1 Proarrhythmic Assessment of Drugs: The Need For a New Paradigm Philip Sager, MD, FACC, FAHA, FHRS Consulting Professor of Medicine Stanford University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
6th European Patients’ Rights Day The EMA Geriatric Medicines Strategy and the empowered aging patient Francesca Cerreta EMA (European Medicines Agency)
Advertisements

The Drug Discovery Process
Marc Bailie DVM, PhD Director In Vivo Facility Michigan State University, Chief Development Officer Integrated Nonclinical Development Solutions (INDS)
Regulatory Framework Leigh Shaw, Director.
Brugada’s Syndrome and Sudden Cardiac Death
Cardiac Safety Assessment: Screening for Drug-Induced Ventricular Arrhythmias by Joseph C. Randall, Ph.D. Director, Drug Development MDS Pharma Services.
CIPA COMPOUND SELECTION OVERVIEW Thomas J Colatsky Director, Division of Applied Regulatory Science OCP/OTS/CDER US Food and Drug Administration.
QTc Trials Presented By: Ad Roffel, Ph.D. PRA International EDS NL P.O. Box 200, 9470 AE Zuidlaren, The Netherlands Tel: Fax:
Proarrhythmic Assessment of Drugs: The Need For a New Paradigm Philip Sager, MD, FACC, FAHA, FHRS Consulting Professor of Medicine Stanford University.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES NATIONAL INSTITUTES OF HEALTH Working with FDA: Biological Products and Clinical Development Critical Path.
The link between non-clinical and clinical testing ~ are non-clinical tests predictive of clinical effects? C Mike Perkins MD Pfizer Global Research &
Cardiac Arrhythmias.
Pharmaceutical Development and Review Process Rev. 10/21/2014 APGO Interaction with Industry: A Medical Student Guide.
Stefan Franzén Introduction to clinical trials.
The New Paradigm for Proarrhythmia Assessment Without the TQT Study
Food and Drug Administration Preclinical safety data for “first in human” (FIH) clinical trials in healthy volunteer subjects Oncology Drug Advisory Committee.
Evaluation of Cardiac Safety by ECG Findings: Focus on QTc Duration Joel Morganroth, M.D. Clinical Professor of Medicine University of Pennsylvania Chief.
Stages of drug development
The EP show: Brugada Syndrome Eric Prystowsky, MD Director
Ibutilide Ibutilide A Class III Antiarrhythmic Drugs ZHANG Dai-fu Shanghai East Hospital Tongji University Tongji University September 10, 2010.
The Need for a New Paradigm to Assess Proarrhythmic Effects of Drugs Philip Sager, MD, FACC, FAHA, FHRS Pharmaceutical Consultant Consulting Professor.
Key Considerations for Demonstrating Utility of Non-Clinical Models Pipeline issues Drugs are often being discarded early if they have a less than a several.
Peter K.S. Siegl, Ph.D. Siegl Pharma Consulting LLC SAFETY PHARMACOLOGY: Opportunities and Expectations 8 th Annual Safety Pharmacology.
CR-1 1 Ranolazine Benefit/Risk Jeremy N. Ruskin, MD, FACC.
Eric Prystowsky, MD Director Clinical Electrophysiology Laboratory St Vincent Hospital Indianapolis, IN Dan Roden, MD Director Division of Clinical Pharmacology,
1 Safety Pharmacology for Oncology Pharmaceuticals at CDER John K. Leighton Associate Director for Pharmacology CDER/OND/OODP.
1 Post Marketing Plan Earl Sands, M.D. Vice President and Chief Medical Officer US Research and Development Solvay Pharmaceuticals Earl Sands, M.D. Vice.
Clinical Trial Review and Approval: New Regulations and their implications Siddika Mithani, Ph.D Clinical Trials & Special Access Programme Therapeutic.
Chair –Derek Leishman Rapportuers –Dianne Garnes and Jean-Pierre Valentin Session II – Dynamics of Periodicity.
Reproductive Health Drugs, Pregnancy Labeling Subcommittee Meeting March 28-29, 2000 Holli A. Hamilton, M.D., M.P.H. Pregnancy Labeling Team Office of.
Disclosures Dr Scirica has received Dr Scirica has received honoraria for educational presentations (modest) from CV Therapeutics The study was supported.
Macrolide Antibiotics and Torsade de Pointes Postmarketing Analysis Telithromycin (Ketek™) Advisory Committee April 26, 2001 Douglas N. Shaffer, MD, MHS.
Clinical Teaching Case Anthony Battad MD, FRCPC University of Manitoba.
Joint Meeting of Anti-Infective Drugs & Drug Safety and Risk Management Advisory Committees December 14-15, 2006 Ketek  (telithromycin) Regulatory History.
CI-1 Ranexa™ (ranolazine) Extended Release Tablets Michael Sweeney, MD, FRCP VP, Medical Affairs CV Therapeutics, Inc. Cardiovascular and Renal Drugs Advisory.
CT-1 Mechanistic Evaluation of the Effects of Ranolazine on Ventricular Repolarization Luiz Belardinelli, MD VP, Drug Research and Pharmacological Sciences.
Cardiovascular Drugs That Prolong The QT Interval
András Varró Department of Pharmacology and Pharmacotherapy University of Szeged, Hungary Albert Szent-Györgyi Medical Center 2007 The importantance of.
The New Drug Development Process (www. fda. gov/cder/handbook/develop
1 QTc and Quinolones: recent regulatory actions Joyce Korvick M.D., M.P.H. Office of Drug Evaluation IV Division of Special Pathogens FDA.
1 A review of the safety of Moxifloxacin Hydrochloride Leonard Sacks MD Medical officer/DSPIDP.
Macrolide Antibiotics and Torsade de Pointes Postmarketing Analysis
Acquired Long QT Syndrome by Antiarrhythmic Drugs Chen Liying MD – Cardiology Department An Zhen Hospital Beijing CHINA. NASPE-Heart Rhythm Association.
European Patients’ Academy on Therapeutic Innovation The key principles of pharmacology.
Applying New Science to Drug Safety Janet Woodcock, M.D. Acting Deputy Commissioner for Operations April 15, 2005.
1 Risk Intervention Study: Cisapride Evelyn M Rodriguez MD, MPH Director, DDREII, OPDRA.
© 2008, American Heart Association. All rights reserved. AHA/ACC/HRS Scientific Statement on Noninvasive Risk Stratification Techniques for Identifying.
Date of download: 5/29/2016 Copyright © The American College of Cardiology. All rights reserved. From: Predicting the Unpredictable: Drug-Induced QT Prolongation.
27 June 2000Victor F. C. Raczkowski, M.D.1 Risk-Management Options Victor F. C. Raczkowski, M.D., M.S. Gastrointestinal Drugs Advisory Committee 27 June.
Viagra (sildenafil citrate): Extensive Clinical and Post-Marketing Experience Michael Sweeney, MD Senior Medical Director Pfizer Inc.
Special cardiac safety concerns
FDA's Two New Draft Guidance on Software and Device
The Stages of a Clinical Trial
HERG Blocking Kiseon Baek.
Balancing Regulation and Innovation: An FDA Division of Cardiovascular Devices Perspective Bram Zuckerman, MD, FACC Director, FDA Division of Cardiovascular.
Within Trial Decisions: Unblinding and Termination
First-in-Man, First In The USA: What’s The Difference?
HERG Blocking 2016/01/22 Jun Min Jung.
Introduction of New Technology: An FDA Division of Cardiovascular Devices Perspective Bram Zuckerman, MD, FACC Director, FDA Division of Cardiovascular.
Brugada’s Syndrome and Sudden Cardiac Death
Medical Device Regulatory Essentials: An FDA Division of Cardiovascular Devices Perspective Bram Zuckerman, MD, FACC Director, FDA Division of Cardiovascular.
Multiple Mechanisms in the Long-QT Syndrome
Molecular biology and the prolonged QT syndromes
Gary Gintant, Bernard Fermini, Norman Stockbridge, David Strauss 
Evaluation of immunogenicity Case presentations CEMDC-PharmaTrain, Module 8. Budapest, Hungary, 12-May-2017 Vid Stanulovic MD, PhD Clinical pharmacologist,
Statement on Concerta and Methylphenidate for the June 30, 2005 Pediatric Advisory Committee The FDA has identified two possible safety concerns with.
HESI/ILSI Health and Environmental Sciences Institute
Implications for safe medication prescribing in older adults
Regulatory Perspective of the Use of EHRs in RCTs
Presentation transcript:

1 Proarrhythmic Assessment of Drugs: The Need For a New Paradigm Philip Sager, MD, FACC, FAHA, FHRS Consulting Professor of Medicine Stanford University School of Medicine Chair, Scientific Programs Committee, Cardiac Safety Research Consortium

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India 2 Industry Relationships Genentech Orexo Aerpio Akebia Balance Medtronic Biomedical Systems ICardiac Heart Metabolics Milestone Theravance Lilly Viamet Shire Helsinn Celgene SNBL Pharmacyclics Anthera Member of DSMB, Adjudication Committee, or Consultant

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India 3 Drug-Induced TdP Quinidine syncope with drug-induced LQTS (Selter and Wray, 1964) Ventricular arrhythmia Torsades de Pointes – TdP (Dessertenne, 1966) Terfenadine Quinidine, d,l-sotalol, dofetilide, ibutilide 1-4% TdP incidence 3 Mean QT change over 12 hours:6ms Mean change at Tmax:12ms Mean change with metabolic inhibition:>82ms Problem not clearly identified after 100,000,000 prescriptions

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India 4 QT Prolonged/Drug-Induced Torsade QT prolongation/TdP – single most common cause of withdrawal or restriction on marketed drugs –Terfenadine, astemizole, cisapride, droperidol, grepafloxacin, levomethadyl, lidoflazine, sertindole, terodiline This has resulted in the need for regulatory guidance. TdP rarely observed during clinical development Focus on surrogates- HERG and QTc testing –QTc- sensitive but not very specific

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India 5 S7B: Nonclinical Testing Strategy Chemical/Pharma- cological Class Integrated Risk Assessment Follow-up studies None Weak Strong Evidence of Risk Other nonclinical and clinical information In vivo QT assay In vitro I Kr assay* * The hERG (gene for K v 11.1 alpha subunit of I Kr) ) related current is used

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India 6 Clinical QT Update Guidance document – ICH E14 Applicable to all new drugs with systemic bioavailability * Positive represents an approximately 1.5% increase in the QTc Gather basic clinical data (e.g. tolerability, PK) Relatively early in development design and conduct “Thorough QT Study” at substantial multiples of anticipated maximum therapeutic exposure +ve (>5ms) -ve* Conduct normal ECG monitoring in development Stop development or Fully describe QT effect in target patient population; Extensive QT evaluation in Phase 2/3 Evidence of QT increase/TdP

7 Examples of Label Implications of a QT Signal Alfuzosin –This observation [mild QT prolongation] should be considered in clinical decisions to prescribe UROXATRAL for patients with a known history of QT prolongation or patients who are taking medications known to prolong QT Ziprasidone –[has a] greater capacity to prolong the QT/QTc interval compared to several other antipsychotic drugs. …raises the possibility that the risk of sudden death may be greater for ziprasidone than for other available drugs... –In many cases this would lead to the conclusion that other drugs should be tried first

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India 8 Consequences: Compound with QT effect Consequences of developing a compound with QT effect Significant development burden Increased perceived risk = increased burden to demonstrate benefit Increased costs Delays in filing and/or approval Label warnings and competitive implications Licensing/partnering issues Often leads to termination of development

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India Torsadogenic Drugs ICH E14/S7B have resulted in no drugs with unrecognized risk being approved Success! Negative impact on drug development –Premature discontinuation due to hERG or QT “signal” (Inaccurate) perception of risk leading to drug discontinuation –Estimates of up to 60% Concerns regarding development burden, costs, labeling Many potentially good compounds never get evaluated in humans due to a hERG effect –Drug development in specific areas- CNS –Many drugs with QT labeling are unlikely proarrhythmic –Engineering-out hERG- applicability/other effects

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India Ventricular Repolarization

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India Evidence of Alternative Mechanisms Strong genetic data illustrating potential impact of non-hERG-mediated changes in QT interval with drug examples for most K+K+ K+K+ K+K+ Ca 2+ Na + C. Pollard

