CONFIDENTIAL www.mcguirewoodsconsulting.com Christopher D. Lloyd DBIA Water & Wastewater/Transportation Joint Program April 21, 2010 Emerging Policy Trends.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Innovative Transportation Finance March 2, 2010 Presented by: Brad Larsen Director of Traditional & Innovative Finance Minnesota Department of Transportation.
Advertisements

Solving Challenges Others Cannot Statutory Frameworks for Public Private Partnerships HMFA Lone Star Chapter 2009 Winter Institute Dallas, TX Christopher.
Symposium on Private Financing for African Power Infrastructure US Treasury Department Washington, DC October 13, 2008.
Introduction to Public Private Partnerships
Presentation to Montgomery County Rapid Transit System (RTS) Steering Committee July 30, 2013 Purple Line Private Public Partnership Initiative.
I-4 Ultimate with Lanes Project Central Florida 1 May 21, 2013.
Overview and Principles for Implementing State PPP (P3) Legislation Presented at the NCPPP P3 Connect Denver, Colorado Conference By Jim Reed, Group Director.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot PPEA Primer Southampton County Board of Supervisors Christopher D. Lloyd November 26, 2007.
1. Virginia’s Public-Private Transportation Act (PPTA) Northern Border Finance Workshop December 11, 2006 Thomas W. Pelnik III, P.E. Director, Innovative.
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd SMPS – Southeastern Regional Conference March 11, 2009 PPP 101: A Primer on Public Private.
Click to edit Master title style Romania - Financing Opportunities for Investors State Aid Schemes September.
Financial Management by Jon Lang. Financial Management Why we do it! “The difference between financial management in the public and private sectors is.
Public-Private Partnerships: State of Practice and Research Needs The 14 th Annual Public Private Partnership Conference World Bank, Washington, DC September.
Doug Brown October 23, Budget Overview A Budget Planning Process (Overland Park’s) Financial Management.
CONFIDENTIAL Susan Liberty and Christopher D. Lloyd June 4, 2009 Public Private Partnerships – Statutory Frameworks for.
VIRGINIA PUBLIC-PRIVATE EDUCATION FACILITIES AND INFRASTRUCURE ACT OF 2002 (PPEA) Augusta County Board of Supervisors Wednesday, January 6, 2009.
CONFIDENTIAL U.S. – Korea Pharma CEO Forum Christopher D. Lloyd November 4, 2010 Economic Considerations for U.S. Operations.
Wales Infrastructure Investment Plan Gerald Holtham Adviser to Welsh government.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Economic Development Policy Trends Christopher D. Lloyd September 24, 2008.
PPP in the UK Ian Rylatt, Chief Executive Officer, Balfour Beatty Investments.
April 26, 2007 Atlanta, Georgia The Focus Georgia Conference: Transportation Funding Solutions for the Future Working with Public-Private Partnerships.
1 The Evolution of Public-Private Partnerships & Best Practices for States The CSG Transportation Policy Academy Washington, DC September 17, 2014 Jonathan.
CONFIDENTIAL Virginia WaterJAM 2010 Christopher D. Lloyd September 22, 2010 Public Private Partnerships – Statutory Frameworks.
CONFIDENTIAL Chesapeake Economic Development Advisory Council Christopher D. Lloyd April 9, 2010 Economic Development Accomplishments.
LOCAL GOVERNMENT INFRASTRUCTURE NEEDS vs DEVELOPMENT CHARGES.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Virginia’s Public Private Partnership Law Toyo University Tokyo, Japan Christopher D. Lloyd September 29, 2008.
Sergio Földes Guimarães Deputy Managing Director – International Division BNDES
1 World Water Congress and Exhibition - Montréal, Canada WATER AND POWER UTILITY PUBLIC SECTOR FINANCING Presented by: James B. McDaniel, Senior Assistant.
Legislative Opportunities and Impediments - The Virginia Experience Virginia Public Private Partnerships ATRA TECHNIX Program Phil Bomersheim “Activist”
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd NCPPP Annual Conference November 19, 2009 Changes in the P3 World – Law and Policy.
Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act 2002 (PPEA) Joe Damico.
State Legislative Update Christopher D. Lloyd McGuireWoods Consulting July 21, 2015.
1. 2 Route 895 PPTA (2002) 3 Communication Dilbertian [v. Newtonian] Logic: We know that communication is a problem, but the company is not going to.
Convergence of Transportation Policy and RFID Enabler of Future Transportation Policy Chris Body Mark IV Vice President, Business Development.
