Labor market reform through welfare reform: How not to activate the jobless Prof Ian Greer University of Greenwich (UK), Cornell University (USA)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CICERO FOUNDATION SEMINAR UK labour market policies - a recipe for success? Georgina Hill British Embassy, Paris.
Advertisements

Trade and Employment Challenges for Policy Research A joint study of.
What Do We Know About Continuing Vocational Education, Training and Work? Philip J. OConnell The Economic and Social Research Institute, Dublin Presentation.
GEOGRAPHICAL INCOME DISPARITIES WITHIN COUNTRIES: IS REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT POLICY THE ANSWER? What is regional policy? Is there a convincing case for regional.
Care Provision Presentation to Care Economy Brainstorming Session, World Bank, Washington DC February 25, 2009 Susan Himmelweit, Open University
STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES IN DANISH POLICIES: LESSONS FROM OECD’S MENTAL HEALTH AND WORK REVIEW Christopher PRINZ Employment Policy Division Directorate.
Teleconference 2 1.Guest speakers in May 2.Policy Brief Project The Employer and Health Insurance.
1 Labour market reforms in OECD countries: some lessons Raymond Torres, OECD.
5 th Meeting of the COMCEC Poverty Alleviation Working Group February 26th, 2015, Ankara, Turkey Activation Policies for the Poor: Lessons from OECD Countries.
The Role and Regulation of Interchange Fees in European Payments Cards The Role and Regulation of Interchange Fees in European Payments Cards Wilko Bolt.
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL POLICY AND INTERVENTION May 15, 2015 Who Adjusts? The Economic Crisis and Labour Market Outsiders.
Re-thinking Welfare to Work Steve Fothergill National Director, Industrial Communities Alliance Professor, CRESR, Sheffield Hallam University.
Ten Years of Activation Policies in the UK and Next Steps in Welfare Reform Joanna Kerrison Economy and Labour Market Division UK Department for Work and.
BARRIERS AT LABOR MARKET AND PROPOSALS OF PRIVATE SECTOR FOR THEIR ELIMINATION Slaviša Delić Montenegro Business Alliance Solun, May 27, 2005.
The U. S. Economy: Private and Public Sectors
The Italian System of Continuous On-the-Job Training and the Interprofessional Funds Conference "Financing of Further Professional “ Conference "Financing.
Michael Jacobsen The Danish Confederation of Trade Unions (LO)
Privatization of Placement Services in Light of the TLM Approach Venice, 10 April 2008 Petra Kaps & Holger Schütz Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin für Sozialforschung.
200 pt 300 pt 400 pt 500 pt 100 pt 200 pt 300 pt 400 pt 500 pt 100 pt 200pt 300 pt 400 pt 500 pt 100 pt 200 pt 300 pt 400 pt 500 pt 100 pt 200 pt 300 pt.
Social Welfare Policymaking
Discrimination in the Labour Market. Aims and Objectives Aim: Understand discrimination in the labour market Objectives: Define labour market discrimination.
AUSTRALIAN DEVELOPMENTS IN WELFARE TO WORK Budget
Revisiting Work Opportunity: From Tax Credits to Subsidized Jobs Big Ideas for Job Creation in a Jobless Recovery June 16, 2011 Elizabeth.
Reform Experiences of Asian Pacific Countries: The Case of Canada Linda French A/Director General Labour Market Policy Human Resources and Skills Development.
Economic Systems SSEF4 The student will compare and contrast different economic systems and explain how they answer the three basic economic questions.
Supply Side policies AS Economics.
Starting your financial future.  Empowering People to be Responsible for Themselves and The World.
The Possibility of Government Failure
Welcome! Sustainable Employment Through Skills JHP Group Jim Chambers, Chief Executive.
Stakeholder Objectives
Flexibility, Job Creation and Globalization: The Case of Italy James J. Heckman University of Chicago December 2002.
Characteristics of Market Economy
Unemployment AS economics presentation on the measurement and causes of unemployment.
How can local initiatives help workless people find and keep paid work? Pamela Meadows Synergy Research and Consulting Ltd and National Institute of Economic.
LSE seminar: London in recession The Recession – London’s experience and some policy implications Duncan Melville, Senior Associate 27 May 2009.
Ideologies of subsidised public works Roundtable "Subsidised jobs in Europe - ideology, legislation and practice" Tallinn City and UBC Commission on Business.
Workfare and Flexicurity – The Danish Case Torben M. Andersen Aarhus University CEPR, CESifo and IZA.
Function of Financial Management and Financial Accounting in the Health and Fitness Sector.
The Free Enterprise System
The Private Sector and Building Effective Demand for Corporate Governance Caribbean Corporate Governance Forum September g.
Matthew 10/07/13 Parking the hardest to help: short and long-term solutions.
IADB Dealing with risk: Implementing employment policies under fiscal constraints Milan, March 23, 2003 What went on in Latin America Labor Markets? Comments.
Chapter 18.  Give examples of the processes used by individuals, political parties, interest groups, or the media to affect public policy.  Describe.
© 2010 McGraw Hill Ryerson 7-1 COMPENSATION Third Canadian Edition Milkovich, Newman, Cole.
The 3 rd Younger Members Convention Matthew Farraker - Aon Consulting Do We Need Actuaries In A DC World?
Macroeconomics 2.6 Supply-side policies (market-based)
The Work Programme Aims of the Workshop: To provide a general overview of the Work Programme, what it sets out to achieve and who will be responsible for.
Partnership in social innovation: capacity for building and managing synergies between Public and Private partners, ESI Funds, and other EU instruments.
Active Labor Market Programs: Potential and Limitations for Breaking the Dependency Cycle in Central and Eastern Europe Michal Rutkowski Sector Manager,
It’s not all about the Work Programme…is it? Tracy Fishwick, Director.
The important issue is: What determines the “natural rate” - this is what policymakers are concerned about! ŸTo analyze this look at more elaborate.
Starting your financial future.  Empowering People to be Responsible for Themselves and The World.
The Province of Milan …is one of the 12 provinces in the region of Lombardy …is a local government authority representing 134 towns and municipalities,
EC15: Social Enterprise 1. Definitions Marcus Thompson University of Stirling.
1 How do Asia/Pacific countries compare? Raymond Torres, OECD.
Social Welfare Policymaking
IGCSE®/O Level Economics
Europe Youth Unemployment Portugal Youth Unemployment.
Overview of Social Security (Benefit Categories and Work Focus) Amendment Bill.
Activation as a stepping stone to participation ? Ides Nicaise, HIVA / Dept. Ed. Sc. (KU Leuven)
SUPPLY SIDE POLICIES YOUSIF AL ZAROUNI. WHAT ARE SUPPLY SIDE POLICIES? Supply side policies are policies designed to improve the supply side potential.
The State of the Labour Market and Long-term Worklessness Dave Simmonds & Paul Bivand Centre for Economic & Social Inclusion.
A2 External Influences Government policies affecting business.
Policy into practice Public Private Partnerships – how smart procurement can deliver better employment and social inclusion Greg Ashmead Managing Director.
Growth: What is it good for? Steven Tobin ILO Research Department.
Employer / Employee Relations. Content Employee / Employer relations Different approaches to employee relations: Collective bargaining Individual bargaining.
“Long-term care in the EU – Models of financing, eligibility criteria, assessment of needs and service providing” Workshop on Long-term Care Nov.
Promoting social cohesion in Korea. Social spending is low but increasing rapidly Rising income inequality and relative poverty and the factors behind.
3.5.1 and unit content Students should be able to:
Government Policies and Actions
Presentation transcript:

