Fiscal Impact Analysis Why Do Fiscal Impact Analysis? □Increasing desire to understand fiscal costs/benefits of development □Residential development typically.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Introduction to Concurrency Management. What is Concurrency? Chapter , F.S. requires Comprehensive Plans to adopt a concurrency management system,
Advertisements

Land Use Controls and Zoning
Smart Growth Update VCARD May 23, Growth Management & Schools during 2005 Volusia County Council adopts new school impact fee. School Board of Volusia.
What is Design?. Engineering design is the communication of a set of rational decisions obtained with creative problem solving for accomplishing certain.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
Presented by: David Crowe – Chief Economist October 25, 2013 Lee County, Florida Home Building Impact in Lee County, Florida.
Center for Land Use Education Understanding the Cost of Community Services Rebecca Roberts Center for Land Use Education.
Materi 2 (Chapter 2) ntroduction to Quantitative Analysis
Multi-Modal Concurrency PSRC TRAC-UW Depart of Urban Design and Planning Evans School.
Lec 21, Project Evaluation Part 1: Impact analysis General characteristics of benefits and costs Estimates of economic costs and benefits A framework for.
Lec 26: Ch3.(T&LD): Traffic Analysis – Trip generation
Technical Question Technical Question
The Effects of Different Land Uses in Missouri on Local Fiscal Conditions – Cost of Community Services Project Update – 4/12/02.
Economic Analysis in Transportation Systems Tapan K. Datta, Ph.D, P.E. CE 7640: Fall 2002.
1 Enviromatics Decision support systems Decision support systems Вонр. проф. д-р Александар Маркоски Технички факултет – Битола 2008 год.
Green Building and Sustainable Architecture
Taking a Square Root to Solve an Equation. Solve: In order to solve for x, you have to UNDO the squared first (i.e. square root) What are the number(s)
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Chapter 19 Residential Real Estate Finance: Mortgage Choices, Pricing.
David Crowe Chief Economist November 13, 2013 Home Building Impact.
© OnCourse Learning Chapter 27 : Investing in Real Estate.
1. 2 VIA Long Range Plan  Vision for High-Capacity Transit across VIA service area by 2035  From extensive public and stakeholder input  Prioritization.
October 4, 2004 Detrich B. Allen City of Los Angeles Environmental Affairs Department 1 Siting New Development Detrich B. Allen General Manager Environmental.
SB 360 and Multi-Modal Impact Fees & Efficiently Managing a Street Lightning System.
Role and Components of Project Evaluation
Reduction and Deferral of Impact Fees Board of County Commissioners Discussion Item March 29, 2011.
Determining Sample Size
Intersection & Interchange Geometrics (IIG) Innovative Design Considerations for All Users Module 8 Intersection- Interchange Evaluation Process.
2014 Budget Department Presentations Infrastructure Funding Options.
Community Development Department GRAND HAVEN DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL IMPACT City Council June 3, 2014.
Navigating SB 375: CEQA Streamlining and SB 743 Transportation Analysis 2014 San Joaquin Valley Fall Policy Conference.
Introduction to revenue, cost and profit terms Variable and fixed costs, cost-volume-profit analysis Pia Nylinder
Introduction to Cost-Benefit Analysis: Using Market Prices
Land Administration in Africa Searching for Land Tenure Security May 22 to 25, 2006 Alternatives to Titling Geoffrey K. Payne Principal Geofftrey Payne.
//plug-in ready michigan //powerpoint// made possible through the generous support of the U.S. Department of Energy plug-in ready michigan an electric.
SPRAWL & GROWTH MANAGEMENT. TOPICS Historical Overview Land use tools & techniques Economics of GM: Benefits & Costs Growth Management (GM) process How.
LAND USE, PLANNING, ZONING, AND ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS
An Online Knowledge Base for Sustainable Military Facilities & Infrastructure Dr. Annie R. Pearce, Branch Head Sustainable Facilities & Infrastructure.
The concept of human dimensions The name of this course is “Human Dimensions of Natural Resources”. What does it mean? What exactly are the human dimensions?
Growth Management Legislative Discussion March 20, 2012.
St. Johns County Association Roundtable June 8, 2015 Jesse Dunn Assistant Director OMB St. Johns County BCC Fiscal Year 2016: Separate Challenges Looking.
Client Name Here - In Title Master Slide Data Requirements to Support Road Pricing Analyses Johanna Zmud, Ph.D. NuStats Partners, LP Expert Forum on Road.
Planning and Community Development Department Housing Element City Council February 03, 2014.
Selecting priorities for MNCH Prioritizing activities of identified problems or challenges.
Yed PROJECTED FISCAL IMPACTS OF THE PROPOSED REDEVELOPMENT OF THE HONEYWELL MORRIS TOWNSHIP HEADQUARTERS CAMPUS Prepared by Biggins Lacy Shapiro & Company.
Community Development Department GRAND HAVEN DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL IMPACT Planning & Land Development Regulation Board May 21, 2014.
Clark County Comprehensive Plan: Unique Opportunities and Resolutions. Land Use in Southwestern Washington Law Seminars International Vancouver Hilton.
IAEA International Atomic Energy Agency Summary and Overview of TECDOC Russel Edge Decommissioning and Remediation Unit Division of Radiation,Transport.
Blueprint for Good Growth Adequate Public Facilities Implementation Capacity LOS Capital Plan Demand Unintended consequence slides adapted from presentation.
Impact Fee Updates Board of County Commissioners Public Hearings October 30, 2012.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT FY Budget Worksession July 17, 2007.
Growth Management Legislative Discussion: Transportation Concurrency April 24, 2012 Growth Management Legislative Discussion: Transportation Concurrency.
Housing Element Update City of Coachella Planning Commission Hearing September 4, 2013.
Community Development Department COUNTRY CLUB HARBOR SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL-2 AND PARKS & GREENWAYS ZONING DISTRICTS REZONING APPLICATION #2511.
Road Impact Fee Update Discussion Item June 21, 2011 Transportation Impact Fee Update Discussion Item June 21, 2011.
LCAs and policymaking: The good, the bad, and the ugly Dr Michael Warhurst, Friends of the Earth.
Engineering design is the process of devising a system, component, or process to meet desired needs. It is a decision-making process (often iterative),
Durham Villas Planned Unit Development TSM & REZ Morris Bud Keeney Butte County Board of Supervisors December 11, 2012.
Planning Commission Study Session: Preferred Plan July 23, 2015.
Green Building and Sustainable Architecture
“State Road 100 MPC Lots” Comprehensive Plan Amendment & Rezoning City Council Public Hearing November 17, 2015.
Water Week 2011 Challenges of Urbanization for Water and Sanitation Infrastructure The Cost Effects of a Lack of Spatial Planning The World Bank 1.
Placer County Housing Element Update Stakeholder/Community Workshop #2 – Auburn | April 10, Stakeholder/Community Workshop #2 Auburn Placer County.
1 Copyright © 2001 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin CHAPTER 9 DETERMINING LAND USE Real Estate Markets: –allocate.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN UPDATE MEETING 1 – ANNEXATION, PLANNING AREA, AND DENSITIES 11/07/2013.
Fiscal Impact Analysis – City of Norwalk, Connecticut October 5, 2006 Prepared by:RKG Associates, Inc. Economic, Planning and Real Estate Consultants 277.
CE 360Dr SaMeH1 Environmental Eng. 1 (CE 360) Associate Professor of Environmental Eng. Civil Engineering Department Engineering College Majma’ah University.
Jefferson County Planning Commissioners Hearing June 26, 2013 Case No SV Foothills Metropolitan District Service Plan Case Manager: Russell D.
Jefferson County Planning Commissioners Hearing June 26, 2013
Planning Commission Impact fees Planning Commission
Guidance for 2017* Q3 2017: Financial net: around -200 million
Presentation transcript:

