Robert Zisk, Elana Resnick, Eugenia Etkina Rutgers University Students have difficulties comprehending science texts. The interrogation method, which prompts.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Teacher Work Sample
Advertisements

Gifted and Talented Education (G.A.T.E.)
Direct Instruction Also called explicit instruction Widely applicable strategy that can be used to teach both concepts and skills Uses teacher explanation.
A Guide to Implementation
Bridging the Gap Between Middle/High School Physics and Mathematics Hector Lopez, Eugenia Etkina, Suzane Brahmia, Jim Flakker, Jeff Goett, Alan Van Heuvelen.
Common Core Standards and the Edmonds School District November 4, 2013.
Apprenticeship and Workplace Mathematics Meeting the Needs of Today’s Students.
Thinking and Writing Like a Scientist: Claims Evidence Reasoning - CER
Can prompts be developed to elicit student metacognition in a lab course which result in a gain in metacognitive awareness and an increase in classroom.
2007 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Longman Publishers Chapter 1: Developing Your Efficiency and Flexibility Efficient and Flexible Reading, 8/e.
© 2005 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Longman Publishers Chapter 1: Developing Your Efficiency and Flexibility Efficient and Flexible Reading, 7/e.
Navigating the Language of Math: Using Active Reading Strategies
Effective Grading and Assessment:. Strategies to Enhance Student Learning.
Chapter 8: Digital Diagrams Section III: Using Visual Learning Tools to Enhance Learning.
Test Preparation Strategies
The Impact of a Faculty Learning Community Approach on Pre-Service Teachers’ English Learner Pedagogy Michael P. Alfano, John Zack, Mary E. Yakimowski,
Fall Conference - Keynote Speaker Sunday, September 25 th, 2011 – Don Shalvey from the Gates Foundation 3 Ambitious Goals of the Gates Foundation 1.80%
General Considerations for Implementation
A Conversation Across the Disciplines to Integrate Literacy into Middle & Secondary Classrooms Drs. Pixita del Hill Prado, Ellen Friedland, & Jevon Hunter.
MELROSE PUBLIC SCHOOLS MELROSE VETERANS MEMORIAL MIDDLE SCHOOL OCTOBER 2013 MCAS Spring 2013 Results.
GE SLO Assessment Guide. Best Practices In the best practices for assessing GE SLOs, there are two dominant modes being used: – Common assessments – Common.
Contributions of Contextual Teaching to Improved Student Learning Richard L. Lynch, PI University of Georgia (706)
Instruction aligned to Iowa Core: What does it look like? #CCSS.
Out with the Old, In with the New: NYS Assessments “Primer” Basics to Keep in Mind & Strategies to Enhance Student Achievement Maria Fallacaro, MORIC
Section 2 Systems of Professional Learning Module 2 Grades K-5: Focus on Content Standards.
Learning Law Orientation: August 16, Synthesis Judgment 4. Problem Solving 3. Spotting Issues 2. Understanding 1. Knowledge 1. Recognition vs.
Learning within Teaching What professors can learn about their students and themselves as teachers when they innovate in their teaching ANABELLA MARTINEZ,
An Orientation of the Surveys of the Enacted Curriculum Ohio ELL Project Carolyn Karatzas Technical Assistance Provider SEC ELL Grant.
Joseph L. Zawicki 1, Kathleen Falconer 2 and Dan MacIsaac 3 1 Department of Earth Sciences and Science Education, Buffalo State College, Buffalo, New York.
1. Principles Equity Curriculum Teaching 3 Assessment Technology Principles The principles describe particular features of high-quality mathematics programs.
INVESTIGATIVE SCIENCE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT (ISLE) Eugenia Etkina Alan Van Heuvelen Rutgers University Moscow, Idaho, April 1st, 2011
LAS LINKS DATA ANALYSIS. Objectives 1.Analyze the 4 sub-tests in order to understand which academic skills are being tested. 2.Use sample tests to practice.
Ensuring that Professional Development Leads to Improved Mathematics Teaching & Learning Kristen Malzahn Horizon Research, Inc. TDG Leadership Seminar.
Got Citizenship? September 12, 2013 Common Core: Close Reading.
Content Area Reading Nakia Gardner Grand Canyon University RDG 583 The Role of Reading in Content Area Classrooms November 4, 2009.
How to Read a Text book Or How to get the most out of a text book.
© 2007 Pearson Prentice Hall This work is protected by United States copyright laws and is provided solely for the use of instructors in teaching their.
