 Subaltern refers to persons socially, politically, and geographically outside of the hegemonic power structure.  Subalterns are groups who have had.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
GLOBALIZATION AND NATIONALISM. Conceptions Nationalism: heightened sense of national identity, discourse of sameness, we-ness Something natural, primordial,
Advertisements

IR2501 – week 8 lectures II – Postcolonial Studies.
Subaltern Perspectives on South Asian History and Society.
Themes in Modern Indian History
Postcolonial Theory Feminist Theory. CRITICAL THEORY an interdisciplinary social theory oriented toward critiquing and changing society as a whole, in.
Week 9: Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak “Can the Subaltern Speak?”
Shirin M Rai.  Provocation: how is what we know framed as knowledge through particular systems of representation and the practices of colonial governance.
Literary Theory and Methodology Session Two: Postcolonialist Theories.
Writing British Asian Cities: History, memory and the postcolonial William Gould.
Michel Foucault A Brief Overview. His Work His writings have had an enormous impact on other scholarly work: Foucault's influence extends across the humanities.
Gramsci iii  Subalterns, Elites, Intellectuals and Cultural Change.
E THNIC AND P OST -C OLONIAL S TUDIES. Authors in previous study blocks have critiqued stable, fixed notions of identity, identity as a state, preferring.
1. Feminisms and Feminist Literary Criticism: Definitions 2. Woman: Created or Constructed? 人社 100 鄭朱晏.
POST- MODERNISM P OST - MODERNISM P OST - MODERNISM POST-MODERNISM.
Cultural Studies. Definitions of Cultural Studies First, cultural studies transcends the confines of a particular discipline such as literary criticism.
Introduction to Post-Coloniality Homi Bhabha: The Location of Culture, 1994.
Literary Analysis, Criticism and Theory. What is a Literary Analysis? Literary analysis involves breaking a text’s structure and content into smaller.
Introduction to Post-Coloniality Homi Bhabha: The Location of Culture, 1994.
SpivakSaid Edward Said – born Edward Wadi SaïdGayatri Spivak –born Gayatri Chakravorty.
Introduction to Post-Coloniality Homi Bhabha: The Location of Culture, 1994.
Critical Lenses. Reader Response Criticism Focuses on the activity of reading a work of literature. Reader response critics shift the meaning of a work.
Feminism and Colonialism
Overview Mohanty continued Spivak Narayan. Gayatri Spivak-Terms Strategic essentialism- no essence based on biology or culture, but can be employed for.
Post-Colonialism From political to cultural independence.
Loomba – The End Post-Modernism and Postcolonial Studies Conclusion.
3. Is Zoroastrianism monotheistic, polytheistic, or animistic?
Literary Theory and Methodology Spring 2008 Session One: Postcolonialist Theories.
1 Literary Criticism Exploring literature beneath the surface.
The Body Janet Wolff: “The body has been systematically repressed and marginalized in Western culture, with specific practices, ideologies, and discourses.
ORWELL’S 1984 AND FOUCAULT THURSDAY ORWELL -BORN ERIC ARTHUR BLAIR, AN ENGLISHMAN, BORN IN INDIA IN SERVED WITH INDIAN IMPERIAL POLICE.
Introduction to Literary Theories and Paragraph Structure Learning Goal: To develop an understanding of postcolonial/cultural theory and effective paragraph.
The question of representation Spivak/Devi. Representation and its meanings a) to re-present, as in the work of imagination that re-presents reality in.
Cultural turns: - how culture impacts translation - why linguistics is not enough - translation: more than a text, it is politics!
Colonialism’s epilogue Liv Magnien The effects of a nation being invaded and colonized.
LITERARY THEORY AND SCHOOLS OF CRITICISM.  Characterized by close reading  The text is studied without a consideration of era or author  Questions.
ORIENTALISM Edward Said.  Edward Said surveys the history and nature of Western attitudes towards the East, considering Orientalism as a powerful European.
TEXT & MEANING Postcolonial Theory. Postcolonial Theory –What it is Focuses on the reading and writing of literature written in previously or currently.
Postcolonialism By Antolin Bonnett and Olivia Rushin.
P OSTCOLONIAL E PISTEMOLOGIES Gurminder K Bhambra Wednesday 6 th November, 2013.
Reconceptualising African Scholarship in a Multi-cultural context : Some Reflections on Humanities and Social Science Disciplines at a South African University.
Lecture 1/Term 3: Postmodernity/Postmodernism Dr Claudia Stein.
A Literature of Their Own!. What is Lit Crit? A very basic way of thinking about literary theory is that these ideas act as different lenses critics use.
Ranajit Guha and Subaltern Studies Broad movements/shifts in historical studies after WW2 Intellectual currents: from Marxism to structuralism,
Representation Ryan, Gemma and Phil. Karl Marx and his ideas “The oppressed are allowed once every few years to decide which particular representatives.
Colonialism. What is colonialism/imperialism? Waylen distinguishes ‘old’ and ‘new’ forms of colonialism Old colonialism – late 15 th and 16 th centuries.
Postcolonialism.
BBL 3403 RESEARCH METHODS IN LITERATURE
Ranajit Guha and Subaltern Studies
The question of representation
Introduction to Feminism
Definitions, Important Concepts, Major Figures, and Uses
MODERN PERIOD IN INDIAN HISTORY
GayatrI Chakravorty SpIvak
Critical Theory or Literary Criticism
The Post Colonial Critic (1990s-present)
POSTCOLONIAL CRITICISM
LITERARY THEORIES ENG4U.
Post-Colonial Criticism
POSTCOLONIAL CRITICISM
Lecture Code: PS_L.10 ENGL 559: Postcolonial Studies UNIT 2: Multi-Disciplinarity “Nation and Nationalisms” by John Mcleod Min Pun, PhD, Associate Professor.
Lecture Code: PS_L.4 ENGL 559: Postcolonial Studies UNIT 1: KEY CONCEPTS “Introduction” by Shirley Chew Min Pun, PhD, Associate Professor Dept of English,
BBL 3403 RESEARCH METHODS IN LITERATURE
Lecture Code: PS_L.11 ENGL 559: Postcolonial Studies UNIT 2: Multi-Disciplinarity “Feminism and Womanism” by Nana Wilson-Tagoe Min Pun, PhD, Associate.
POSTCOLONIAL CRITICISM
Literary Theory: Postcolonialism
Post-Structuralist and Postmodernist Approaches to Gender Theory
A Woefully Brief and Limited Intro to Post-Colonial Theory
Marxist Criticism.
Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak
HIST300: Historiography Fall 2012
Presentation transcript:

 Subaltern refers to persons socially, politically, and geographically outside of the hegemonic power structure.  Subalterns are groups who have had their voices silenced, they can speak through their actions as a way to protest against mainstream development and create their own visions for development.  In the 1970s, the term began to be used as a reference to colonized people in the South Asian subcontinent.  Some thinkers use it in a general sense to refer to marginalized groups and the lower classes—a person rendered without agency by his or her social status.  According to Gayatri Spivak, subaltern is not just a classy word for oppressed, for Other, for somebody who's not getting a piece of the pie....In postcolonial terms, everything that has limited or no access to the cultural imperialism is subaltern—a space of difference.

 Subaltern studies detached from the economic determinism of Orthodox Marxist scholarship.  In India founder of Subaltern studies- Ranajit Guha.  Subaltern studies reflect the interplay between Western Marxism and Indian political culture.

Impact of Susobhan Sarkar- Bengali historian who was influenced by Gramasci’s works. It took shape in Britain due to the impact of Gramasci’s “Prison Notebooks”. Partha Chatterjee linked Marxian social theory to Foucauldian notions of power within 19 th and 20 th c. India. Political developments in India accelerated this struggle- Maoist peasant insurgency of Naxalbari, Indira Gandhi’s turn towards authoritarianism during the emergency years of

o This movement led towards peasant consciousness o It led towards the emergence of identity politics and multi-culturalism. o Subaltern studies became objective towards economic base as the central zone of power and contestation and moved towards culture conceived in terms of textual and discourse analysis.

 Gayatri is an Indian literary critic, theorist and Professor at Columbia University.  She considers herself as a "practical Marxist- feminist-deconstructionist“.  She is concerned for the cultural texts of those who are marginalized by dominant western culture: the new immigrant, the working class, women and other "postcolonial subjects."

 Myself, I Must Remake: The Life and Poetry of W.B. Yeats (1974).  Of Grammatology (translation, with a critical introduction, of Derrida's text) (1976)  In Other Worlds: Essays in Cultural Politics (1987).  Selected Subaltern Studies (edited with Ranajit Guha) (1988)  The Post-Colonial Critic (1990)  The Spivak Reader (1995).  A Critique of Postcolonial Reason: Towards a History of the Vanishing Present (1999).  Death of a Discipline (2003).  Chotti Munda and His Arrow (translation with critical introduction of the novel by Mahasweta Devi) (2002)  Red Thread (forthcoming)

 First of all she refers to the radical criticism that confirms the western superiority and projects it as the ‘Subject’.  Western subjectivity questioned by ‘pluralized subject effects’.  Economic factor though put under the erasure works as the ‘transcendental signified’.  French intellectuals like Foucault and Deleuze try to erase the economic determinants.  Secondly she refers to the Western world that constituted the colonized as the other and shadow of the self which is challenged and reversed by Foucault.

 The French intellectuals questioned imperialism as the best version of history.  Imperialists confirmed their version as authentic, normative, legal and politically strengthened.  According to Deleuze and Foucault the oppressed- illiterate peasantry, the tribals, the lowest strata of the urban subproletariate- if given the chance can speak and know their conditions.  The phased development of the subaltern is complicated by the imperialist project, that is confronted by subaltern studies group. They including Ranajit Guha try to rethink Indian colonial historiography from the perspective of the discontinuous chain of peasant insurgencies during colonial rule. Ranajit Guha divides elites into three – a. Dominant foreign group b. Dominant indigenous group at all India level c. Dominant indigenous group at the regional and local levels also known as ‘Buffer group’, which is called as ‘antre’ by Derrida.

 On the third hand, she talks about as to how the theories of Foucault and Derrida helped in erasing the superiority of the western world-i.e. Foucault’s concept of ‘power dynamics’ and Derrida’s questioning of the centre and its authenticity as no finality is there. Derrida also refers to the general crisis of European consciousness.  In the fourth part of the essay Spivak talks about the female subjects and their consciousness. In order to support her ideas she refers to Freud’s concept of repression, Indian classical sati system. The British abolition of Sati System in 1829, is understood as ‘white men saving brown women from brown men’.

 As opposed to these elite groups are people i.e. synonymous to the subaltern classes.  These intellectuals are bent upon rewriting the development of the consciousness of the Indian nation.  Foucault suggests that ‘to make visible the unseen can also mean a change of level… It is the slippage from rendering visible the mechanism to rendering the individual while avoiding psychological or linguistic analysis….’

 In the semioses of the social text elaborations of insurgency stand in the place of the utterance.  The sender – the peasant is marked only as a pointer to an irretrievable consciousness.  The historian tries to transform insurgency into text for knowledge.  So also female subject is not taken into consideration. She is doubly or triply marginalized.  For this women themselves have to take the initiative to come out of the ideology of womanhood and speak for themselves.