Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration Analysis of HOS Rules briefing to the Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee December 7, 2009 Mark Johnson,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
NEW HOURS-OF-SERVICE REGULATIONS Effective October 1, 2005.
Advertisements

Safety Data Analysis Tools Workshop Michael S. Griffith, Director FMCSA Office of Research and Analysis TRB Transportation Safety Planning Working Group.
NYSE: CGI KeyBanc Capital Markets Industrial, Automotive, and Transportation Conference June 2, 2011.
Industry Benchmarks How do you measure up?. Driver Qualification Standards For years insurance companies have been tightening up their driver MVR standards.
Interstate Passenger Carriers Registration & Safety Regulations.
Gary Nichols Director of International Sales US Xpress, Inc. September 16, 2010.
HOW TO MANAGE THE “REGULATORY TSUNAMI” A Logistics Management Webcast with John Cutler, NASSTRAC General Counsel, Candace Holowicki, Director of Global.
Managing Safety and Health, Overview Ron Hopkins, CFPS, CFEI TRACE Fire Protection and Safety Consultants. Ltd. Richmond, Kentucky.
Office of Research and Information Technology Flexible Sleeper Berth Pilot Program October 27, 2014 Martin R. Walker, Chief Research Division.
SAFETY & QUALITY MANAGEMENT IMPROVE SAFETY WITH QUALITY & PRODUCTIVITY BENEFITS Dave Copley, Matt Pierce.
Introduction to Freight Transportation Unit 1: Defining the Freight System.
Directions After reading the following article, write a Quickwrite answering the questions at the end.
Controlling Labor Costs
OPERATING SAFELY AND IN COMPLIANCE James Daulerio CDS CDT Senior Risk Consultant.
RESEARCH DEMONSTRATES CONSTRUCTION WORKER HEALTH PROTECTION IS LINKED TO SPECIFIC SAFETY MANAGEMENT ELEMENTS The University of Tennessee UT Safety Center.
Agenda Commercial Driver’s License (CDL) School Curricula and Driver Safety Performance Online Survey of Entry-Level CDL Drivers Mexico’s Experience Model.
Hours Of Service: Are you prepared ?. Hours of Service– FMCSR Applicability: 49 CMR Part 395 – Hours of Service of Drivers Hours of Service Compliance.
Motor Carrier Industry Overview April 2007 Tavio Headley Economist American Trucking Associations.
NIOSH Road Safety Research Current Projects and Future Directions May 25, 2005 Stephanie Pratt National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health Centers.
Motor Carrier Safety The Highway Safety Problem Safety in the Motor Carrier Industry Causes of Accidents Government Solutions Hours of Service Rules Drug.
Hours of Service of Drivers Revision Published in Federal Register/Vol. 76, No. 248, pages – 81188, December 27, 2011.
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration
New Jersey Transit Fatigue Risk Report Assignments for 27 th October December
Origins, Characteristics, and Uses of Crash Data.
1. Percent change in employment, (Seasonally adjusted: private wage-and-salary workers) Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current.
The Trucking Industry’s Top 10 Rebecca M. Brewster President and COO American Transportation Research Institute.
Economic & Industry Update March 8, 2011 Bob Costello Chief Economist & Vice President American Trucking Associations.
December 7, 2009 MCSAC Presentation1 Commercial Motor Vehicle Drivers’ Hours of Service Background Information Tom Yager Chief, FMCSA Driver and Carrier.
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration & DOT Safety Regulations Updates.
CSA 2010 Comprehensive Safety Analysis Scheduled Implementation Dates July 2010 through December 2010.
Hours of Service Listening Session: MCSAC Briefing February 1, 2010.
See the end pages of this presentation for analyst certification and important disclosures, including non-US analyst disclosures. J.P. Morgan does and.
Tracking the Trucking Industry… 2004 and Beyond Presented by Dan Murray American Transportation Research Institute.
Transportation & Logistics Anthony P. Gallo, CFA(410) office, (410) mobile Michael R. Busche(704)
CAMAR FALL 2012 MEETING Workers Compensation Update: A Little Information About a Lot of Topics Tim Wisecarver, Presenter October 10,