Student Preferences For Learning College Algebra in a Web Enhanced Environment Dr. Laura J. Pyzdrowski, Pre-Collegiate Mathematics Coordinator Institute.
Module 3.2.  Learn the differences between kinds of textbooks  Learn ways to help students focus their reading and manage multiple or very large reading.
Copyright © 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Lecture Outline Chapter 5 Physics, 4 th Edition James S. Walker.
IRIS CENTER Learning Outcomes for IRIS Online Modules Used in College Courses Project # H325F OSEP Project Directors’ Conference Washington, DC July.
Teaching Academic Vocabulary Focus on: Activities 10/29/2015.
An overview for parents and families Butler Avenue School Julie Gillispie--March st Century Community Learning Center.
National Science Education Standards. Outline what students need to know, understand, and be able to do to be scientifically literate at different grade.
TfR Seminar: Session 4 Mathematics in Science. Do Now! Do Now! (3 min) Take out all session 4 Handouts, please! Select Handouts 3.17 and 3.18: Strategy.
#1 Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them How would you describe the problem in your own words? How would you describe what you are trying.
DAY 8 FEB. 17 Reading 091. SQ5R Study Method A good overview (also see handout):  Survey  Question 
Goals and Objectives  Why Use Questioning Strategies?  Effective Questioning Techniques  Levels of Questioning…Increasing Understanding, Models for.
Understanding the Common Core Standards Adopted by Nevada in 2010 Our State. Our Students. Our Success.
Instructional Practice Guide: Coaching Tool Making the Shifts in Classroom Instruction Ignite 2015 San Diego, CA February 20, 2015 Sandra
Section 1 Systems of Professional Learning Module 3 Grades 6–12: Focus on Teaching and Learning.
ECE 353 Week 5 Final Paper To purchase this material click below link For more classes.
How do brain studies and cognitive science help us create an active learning environment? Eugenia Etkina Rutgers University,
Unit 3 The National English Curriculum
IES Recommendations Explicit vocabulary instruction
Thinking and Writing Like a Scientist: Claims Evidence Reasoning - CER
Common Core State Standards and Disciplinary Literacy
EDU 675Competitive Success/snaptutorial.com
EDU 675 Education for Service-- snaptutorial.com
EDU 675 Teaching Effectively-- snaptutorial.com
Thinking and Writing Like a Scientist: Claims Evidence Reasoning - CER
Critical Reading Charting the Text.
Performance Task Overview
CLAIM EVIDENCE REASONING
Yes! You Can Teach Social Studies through Literacy
STAAR: What do we notice?
Making Progress in Multiplication
Creating and Developing My Professional Development Quest Portfolio
EPAS Educational Planning and Assessment System By: Cindy Beals
Third Grade FSA Parent Meeting
Presentation transcript:

Robert Zisk, Elana Resnick, Eugenia Etkina Rutgers University Students have difficulties comprehending science texts. The interrogation method, which prompts students to read sentences from the text and answer, “Why is this true?” has been developed to enhance students’ ability to read and comprehend science texts. To enact this method, instructors must choose sentences that are both important conceptually and can be interrogated. However not every sentence in a textbook is important or can be interrogated. Can instructors choose the sentences productively? To answer this question, we analyzed the sentences that the teaching assistants (pre-service teachers), learning assistants (undergraduates who took the course last year), and the course coordinator chose for interrogation in the course where this reading comprehension method was used. We analyzed the conceptual importance of the sentences and their interrogatability, as well as their underlying epistemologies. Based on analysis of the chosen sentences, we developed a model for choosing productive sentences to interrogate. Why is this sentence true? Helping students read the textbook Choosing highly interrogatable sentences requires an in depth knowledge of the textbook and the subject matter. When choosing an interrogatable sentence the instructor must be aware of all of the epistemologies the students may implement in order to respond to the sentence. While all the groups frequently chose sentences that allowed for reasoning through multiple representations to respond, there were very few instances of reasoning through evidence. Opportunities for the future: Analyze student responses to the sentences to further enhance the model of choosing sentences to interrogate. Develop training to enhance instructors’ abilities to choose productive sentences to interrogate. Implications for Instruction Results The sentences chosen by the instructor, TA’s and LA’s most frequently required students to reason through authority or the use of multiple representations. Among the highly interrogatable sentences, most could be responded to using multiple representations. However, very few could be answered using reasoning through evidence. The groups differed significantly on interrogatability but not on importance. The instructor’s sentences were significantly more interrogatable than sentences chosen by the TA’s and LA’s. Comparing Interrogatability and Importance Epistemologies Coding Scheme To enact the interrogation method properly, chosen sentences should be: - Important Conceptually - Deeply interrogatable (how much additional information one can provide explaining why this sentence is true) - Force students to use productive forms of reasoning -Reasoning with multiple representations -Reasoning through evidence Productive Sentences Epistemological Ideas Comparing Interrogatability and Importance When the elevator is at rest or moving at a constant speed the scale reading is the same as the magnitude of the force that the Earth exerts on you. Model Sentence References 1.N. Podolefsky, and N. Finkelstein. “The perceived value of college textbooks: Instructors and students may not see eye to eye.” TPT. 44(6) (2006). 2.J.P. Gee. “Language in the science classroom: Academic social languages as the heart of school-based literacy.” In: E.W. Saul (Ed.), Crossing borders in literacy and science instruction: Perspectives on theory and practice (pp. 383 – 394). Newark, DE: International Reading Association and Arlington, VA: National Science Teachers Association (2004). 3.B. Smith, W. Holliday, and H. Austin. “Student’s comprehension of science textbooks using a question- based reading strategy.” JRST, 47(4), (2009). 4.A. Van Heuvelen. “Learning to think like a physicist: A review of research based instructional strategies.” AJP, 59(10), (1991). 5.D. May,& E. Etkina. “College physics students’ epistemological self-reflection and its relationship to conceptual learning.” AJP, 70 (12), (2002). 6.E. Etkina, M. Gentile, and A. Van Heuvelen. Physics, the process approach. Pearson. Trial edition (2012). -Introductory Physics for non-physics science majors. -Instructors: -Teaching Assistants (TA’s): pre- service physics teachers -Learning Assistants (LA’s) : Undergraduates who have previously taken the course -Course Coordinator: Full time instructor in the Physics Department Course Textbook Used in Course Highly Interrogatable Sentences Epistemology Totals Physics: A Process Approach E. Etkina, M. Gentile, A. Van Heuvelen Pearson, 2012 Sentence 1: The line shown on a kinematics graph is not a picture of the actual path that the object takes as it moves. Sentence 2: These two forces are exerted on the same object and are of different types, so they cannot be a Newton’s third law pair of forces. Example Sentences Codes for Sentences Reasoning through evidence The students can observe this experiment being performed. Math Students can use a mathematical equation. Multiple Representations Student can use motion diagrams and force diagrams in order to answer the question. High interrogatability This sentence requires the use of high levels of cognitive processes in order to completely answer the question. High importance This sentence represents several conceptually important ideas in physics: system choice, Newton’s three laws, motion diagrams, and force diagrams. Corresponding Codes Epistemological Value Interrogatability/ Importance InterrogatabilityCode None0 Low1 High2 ImportanceCode None0 Low1 High2 GroupLATA Course Coordinator Interrogatability Importance Source of VariationSSdfMSFP Between Groups Within Group Total ContrastsValueTP Course Coordinator vs. TA and LA Source of VariationSSdfMSFP Between Groups Within Group Total EpistemologyCode Reasoning through EvidenceRE MathM AuthorityA Reasoning with Multiple RepresentationsMR SkillS Sentence 1Sentence 2 Importance22 Interrogatability20 EpisemologiesA, MR, SA -Only 37 percent of students self report that they regularly complete their assigned reading -The lack of thorough reading limits students’ mastery of new science topics -Reading and learning from science texts is a critical component of learning and success after college -Professionals who regularly read science texts tend to be higher achievers compared to those who report reading less. Motivation - Each week, the TA’s and LA’s were asked to read the textbook chapter assigned to the students. -They were then presented with the following prompt: -“As you read the textbook be on the lookout for sentences that would be interesting to ask ‘why is this sentence true?’ As you come across these sentences fill them in below (do at least 2). Also include the section, page, and paragraph where each sentence is located. Choose sentences from sections that have the fewest sentences already chosen so there is even coverage throughout the chapter.” Data Collection -Developed to enhance students’ ability to read textbooks. -Students read a sentence from the text and answer “Why is this sentence true?” -Instructors need to be able to choose productive sentences to interrogate - What type of sentences do instructors choose for students to interrogate? Interrogation Method Summary of mean interrogatability and importance ratings ANOVA table for interrogatablilty ANOVA table for importance Contrast comparing assistants with course coordinator for interrogatability