Fairness and the Federal Tax Treatment of Health Insurance and Medical Care Mark Pauly Wharton School University of Pennsylvania Prepared for The President's.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Massachusetts Health Care Reform June 6, The healthcare status quo is unsustainable Double-digit, annual increases in insurance premiums Half.
Advertisements

Four Proposed Tax Changes for Health Insurance Bob Lyke December 5, 2008.
Private Health Insurance: Challenges for Reform Karen Pollitz Research Professor Georgetown University Health Policy Institute Alliance for Health Reform.
John M. Colmers Secretary Department of Health and Mental Hygiene How States Are Trying To Expand Employer Sponsored Health Coverage.
1 Improving the Tax Treatment of Health Insurance Katherine Baicker Professor of Health Economics Harvard School of Public Health.
Health Savings Accounts: Early Estimates Of National Take-Up Roger Feldman, Stephen T. Parente, Jean Abraham, Jon B. Christianson and Ruth Taylor
Massachusetts HC Reform November 29, The Context The problem of the “uninsured” and “underinsured” is perennial issue Clinton Health Security Act.
Teleconference 2 1.Guest speakers in May 2.Policy Brief Project The Employer and Health Insurance.
Policy Proposals Health Care Coverage, Costs, and Financing.
Background on Employer- Sponsored Health Insurance in the U.S. Jim Reschovsky, Ph.D. Senior Researcher Center for Studying Health System Change (
— A Proposal to Cover All Americans —. 2 Health Coverage Passport Charles N. Kahn III President Federation of American Hospitals National Congress On.
Obama’s Heath Reform Proposal Helen Halpin, PhD. Professor of Health Policy UC Berkeley, SPH.
Health Care Forecasting Conference James Baumgardner Deputy Assistant Director for Health Policy Congressional Budget Office February 19, 2009.
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) Better known as ACA
1 Employer sponsored health insurance, Part 1 ECON Fall 2007.
Major Health Issues The Affordable Healthcare Act.
Employer-Sponsored Health Coverage Release Slides Tuesday, September 11, 2012 March 15, 2013.
Congressional Budget Office Presentation to The Tax Policy Center and the American Tax Policy Institute Taxes and Health Insurance February 29, 2008.
Robert B. Helms Resident Scholar American Enterprise Institute ARIA Annual Meeting The Capital Hilton August 7, 2006 Tax Policy and Health Insurance: History.
Experience, Commitment, Results. Federal Health Care Reform The impact on individuals, employers, and our health insurance coverage… National Worksite.
Reducing the Uninsured Through Tax Reform Robert E. Moffit, Ph.D. Director, Center for Health Policy Studies The Heritage Foundation 2007.
The Tax Treatment of Health Insurance: Introduction and History Sherry Glied, Ph.D. Mailman School of Public Health Columbia University
THE HEALTH CARE MARKET Chapter 9.
CHAPTER 20 SECTION 1 PGS Taxing and Spending.
This presentation is a high-level summary and for general informational purposes only. The information in this presentation is not comprehensive and does.
Major Tax Structures: Income Taxes Troy University PA6650- Governmental Budgeting Chapter 8.
The Affordable Care Act’s Credits, Subsidies, Penalties and Fees This presentation is a high-level summary and for general informational purposes only.
A Primer on Tax Subsidies for Health Care Larry Levitt Kaiser Family Foundation December 5, 2008.
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) – signed on March 23, 2010 Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act (Reconciliation Act) – signed.
Health Care Reform Quynh Smith. Sources of Inefficiency in the Health Care Delivery System   We spend a substantial amount on high cost, low-value treatments.
Health Reform: What It Means to Our Community. Health Reform: Key Provisions o Provides coverage to 32 million uninsured people by o Changes insurance.
PATIENT PROTECTION AND AFFORDABLE CARE ACT (AKA HEALTH CARE REFORM)
CHCWG DRAFT March 2, 2006 Hearing from the American People: Preliminary Overview of Sources and Reports March 2006 Caution: Preliminary Data Do not cite.
1 © 2007 ME™ - Your Money Education Resource™ Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits for Financial Planners Chapter 14: Employee Benefits: Group Benefits.
