Explaining Residential Ethnic Segregation in the Netherlands using Price Hedonics Cheng Boon Ong HSA-ECS Workshop 15 April 2010.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Hedonic Modeling Mats Wilhelmsson Center for Banking and Finance (Cefin)
Advertisements

1 The Real Estate Market Chapter 19 Florida Real Estate Principles, Practices & Law Copyright 2013 Kaplan, Inc.
Hedonic Prices © Allen C. Goodman, 2000 Hedonic Price Analysis It became clear in the 1960s that for many types of analyses one wanted to look at the.
Valuation 10: Hedonic Pricing
What 21 st Century Home Buyers Want International Builders Show Atlanta, GA February 2002 Presented by Gopal Ahluwalia Director of Research National Association.
Residential Location and Household Expenditures for Transport and Housing: the example of the Greater Paris region Akli BERRI INRETS-DEST COST 355 WG 1.
IMPUTED RENT IN HOUSEHOLD BUDGET SURVEY Inga Masiulaitytė, August 24-28, Ventspils, Latvia 2006.
CHR – Centre for Housing Research, University of St Andrews Who wants to leave the neighbourhood? The effect on moving wishes of being different from the.
Amenity Value of Proximity to National Wildlife Refuges Timothy Hamilton North Carolina State University Camp Resources XVIII.
What kind of demands does a new real estate market growth make on real estate quality in Estonia? Ene Kolbre Angelika Kallakmaa-Kapsta Tallinn University.
Australian House Prices Rental value of land.
The Impact of Mature Trees on House Values and on Residential Location Choices in Quebec City Marius Thériault, Ph.D. Yan Kestens, Ph.D. Candidate François.
PPA786: Urban Policy Class 7: Housing Problems and Federal Housing Programs.
Estimation of the stock of land in OECD countries Working Party on National Accounts October 2008 Young-Hwan Kim, OECD.
1 1 Overview of the family of property price indices and their importance Lunchtime seminar: Measuring Property Prices, UNSC, New York Tuesday February.
MEASUREMENT OF LAND ON A COUNTRY’S BALANCE SHEET Jennifer Ribarsky National Accounts Division, OECD 2014 NBS-OECD Workshop 2 – 5 December 2014.
Constructing the Welfare Aggregate Part 2: Adjusting for Differences Across Individuals Bosnia and Herzegovina Poverty Analysis Workshop September 17-21,
Do Sydney tenants pay energy efficient office premiums? Jeremy Gabe & Michael RehmJuly 2013.
Measuring poverty and inequality in the Republic of Belarus Inna Konoshonok Head of the Living Standards Statistics and Household Survey Department NATIONAL.
Application Orientation Lancaster County March 2010.
Multilevel models for predicting personal victimisation in England and Wales Andromachi Tseloni Analysis of crime data ESRC Research Methods Festival 2010.
Reconciling User Costs and Rental Equivalence: Evidence from the U.S. Consumer Expenditure Survey Thesia I. Garner* Randal Verbrugge* Division of Price.
The Importance of Accurate & Integrated Measures of Property Prices J. Steven Landefeld, Director February 23 rd, st Session of the.
Andrey Veykher National Research University «Higher School оf Economics» in St-Petersburg, Russia The representative study of households based on the data.
Development and Application of a Land Use Model for Santiago de Chile Universidad de Chile Francisco Martínez Francisco Martínez Universidad de Chile
Housing markets and ethnic segregation in the Nordic countries Hans Skifter Andersen Affiliated professor Danish Building Research Institute at Aalborg.
Distributional Implications of Power Sector Reforms in the Philippines WONDIELYN Q. MANALO-MACUA University of Tsukuba.
Household Energy Bills and Subsidized Housing Samuel Dastrup, Simon McDonnell, Vincent Reina March 8, 2011 American Housing Survey User Conference.
Who emits most? An analysis of UK households’ CO2 emissions and their association with socio-economic factors Milena Büchs & Sylke V. Schnepf with Nick.
On visible choice set and scope sensitivity: - Dealing with the impact of study design on the scope sensitivity Improving the Practice of Benefit Transfer:
Poverty measurement: experience of the Republic of Moldova UNECE, Measuring poverty, 4 May 2015.
Berna Keskin & Craig Watkins1 University of Sheffield, Department of Town and Regional Planning Exploring the Case for Expert-Defined Housing Submarket.
Welfare implications of subsidization in the Dutch housing market Frans Schilder
Berna Keskin1 University of Sheffield, Department of Town and Regional Planning Alternative Approaches to Modelling Housing Market Segmentation: Evidence.
Outline of presentation Travel cost method – concept, example, assumptions Consumer surplus related to TCM Visitor’s table Demand curve Concerns regarding.
Household wealth What we can learn from micro data registers Gitte Frej Knudsen Søren Brodersen.
The Annual Meeting of the RSAI – The Israeli Branch, Tel-Aviv University, January 10, 2010 Development and estimation of a semi- compensatory residential.
To Hold or Not to Hold? An Analysis of Holding Periods in Five European Property Markets Jan Reinert July 2013 Portfolio Analyst, IPD.
ECN741: Urban Economics Homeownership Gaps Between Ethnic Groups.
Housing Studies Association conference paper Assessing the growth of the private rented sector: choice versus constraints Paul Sissons and Donald Houston.
PPA786: Urban Policy Class 7: Housing Problems and Federal Housing Programs.
2006 Government of Canada study of real estate prices for the next 30 years.
1 The Decomposition of a House Price index into Land and Structures Components: A Hedonic Regression Approach by W. Erwin Diewert, Jan de Haan and Rens.
George Penfold Regional Innovation Chair Selkirk College LCCDT, Trail B.C., September24, 2008.
George Penfold Regional Innovation Chair Selkirk College Selkirk College, EDCO, Nelson B.C., December 9, 2008.
Rents as incentive for saving energy: an empirical analysis for Austria Gunther Maier, Philipp Kaufmann, Andreas Oberhuber.
ECN741: Urban Economics Homeownership Gaps Between Ethnic Groups.
CITY OF BEND | ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE IN AN URBAN AREA JIM LONG, AFFORDABLE HOUSING MANAGER HOUSING LAND ADVOCATES 2015 CONFERENCE, NOVEMBER 6, 2015.
George Penfold Regional Innovation Chair Selkirk College Boundary Economic Development Committee Greenwood B.C., October 14, 2008.
George Penfold Regional Innovation Chair Selkirk College.
George Penfold Regional Innovation Chair Selkirk College City of Castlegar, May 19, 2009.
REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT MARKET PERSPECTIVES IN ESTONIA: A SURVEY ANALYSIS Kaia Kask School of Economics and Business Administration University of Tartu.
Use of rental equivalence method in CPI CPI workshop Istanbul, 10 – 13 October 2011.
Effects of migration and remittances on poverty and inequality A comparison between Burkina Faso, Kenya, Nigeria, Senegal, South Africa, and Uganda Y.
Construction of New Housing Price Indices for Monetary and Macro-prudential Policies: Experience of Thailand Saovanee Chantapong, Bank of Thailand, The.
Accounting for Spatial Variation of Land Prices in Hedonic Imputation House Price Indexes: A Semi- Parametric Approach Jan de Haan * and Yunlong Gong **
Improving the Residential Location Model for the New York Metropolitan Region Haiyun Lin City College of New York Project Advisors: Prof. Cynthia Chen,
Chris Curington Hedonic pricing.
The determinants of housing demand An analysis for French households
Evangelos Charalambakis
Introduction to statistical background
HOUSING RENTS in Wallonia: Modelling two different worlds Marko Kryvobokov ERES 2015, Istanbul, ITU, 26 June 2015.
The European Statistical Training Programme (ESTP)
ECONOMY FOR REAL ESTATE (BPE 33902)
Mats Wilhelmsson Center for Banking and Finance (Cefin)
Florida Real Estate Principles, Practices & Law 38th Edition
Homeownership Gaps Between Ethnic Groups
Workshop on Residential Property Price Indices
Chapter 5: The analysis of nonresponse
Homeownership Gaps Between Ethnic Groups
Presentation transcript:

Explaining Residential Ethnic Segregation in the Netherlands using Price Hedonics Cheng Boon Ong HSA-ECS Workshop 15 April 2010

Presentation Outline 1.Context 2.Price Hedonic Method 3.Data and specification 4.1 st stage semiparametric 5.3 rd stage: heterogeneous preference for neighbourhood ethnic composition

Ethnic segregation in a Dutch context

NativeNon-westernWesternTotal Homeownership Social rental Private rental Median indoor floor space (m 2 ) Average net rent (€/month) Average WOZ dwelling price (€ ‘000) Big City (Randstad) Other municipalities

Why homeowners and segregation? Non-price mechanism drives social rented sector (e.g. waiting list) Increase in homeowner sector at the expense of social rented sector (mortage tax relief, privatisation of housing associations, …) This line of research is relatively unexplored for the Netherlands

Price Hedonic Method Real estate valuation, transaction data Microeconomic consumer choice theory (utility, budget constraint, …) Housing as a bundle of separable attributes with unique subutility components and implicit prices for each attribute (Lancaster 1966, Rosen 1974) Bajari and Kahn (2005): heterogeneous preferences

Bajari and Kahn (2005) three-stage 1st stage: estimate implicit prices for each housing attribute (semiparametric GAM) 2nd stage: recover household preference parameter with 1 st stage coefficients and observed housing attributes 3rd stage: estimate joint distribution of preferences and household characteristics

Utility of household i consuming dwelling j with housing attributes, k: u ij = u(x j, ξ j, c) = β i,k ln(x j ) + β i,k x j + β i,j ln(ξ j ) + c Household preference for attribute k, β i,k = x j*,k (∂p(x j*, ξ j* )/∂x j,k ) …as a function of household characteristics, z β i,k = f k (z i ) + ε i,k

Dutch Housing Survey (WoON 2006) Nationally representative sample > 60,000 respondents Household characteristics, housing and neighbourhood conditions, mobility Linked to administrative (postcode) neighbourhood data

1 st semiparametric model Log(Price j ) = β 0,j + β 1,j* YEAR β 2,j* YEAR β 3,j* YEAR β 4,j* YEAR β 5,j* YEAR β 6,j* YEAR after β 7,j* s(log(ROOMS)) + β 8,j* s(log(INDOORSIZE)) + β 9, j* s(log(OUTDOORSIZE)) + β 10, j* ONEFLOOR + β 11, j* GARDEN + β 12, j* BALCONY + β 13, j* CARPARK + β 14, j* CENTRALHEAT + β 15, j* DETACHED + β 16, j* SEMIDETACH + β 17, j* APARTMENT + β 18, j* DISTANCETOWN 15minwalk + β 19, j* DISTANCETOWN withintown + β 20, j* DISTANCETOWN surrounding + β 21, j* DISTANCETOWN countryside + β 22, j* s(log(MEANINCOME)) + β 23, j* s(log(NONWESTERN)) + β 24, j* s(log(URBANITY)) + β 25, j* BIGCITY

Log WOZ (indexed)dfLin. Coef.Std. ErrorzGainP>Gain after log rooms log indoor size log outdoor size detached house semidetached apartment single floor garden balcony carpark central heating distance distance distance distance log mean WOZ proportion non-western log urbanity big city

‘Downhill’ once proportion of non-western minorities exceeds 3.7%

Partial residual plots show nonlinearity

3rd stage: OLS MWTP i,nonwestern = β 0,i + β 1,i FamilyKid + β 2,i HouseholdSize + β 3,i NativeDutchHead + β 4,i WesternHead + β 5,i NonWesternPartner + β 6,i LowIncome + β 7,i 1to1.5ModalIncome + β 8,i 1.5to2ModalIncome + β 9,i 2ModalhighIncome + β 10,i log(Age) + β 11,i TertiaryEducated

Calculate Marginal Willingness to Pay MWTP nonwestern10-35%increase,i = β i,k* (10) - β i,k* (35) MWTPnonwestern0-3%increase,i = β i,k* (3) - β i,k* (0)

MWTP 10% to 35% non-westernCoef.Std. Err.tP>t[95% Conf.Interval] Family with kids # household members Western minority Native Dutch < Social minimum Model income Modal income > 2 Modal income Log age of household head Tertiary education Non-western partner constant Adj R-squared0.0817

MWTP 0% to 3% non-westernCoef.Std. Err.tP>t[95% Conf.Interval] Family with kids # household members Western minority Native Dutch < Social minimum Model income Modal income > 2 Modal income Log age of household head Tertiary education Non-western partner constant Adj R-squared0.0817

Some preliminary conclusions Nonlinear relationship between proportion of non-western households in neighbourhood and dwelling price Different demand across ethnicity of household for non-western neighbours – some positive “taste” for non- western neighbours up to a certain level and then the “distaste” sets in

Thank you for your attention! Comments/suggestions welcome: