Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone. Harlem Children’s Zone Started by Geoffrey Canada in a 97 block area of Harlem in NYC. Combines high energy “no excuses”

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations

Advertisements

Six Year Plan Meeting the state targets Region Meeting August 16, 2007.
Education and Policy aimed at Early Childhood. Education and Early Childhood Policy We have seen throughout this class that poverty and racial inequality.
Types of Early Childhood Programs
Effective Practices for Preventing and Addressing Young Children’s Challenging Behaviors Mary Louise Hemmeter, Ph.D.: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.
1 ADVOCACYDENVER Special Education 101 Pamela Bisceglia Advocate for Children and Inclusive Policy Implementation August 31, 2011.
What the Supporters of SB 71 Are Saying. What’s Really Happening With Increased Early Childhood Ed …
Extended Services – ‘Myth Buster’  ES distract a school from its core business of teaching and learning  There is no funding – who’s going to pay for.
What do we know about effective preschool programs? Steve Barnett, PhD.
Successes Systems level –Synergy between Sprockets, Mayor, U of M, Generation Next (STRIVE), MDE (21 st CCLC), Beacons has created.
How Northern Ireland Can Get Lasting Returns on Preschool Investment: A Tale of Two Studies Larry Schweinhart, Ph.D. President, HighScope Educational Research.
Resources for Special Needs Kids Kathy Bohanon, MD CASA Advocate, Pediatrician.
Embedding the Early Brain & Child Development Framework into Quality Rating and Improvement Systems Meeting Name Presenter Name Date 1.
Building Blocks for Starting School the Right Way Ilene S. Schwartz College of Education
Full Day vs. Half Day Kindergarten Presented by: Sevin Jordan, Brittney Adams, Stephanie Kragness, & Brittany Humphrey.
WARM UP  Write a short response to the following questions: 1. What are the most important elements of taking notes in class? 2. What do we need to know.
CSU Summit on the Preparation of Teachers Irvine, California February 14, 2011 Connecting Teacher and Administrator Preparation with After-School Learning.
NEARLY 50% OF OUR KIDS ENTER KINDERGARTEN ALREADY BEHIND COST: $860 MILLION MINNESOTA’S PROBLEM:
VALUE ADDED DESIGN TEAM Pay For Performance. VA Ideas This power point is to relay ideas that members of the VA design team have developed. No decisions.
Policy Proposal Amy Peterman ADMS 628. Proposal To institute free Pre-kindergarten programs in all public elementary schools for children who are age.
IMPACTS OF A WORK-BASED POVERTY REDUCTION PROGRAM ON CHILDREN’S ACHIEVEMENT AND SOCIAL BEHAVIOR: THE NEW HOPE PROJECT Aletha C. Huston, Greg J. Duncan,
Activities Outcomes – Impact Short Term Medium Term Long Term Problem statement: New York City teen pregnancy rates are higher than the national average,
Culturally Competent Services: Why is Your Leadership Needed?
Building a Brighter Future for Our Kids and Families Multnomah County Department of School and Community Partnerships.
New Jersey Department of Education Division of Early Childhood Education March 3, 2009.
Evaluating Charter Schools. Harlem Children’s Zone Started by Geoffrey Canada in a 97 block area of Harlem in NYC. Combines high energy “no excuses” type.
Potential Preschool Provider Info Session April 2015 – Part 1.
Early Childhood Education The Research Evidence Deborah Lowe Vandell December 11, 2003.
ECEAP 25 years of growing our future!
Leaky Education Pipeline Of every 100 students who enter kindergarten: 71 graduate from high school 42 enter a community college or university 18 receive.
Dr. Tracey Bywater Dr. Judy Hutchings The Incredible Years (IY) Programmes: Programmes for children, teachers & parents were developed by Professor Webster-Stratton,
Unit 2 – Visual and Performing Arts: Key Topic 4 1.
Positive Impacts and Return on Investment: What We Can Learn from Head Start Research Hilary Shager WI Department of Children and Families April 25, 2012.
Education and Policy aimed at Early Childhood. Education and Early Childhood Policy We have seen throughout this class that poverty and racial inequality.
EDUCATION Chapter 7.
1 Pre-Elementary Education Longitudinal Study (PEELS) Elaine Carlson, Westat 2005 OSEP National Early Childhood Conference Washington, DC February 8, 2005.
Obama Administration Prenatal to Five Child Development Commitments Robert H. Dugger Managing Director Tudor Investment Corporation Invest in Kids Working.
More at Four Pre- Kindergarten Program Ready for School.
Agents of Socialization FAMILY –HAS THE GREATEST IMPACT ON SOCIALIZATION –THE FIRST TO TEACH SKILLS, VALUES, & BELIEFS –EVEN TEENS CONTINUE TO PLACE THEIR.
©2015 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. Chapter 19 Planning Transitions to Support Inclusion.
ARRA Update Policy and Fiscal Committee April 4, 2011.
NAZ as a Promise Neighborhood….. Where opportunities rise to meet their promising future! NAZ Family Academy Graduates.
Inclusion and Early Childhood Education. Population of Young Children with Special Needs Birth to age 8 Children with developmental delays Biologically.
1 Early Intervention Graduates Go to Kindergarten: Findings from the National Early Intervention Longitudinal Study (NEILS) Kathleen Hebbeler Donna Spiker.
NEARLY 50% OF OUR KIDS ENTER KINDERGARTEN ALREADY BEHIND COST: $860 MILLION MINNESOTA’S PROBLEM:
New Research and the Pay-Off to Quality Early Care and Education Atlanta, GA September 23, 2013 Steve Barnett, PhD.
Scheduling: Block or Not? Larry Tash Office of School Redesign March 8, 2006 Supporting Increased Student Achievement.
1 Sharing the Aid Awareness Challenge: How to Reach Diverse Groups in Urban and Rural Settings Jane Collins Cissy VanSickle Session 23.
Collaborative Data Teams Growing to Learn & Learning to Grow Eugene Field Elementary Kindergarten-4 th grade Maryville, Missouri.
CT Speech Language Hearing Association March 26, 2010.
Equal Education in Practice!. 2 Kunnskapsdepartementet Aims for this introduction: Background information on immigrant children in Norway, integration.
Continuity and Change in Early Childhood Education Chapter 1.
School for Early Development and Achievement Kim Johnsen SPE 644.
CREATING A WORLD CLASS KINDERGARTEN FINDING EXAMPLES OF EXCELLENCE IN MINNESOTA SCHOOLS.
Family-School Collaboration Lara Pascoe February 10, 2011 Dr. Coleman.
K-12 And Early Childhood Data Connections NCES Forum February 2011 Presented by: Kathy Gosa Kansas State Department of Education.
Archived Information A Comprehensive Strategy for Preventing and Recovering Dropouts Richard Tuck Supervisor of Dropout Prevention/Parent Outreach Guilford.
Chronic Absence in the Early Grades Jane Quinn, Director Abe Fernández, Deputy Director November 8, 2010 | Portland, OR.
East Durham Children’s Initiative Providing a pipeline of services from birth through high school for children and families in East Durham, with support.
Schools as organisations
Photos by Susie Fitzhugh Bell Times Analysis Task Force Child Care and After-School Programs February 26, 2015.
STAFF/CURRICULUM DEVELOPMENT NETWORK (S/CDN) September 14, 2006 Albany Marriott Hotel Presented by: Jean C. Stevens Interim Deputy Commissioner New York.
ABC ______________________ are the simplest forms of direct observation. a. Anecdotal records b. Checklists c. Rating scales.
The Effects of High Quality Early Childhood Education.
How High Schools Explain Students’ Initial Colleges and Majors
Travis Wright, Ed.D April 26, 2018
Types of Early Childhood Programs
Supportive Leadership in Small Learning Communities
Inequality Starts Before Kindergarten
Snowshoe Elementary School $109,762
Presentation transcript:

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone

Harlem Children’s Zone Started by Geoffrey Canada in a 97 block area of Harlem in NYC. Combines high energy “no excuses” type charter schools (Promise Academy) with a web of other community services. 1,300 students attend “Promise Academy” schools, community programs served 8,058 kids and 5,291 adults. Meant to support children from “birth to college.”

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone Schools Extended school day and school year. Saturday school for students needing extra help. Overall, roughly twice as many hours as other comparable students around city. High quality teachers and use “value” added pay incentives. High turnover, but lots of support and feedback. Schools provide medical, dental, mental health services, meals, incentives for achievement. Notably, they aim to provide a “culture of achievement” with no excuses. Widely stated goal (outside and inside of schools) is to send every student to college.

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone Community Programs Baby college early childhood programs, After-school programs (e.g. karate, dance, etc) Family health programs Over 20 programs available to members of the community.

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone Questions of interest: 1. How much do kids benefit from this program relative to other alternatives in the area? 2. Is it the schooling or community services or both that provide benefit? What strategies do Dobbie and Fryer use to try to “identify” the impact of HCZ?

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone Lottery Too many applicants for spaces in schools, so there is a lottery to determine who gets offered a slot. Empirical design is essentially to compare lottery winners to lottery losers in terms of standardized test scores.

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone

Cohort and Zone Boundaries (Instrumental Variable or IV) Due to timing of when the programs were started, only some aged kids had access (i.e., had to be entering sixth grade or kindergarten the year the school was opened, those entering those grades the year before weren’t eligible) While all kids in eligible cohorts can apply for lottery to attend schools, only those within the HCZ were actively recruited. Argument is that this made those kids in HCZ more likely to enroll relative to otherwise similar kids outside of HCZ.

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone So basic design is a diff-in-diff. Compare test score outcomes of eligible cohorts to non-eligible cohorts within boundary, difference out how these two groups compare just outside of boundary. Estimated impact = (TS E,In - TS NE,In ) - (TS E,Out - TS NE,Out ) Via regression? TS = α + β 1 EligibleCohort + β 2 InHCZ + β 3 EligibleCohort*InHCZ Key Assumptions?

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone

Is it the school or the “other” services? How can they try to identify one from the other?

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone IV results If it was the “other” community services, then cohort/zone IV shouldn’t have shown anything. That method only produces an “effect” if treated cohort outperforms untreated cohort within HCZ by more than treated cohort outperforms untreated cohort outside HCZ. Since both treated and untreated cohorts in HCZ are eligible for other services, the estimated effects must be coming primarily from schools.

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone Estimate the effect of having a “sibling” in one of the academies for those who aren’t enrolled in one of the academies. Idea: Siblings of those enrolled in one of the academies should have similar access to “other” community programs, so if it is those programs that primarily impact kids’ outcomes, siblings of those enrolled should do better than siblings of those not enrolled.

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone Why is Promise Academy so effective at educating the poorest minority students? Teacher quality? Extremely high turnover (48% left after first year) Curriculum Seem to focus on what has shown to be effective (210 instruction days per year, 8 hour instructional days, Saturday school, after- school program, avg class size of 20, no broken windows discipline policy, administers internal evaluations of teachers, requires school uniforms and a dress code, requires a parental contract, etc.) Money NYC Dept of Ed provides $12,443 per student, HCZ spends and estimated $19,272 per pupil.

Evaluating Harlem Children’s Zone Summary Growing body of evidence seems to suggest that early, often relatively large scale interventions can lead to both short-term and long-term impacts. Questions still remain how to effectively do this at a large level. Things like Perry Preschool and HCZ are very specialized, can they be scaled up? While some evidence that large scale programs like Head Start have impacts, impacts are much more modest. KIPP schools (Knowledge is Power Program) have tried to develop a replicable but flexible platform for effectively educating at-risk kids. A relatively recent paper suggests that at least one of the KIPP schools in the Boston area is having substantial success.