From traditional lectures to active learning: Persistent gender differences in large introductory biology classrooms Sara E. Brownell Assistant Professor.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
MEASURES OF SUCCESS: An Evaluators Perspective Carol L. Colbeck Director & Associate Professor Center for the Study of Higher Education The Pennsylvania.
Advertisements

Broadening Participation – Recruiting and Retaining Outstanding Scientists in the Botanical Sciences Organized by Anna K. Monfils and Ann K. Sakai BSA.
Access to Resources: Pre-college Characteristics and Experiences of Underrepresented Minority Students in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences Sylvia.
Getzel. Sheryl Burgstahler, Ph.D. University of Washington Services, Supports and Accommodations Role of Technology.
Where Have We Been? Where Are We Going? Using Student Surveys to Assess and Improve Literature Courses Kelly Douglass, PhD Asst. Professor, English Riverside.
Making Your Assessments More Meaningful Flex Day 2015.
The exit from STEM fields is far worse for minority students: After 4 years, only 15% of Latinos, Black and Native American students who had an initial.
Fostering STEM Diversity OPAS Vision for the Year All Oregonians have the opportunity to choose and successfully pursue engineering or applied science.
OCTOBER 13, 2010 SCHOOL OF EDUCATION RESEARCH SEMINAR SERIES Natasha K. Bowen UNC School of Social Work Too Good to Be True: Can a Brief Writing Intervention.
Promoting Diversity: Access and Engagement in Biomedical and Behavioral Research Careers Sylvia Hurtado, Professor & Director Mitchell Chang, Associate.
SUNY Cortland Conceptual Framework … our shared vision for preparing candidates to work in P-12 schools.
© 2008 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. 1 CHAPTER 5 Sociocultural Diversity.
Examining the Gender Gap in Introductory Physics Lauren Kost Steven Pollock, Noah Finkelstein Department of Physics, University of Colorado at Boulder.
Origins of the Gender Gap: Pre-College and College Influences on Differences Between Men and Women Linda J. Sax Casandra E. Harper University of California.
The Multicultural Classroom
Understanding and Supporting Gender Equality in Schools
Where You Go, What You Do, What You Know? Understanding the Influences of Campus Experiences on the Academic Achievement and Self-Concept of Black Undergraduates.
Issues with Inclusion in Physical Education Melissa Ewerth West Chester University KIN 586: Professional Issues in Adapted Physical Education
Why So Few? Women in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics.
The University of Arkansas GK-12 KIDS (K-12, I, Do, Science) Program Changing Graduate Training to Include a Responsibility for K-12 Science and Math Education.
 Student Diversity in Development and Learning  School psychologists have knowledge of individual differences, abilities, and disabilities and of the.
The Impact of CReSIS Summer Research Programs that Influence Students’ Choice of a STEM Related Major in College By: Alica Reynolds, Jessica.
Introduction: While factors within the classroom no doubt play a major part in students’ academic achievement, there is growing interest in how psychosocial.
Assessing Bias Before and After Completing a Course in Cultural Diversity Preliminary Findings Sarah W Morgan RN, PhD, CNE Clinical Assistant Professor.
Attracting the Best and Brightest Minds to Science Geraldine Richmond University of Oregon.
Academic Attainment in California Community Colleges: Racial And Ethnic Disparities in the ARCC 2.0/Scorecard Metrics Tom Leigh Alice van Ommeren.
Developing Teaching Assistant Self-Efficacy through a Pre-Semester Teaching Assistant Orientation K. Andrew R. Richards & Chantal Levesque-Bristol Purdue.
Asian International Students Attitudes on Women in College Keyana Silverberg and Margo Hanson Advised by: Susan Wolfgram, Ph.D. University of Wisconsin-Stout.
ICEE 2010 Attracting and Retaining Women and Underrepresented Groups in Engineering, Science, and Related Programs ICEE 2010 – Gliwice, Poland July 18-22,
Increasing the Representation of Women Full Professors in Academe Barbara A. Lee Dean School of Management & Labor Relations Rutgers University.
Self Competence and Depressive Symptoms in Ethnic Minority Students: The Role of Ethnic Identity and School Belonging Praveena Gummadam and Laura D. Pittman.