Acquired LQTS: APD/EAD/QT Interval Prolonging Models Drug/Gene Defect/Intervention Principal Target Veratridine, ATX II, anthopleurin A, Enhance late I Na alfuzosin, (mutations in Na + channels) Bay K 8644 (mutations in Ca 2+ channels)Enhance I Ca-L Cs +, quinidine, procainamide, bepridilSuppress K + currents E-4031, dofetilide, ibutilide, sotalol, terfenadine,Suppress I Kr astemizole, desmethylastemizole, cisapride, haloperidol, droperidol, halofantin, erythromycin, fluoxetine, etc. (mutations in Kv11.1 K + channels) Azimilide, Chromanol 293BSuppress I ks (mutations in Kv7.1 K + channels) Conclusions: Most LQTS drugs cause rapid direct channel block of I kr, but this is not the exclusive mechanism Modified from January: CSRC Mtg 2013

Development of TdP 13  Dispersion of ventricular repolarization (ΔAPD) Torsade de pointes Early afterdepolarizations (EADs)  Net repolarizing current  Action potential duration and QT interval Antzelevitch C et al. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol Therapeut. 2004;9(suppl 1):S TriggerSubstrate

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India QT Prolongation: Dissociation from TdP Sodium Pentobarbital - Prolongs QT but no TdP -Inhibits I kr, I ks, and late I Na Amiodarone - TdP very rare -Inhibits I kr, I ks, late I Na, and I ca Verapamil -Inhibits I Kr but also Ca influx Ranolazine - Prolongs QT but no TdP - Inhibits late I Na, I kr, and I NaCa

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India QT Prolongation: Dissociation from TdP Sodium Pentobarbital - Prolongs QT but no TdP - Inhibits I kr, I ks, and late I Na - No EAD’s, reduces dispersion Amiodarone - TdP very rare - Inhibits I kr, I ks, late I Na, and I Ca - No EAD’s, reduces dispersion Verapamil - Inhibits I Kr but also Ca influx -No QT prolongation or TdP Ranolazine - Prolongs QT but no TdP - Inhibits late I Na, I kr, and I NaCa - No EAD’s, reduces dispersion; - Suppresses E4031 induced TdP Thus QTc Prolongation need not cause TdP

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India Issues QT prolongation = Proarrhythmia HERG block = Proarrhythmia Negative impact on drug development New paradigm

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India New Paradigm A new cardiac safety paradigm focused on non- clinical measurement of proarrhythmia proclivity Focus on the real issue: Proarrhythmia Reduce the premature termination of drugs with favourable benefit:risk profiles Make drug development more efficient –Move the bulk of proarrhythmic assessment to the discovery phase –Use the assays to potentially guide candidate selection –Obviate the TQT study Enhance the accuracy with which existing and/or new drugs are labelled relative to actual proarrhythmic risks

American Heart J 2014 Proarrhythmic risk can be determined by pre- clinical assessments Proclivity to develop EAD’s Ionic Currents in silico modeling Cell-Based Approach Focus on high throughput approaches ECG Phase 1 Assessment American Heart Journal

CiPA: Two Component Proposal -Complementary approaches -Not designed to reproduce arrhythmia Effects on Multiple Cardiac Currents (Voltage Clamp Studies) Reconstruction of Cellular Electrophysiology (In Silico Studies) + Effects on Human Ventricular Myocytes (In Vitro Studies) Ionic Currents / In Silico Myocyte-Based Based Approach Approach Define a gradation of risk instead of a binary approach 2

Potential to make drug development more efficient Move arrhythmia risk assessment to the discovery phase Reduce the premature termination of drugs with favorable benefit:risk ratios Comprehensive In Vitro ProArrhythmia Assay (CIPA)

Drs. Stockbridge, Gintant, Petit, and the Steering Comm. FDA EMA PMDA Health Canada CSRC HESI SPS In Silico Modelers Pharmaceutical and Device Companies CRO’s Numerous Academic Groups Collaborators

4th Annual Conference on Drug Discovery and Clinical Development in India | November 14-18, New Delhi, India Thank you Philip Sager, MD, FACC, FAHA Ph