Labor market reform through welfare reform: How not to activate the jobless Prof Ian Greer University of Greenwich (UK), Cornell University (USA)

Punitive active labor market policies The principle – Cut back welfare entitlements. – Increase labor market participation. The policy recipe – Demand that jobless people on welfare benefits look for work and accept any job. – Provide training, advice, and job-placement services to support them. – Demand that they participate in those services. – Take away benefits from non-compliant clients. – Extend this to so-called ‘inactive’ people, e.g. disabled people and lone parents. – Use performance management and market mechanisms to deal with non-compliant front-line workers. – And don’t spend too much money. In effect: more flexibility, less security.

Do they work? Card, Kluwe, and Weber (2010): ‘Few studies include enough information to make even a crude assessment of the benefits of the programme relative to its costs’ (476). Schmid (2008): ‘The fact is that many evaluation studies come to dissatisfying results... the role of ALMP in containing unemployment is modest’ (248).

Employers and claimants

A recipe for precarity? Marx: When “adverse circumstances prevent the creation of an industrial reserve army and, with it, the absolute dependence of the working class upon the capitalist class, capital... rebels against the ‘sacred’ law of supply and demand, and tries to check its inconvenient action by forcible means and State interference” (Capital v 1 ch 23). OECD 1994: “And higher public spending on active measures may lead to wage moderation by strengthening the ability of ‘outsiders’, particularly the long-term unemployed and first-time job-seekers, to compete more effectively for jobs” (Jobs study). OECD 2012: “Eligibility criteria for unemployment benefits, which require recipients to actively look for work, take up suitable job offers or take part in active labour market programmes (ALMPs), or risk benefit sanctions, can play an important role in offsetting the negative impact of generous unemployment benefits on employment incentives” (Venn paper).

Administrative failures Bureaucracy: market openness vs low costs Race to the bottom: cost vs quality Creaming and parking effects: payment by results vs equal access to services Compulsion vs customer choice Destruction of capacity: threat to nonprofit and public sectors vs open market There are no easy solutions to these dilemmas

A worst practice – Britain’s Work Programme ‘Black-box’ contracting – weak state control – payment by results. – Create incentives for private firms to invest and innovate Inexpensive due to low numbers of job placements Control and profiteering by large private firms – A4e, paid its largest shareholder more than 10m euros in the first year of the scheme. – Ingeus owners received a windfall of 150m pounds when it was purchased by an American competitor. Poor performance for clients furthest from the labor market, with strong creaming and parking effects

A less bad practice – French ‘insertion’ Funding from ESF, but local control – Strong nonprofits – Strong and autonomous professionals – Complex network of public agencies Anti-workfarist consensus among the actors – pay for performance does not work, – what does work is detailed intervention, subsidized jobs, strong investment in skills is seen as necessary, Highly bureaucratic, but weak performance management Low degree of marketization

In conclusion: Be skeptical of international ‘good practices’. How do they ‘work’ in their country of origin? What are the perverse consequences not mentioned in mainstream policy discourse? Use professional common sense: Any policy that sounds too good to be true probably is…