Frances Lawrenz and The Noyce evaluation team University of Minnesota 1 Acknowledgement: This project was funded by National Science Foundation (Grant#REC )
Figure 3. The average interest of males and females pursuing a science career comparing pre-adolescence and adolescence. Averages were not significantly.
Science Case Network GAPS IN REACHING DIVERSE AUDIENCES Aditi Pai Networking Conference August 6-7, 2012 RCN-UBE Project #
Evidence of Student Learning Fall Faculty Seminar Office of Institutional Research and Assessment August 15, 2012.
Bryce E. Hughes and Sylvia Hurtado UCLA Association for the Study of Higher Education November 2013 St. Louis, MO.
High rates of attrition exist among college students in science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) fields, especially among women and minorities.
A College-level Analysis of Service-Learning at CUNY, Queensborough Community College IARSCLE 2011 Nov. 3, 2011 Chicago, IL Sharon S. Ellerton, PhD Assoc.Prof.
Education That Is Multicultural
Online Course Evaluations Is there a perfect time? Presenters: Cassandra Jones, Ph.D., Director of Assessment Michael Anuszkiewicz, Research Associate.
1 Self-Regulation and Ability Predictors of Academic Success during College Anastasia Kitsantas, Faye Huie, and Adam Winsler George Mason University.
Key Issues in Recruiting and Retaining Underrepresented Students in STEM Pat Marsteller Director, Hughes Science Initiatives Director, Emory Center for.
1 Diversity issues in science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) in higher education Education 286 Lisa Hunter Associate Director, Education & Human.
Total Workforce vs. STEM Workforce Demographics Sources: National Science Foundation, 2009 & U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2009.
Division III Open Meeting— Feb. 19, 2015 Diversity and Successful General Education.
MAP the Way to Success in Math: A Hybridization of Tutoring and SI Support Evin Deschamps Northern Arizona University Student Learning Centers.
STANDARD 4 & DIVERSITY in the NCATE Standards Boyce C. Williams, NCATE John M. Johnston, University of Memphis Institutional Orientation, Spring 2008.
Opportunity Structures for Preparation and Inspiration (OSPrI): Case Studies of 8 “Exemplar” Inclusive STEM-focused High Schools This work was conducted.
Can Mentoring Help Female Assistant Professors? An Evaluation by Randomized Trial Francine Blau, Cornell University Rachel Croson, University of Texas,
Teaching Strategies Equity in the Classroom. An Overview Defining equity in the classroom Meeting basic needs first Identifying some best practices –
Early Identification of Introductory Major's Biology Students for Inclusion in an Academic Support Program BETHANY V. BOWLING and E. DAVID THOMPSON Department.
Biology 1113 Course Redesign Caroline Breitenberger, Director Judy Ridgway, Assistant Director Center for Life Sciences Education.
Motivating Students to Follow Through on Campus Referrals
Continuing Education Provincial Survey Winter 2012 Connie Phelps Manager, Institutional Research & Planning.
Girls and Physics Chris Meyer York Mills C. I.
Asking the Right K-12 Questions How to Answer Them to Evaluate K-12 STEM Outreach and Engagement Carlos Rodriguez, Ph.D., Principal Research Scientist.
Adventures in flipping a cell biology course Dr. Katie Shannon Biological Sciences Missouri S&T How do online videos and textbook reading engage students.
Project SPROUT Simple Protocol for Observing Undergraduate Teaching Lynn C. Reimer School of Education University of California, Irvine This material is.
ASCCC Cultural Competency and Advocacy Plan Update Cleavon Smith, Berkeley City College Carolyn Holcroft, Foothill College.
Staff Development and the Implementation of UDL: Some Important Questions Alan Hurst Independent Consultant (Retired Professor, School.
Scott Elliot, SEG Measurement Gerry Bogatz, MarketingWorks
Jo Handelsman Associate Director For Science
Linda J. Sax, Professor, GSEIS/UCLA
Part #3 Beyond Bias and Barriers
Science in Australia Gender Equity (SAGE) Pilot of the Athena SWAN Charter - Update A./Prof. Kay Latham, RMIT University Lead Contact 22nd August 2016.
Sara E. Brownell Assistant Professor School of Life Sciences
University of Washington The Evergreen State College
Field Experiences and Clinical Practice
Education That Is Multicultural
The Heart of Student Success
Presentation transcript:

From traditional lectures to active learning: Persistent gender differences in large introductory biology classrooms Sara E. Brownell Assistant Professor in Biology Education School of Life Sciences Arizona State University

1.Equity is important 2.We currently have inequities in our classrooms 1.There are strategies that we can use to make our classrooms more equitable

1.Equity is important 2.We currently have inequities in our classrooms 1.There are strategies that we can use to make our classrooms more equitable

What is equity? Equity = what is fair and just Equity encompasses a wide variety of educational models, programs, and strategies that may be considered fair, but not necessarily equal. Equity is the process; equality is the outcome

Why is equity in STEM important? Social Justice Rationale: Science education and training provides access to highly skilled and paid jobs, which will address socio-economic inequalities Talented Workforce Rationale: We will not exclude some of the best and brightest scientific minds or limit the pool of talented scientists Increased Objectivity Rationale: Diverse community of researchers can minimize the negative influence of bias in scientific reasoning Intemann 2009

Why is equity in teaching important? Students come into the classroom with differing prior knowledge, life experiences, socioeconomic statuses, genders, ethnicities, first generation statuses, etc. As instructors, we choose what to teach, how to teach it, and perhaps unconsciously, who to teach it to. Equity is about striving to structure teaching environments that maximize fairness to all students

1.Equity is important 2.We currently have inequities in our classrooms 1.There are strategies that we can use to make our classrooms more equitable

1.Equity is important 2.We currently have gender inequities in our biology classrooms 1.There are strategies that we can use to make our classrooms more equitable

Gender differences in STEM Females are underrepresented in STEM majors, graduate school, and the professoriate (NSF 2011) Exception is the field of biology – Females make up 60% of undergraduates – Females make up 50% of graduate students – Gender differences only begin to emerge beyond graduate school

Why are there fewer females in biology post- graduate school? Most common reasons are based on life decisions – Two-body problem, desire to have family, etc. What if the root cause of this originated much earlier… – Female experiences in undergraduate biology

Looking beyond the numbers Performance of students on exams Participation of students in class discussions Confidence in course material Science identity, professional role confidence, sense of belonging in a course, major, or discipline The persistence and retention of females in biology is only one metric of equity. Others include:

Performance of students on exams – Mixed results: Some studies have shown no differences in intro bio (Strenta et al. 1994; Lauer et al. 2013) Some studies have shown female underperformance in biochemistry courses (Rauschenberger and Sweeder 2010; Creech and Sweeder 2012) Participation in class – To our knowledge, no studies have been done on the participation of students in college biology classrooms Need for additional studies with larger numbers of classes! What is known about gender differences in undergraduate biology…

Are there are gender disparities in introductory biology at the University of Washington? Large public R1 institution on West coast Quarter-system: 3 classes make up intro bio series – Ecology/evolution – Molecular/cell – Physiology Each course is offered each quarter, taught by different instructors

Are there are gender disparities in introductory biology at the University of Washington? Looked across multiple large introductory biology classrooms with multiple instructors Examined achievement in the course, whole class participation, and student self-report of confidence, self-efficacy, participation, and sense of belonging

Examined total exam points over 10 week quarter in 23 different introductory biology classes Accounted for student characteristics, including gender, ethnicity, and GPA as a measure of prior academic ability Are there gender differences in achievement on exams?

If crosses red line, not significant Class 1 Class 2 Class 3 Class 4 Regression Coefficient 95% Confidence Interval 95% Confidence Interval Increases Achievement Increases Achievement Decreases Achievement Decreases Achievement

Across 23 different introductory biology classes, females significantly underperformed compared with males Compared to males

Gender differences are on a similar scale of racial/ethnic differences Small yet potentially important

Analyzed videotaped classes from 26 instructors, 3 class sessions per instructor – Recorded who asked and answered questions – Only included instructors who had at least 5 student responses, which decreased the sample to 11 instructors Who is asking and answering questions in class?

There were NO gender differences in who asked questions in class

There were gender differences in who answered questions in class

Gender differences in achievement and whole class participation in introductory biology classes What about classes that use active learning? Active learning classes tend to have more student participation in small groups. Does this eliminate the gender inequities?

Preliminary results indicate that gender achievement gaps still present in classes with active learning Compared to males

What about student participation in this active learning class with an achievement gap? Compared to males

Administered a Likert-scale survey asking: “Do you feel as though you participated as much as others in your group” Accounted for student characteristics, including gender, ethnicity, and GPA as a measure of prior academic ability How do students feel about participation in small groups?

Self-reported participation gaps in small groups Compared to white Compared to White U.S. citizen Compared to male

Administered a Likert-scale survey asking: “Do you feel as though you belong in this class, major, or discipline?” “Do you feel others are smarter than you in this class” “Do you feel as though you understand the material as well as others in your group? In this class?” Accounted for student characteristics, including gender, ethnicity, and GPA as a measure of prior academic ability How do students feel about belonging and self-efficacy?

Males have a higher sense of belonging and self-efficacy than females Compared to female

Gender differences in achievement and whole class participation in introductory biology classes Even active learning classes demonstrate gender inequities in achievement and participation. Perhaps we need to be more attentive to how students are interacting and how we are structuring the student-centered instruction in order to promote equity.

1.Equity is important 2.We currently have gender inequities in our biology classrooms 1.There are strategies that we can use to make our classrooms more equitable

1.Equity is important 2.We currently have gender inequities in our biology classrooms 1.There are strategies that we can use to make our classrooms more equitable

Random call removed gender inequities in whole class participation

1. Encourage, demand, and actively manage the participation of all students 2. Build an inclusive and fair biology classroom for all students 3. Teaching all of the students in your biology classroom

1.Equity is important 2.We currently have inequities in our classrooms 1.There are strategies that we can use to make our classrooms more equitable

Acknowledgements Mary Pat Wenderoth, Ph.D.Sarah Eddy, Ph.D. University of Washington Course coordinators for intro series Study participants Mercedes Converse, Carl Longton, Michael Mullen Biology Education Research Group (BERG)