Limited Medical Plans: Unlimited Possibilities William Kramer Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company March 22, 2007.
1 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Cheri D. Green This Presentation is not designed or intended to provide legal or professional.
The Causes and Consequences of Rising Health Insurance Premiums Mark Pauly, Ph.D. Wharton School University of Pennsylvania.
Current tax laws Under current tax law, health insurance premiums are largely tax exempt if the insurance is provided through an employer. The share of.
Comparison of Major Health Care Reform Proposals BushKerry Aims to Cover All Americans X Tax Credits for Premiums XX Automatic Enrollment/ Individual Mandate.
Catastrophic health insurance and health savings accounts in the US February, 2008.
Potential State Applications of Section 125 Plans Rick Curtis, President Institute for Health Policy Solutions SCI/NASHP/NGA Section 125 Plans Meeting.
Exhibit 1. Only One of Three Small-Firm Workers Was Insured Through Their Employer in 2010 ^ Includes both part-time and full-time workers who are not.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND The 2009 Congressional Health Reform Bills: Insurance Coverage Sara R. Collins, Ph.D., Vice President Rachel Nuzum, M.P.H., Senior.
Recent and Future Developments for Health Savings Accounts Roy Ramthun, President HSA Consulting Services, LLC February 1, 2007.
The Tax Expenditure for Health: Update for 2007 John Sheils April 29, 2008.
Chartbook 2005 Trends in the Overall Health Care Market Chapter 1: Trends in the Overall Health Care Market.
21 - 1Copyright 2008, The National Underwriter Company Taxation of Individual Health Insurance Coverage  What is it?  Individual health insurance  Provides.
The Best of the Second Best: Using Tax Breaks to Manipulate Health Insurance Mark V. Pauly, Ph.D. ARIA Meeting August 7, 2006.
UNDERSTANDING THE POLICY IMPACT OF SECTION 125 PLANS Lynn Quincy Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. (MPR) July 18, 2008 Lynn Quincy Mathematica Policy Research,
Medical Expenditure Burdens: The Impact of Tax Subsidies, Within-Year Expenditure Concentration, and More Thomas M. Selden, Ph.D. Division of Modeling.
Modeling Health Reform in Massachusetts John Holahan June 4, 2008 THE URBAN INSTITUTE.
State Trends in Premiums and Deductibles, : Eroding Protection and Rising Costs Underscore Need for Action Cathy Schoen Senior Vice President.
September 12, 2011 Objective: Students will examine optional payroll deductions.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Exhibit 1. Employer Coverage Continues to Be Major Source of Coverage for Employees of Larger Firms Percent of firms offering health.
What Are Section 125 Plans and How Can They Be Used To Expand Health Coverage? Lynn Quincy Mathematica Policy Research February 7, 2008 Lynn Quincy Mathematica.
Long-Term Care Plan Chapter 49 Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning Copyright 2011, The National Underwriter Company1 What is it? An employer-provided.
The Excise Tax on High-Cost Employer-Sponsored Health Coverage: Background and Economic Analysis Written By: Sean Lowry Published Online By: Congressional.
Taxes and Health Insurance Chapter Overview Taxes and health insurance incentives Taxes and health insurance incentives Tax expenditures Tax expenditures.
Health Insurance Chapter 9. Importance Of Health Insurance In 2007, 60% if all personal bankruptcies were due to medial costs.
A Look at the Individual Mandate: Massachusetts and California.
Small Business Conversations
Presenting on behalf of the author team
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act – What it Means to Businesses and Individuals Linda Ialacci, CPA Horvath & Giacin, P.C. July 18, 2012.
Potential State Applications of Section 125 Plans
GOVERNMENT AND THE MARKET FOR HEALTH CARE
UNDERSTANDING THE POLICY IMPACT OF SECTION 125 PLANS
Cathy Schoen Senior Vice President The Commonwealth Fund
How Well Does Insurance Coverage Protect Consumers from Health Care Costs? Findings from the Commonwealth Fund Biennial Health Insurance Survey, 2016 Sara.
Households with employer coverage can spend thousands of dollars on premiums and out-of-pocket costs. Distribution of spending on premiums and out-of-pocket.
Presentation transcript:

Fairness and the Federal Tax Treatment of Health Insurance and Medical Care Mark Pauly Wharton School University of Pennsylvania Prepared for The President's Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform New Orleans, LA March 23, 2005

Main Points to Be Made Provisions in the tax code cause households’ net tax to be significantly affected by the amounts and types of health insurance they obtain and by their uninsured medical care spending. By most definitions of equity, the resulting patterns of tax payments, health insurance coverage, and medical spending are made more inequitable by these provisions. These unfair tax provisions also may increase medical care spending.

Major Tax Provisions Related to Insurance and Care Compensation paid by employers in the form of health insurance premiums is excluded from taxable income and payroll. Cafeteria (Section 125 Plans) permit explicit employee premiums to be excluded. Taxable income may also be reduced through flexible spending accounts. Deductibility of spending in excess of 7.5% of AGI is permitted to itemizers for income taxes. (Future) HSA/CHP arrangements lower taxes.

Equity/Fairness Analysis:Vertical Inequity Note: Employer premium payments are assumed to come out of what would otherwise be taxable employee income. Exclusion leads to tax expenditures that are larger for higher income households: vertically inequitable. Higher income households benefit more because they have higher tax rates, they are more likely to have insurance, they buy more generous and costly insurance, and live in high-priced areas.

Estimated Value of Federal Tax Exclusion, 2004 (Sheils/Haught * ) Total value: $188.5 billion (about 29% of private insurance spending). Income tax exclusion: $100 Billion; OASDI tax, $50 Billion. Exclusion of employment based premiums is 80% of subsidy; income tax deduction is 7%; smaller percentages for flex accounts, self employed, HSA/CHP (very small now) * John Shiels and Randall Haught. “The Cost of Tax-Exempt Health Benefits in 2004.” Health Affairs Web Exclusives, February 25, 2004.

Value of tax exclusion and private insurance by income as % of poverty line % of Poverty Line Average Value of Exclusion* % of Total Exclusion % with Private Insurance (adults) % of Total Uninsureds >400$2, < * Value of exclusion = additional tax on excluded income.

Summary: Effects by Income The half of the population above the median income gets 75% of the subsidy; half below gets 25%. The half of the population above the median income makes up 25% of uninsured; half below makes up 75%.

Equity/Fairness Analysis: Horizontal Inequity Within a “full” income class, those who work for a firm offering insurance pay less taxes. Those whose employers offer cafeteria plans pay lower taxes. Those who chose higher priced insurance pay lower taxes. Those who use flex accounts, especially those who “clean out” the account, pay less taxes.

Equity/Fairness Analysis: Horizontal Inequity In a given tax bracket, taxes differ for households with the same average medical spending: In the group market, using cost containing HMO coverage shields more income than using a high deductible plan. HSAs redress this somewhat in the group setting, but lower taxes in the individual market only for those who choose a high deductible plan.

Tax Benefits Lead to Uneven Distribution of Risk Protection and Medical Care Use Higher income people are induced to buy more generous coverage with high administrative costs, may also be more likely to obtain coverage. This more generous coverage causes higher spending for them. The tax treatment thus worsens disparities in insurance coverage, use of care, and perhaps health outcomes.

Tax Subsidies and Medical Spending Tax subsidies cause medical spending to be higher by higher income people. Estimates are imprecise, but removing subsidies could lower private spending by 5-20%. Removal of tax distortions would increase our confidence in the operation of competitive markets in health care and insurance. Subsidies to the well off may raise premiums for lower income people too and discourage coverage; they may also lead to a higher rate of growth of spending for all.

Conclusions Limiting the tax subsidy would improve fairness and efficiency in private health insurance markets. Including all compensation as taxable income is best; second best is to allow all spending and insurance to be excluded. My view: subsidies for the upper middle class should be limited but refundable insurance tax credits should be used for lower income people In a flat tax setting, make the size of the allowance conditional on obtaining (yet-to-be-defined) basic insurance coverage.