Fiscal Impact Analysis Why Do Fiscal Impact Analysis? □Increasing desire to understand fiscal costs/benefits of development □Residential development typically represents a net fiscal loss □Costs more in services than it generates in property taxes □Burden for school systems in particular □Suburban development not always considered desirable □Featureless □Not walkable □Wasteful of infrastructure (i.e., expensive) □Therefore, a push is on to quantify fiscal costs of development

Fiscal Impact Analysis What Fiscal Impact Analysis Involves □A model (an algorithm or system of mathematical equations) approximating how the real fiscal world works □Assumptions on how the real fiscal world works (which may or may not be correct) □A variety of fiscal impact methodologies exist □Some will be more relevant to your community’s situation than others □Some will deliberately skew the results to fit a particular viewpoint □Adopt a method that your community is comfortable with in knowing that it represents a realistic approximation of your fiscal situation

Fiscal Impact Analysis Now That You Have A Fiscal Impact Methodology, What Do You Do With It? □Establish criteria for when a fiscal study is required □Require the study for all projects meeting the criteria □Report results to the plan commission □Plan commission incorporates results with other considerations into its decision-making process

Fiscal Impact Analysis It’s Not That Simple: Plan Commission □What’s an acceptable result? □Net neutral result □Net negative result □Barely negative or positive result □Negative components within a net positive result □How much weight to you give the results? □Compared to comp. plan recommendations □Compared to traffic and drainage studies □Compared to any other factor the PC considers important

Fiscal Impact Analysis It’s Not That Simple: Remonstrators □Lose site of big picture: use technical quibbles with methodology to oppose projects □Fiscal effect on schools □Sole variable evaluated □Oppose or approve projects solely on fiscal performance □No-growth strategy may result by default

Fiscal Impact Analysis It’s Not That Simple: Developers □Develop to the fiscal study □Manipulate development variables to get acceptable results □Mixed use proposals don’t pan out □Housing cost points not enforceable

Fiscal Impact Analysis Unintended Consequences □Residential development □Not necessarily supposed to pay its own way □Moderately priced housing may lose out □Over-emphasis on fiscal costs exclude other characteristics of residential development □Mixed use proposals don’t pan out □Housing cost points not enforceable □Community’s fiscal health becomes one-dimensional □Use of fiscal studies to stop development □Emphasis on housing price points □Developing to the fiscal study

Fiscal Impact Analysis Solving The Problems Fiscal Studies Reveal: Limiting The Costs □Direct solution □Limit building permits □Building moratorium □Discourage low cost housing □Indirect solution: phasing growth □Urban service areas □Adequate public facilities ordinances (concurrency)

Fiscal Impact Analysis Solving The Problems Fiscal Studies Reveal: Paying The Costs □Impact fees