Click to edit Master title style 1. 2 FEDERAL MOTOR CARRIER SAFETY ADMINISTRATION The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) is part of the.
Keller and Ozment (1999)  Problems of driver turnover  Costs $3,000 to $12,000 per driver  Shipper effect  SCM impact  Tested solutions  Pay raise.
Border Efficiency Research Initiatives American Transportation Research Institute August 16, 2006.
UTAH’S CURRENT ECONOMIC OVERVIEW April 2014 Mark Knold Supervising Economist Utah Department of Workforce Services.
AST Research and Development Activities COMSTAC Launch Operations and Support Working Group Chuck Larsen October 24, 2006 Federal Aviation Administration.
One job or two? Truck driver work, sleep, alertness and performance Hamish Mackie.
Special Committee on Intermodal Transportation and Economic Expansion Workshop October 23, 2009 Patrick E. Quinn Co-Chairman & President U.S. Xpress Enterprises.
CMV Studies: Crash Causation and Safety Belt Use Tapan K. Datta, Ph.D., P.E. Professor Wayne State University Transportation Research Group March 13, 2007.
Imagine the result ARCADIS DOT Program Commercial Motor Vehicles Imagine the result.
LARGE TRUCK CRASHES Michigan Traffic Safety Summit East Lansing, Michigan March 13, 2007 PRESENTED BY: Capt. Robert R. Powers Commanding Officer Motor.
Total Fatalities in Drunk Driving Crashes Vehicle Miles Traveled Total Drunk-Driving Fatalities Down 39% Despite an 86% Increase in Vehicle Miles Traveled.
Evaluation of Wood Smoke Quantification and Attribution RTF PAC October 17, 2014.
Public Health Lessons from HACCP-Based Inspection Models Project Presentation by Loren D. Lange August 7, 2007 United States Department of Agriculture.
Using NHTS Data as a Measure of Exposure Data Meg Sweeney* Lee Giesbrecht Jonaki Bose Bureau of Transportation Statistics This work was completed while.
US DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION FEDERAL MOTOR CARRIER SAFETY ADMINISTRATION OREGON DIVISION Summary of 2011 HOS Final Rule.
CONFIDENTIAL Recruiting and Developing Young Producers Tom Doran.
Trucking: Issues and Policy Challenges Kristen Monaco Department of Economics California State University Long Beach.
Sanitary Transportation of Human and Animal Food Analysis of Economic Impacts 1.
Economic & Motor Carrier Industry Update March 26, 2015 Bob Costello Senior Vice President & Chief Economist ATA
Trucking Industry Benchmarking ProgramWayne State University © 2009 by Michael H. Belzer Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee Federal Motor Carrier.
Office of Research and Information Technology 2013 Large Truck and Bus Crash Overview Office of Analysis, Research, and Technology June 2015.
Office of Research and Information Technology Entry Level Training Research Plan December 3, 2012 Martin R. Walker, Chief, Research Division.
Industry Update for: FEI – St. Louis Chapter February 2012.
The FMCSA Program Effectiveness Study How Effective Are Compliance Reviews?
Overview: Analysis & Information Online & Driver Information Resource (DIR) 2007 Eastern In-Service Training Williamsburg, VA August 2007.
The Transportation Logistics Company Indiana Logistics Summit Infrastructure Needs and Opportunities September 26, 2007.
Economic Dynamics of Freight & Modes. The Trucking Industry.
Crash Profiles Online Overview. What are Crash Profiles? What is Crash Profiles Online? What Data Sources are used to Compile Crash Profiles? FARS Data.
FMCSA Data for Safety Stakeholders| December FMCSA Data for Safety Stakeholders.
Occupational Health Indicators in Wyoming, 2001 – 2005 Mulloy KB 1, Stinson KS 1,Boudreau Y 2, Newman LS 1, Helmkamp J 2 1 – Mountain and Plains Education.
Office of Research and Information Technology Large Truck Crash Studies: Past and Future Steven K. Smith, Ph.D. Ralph Craft, Ph.D. CSA Subcommittee, Motor.
Topics Wage and Hour Division (WHD) enforcement
Personal Automobile Insurance More Accidents, Larger Claims Drive Costs Higher October 2016 Insurance Information Institute  110 William Street  New.
CSA 2010 A Compendium for Shippers April 14, 2010.
Hours of Service Regulations
Presentation transcript:

Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration Analysis of HOS Rules briefing to the Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee December 7, 2009 Mark Johnson, Economist, Analysis Division FMCSA Barry Galef, Senior Economist, ICF

2 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Overview: Presenters and Topics Mark Johnson, FMCSA: Data Sources for Analysis  Crash Data  Fatigue Data  Industry Data Barry Galef, ICF International: Use of the Data for Regulatory Analysis  Cost analysis  Benefit analysis  Impact analysis

3 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Crash Data ►Motor Carrier Management Information System Crash Data (MCMIS) Fatal, injury, and tow-away crashes, but no associated factor info. ►Fatal Accident Reporting System (FARS) Only fatal crashes, but has limited associated factor data ►Trucks Involved in Fatal Accidents (TIFA) Based on FARS, but supplemented with closer scrutiny of police accident reports and follow on questions Has associated factor and hour of driving information ►Large Truck Crash Causation Study (LTCCS) Most comprehensive associated factor data Limited collection period and smaller sample size than other data sources

4 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Data on Driving & On-duty Schedules ►FMCSA Field Survey (mostly small carriers) Average length of tour of duty (on-duty and drive time) Weekly drive time, and use of 11 th hour and 34 hour restart Data on local vs. over-the-road drivers ►Schneider Survey (large truck load carrier) Use of 11 th hour and 34 hour restart Average daily and weekly duty and driving time ►OOIDA Survey of Owner-Operators Data on frequency of use of 11 th hour and 34 hour restarts ►Anonymous surveys give indications of compliance UMTIP survey of truck drivers IIHS anonymous survey of long-haul truck drivers

5 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Industry Profile Data ►Truck driver wage and compensation data: Bureau of Labor Statistics ►Revenue/Profitability data TTS Blue Book of Trucking Companies for larger firms Risk Management Association for smaller firms ►Owner-Operator profile – Owner-Operator Independent Driver Association, MCMIS Census ►Total size of the industry – MCMIS Census, OOIDA, TTS, ATA and Economic Census ►Drivers and Power Units – VIUS, TTS, Economic Census, MCMIS and ATA

6 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 RIA Overview: Answering These Questions ►What is the baseline? ►How do HOS options affect operations? ►How do the operational changes affect … Industry costs? Crashes? ►Given these changes, which options are cost- effective? ►What impacts are there besides costs and benefits?

7 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Establishing an Industry Baseline ►Profile of the Affected Industry Divide into short vs. long-haul (LH) Divide into private fleets vs. for-hire Divide LH into TL (truckload) /LTL (less than truckload) and team/solo ►Operational Patterns Estimate distribution of freight hauls Divide into regular/“random” patterns Estimate current use of HOS provisions

8 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Estimating Cost Impacts of HOS Options ►Analysis starts with impacts on schedules ►Regular patterns can be assessed directly ►Complex/irregular operations call for detailed modeling of HOS options RIA for 2003 rules used commercial software RIA for 2005 rules used a computer simulation of “drivers” choosing among randomly generated loads under various HOS constraints

9 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Valuing Changes in Productivity ►Assuming the same freight needs to be delivered, lower productivity implies more drivers ►Cost of hiring another driver is compared to the cost of using the same drivers slightly more ►Examined the compensation of drivers working different schedules to compare costs ►Found that a 1 percent drop in productivity increases industry costs by about $300 million

10 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 ►HOS options affect work schedules  change in amount and timing of rest  change in alertness/fatigue  changes in crashes  change in damages ►To draw quantitative conclusions, we had to model most of these steps explicitly Overview of Benefits Analysis

11 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Effect of Work Schedules on Rest Hours on Duty Hours of Sleep Δ in Sleep per Hour on Duty ►Another hour off duty can mean more sleep – but not on a one-to-one basis ► Walter Reed Field Study let us estimate relationship

12 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Driver Health Research Effect of Changes in Rest on Alertness ►RIA for 2003 HOS rules used the Walter Reed Sleep Performance Model (SPM) (in Excel) ►For 2005, we used SAFTE/FAST (related to SPM) Regular ScheduleIrregular Schedule

13 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Driver Health Research Separate “Time on Task” Adder for 2005 and After ►Allowed for an independent effect beyond effect of excessive time awake ►Fit a polynomial, then a logistic, to TIFA data

14 FMCSADecember 7, 2009 Driver Health Research Assessing the Results ►We “monetized” the changes in crashes using a study of crash damages ►Subtracting compliance costs from the dollar value of benefits yielded the net benefit of a proposal ►Some benefits are hard to quantify, though, and are often left out of net benefit calculations ►Other impacts – mode shifts, jobs losses, hardships for small entities – are often important to decision makers, and need to measured