Geriatrics, Inter-professional Practice and Inter-organizational Collaboration (GiiC): Primary Care Lessons David Ryan, PhD, Regional Geriatric Program.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
A Valuable Asset School districts put a valuable asset of the nation’s schools at risk when they ignore the health of their employees. WHY? BECAUSE… Actions.
Advertisements

Care Transitions – Critical to Quality and Patient Safety Society of Hospital Medicine Lakshmi K. Halasyamani, MD.
Interdisciplinary Education and Training Prof Jim Buchan Discussant.
Family Doctor for All Overview & Research Opportunities Kristin Anderson Director, Primary Health Care Branch Applied Health Research.
Keele Management School
Integrating Ethics Into Your Compliance Program John A. Gallagher, Ph.D Center for Ethics in Health Care Atlanta, GA.
PROFESSIONAL NURSING PRACTICE
Primary Health Care Reform in Australia National Health and Hospital Reform Commission Professor Justin Beilby University of Adelaide.
EDUCATIONAL CURRICULUM IN TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH Panel Session Goals:  To discuss how CTSA training programs currently prepare clinical and translational.
The Partnership Way: Blueprint Development Session Joanne Cashman Director, The IDEA Partnership At NASDSE Luann Purcell Executive Director, CASE Stacy.
Inter-organizational collaboration in the primary care of frail seniors David Patrick Ryan, Ph.D. C.Psych. Director of Education & Knowledge Processes,
CW/MH Learning Collaborative First Statewide Leadership Convening Lessons Learned from the Readiness Assessment Tools Lisa Conradi, PsyD Project Co-Investigator.
1 EFPC congress Gőteborg 2012 Interprofessional Education for Primary Care Professionals L. van Amsterdam.
Linking Actions for Unmet Needs in Children’s Health
Common Ground One Approach, Many Adaptations Juanita Blount-Clark August, 2011.
TRANSFORMING HEALTH CARE THROUGH RESEARCH AND EDUCATION 2012 Illinois Performance Excellence Bronze Award Leading Improvement Across the Continuum: Skills,
Dr. Dalal AL-Matrouk KBA Farwaniya Hospital
European Forum for Primary Care: "Twinning Population Health and Primary Care" Barcelona, Spain, 1-2 September, 2014 WHO Strategy on People-Centered and.
Co-operation in emergency care between Helsinki University Central Hospital and City of Helsinki Liisa-Maria Voipio-Pulkki MD, PhD Chief Physician, Emergency.
Pleased to be sharing the 2020 Workforce Vision with you today
Competency Assessment Public Health Professional (2012)-
Curriculum Development For Adult Learners. Basics Educational objective- – What they will learn – Learning needs assessment or gap analysis Learner outcomes-
TRANSFORMING HEALTH CARE THROUGH RESEARCH AND EDUCATION 2012 Illinois Performance Excellence Bronze Award Integrating Behavioral Health Across the Continuum.
Mental Health is a Public Health Issue: What I Learned from Early Childhood.   Presented by  Charlie Biss 
Quality Indicators & Safety Initiative: Group 4, Part 3 Kristin DeJonge Ferris Stat University MSN Program.
1 Interdisciplinary Collaboration for Elder Care.
Building the Health Workforce as We Transform the Delivery System Mary D. Naylor, PhD, RN Marian S. Ware Professor in Gerontology University of Pennsylvania.
Public Health Human Resources: A Comparison of British Columbia and Ontario Policies Sandra Regan 1, Diane Allan 2, Marjorie MacDonald 2, Cheryl Martin.
Leadership and Management Training for physicians Maria V. Gibson, MD, PhD Trident / MUSC Family Medicine Residency Program Background Practice Problem.
Chronic diseases & Community – Based Care Dr. Etemad Deputy of health Head of Center for Non-Communicable Diseases.
National Standards for Safer Better Healthcare
Inter-professional practice in health care David Patrick Ryan, Ph.D. Director of Education & Knowledge Processes, Regional Geriatric Program of Toronto.
Interprofessional Education: How can it Benefit Child & Youth Health
MENTAL HEALTH AND EDUCATION PARTNERSHIP Joanne Cashman, Ed.D., Director of IDEA Partnership, National Association of State Directors Special Education.
Success Principles in Integrated Delivery System.
ORIENTATION SESSION Strengthening Chronic Disease Prevention & Management.
Stacee Lerret PhD, RN, CPNP, CCTC Medical College of Wisconsin Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin WI ITNS Annual Conference October 13, 2012 MOVING ON UP:
National Head Start Association Leadership Institute January 29, 2009 Presentation by Joan Lombardi, Ph.D. Early Childhood Development: At the dawn of.
2 Partnerships with professionals. Partnerships and Collaboration Partnerships with other professionals are ongoing long- term relationships based on.
PROJECT BACKGROUND WORKSHOP LEARNING OUTCOMES AND FACILITATOR CONFIDENCE RATINGS Geriatrics The RGPs of Ontario, CERAH, and the North East SGS are grateful.
Nova Scotia Falls Prevention Update Preventing Falls Together Conference October 29, 2009 Suzanne Baker.
Collaborative Model of Social Work Education with Strong University – Agency Partnerships Michael A. Patchner, Ph.D. Indiana University School of Social.
Challenging / Responsive Behaviours Symposium: Developing an Alberta Action Plan November 21, 2012 Edmonton Clinic Health Academy University of Alberta,
1 Amina in the Nexus: A Shared Vision A look at team-based care The National Center for Interprofessional Practice and Education is supported by a Health.
BRIEFING KidsMatter. A national priority National Child Mental Health Survey (Sawyer et al., 2000) Australian Health Ministers (2003) Estimates suggest.
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
Psychology Workforce Development for Primary Care Cynthia D. Belar, PhD, ABPP Executive Director, APA Education Directorate Collaborative.
Working with people living with dementia and other long term conditions Karin Tancock Professional Affairs Officer for Older People & Long Term Conditions.
PROJECT BACKGROUNDLEARNING OBJECTIVES advance directives capacity assessment caregiver support delirium dementia screening depression driving capacity.
SUMMARY Emergency Departments (EDs) are an essential service for the care of injuries and trauma for everyone. They provide a safety net when the system.
Perspectives on the Future of Pediatric Nursing Education and Practice Marion E. Broome, Ph.D., R.N. FAAN Distinguished Professor and Dean Indiana University.
Mental Health Services Act Oversight and Accountability Commission June, 2006.
Ryan White All Grantees Meeting Washington, DC November, 2012 Supporting National HIV/AIDS Strategies: the domestic experience and the AETCs.
OIPRC Injury Prevention Forum March 3,  Mississauga Falls Prevention Initiative  Funded projects  Lessons learned  Recommendations.
Older People’s Services The Single Assessment Process.
Overview of Integrated Care Sheila A. Schuster, Ph.D.Advocacy Action Network
Unit 1: Health IT Teams Examples and Characteristics Component 17/ Unit 11 Health IT Workforce Curriculum Version 1.0/Fall 2010.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم.
The Future of KT Harley Dickinson Department of Sociology Harley Dickinson Department of Sociology QEOL Research Group Workshop August 22, 2006 University.
Canadian Best Practice Recommendations for Stroke Care Recommendation 1: Public Awareness and Patient Education (Updated 2008)
HEALTH AND CARE STANDARDS APRIL Background Ministerial commitment 2013 – Safe Care Compassionate Care Review “Doing Well Doing Better” Standards.
Behavioral Health Providers in Primary Care: Competencies, Onboarding, and Team Culture for Successful Integration Emma C. Gilchrist, MPH Benjamin F. Miller,
Why Has it got to be Multi Professional ? The extent to which different healthcare professionals work well together can affect the quality of the health.
Henry M. Sondheimer, MD Association of American Medical Colleges 7 August 2013 A Common Taxonomy of Competency Domains for the Health Professions and Competencies.
The Transformation of Social Care Janet Walden 13th November 2008.
Chapter 9 Case Management Copyright © 2015, 2011, 2007, 2001, 1997, 1993 by Saunders, an imprint of Elsevier Inc.
Lehigh Valley Hospital & Health Network
Chapter 1: Introduction to Gerontological Nursing
EDC ©2016. All rights reserved.
Leading Improvement Across the Continuum: Skills, Tools and Teams for Success January 2014.
Presentation transcript:

Geriatrics, Inter-professional Practice and Inter-organizational Collaboration (GiiC): Primary Care Lessons David Ryan, PhD, Regional Geriatric Program of Toronto, University of Toronto Cheryl Cott Ph.D. William Dalziel MD, Dr. Iris Gutmanis PhD, David Jewell MSW, Mary Lou Kelley PhD, Barbara Liu MD & John Puxty MD

What is frailty? Complex bio-psychosocial and functional difficulties co-occur. Risk of adverse health events is high Independence and self-worth are easily compromised Risk of institutionalization is high A fast growing demographic Frailty brings increased need for health care services and demands high levels of teamwork and inter- sectoral collaboration.

“Go to where the puck is going to be” Wayne Gretsky’s Dad

Articles on Teamwork in the Journal of Orthopsychiatry by Decade, since the Journal began in 1930 # of Articles The medical model and the orthopsychiatri c trinity The trinity won the right to treat Sociotherapy and broadening of the mental health team Community mental health and sociotherapy’s democracy Hospitals emptied and community mental health funding dwindled DRG’s, managed care and mental health fragmentation Integrated care and inter-team collaboration From moral treatment to mental hospitals Decades s40s50s60s70s80s90s

The framework for health systems renewal in Ontario 2007

Funding supported 90 interprofessional research & development projects Regulatory Colleges formed an interprofessional care working group Investment in Academic Interprofessional Education & Training eg: interprofessional coaching interprofessional mentoring interprofessional preceptorship stand alone and embedded interprofessional curricula Investment in interprofessional development in the practice environment eg: Interprofessional care of the diabetic foot Accountability Framework for Regulated and Unregulated Health Care Providers in Long Term Care Interprofessional prevention of delirium in the Emergency Department Geriatrics, Interprofessional Practice & Inter-organizational Collaboration (GiiC) Initiatives

