STATEWIDE WORKSHOP ON THE CALIFORNIA MOTOR VEHICLE EMISSIONS STANDARDS INCLUDING GREENHOUSE GASES December 5, 2007 Department of Environmental Regulation Division of Air Resource Management

EXECUTIVE ORDER Establishes Immediate Actions to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions within Florida Establishes Immediate Actions to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions within Florida DEP to develop rules to achieve…… DEP to develop rules to achieve…… Adoption of the California motor vehicle emissions standards in Title 13 of the California Code of Regulations, effective January 1, 2005, upon approval by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency of the pending waiver, which includes emissions standards for greenhouse gases, submitted by the California Air Resources Board. Adoption of the California motor vehicle emissions standards in Title 13 of the California Code of Regulations, effective January 1, 2005, upon approval by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency of the pending waiver, which includes emissions standards for greenhouse gases, submitted by the California Air Resources Board.

Request for Comments August 23 Workshop Implementation Implementation Compliance verification Compliance verification Phase-in schedule Phase-in schedule Costs Costs ZEV Choice ZEV Choice Data Collection Data Collection Projections Projections

Summary of Comments to Date Air Quality/GHG Reductions Air Quality/GHG Reductions Significant environmental benefit Significant environmental benefit Minimal to no environmental benefit Minimal to no environmental benefit Costs Costs Consumers save on fuel costs Consumers save on fuel costs Increase vehicle costs outweigh environmental benefits Increase vehicle costs outweigh environmental benefits ZEV ZEV Manufacture warranty requirements potentially hurt independents Manufacture warranty requirements potentially hurt independents

Request for Comments December 5 Workshop Implementation Implementation ZEV requirement ZEV requirement Opt in/out Opt in/out Warranty/recall Warranty/recall Super warranty Super warranty Recall provisions Recall provisions Phase-in Phase-in Flexibility in scheduling Flexibility in scheduling

Request for Comments (Continued) Implementation (con’t) Implementation (con’t) Compliance certification/verification Compliance certification/verification Exemptions Exemptions Cross border sales Cross border sales Registration Registration First time registration First time registration Previous registration Previous registration Compliance/Enforcement Compliance/Enforcement Deny registration Deny registration Reporting/monitoring requirements for industry for fleet averages Reporting/monitoring requirements for industry for fleet averages Penalties Penalties Coordination Coordination Other state agencies Other state agencies California California Tasks performed by others Tasks performed by others

Request for Comments (Continued) Costs Costs LEV II in Florida LEV II in Florida Pavley in Florida Pavley in Florida Incentives Incentives

Request for Comments (Continued) Background data Background data Fleet mix (auto industry) Fleet mix (auto industry)

Comments Mail comments to: Mail comments to: Ms. Sandy Bowman Division of Air Resource Management Department of Environmental Protection 2600 Blair Stone Road Tallahassee, Florida cc: Ms. Lynn Scearce, Rules Coordinator (same address) or to: All comments are public records and will be posted on the Department’s web site

Distribution List To receive updates on this project by , provide name, affiliation, and address to Ms Lynn Scearce at To receive updates on this project by , provide name, affiliation, and address to Ms Lynn Scearce at