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd Virginia Educational Facility Planners 2009 Annual Conference March 3, 2009 What the Federal.
CONFIDENTIAL Council for Resource Development Christopher D. Lloyd November 3, 2010 Public Private Partnerships – How They.
Innovations in Water and Wastewater Infrastructure Procurement – The Virginia Experience Water Finance and Investment Summit New York, NY Chris Lloyd McGuireWoods.
WATER RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION FINANCE WORKING GROUP REPORT OF FINDINGS September 9, 2011.
© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Selecting and Designing Concession / PPP Projects Martin Darcy.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Using the PPEA for Infrastructure Development Design-Build Institute of America Mid-Atlantic Chapter Christopher D. Lloyd.
Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) and The World Bank
Alternative Procurement Tools for Historic Revitalization Projects Local Government Attorneys of Virginia Association Presentation Chris Lloyd McGuireWoods.
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd Urban Land Institute – Richmond Urban Marketplace May 4, 2009 Role of Transportation and.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Using Public Private Partnerships Parkland Blue Ribbon Panel Christopher D. Lloyd October 22, 2007.
Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act.
Public Private Partnerships What We Have Learned & What More We Need to Know.
TIFIA Credit Program Overview Updated May 2011 T ransportation I nfrastructure F inance and I nnovation A ct (TIFIA)
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Statutory Frameworks for Public Private Partnerships NCPPP/AGC Conference Phoenix, AZ Christopher D. Lloyd January 27,
An introduction to smart investment solutions: the case of PPP Twinning project Public Agency for Rail Transport of Republic Slovenia Daniel Loschacoff.
MAKING IT HAPPEN. TRB 88 th Annual Meeting Risk Management in Public-Private Partnerships January 14, 2009 Statutory and Public Policy Approaches to PPP.
CONFIDENTIAL Virginia’s PPEA, NC SB 822, and Lessons Learned Institute for Emerging Issues North Carolina State University.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Using the PPEA for Downtown Revitalization Virginia Downtown Development Association Christopher D. Lloyd October 4, 2007.
LEGISLATIVE REQUIREMENTS FOR UNSOLICITED PROPOSALS FLORIDA COUNCIL FOR PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS OCTOBER 3, 2013 Lee A. Weintraub, Esq. Becker & Poliakoff,
Governor’s Commission on Job Creation and Economic Development – An Update Chris Lloyd July 22, 2010.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Economic Development Trends Christopher D. Lloyd March 23, 2008.
CONFIDENTIAL Montgomery County Board of Supervisors Christopher D. Lloyd October 25, 2010 Public Private Partnerships for.
CONFIDENTIAL VASCUPP Conference Christopher D. Lloyd September 25, 2013 Is the PPEA Process Right for You?
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Economic Development Policy Trends Christopher D. Lloyd June 18, 2008.
Virginia Office of Public-Private Partnerships (VAP3) Adopted Public-Private Transportation Act (PPTA) enabling legislation in 1995 Public-Private Education.
CONFIDENTIAL 9 th Annual Focus Northwest Florida Christopher D. Lloyd October 16, 2010 Economic Development Policy Trends.
Office of Major Project Development (OMPD) Overview November 2015.
Budget Workshop Capital Improvement Plan Presentation on Public Private Partnership and Strategy for Municipal Complex, HWY 50, and Coast to Coast Trail.
One East Broward Blvd., Suite 1800
Using Public-Private Partnerships to Move More People The Story of HOT Lanes in Northern Virginia January 30, 2017 Morteza Farajian, Ph.D.
Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada Leveraging Infrastructure Funds
A Primer on Virginia’s PPEA
Virginia’s Public Private Partnership Law
Virginia’s PPEA and Water and Wastewater Partnerships
Virginia’s P3 Program Morteza Farajian, PhD.
BASICS OF PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
Presentation transcript:

CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd DBIA Water & Wastewater/Transportation Joint Program April 21, 2010 Emerging Policy Trends For Innovative Project Delivery

2 Presentation Overview America’s Infrastructure Crisis Historical Solutions Public Policy Barriers and Opportunities Emerging Statutory Frameworks Recent Project Examples