What we wanted... Health professionals still aren’t being sufficiently trained in geriatrics Help us to build the health human resources needed for an aging population Going to where the puck is... “Just putting people to together to work doesnt necessarily produce effective teamwork let us help build your 200 new family health teams” “Teamwork is the traditional method of service delivery in geriatrics. Let us use geriatrics as a clinical focus through which we can train family health teams” “We are in the integration era but no-one is trained let us add our inter- organizational collaboration skills into the mix” “Then let us help the entire circle of care work from a common toolkit”... Suddenly the puck was on our stick

GiiC: Family Health Teams/Community Health Centers GiiCPlus: Community Care Access Centers, Public Health and Community Support Agencies GiiC Plus: Patients Families and Health Care Teams GiiC Hospitals: Seniorfriendlyhospitals.ca

Geriatric Practice in FHTs 32% 2% 0%73%24% Delirium Screening 92%13% 0%85% 3% Cognitive Screening 18%41%19%35% 5% Polypharmacy Reviews 26% 12% 5%73%12% Drive Safe Protocol 9%25% 0%68%12% Continence Screening Use of Standardized Tools Routinely every year Routinely every 6 months Only if symptoms NeverClinical Focus 25%15% 2% 63% 20% Abuse Screening 29%23% 0% 64%13% Falls Risk Assessment 74% 20% 2%78% 0% Depression Screening 41%18% 3%74% 11% ADL/IADL Assessment

When is a family health team not a high performance team? When it is an organization – some family health teams have 250 people When it is a network - some family health teams have docs in their offices and a new building in the middle of town for allied health folks When it doesn’t take on the qualities of team – one manager had a “closed door policy” When its roles are fixed, leadership hierarchical and everyone does their own thing.

When it excludes unregulated employees from making credible contributions When is a family health team not a high performance team?

The distinction between “formal” and “informal” care giving does not reflect the reality of the work of many family caregivers who are often: 1.Geriatric Case Managers 2.Mobile medical records 3.Service gap fillers 4.Continuous care providers 5.Acute change of condition monitors 6.Paramedic service providers 7.Quality Control experts 8.Inter-organizational boundary crossing 9.Continuing medical education students (From Brookman & Harrington: 2007) When is a family health team not a high performance team? When the “shadow workforce” is not incorporated in team proceedings

‘Edumetrics” and the Knowledge-To-Practice Process In the continuing health professional education world a new model has emerged in the pursuit of practice change outcomes Knowledge translation, knowledge transfer, implementation science and the knowledge-to-practice process emerged as guiding constructs Central to all, is the idea that practice change is more likely to the extent that researchers engage ‘subjects’ more actively in the development of research questions and the dissemination of findings.

GiiC researchers wanted to understand the performance of family health teams, standardize a Dimensions of Teamwork Survey (DTEAM) for use by Family Health teams and compare DTEAM surveys with social network analyses, and improve interprofessional practice. Fifty-five participating Family Health Teams wanted information on the quality of their teamwork and how they stood with regard to other similar teams.

9(16%)37(68%)9 (16%) Total teamwork 5 (9%)38 (69%)12 (22%) Organizational Support 10 (18%)36 (68%)9 (16%) Decision-making and leadership 9 (16%)35 (64%)11 (20%) Clarity of Team Goals 11 (20%)35 (64%)9 (16%) Roles and Interdependence 7 (13%)39 (71%)9 (16%) Communication and Conflict Management 10 (18%)40 (73%)7 (13%) Team members strengths and skills 10 (18%)40 (73%)5 (9%) Patient and Inter-team focus High Performance Teamwork (One standard deviation above the group mean ) Teams at Average Levels of Teamwork ( Within +/- one standard deviation of the group mean ) Below Average Levels of Teamwork (One standard deviation below the group mean ) Level of Inter-professional Teamwork Dimension of Teamwork The distribution of high performance teamwork in a sample of 55 family health teams using the Dimensions of Teamwork Survey

When environments require complex interdependency the quality of collaborative alliances may predict outcomes better than the internal processes of individual teams (Pfeiffer, 86)

And then we started working on the “community care” side of the health system where the world is different and so are teams

On Emergence in Community Based Shared Care Health professionals don’t own the space Co-caregivers may not know each other Care providers are inter-organizational Regulated and unregulated providers Unpaid “shadow workforce” prevails Interactions are non-linear Self-organizing Local ecology and regional diversity Strength of ties is variable No single agent knows everything Practice Jazz Lots of surprises No standardization Improvisational Sense-making Local Adaptations Co-evolving Initial conditions Patient Focused Community Based Teamwork

Questions for the Interprofessional Academies Are we responding to emerging conditions? Does it matter how the word ‘team’ is used? Are we developing the essential skill sets? What is the relationship between teams and the shadow workforce? How are regulated and unregulated health professionals working together Is ‘knowledge-to-practice process’ in the curriculum? Is ‘team’ the right concept for community based health care collaboration? Are we heading to where the puck is going now? Economic Recession Integration Quality Management Safety

That’s all for now Goodnight Irene