Www.ccp.uea.ac.uk To abuse, or not to abuse: discrimination between consumers (2007) 32 European Law Review 492 Dr. Pinar Akman The Norwich Law School.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
European Business Law Lesson 2 February 27 th, 2013.
Advertisements

GREETINGS TO CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS FOR ICAIS POST QUALIFICATION COURSE VIDEO CONFERENCE FROM HYDERABAD 26 AUGUST 2005.
1 SPORT AND COMPETITION LAW AT EU LEVEL Madrid, february 2007 MICHELE COLUCCI
Consumer Welfare in Article 82EC Work in Progress Dr. Pinar Akman The Norwich Law School and ESRC Centre for Competition Policy
Department of Law On the Concept of Relative Market Power CLEEN Workshop June 2008 Lúcio Tomé Féteira, PhD Candidate, EUI (Florence, Italy) –
To draw a picture…. To draw a picture… Coordination of Public and Private Enforcement of Competition Law (Work in progress) Sebastian Peyer ESRC Centre.
Private Labels & Brand Competition Dr Ariel Ezrachi, The University of Oxford Centre for Competition Law and Policy 16 January 2009, CCP UEA.
Exploring the Role of Legal Presumptions under the Convincing Evidence Standard in EC Merger Control Alexandr Svetlicinii European University Institute.
1 Community Budget and Agricultural Policy Reform: The Tony Blair Proposal A German Point of View Ulrich Koester University of Kiel Germany.
1 S.Tronchon Legal Considerations when drafting a standard.
The fundamentals of EC competition law
LUMSA – International Commercial Law COMPETITION LAW – GENERAL PRINCIPLES Competition law is law that promotes or seeks to maintain market competition.
EU Competition Policy. Internal Market One of the activities of the Community: “an internal market characterised by the abolition, as between member States,
Administration in International Organizations PUBLIC COMPETITION LAW Class I, 6th Oct 2014 Krzysztof Rokita.
1 REFORM OF ARTICLE 82 EC BIICL, 24 February 2006 Treatment of Rebates Johanne Peyre.
Georgetown University. The Efficiency Properties of Competitive Markets Q $/q S D MC ATC P P=MC Allocative efficiency P=minAC Productive efficiency IndustryFirm.
1 Competition Policy Development, Objectives and the Law This presentation is based on Motta (2004), Competition Policy, Cambridge University Press.
Objectives of Competition Policy Lesson 2. Welfare  Welfare of the industry (consumer surplus + producer surplus)  Effects of price increases (the increase.
Policy Proposal & Contentions Systematic Review. Keep policy proposals conceptually simple and specific. Bad Congress should provide greater incentives.
Administration in International Organizations PUBLIC COMPETITION LAW Class V, 3rd Nov 2014 Krzysztof Rokita.
US Government March Basic Factors: US citizens have great # of economic freedoms Market model: driven by individuals Capitalist Free-enterprise:
Governmental Opportunities and Constraints
Consumers Aims to afford some parity of power to consumers. KEY LEGISLATION: 1. Sale of Goods Act 2. Trade Descriptions Act 3. Fair Trading Act 4. Consumer.
What the government does A2 Economics and Business Unit 4B By Mrs Hilton for revisionstation.
Competitive dialogue – a French perspective François Lichère Professor of public law University of Aix-Marseille.
“Equal and open access to the market in terms of economic integration and increased competition ” Astana Forum, 24 May 2013 Presented by Hassan Qaqaya,
Post Danmark: a big step towards a consistent application of a consumer oriented effects-based approach to exclusionary pricing practices Luc Peeperkorn*
LUMSA – International Commercial Law 17 October 2014 Prof. Avv. Roberto Pirozzi
An Introduction to regulation, it ’ s significance and rationale Kevin Hinde.
STRUCTURE AND FUNCTIONS OF COMPETITION AGENCIES. GENERAL STRUCTURE OF CA CAs differ in size, structure and complexity The structure depicts power distribution.
Strategic Pricing: Theory, Practice and Policy Professor John W. Mayo
EUROPEAN COMPETITION POLICY
Introductory course on Competition and Regulation Pál Belényesi University of Verona October 2006.
16 August Capacity Building on Competition Policy in Namibia Rehabeam Shilimela NEPRU.
Can a Competition Law Violation be Legally Insignificant? A U.S. Perspective Russell W. Damtoft Associate Director Office of International Affairs United.
1 FRAND COMMITMENTS AND EU COMPETITION LAW Thomas Kramler European Commission, DG Competition (The views expressed are not necessarily those of the European.
Competition Policy and Law Presentation to Study Tour for Russian Member Universities of the Virtual Institute Network 26 March 2009.
Trends in Retail Competition: Private Labels, Brands and Competition Policy A Symposium on the Role of Private Labels in Competition between Retailers.
1 Restrictive Product and Factor Market Regulations as Major Barriers to Competition The case of Ethiopia.
Parallel Trade of Pharmaceuticals - Competition Law Developments Assimakis Komninos.
International & Foreign Law Search, Liu 1 Separation of Powers? Commission—executive? Council—Legislative? Parliament—Legislative? Court--Judiciary.
UNCTAD The interface between competition policy, trade, investment and development Geneva, 23 July 2007 Abuse of Market Power Presentation by: Ursula Ferrari.
JKU Dissertation Colloquium Economics [3DVWLKS; ] Linz, 23 th January 2012 Markus LINDNER.
FEDERAL ANTIMONOPOLY SERVICE Moscow 2006 New Antimonopoly Law of the Russian Federation.
EU Discussion Paper on Exclusionary Abuses Michael Albers European Commission DG Competition 54th Antitrust Law Spring Meeting Washington DC, 30 March.
European competition policy. Role of competition policy Promote economic efficiency To control intensity of competition within economy Some areas it is.
Law and Economics EU/EC Competition Law Professional Career Programme (PCP) Yoshiharu, ICHIKAWA 2011/12/10.
Law and Economics EU/EC Competition Law Professional Career Programme (PCP) Yoshiharu, ICHIKAWA 2011/12/17.
6/23/2016Senior Seminar1 Markets, Competition and Efficiency Competition Commission of India Delhi, January 7, 2010.
The Economic Environment of Business – Lecture 5 Competition Policy.
Law and Economics EU/EC Competition Law Professional Career Programme (PCP) Yoshiharu, ICHIKAWA 2012/01/14.
Competition Policy in India: an Overview Pankaj Jain Faculty : Lovely Professional University.
Research problem and research question ENGL 7702 Lecture.
LEB Slide Set 14 Competition Law Matti Rudanko. LEB Slide Set 14 2 A Constitution of Market Economy Well-functioning markets – an unwritten fundamental.
Competition Law Understand the legal rules relating to monopolies, mergers and anti-competitive practices.
Managing the (Traffic) Managers
Markkinoiden juridinen toimintaympäristö Kalvot 15
European Union Law Week 10.
Competition Law and its Application: European Union
Lear - Laboratorio di economia, antitrust, regolamentazione
EVOLUTION OF DISCLOSURE REGULATION RATIONALES: PRELUDE TO A NEW THEORY
The competition enforcement in regulated sectors
8 Government, the Firm and the Market.
Dr. Rajesh Kumar Lecture-1
SPORT AND COMPETITION LAW AT EU LEVEL beyond the White Paper on Sport
Intel and the future of Article 102 TFEU
Internal (single) market
SPORT AND EU COMPETITION LAW
SPORT AND COMPETITION LAW AT EU LEVEL beyond the White Paper on Sport
Competition policy Made by : Mádi Vivien.
Presentation transcript:

To abuse, or not to abuse: discrimination between consumers (2007) 32 European Law Review 492 Dr. Pinar Akman The Norwich Law School and ESRC Centre for Competition Policy

Identifying the problem While writing the previous chapter of my PhD on unfair pricing I ended up reading about price discrimination. Then it occurred to me that… Article 82(c)EC prohibits applying dissimilar conditions to equivalent transactions with other trading parties, thereby placing them at a competitive disadvantage. Legal literature has predominantly interpreted this as a ban on discrimination directed at other undertakings. Hence, secondary line discrimination. Economics literature generally examines price discrimination as a practice directed at consumers, ie end-users. No decision of EC Courts on discrimination between consumers.

Research Questions Can discrimination between consumers be an abuse under Article 82EC? (Question 1) If so, should discrimination between consumers be an abuse under Article 82EC given the economics of price discrimination? (Question 2)

Initial Hypotheses Proposition 1: Article 82EC can cover discrimination between consumers. - List not exhaustive. - EC Commission/Courts have not looked for competitive disadvantage which is supposedly what excludes consumers from scope. Proposition 2: Given Proposition 1 and the ambiguous welfare effects of discrimination according to economics, Article 82EC may prohibit welfare- enhancing conduct. Possible over-intervention.

Methodology 1 To answer Question 1, I found out the reasons why Article 82EC cannot arguably cover discrimination between consumers. - Literal reading of Article 82EC: trading parties understood as traders; competitive disadvantage requirement, etc. I tried to disprove these arguments. - Trading parties can be anyone that enters into trade with the dominant undertaking, including consumers. - Competitive disadvantage has almost been read out in practice. Economics shows that in some cases consumers demands can also be interdependent. Then, I came up with the arguments why it can cover discrimination. – Case-law; - Non-exhaustive list; - Exploitation. Question 1 answered in the affirmative.

Methodology 2 To answer Question 2, I studied the economics literature on price discrimination: effects of discrimination on welfare are ambiguous. Then I considered other arguments: effects-based approach; fairness; etc. Finally I looked at the implications of prohibiting discrimination between consumers: risk of over-intervention; greater limit on freedom of contract; fairness vs efficiency; increase in (private) enforcement of Article 82EC; increase in the special responsibility. Reconciliation with economics – define abuse properly. I concluded that discrimination should be an abuse only if the Commission can prove that the practice reduces welfare – compared to non-discriminatory pricing. Outright ban of discriminatory practices is not justified. Mere exploitation of some consumers due to discrimination should not suffice.

Lessons Learned… This paper was not in my research proposal for the PhD. I did not (strictly) plan the structure, but I followed what seems to be the most logical way of answering the question. This was probably the easiest chapter of my PhD to write and the first one to be published. This could be because the question was - narrow enough to be tackled in a clear and concise way; - timely – reform of Article 82; economic approach; private enforcement; - appealing to a wider audience – hence the generalist journal; - quite simple, basic and obvious, but no one had tackled it before in the literature.