3 America’s Crumbling Infrastructure

4

5

6

7 Public complains but has no interest in increasing taxes/fees/tolls to pay for it Politicians talk infrastructure, but it is always the first to item to go when money gets tight Cost of maintaining existing infrastructure is eroding construction budgets Failing infrastructure is harming US competitiveness

8 Why Use Alternative Procurement? Faster, better, cheaper (sometimes) Single point of responsibility Shift of risk away from public sector Distances rate making/price setting decisions from the political sector Lack of faith in the public sector

9 Virginia in the Vanguard Virginia PPTA (1995) and PPEA (2002) legislation seen as model statutes Virginia has done 100+ deals Range from $1.5 million - $5 billion+ Provides fast track to design-build, predictable process

10 PPEA: Process Public entity solicits for proposals or accepts unsolicited proposals Minimum of 45 day open competition period for unsolicited proposals FOIA protections for confidential information are negotiated Conceptual proposal outlines team qualifications, proposed cost, proposed scope and public benefits Public entity may levy a proposal review fee on both solicited and unsolicited proposals Proposal review fee is used to cover procurement costs

11 PPEA: Process All competing proposals are reviewed, followed by a downselect Detailed proposals are requested – often relies on recommendations of outside/inside advisors Detailed proposals start to lock in project scope, costs, schedule Leads to an interim or comprehensive agreement with one firm Significant requirements for public notification and hearings

12 Evolution of Virginia’s PPEA Creation of interim agreement concept Increased public input and transparency Development of “best practices criteria” Creation of legislative oversight panel Expansion to technology projects and services

13 Creating the Ideal Procurement Law Allows solicited and unsolicited proposals Open to all financing vehicles Ensures transparency and public participation Fairly balances public and private risks Provides for sufficient competition Adequate public staffing to speed project approvals

14 Barriers to Public Private Partnerships Stimulus promises diminished public sector appetite for creative approaches CIP budgets were first cuts to meet government fiscal challenges General distrust of Wall Street/corporate America Public sector layoffs create staffing/evaluation challenges

15 Support for Public Private Partnerships Stimulus “list making” exercise shows need for infrastructure Lack of funding causing public sector to be more open to creative financing/development opportunities Construction price declines/increased competition Failure of other alternatives leaves few options Appetite for “asset maximization”

16 Recent Transactions (post-Lehman) Several major players have exited the market (RBS, Babcock & Brown) Several major deals faltered (Midway Airport, PA Turnpike) Despite financial crisis, some deals are being done Infrastructure funds are still successfully raising money Era of cheap equity has ended (for now) Market expects major public participation – risk aversion

17 I-595 Florida 10.5 mile, $1.8 billion project Creates new express lanes, BRT Financial close March 2009 ACS Dragados as equity investor with bank consortium $800 million bank debt, $600 million TIFIA, $232 million FDOT, $200 million equity First “availability payment” scheme in US - $63.98 million per year for 30 years, FDOT controls toll revenue and rates Additional information at com/default.aspx com/default.aspx

18 SPSA Waste to Energy Sale of waste-to-energy plant to Wheelabrator/Waste Management Provides for substantial rehabilitation to neglected facility $150 million cash infusion lowers SPSA debt/tipping fees Allocation of PAB’s lowers costs – merges public and private financing vehicles

19 Recent Transactions – Market Reaction Private sector looking for more legal certainty, traffic track record, public financial participation Public sector looking for stronger parent guarantees, additional sweat equity, assistance in building public support for project Increased interest in “social” infrastructure projects Strong interest in energy-related infrastructure

20 Future Opportunities and Issues How will SAFETEA-LU reauthorization impact the development of new infrastructure? Will the availability of new bond vehicles dampen desire for non-traditional financing? How much flexibility will states/feds have to raise taxes to develop/maintain crumbling infrastructure? Will governments be able to deliver on funding and matching commitments in a challenging fiscal environment? Will new environmental/safety/labor requirements restrict infrastructure development?

21 Infrastructure & Economic Development | Federal Public Affairs | Strategic Communications & Grassroots Mobilization State & Local Government Affairs | Emerging European Markets Atlanta Charlotte Charlottesville Chicago Columbia Norfolk Raleigh Springfield Tyson’s Corner Washington, D.C. | Bucharest, Romania