do you believe.
PEP 570, DeGeorge, Chp. 3 10/28/20151 Chapter Three: Dr. DeGeorge Utilitarianism: Justice and Love.
Enrichment Seminar #3 “Creative Thinking” – Part B Dr. Kelly Cohen July 21, 2009.
WHEN CHRISTIANS GET IT WRONG When Bad Things Happen.
Being True to Ourselves. What does it mean to “follow your conscience?” How do you know that following your conscience is the right thing to do?
It’s Dialogue Not Debate!.  Socrates believed that enabling students to think for themselves was more important than filling their heads with “right.
SELF-ESTEEM. Workshop Overview Self-Esteem…What is it? Self-Esteem…What’s it made of? Types of Self-esteem The secret to improving Self-esteem.
Philosophy 224 What is a Theory of Human Nature?.
Module 2.2.  Learn the importance of using probing questions during the tutoring session.
Asking Questions C&I 212 Spring 2007 Dr. Toledo Source: Taxonomy of Socratic QuestioningTaxonomy of Socratic Questioning.
Beyond Blooms – Socratic Questioning Extension from the training day
Philosophy 1050: Introduction to Philosophy Week 4: Personal Identity III and Plato.
Slide 21-1 Copyright © 2004 Pearson Education, Inc.
Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 1-a What is philosophy? By David Kelsey.
w/ The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
Plato’s Allegory of the Cave Philosophy Philos – love, like, seeking Sophia - wisdom, knowledge, truth.
Socratic Seminar By participating in Scholars will practice academic behavior and language that will be expected in a 21 st century classroom & worksplace.
Writing an Essay. Reading a Primary Source: Step 1 Who wrote this document? In the first place, you need to know how this document came to be created.
Logical Fallacies A logical fallacy is an element of an argument that is flawed If spotted one can essentially render an entire line of reasoning invalid.
Philosophy An introduction. What is philosophy? Ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle said that philosophy is ‘the science which considers truth’
NOTES Chapter 3 – Communication, Conflict, and Conflict Resolution.
Socratic Method and Reasoning
WHERE QUESTIONS, NOT ANSWERS, ARE THE DRIVING FORCE IN THINKING Socratic Discussion.
Critical Thinking  A key academic skill  Required for successful study.
#1 Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them How would you describe the problem in your own words? How would you describe what you are trying.
PBIS COOL TOOLS for SUCCESS Courtesy Being courteous means treating others with respect. When you are courteous you are showing others that you have.
Ethics in Sports and Physical Education: A Source of Role Conflict.
BBI 2O Name:. With a partner discuss each of the following terms and what they mean to you. Then write IN YOUR OWN WORDS the definitions in the following.
Week 24 Antigone AP Prompt How should I write this? What are they talking about and what are they asking me to do?
The Fine Art of Knowing How Wrong You Might Be. To Err Is Human Humans make an infinitude of mistakes. I figure safety in numbers makes it a little more.
Building peace starts with you
Learning to Think Critically
Learning to Think Critically
Socratic Questioning.
Critical Thinking and Viewing
CBT For Chronic Illness And Palliative Care: A Workbook and Toolkit
Bellwork In two large groups, analyze the post-it notes for ABSTRACT or CONCRETE concepts Does the example fit the description of ABSTRACT or CONCRETE?
Learning to Think Critically
Zimbabwe 2008 Critical Thinking.
Presentation transcript:

{ Philosophical Methods Exploring some ways people go about “thinking about thinking”.

We already know that philosophy is highly concerned with critical thinking and asking questions. Choosing the correct words for questions and arguments is very important. Imprecise language often leads to confusion and unnecessary disagreements. This is why Socrates stressed the importance of precise definitions in philosophical discussion. Definitions and Clarity

Imagine you and a friend are discussing the fairness of a quiz – if you don’t have a similar idea of what is meant by “fairness”, then your discussion could amount to nothing. Definitions and Clarity

Dictionary.com defines “fair” as: adjective1.free from bias, dishonesty, or injustice: a fair decision; a fair judge.decision This definition is a good starting point, and be fine for discussing a quiz in school, but a philosopher would prefer to go well beyond this. They seek a deeper, more thorough understanding of the concept being discussed. Definitions and Clarity

What is Freedom? A philosopher would not find the answer they are looking for in a dictionary. They would try to understand the role of freedom in people’s lives and thoughts, whether freedom can be misused and whether it relates to other concepts like equality and justice. Can a philosopher ever find the truth they seek? Can true definitions ever be reached for concepts like freedom, love, equality, hate or evil? Philosophers continue to discuss and try. Definitions and Clarity

As we have said, choosing the right words for questions is very important. Philosophers pay special attention to first order and second order language. Language Matters

First order language is concerned with the specific. (ex.) His lie caused the mistake. First order questions have a limited number of responses. (ex.) Is it right or wrong for me to cheat on this test? Language Matters

Second order language is considered higher order language. It is used to clarify first order language. (ex.) What does it mean to say that cheating is right or wrong? (ex.) What does it mean to say that his lie caused the mistake? Second order language helps clarify ideas and allows people to think critically. It looks at all possibilities and implications. Language Matters

You try! With a partner, create 2 first order questions. Then look at the questions again – how can you turn them into second order questions ? Example: 1 st order: Should I go to the party? 2 nd order: What would be the consequences if I went to the party? 1 st order: Is it stealing to take a better seat at a concert? 2 nd order: What does it mean to steal? Is there ever a time when stealing can be justified? Language Matters

Recall that Socrates wanted people to accept that there was much they did not know. One highly effective technique that encourages people to challenge common-sense beliefs and develop clear definitions is the Socratic method. Socratic Method

Article: How to Argue Using the Socratic Method Socratic Method

What kinds of questions can we ask to refute somebody’s argument?  Why do you say that?  How does this relate to our discussion?  What could we assume instead?  How can you prove that?  What is an example?  But what if…?  Why do you think that happens?  What’s another way to look at it?  Who benefits from that?  Why is that best?  What are the strengths and weaknesses of this argument?  What generalizations can you make?  What are the consequences of this assumption?  What was the point of that question?  Why did I ask that question? Socratic Method

Thought experiments are another tool philosophers use to push common-sense beliefs to the breaking point. The logic behind a thought experiment is that if people’s common-sense beliefs crumble under the pressure imposed by a thought experiment, perhaps those beliefs should be re-examined. Thought Experiments

Thought experiments usually begin with, or include, the question “what if?” They then propose an imaginary situation or event, something that does not exist, has never existed, and will probably never exist. In other words, thought experiments propose a possible world. Everything in the possible world is the same as the real world, except for the imaginary situation or event. Thought Experiments

(ex.) The Ship of Theseus

Another philosopher returned to the thought experiment of The Ship of Theseus and asked another question – suppose somebody had taken each rotting plank as it was removed from the ship and had assembled them into a ship again. Now which ship is the original ship? (ex.) The Ship of Theseus

Thought experiments must be handled with great care. It is possible that they help people arrive at new perspectives on common-sense beliefs, some thought experiments prove little or nothing at all. What do you think the possible drawbacks or cons of doing a thought experiment are? Thought Experiments

The most difficult part about participating in a thought experiment is marking the boundaries of the discussion. Once an imaginary situation is proposed, it can lead to proposing an infinite number of imaginary situations – “what ifs” can build and build with no end in sight, effectively defeating the purpose of the experiment. Thought Experiments