September 22, 2010 LIOB Meeting Independent Evaluation of PG&E’s Electric SmartMeters™ Structure Consulting Group, LLC. provided report at September 2,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
NAESB Measurement and Verification Model Business Practice Retail Electric Demand Response 5/29/09 update.
Advertisements

RETAIL METERING WORKING GROUP Process for Performing VEE for AMS June 3, 2009.
1.Quality-“a characteristic or attribute of something.” As an attribute of an item, quality refers to measurable characteristics— things we are able to.
A Multi-Year Improvement System and Schedule
DISPUTES & INVESTIGATIONS ECONOMICS FINANCIAL ADVISORY MANAGEMENT CONSULTING Early Lessons Learned from DOE-EPRI Framework Experience Melissa Chan MA DPU.
Introduction Build and impact metric data provided by the SGIG recipients convey the type and extent of technology deployment, as well as its effect on.
Key Reliability Standard Spot Check Frank Vick Compliance Team Lead.
Preparing for Compliance Monitoring Reviews Understanding CMS Protocols Used by Review Organizations January 14, 2009 Presented by: Margaret deHesse, RN,
Collect and Validate Data (Daily) Summarize and Validate Deliver Data Data Warehouse CUSTOMER BILLING CYCLE Day 1 Day 30 Day-after Green Button data retrieved.
AMI & Grid Data Analytics & Analysis Management Platform Page  1 What does this platform offer? Our tool is a next generation grid management software.
Predictor of Customer Perceived Software Quality By Haroon Malik.
AMS DATA WORKSHOP III TDSP UPDATE September 19,
CPUC Submetering Pilot Adam Langton CPUC Energy Division May 2014.
California Energy Commission Resource Adequacy Demand Forecast Coincidence Adjustments R Resource Adequacy Workshop January.
Overview Lesson 10,11 - Software Quality Assurance
PROCESS AND PRODUCT QUALITY ASSURANCE
SmartMeter Program Overview Jana Corey Director, Energy Information Network Pacific Gas & Electric Company.
Pertemuan 16 Matakuliah: A0214/Audit Sistem Informasi Tahun: 2007.
1 Predictors of customer perceived software quality Paul Luo Li (ISRI – CMU) Audris Mockus (Avaya Research) Ping Zhang (Avaya Research)
Purpose of the Standards
Solutions for Meter Data Management Layne Nelson Product Manager LODESTAR Corporation Copyright © 2005 LODESTAR Corporation - All Rights Reserved LODESTAR.
SmartMeter Program Overview and Impacts for ESPs April 2007.
Solar Metering and Performance Monitoring Exposition June 4, 2007.
1 Demand Response Update April, Strategic Perspective Demand Response  Aligns with PGE’s Strategic Direction; helping to provide exceptional.
1 SmartMeter™ Delivering Customer Benefits Jana Corey Director, Policy Planning Integrated Demand-side Management Pacific Gas and Electric Company.
Kinetiq Canada Savage Data Systems
May 2014 Zimele Technologies Customer convenience through mobile MDMS applications.
World Health Organization
The Key Process Areas for Level 2: Repeatable Ralph Covington David Wang.
1 Ex Ante Review of the SBD Program Energy Division Staff and Contractors Energy Efficiency Industrial/Agricultural Programs and Portfolio Forecasting.
Complaint Analysis and Multi State Collaboration Anne Marie Narcini Manager of Consumer Protection Services NJ Department of Banking & Insurance.
Implementation of the Essential Standards The Australian Quality Framework (AQTF) is the national set of standards which assures nationally consistent,
Encounter Data Validation: Review and Project Update August 25, 2015 Presenters: Amy Kearney, BA Director, Research and Analysis Team Thomas Miller, MA.
Service Transition & Planning Service Validation & Testing
Reviewing the Audit Results. Defining a Quality Base Year is Key to Maximizing Project Value n Base year is the mutually agreed upon pre-retrofit annual.
1 Overview of the Proposed Energy Education Study Presentation to the LIOB September 26, 2011 Sacramento, California.
Samordningsrådet med kunskapsplattform för smarta elnät Smart Grid and Smart Metering - Swedish Experiences Karin Widegren, Director Swedish Coordination.
Organization and Implementation of a National Regulatory Program for the Control of Radiation Sources Inspection Part II.
Implications of Mediated Instruction to Remote Learning in Mathematics Joy L. Matthews-López Educational Testing Service Sergio R. López-Permouth David.
09/15/10 RMS RMS Market Reports – Recommendations Karen Farley Manager, Retail Customer Choice.
Review of the New England “Mini-Pilot” DHP Evaluation Why we ignore this study.
10/13/10 RMS RMS Market Reports – Recommendations Karen Farley Manager, Retail Customer Choice.
Copyright 2008 Introduction to Project Management, Second Edition 2  Closing projects involves gaining stakeholder and customer acceptance of the final.
DR issues in California discussed last year in March Historical DR in California: some background issues –Twenty years of programs/tariffs I/C and AC cycling.
Dynamic Pricing Case Studies. Digi International.
MARS Taskforce RMS Update November 10, Conference Call concerning Settlement Estimates TDSPs held a conference call on October 28, 2010, where we:
1 CenterPoint Energy Response RMS Update January 14, 2008 CenterPoint Energy’s Update on Usage & Invoices Backlog.
Utilities’ Update on Energy Savings Assistance Program Studies Ordered in D LIOB Meeting August 21, 2013 Sacramento, California.
Open AMI Network 10/22/08.
1 TX SET Mass Transition Project RMS Update March 15, 2006.
AEP ONCOR TNMP TDSP AMS Data Practices Summary TDSP_AMS Data Practices Summary.ppt CenterPoint.
CEC Public Workshop Order Instituting Informational and Rulemaking Proceeding (08-DR-01) March 3, 2008.
MyFloridaMarketPlace Quality Improvement Plan. Page 2 MFMP Quality Improvement Plan  The MFMP team has developed a quality improvement plan that addresses.
Automating Work Order Processes for Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) Devices with Collector for ArcGIS and Portal for ArcGIS Subrahmanyam Pendyala.
SmartMeter Status Report For December, 2011 (Prepared January, 2012) Work Plan Deliverable Continue the general meter deployment in the Coastal Region.
Presented to The Raymore Peculiar Schools Board of Education Van McLain Energy Educator/Manager February 26 th, 2007Energy Management Conservation Program.
1 PG&E’s Response to the Summer 2006 Heat Storm LIOB Meeting September 14, 2006 Sacramento, CA.
ISO Certification For Laboratory Accreditation ISO Certification For Laboratory Accreditation.
Jean-Pierre Garitte Budapest 29 March 2017
Settlement Timeline Workshop
Auditing Information Technology
Software and Systems Integration
Deploying CIM to Bridge the Modeling Gap Between Operations and Planning Mike usa.siemens.com/digitalgrid unrestricted © Siemens AG 2017.
How can metros and municipalities operate to ensure that revenue generated from electricity sales is sustainable? by Dr Minnesh Bipath and Dr Willie de.
Meter Data Management Agenda What is MDM? Where does MDM fit?
Ombudsman Services Good for consumers – Good for business EHU Update 2nd November 2016 Sue Jackson – Relationship Manager Jay Ross- Energy Sector Expert.
Electricity Demand Response and Advanced Metering for Integrated Utilities Arkansas Public Service Commission Lonni Dieck AEP May 24, 2007.
Resource Adequacy Demand Forecast Coincidence Adjustments
Behavior Modification Report with Peak Reduction Component
1099 TRAINING Presented by:
Presentation transcript:

September 22, 2010 LIOB Meeting Independent Evaluation of PG&E’s Electric SmartMeters™ Structure Consulting Group, LLC. provided report at September 2, 2010 Commission Meeting. Structure found that the AMI technology deployed by PG&E appears to be Consistent with industry standards, based upon the goals of the AMI implementation and upgrades approved by the CPUC, and Accurate from a metering and billing perspective. Structure identified gaps in customer services and processes related to high bill complaints, and determined certain PG&E practices to be partially noncompliant relative to industry best practices.

September 22, 2010 LIOB Meeting Independent Evaluation of PG&E’s Electric SmartMeters™  Perform testing across a sampling of meters. Examine data to determine whether PG&E’s SmartMeters ™ are collecting, measuring and billing electric usage accurately, both now and since deployment began. SmartMeters are accurately recording electric usage within acceptable CPUC tolerances, and are being accurately utilized in Customer billing.

September 22, 2010 LIOB Meeting Independent Evaluation of PG&E’s Electric SmartMeters™ Conduct analyses of the high bill customer complaints; including interviews with a sample of those customers. Rates Meter deployment coincided with increased energy usage caused by a heat wave. Some Customers experienced load changes reflective of changes in personal circumstances. Customer Service PG&E processes did not address the Customer concerns associated with the new equipment and usage changes. Customer skepticism regarding the new advanced meter technology was not effectively addressed by PG&E. PG&E Customer complaint resolution did not provide information available with Smart Meters, which may have assisted Customers’ understanding of hourly usage patterns. Process Customers indicated that communications/notifications surrounding physical meter installation were lacking, or that the Customer had issues with the installation personnel. The transition to automate the Smart Meter data for use in billing was not clearly addressed with Customers. PG&E’s system tolerances related to billing quality control were not stringent enough, resulting in multiple bill cancelations and re-billings, which were confusing to Customers.

September 22, 2010 LIOB Meeting Independent Evaluation of PG&E’s Electric SmartMeters™ Analyze past and current operational and deployment processes against industry best practices. Structure found PG&E to have been historically in compliance, or have recently come into compliance, with the majority of Best Practices Associated with Smart Meters. Structure identified several items of partial or non-compliance related to industry best practices The lack of documentation verifying compliance with the Meter Deployment best practice to deploy WAN/LAN collectors prior to meter deployment. The inability to verify compliance around: The Meter Data Managements (MDMS) Interface best practice to correlate AMI meter events and alarms with Validation, Estimating and Editing (VEE) and Customer Information System (CIS) audits and checks for automated exception handling; and The VEE Best Practice of MDMS must provide an on-line method, with workflow, resolving validation errors rather than reports.