David Dowdy, Elvin Geng, Katerina Christopoulos, James Kahn, C. Bradley Hare, Daniel Wlodarczyk, Diane Havlir Internal Medicine Residency Program, UCSF Positive Health Program, San Francisco General Hospital
ART has shifted the spectrum of HIV-related mortality in the developed world. – <50% of deaths in ART-treated patients are AIDS- related. (ART-CC, Clin Infect Dis 2010, 50:1387) Socially-disadvantaged patients die more often, and of AIDS. New York AIDS registry: (Sackoff JE, Ann Int Med 2006,145:397) – 74% of deaths AIDS-related – Mortality 1.6 times higher in IDU Is excess, AIDS-related mortality seen in such patients who have linked to care? – Is this story changing over time?
To characterize mortality among HIV-infected patients eligible for ART and linked to care at an urban public hospital ◦ Has mortality decreased in the last decade? ◦ Focus on 5 disadvantaged sub-populations: Injection drug use Alcohol abuse Mental health diagnosis Non-white race Female/transgender
Design: Cohort study Setting: Urban safety-net HIV clinic San Francisco, California, USA Patients among the poorest in the city Patients: All patients linked to care & eligible for ART – ≥2 primary care visits – CD4 nadir ≤350 cells/mm 3 – Jan through Aug – N = 1651
Measurements: At study entry: CD4/VL, HIV risk factors, prior ART Mortality: chart review & death index Analyses: Cox proportional hazards with delayed entries Primary comparison: mortality in vs /1/05: midpoint of study period & decade Secondary analyses: Disadvantaged subpopulations Causes of death, viral suppression
VariableValue Age (years)49 (43-56) Male Gender1432 (87%) White Race779 (47%) HIV Risk Factor Men having Sex with Men (MSM) Injection Drug Use (IDU) Heterosexual Sex 981 (59%) 408 (25%) 419 (25%) CD4 at Eligibility (cells/mm 3 )205 (78-289) Exposed to ART before Eligibility672 (41%) Mental Health Diagnosis (in chart)664 (40%)
ART-CC
Causes of Death
Disadvantaged Subgroups Had Higher Mortality in Subpopulation HR for mortality: vs HR (95% CI) p Female/Transgender1.73 ( ) 0.41 Injection Drug Use4.15 ( ) Non-White Race1.70 ( ) 0.12 Alcohol Abuse6.62 ( ) 0.07 Mental Health Diagnosis2.68 ( ) 0.12 Adjusted for age, initial CD4 count, baseline HIV viral load, HCV, and prior ART exposure
Mortality in Injection Drug Users
Unknown 19 (31%) Not AIDS 17 (28%)
Viral Suppression at Any Point Deaths (n = 172) Survivors (n = 1479)
Mortality was high & did not improve over time. 10% over 4 years (2.6% per person-year) in % (2.7% per person-year) in Increased among IDU and other disadvantaged groups HIV-related mortality still dominates. Liver, heart, renal + non-AIDS cancer: <10% of deaths Most patients who died never suppressed their viral loads.
In developed countries, wide disparities in mortality still exist among PLWHA. ◦ High mortality in socially-disadvantaged populations despite linkage to highest-quality care ◦ Parallel research needed on “old” & “new” HIV epidemics Intensive, multi-dimensional approach needed Future research directions: ◦ Comparing mortality among at-risk HIV-infected patients with non-infected peers ◦ Impact of linkage vs. maintenance of care
Collaborators: ◦ Elvin Geng ◦ Kat Christopoulos ◦ Jim Kahn ◦ Brad Hare ◦ Dan Wlodarczyk ◦ Diane Havlir UCSF Resident Research Program Physicians & Patients of Ward 86
Thank You!