1 Productivity Stagnation and Low Human Capital Investment in a Wealthy Economy: The Case of Italy Productivity Stagnation and Low Human Capital Investment.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
International Outsourcing and the Demand for Skills Kurt Kratena WP8 EUKLEMS Consortium Meeting Brussels, March, 2007.
Advertisements

THE EU IN THE WORLD ECONOMY By Dale W. Jorgenson Harvard University March 15, European Union.
CAPITAL AND ITS PRODUCTIVITY IN FINLAND, Pirkko Aulin-Ahmavaara & Jukka Jalava Statistics Finland / Helsinki School of Economics.
The Productivity Gap between Europe and the US: Trends and Causes Marcel P. Timmer Groningen Growth and Development Centre The EU KLEMS project is funded.
WORLD KLEMS CONFERENCE August 2010 Harvard University KLEMS Methodology Basic Building Blocks: Measuring Capital Paul Schreyer, OECD.
International Comparisons of Industry Output, Inputs and Productivity Levels: Methodology and New Results Presentation prepared for Discussion session.
Searching for the Robust Method to Estimate Total Factor Productivity at Firm Level Yin Heng Li Shigang Liu Di SEBA Beijing Normal University
Neoclassical Growth Theory
Chapter 4: Labor Demand Elasticities
Comments on DATA WATCH: Implementation of a New Architecture for the U.S. National Accounts Bart van Ark The Conference Board January 4th, 2009 www. conference.
The Reconciliation of Industry Productivity Measures with National Measures: An Exact Translog Approach EMG Workshop 2006 December 13, 2006 Erwin Diewert.
Systems of Index Numbers for International Price Comparisons Based on the Stochastic Approach Gholamreza Hajargasht D.S. Prasada Rao Centre for Efficiency.
MINISTRY OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT 1 Impact of cohesion policy on the Polish economy. Results of macroeconomic modeling of ex-post impact and forecasts for.
The Role of Latin America in the World Economy By Dale W. Jorgenson Harvard University October 6, 2008 Seminario Internacional Fundacion BBVA – Ivie 2008.
1 The Industry Origins of the Second Surge of U.S. Productivity Growth Kevin J. Stiroh* Federal Reserve Bank of New York May 2006 *These comments are the.
1 Impact of the Terms of Trade on the Australian Economy by W. Erwin Diewert, University of British Columbia and the University of New South Wales, and.
Growth of the Economy And Cyclical Instability
Measuring Output and Productivity in Service- Producing Industries Barry Bosworth.
1 Copyright  2002 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd PPTs t/a Macroeconomics by Dornbusch, Bodman, Crosby, Fischer and Startz Slides prepared by Ed Wilson.
The Estimation of Industry-level Capital Stock for Emerging-Market and Transition Economies Hak K. Pyo Seoul National University.
1 Convergence and Divergence in the Global Economy University of Hull.
Changes in the Terms of Trade and Canada’s Productivity Performance 2008 World Congress on National Accounts and Economic Performance Measures for Nations,
1 Chain-Consistent True Index Numbers of Productivity: An Application to the EU KLEMS Data by Carlo Milana Istituto di Studi e Analisi Economica, Rome,
Rebasing and Linking of National Accounts
Measuring the Contributions of Productivity and the Terms of Trade to Australian Economic Welfare ABS and Productivity Commission Workshop on Productivity.
Economic growth and living standards. Long-Term Growth Trends (US)
Total Factor Productivity in Korea and International Comparison - Data Structure and Productivity Estimates of Korea Industrial Productivity (KIP) Database.
1 A Net Profit Approach to Productivity Measurement, with an Application to Italy by Carlo Milana Istituto di Studi e Analisi Economica, Rome, Italy This.
Constant Price Estimates Expert Group Meeting on National Accounts Cairo May 12-14, 2009 Presentation points.
Production and Efficiency. Content Specialisation Division of labour Exchange Production and productivity Economies of Scale Economic Efficiency.
Production Functions. Students Should Be Able To Use the Cobb-Douglas production function to calculate: 1. Output as a product of inputs 2. marginal and.
C HANGING P RODUCTIVITY OF O IL F IRMS IN N IGERIA By David Mautin Oke (Ph.D.) Department of Economics Lagos State University, Nigeria.
Infrastructures and ICT. Measurement Issues and Impact on Economic Growth Matilde Mas Universitat de València & Ivie OECD Workshop on Productivity Analysis.
NS4053 Winter Term 2014 Growth, Convergence and Income Distribution.
Productivity Micro-economic Analysis Division 1 Productivity Micro-economic Analysis Division Statistics Canada January 2008.
Principles of Macroeconomics Lecture 1 INTRODUCTION TO MACROECONOMICS & MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY.
Comparing Growth and Labour Productivity - measurement issues OECD Working Paper Presented by Francois Lequiller (OECD)
Productivity in agriculture Christine Holleran Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs Agricultural Statistics and Analysis Team.
Economic Growth. Growth and the business cycle Short-run economic growth and the business cycle.
National Institute of Economic and Social Research Public Sector Output: Output Indicators and Welfare Indicators Martin Weale.
The Distribution of Recent Economic Gains: Some early observations Ben Dolman.
Economics 1490 GROWTH AND CRISIS IN THE WORLD ECONOMY with Professor Dale W. Jorgenson Lecture 26: December 3, 2015 Outlook for World Economic Growth Harvard.
On the Estimation of Returns to Scale, Technical Progress and Monopolistic Markups by Erwin Diewert and Kevin Fox Discussion by Susanto Basu Comments on.
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND PRODUCTIVITY SPILLOVERS: Firm Level Evidence from Chilean industrial sector. Leopoldo LabordaDaniel Sotelsek University of.
ECONOMIC GROWTH Mr. Griffin AP Economics - Macro: VI.
KLEMS productivity accounts for the Polish economy Dariusz Kotlewski (University of Warsaw, Central Statistical Office of Poland) and Mirosław Błażej (Central.
The Rise of Asia and the Transformation of the World Economy by Dale W. Jorgenson Samuel W. Morris University Professor Harvard University
Lecture 3. PURCHASING POWER PARITIES
Chapter 3 Growth and Accumulation
Slides prepared by Ed Wilson
EU-KLEMS project: Progress in Economic Underpinnings and Measurement
Lecture 5. GLOBALIZATION AND COMPETITIVENESS
Lecture 2. THE WORLD ECONOMY SINCE 1990
Lecture 22. INVESTING IN HUMAN CAPITAL
Lecture 11. U.S. Growth Resurgence
Lecture 4. SOURCES OF GROWTH
Lecture 5. GLOBALIZATION AND COMPETITIVENESS
Environmental input-output analysis at Statistics Netherlands
Capital and global productivity comparisons
Fifth World KLEMS June 4, 2018 Joji Tokui and Takeshi Mizuta
Measurement of Economic Performance
NS4053 Spring Term 2017 Growth, Convergence and Income Distribution
PURCHASING POWER PARITIES
Zhan Li Institute of Economic Research Hitotsubashi University, Tokyo
Global Value Chains: Analytical and Policy Framework
“Post-crisis productivity: Lessons from the UK”
Productivity Productivity Erik Veldhuizen.
GROWTH AND CRISIS IN THE U.S. Growth Resurgence and European Slowdown
Rebasing and Linking of National Accounts
Productivity Productivity Erik Veldhuizen.
Presentation transcript:

1 Productivity Stagnation and Low Human Capital Investment in a Wealthy Economy: The Case of Italy Productivity Stagnation and Low Human Capital Investment in a Wealthy Economy: The Case of Italy Invited presentation at the Third World KLEMS conference organized by RIETI Invited presentation at the Third World KLEMS conference organized by RIETI and Harvard university, Department of Economics in Tokyo, May and Harvard university, Department of Economics in Tokyo, May Carlo Milana Birkbeck College, University of London

2 Overview II. Measurement problems and proposed solution III. Empirical results I. Defining the productivity problem in Italy VI. Concluding remarks

3 Overview II. Measurement problems and proposed solution III. Empirical results I. Defining the productivity problem in Italy VI. Concluding remarks

Table 1. Nominal tangible assets per capita USA Japan U.K. Germany Italy Nominal tangible assets per capita Gross internal rate of return (percent) (USA = 100)

7

8

9 Overview II. Measurement problems and proposed solution III. Empirical results I. Defining the productivity problem in Italy VI. Concluding remarks

10 Related contributions Afriat’s minimum (maximum) path chained Laspeyers (Paasche) index numbers are very close to the following contributions combined together: Dale W. Jorgenson and Zvi Griliches (1967), “The Explanation of Productivity Change”, Review of Economic Studies 34: Dale W. Jorgenson and Zvi Griliches (1971), “Divisia Index Numbers and Productivity Measurement”, Review of Income and Wealth, pp , who wrote: “The main advantage of a chain index is the reduction of errors of approximation as the economy moves from one production configuration to another. […] The Laspeyres approximation to the Divisia index of total factor productivity was employed in our original study of productivity change (1967)” Samuelson and Swamy (1974, pp. 576) where it is stated that “Fisher missed the point made in Samuelson (1947, p. 151) that knowledge of a third situation can add information relevant to the comparison of two given situations” Kruskal's Minimum Spanning Tree recently proposed. See Hill, Robert J. (1999a), "Comparing Price Levels across Countries Using Minimum Spanning Trees", Review of Economics and Statistics 81: Hill, Robert J. (1999b), "International Comparisons using Spanning Trees", in A. Heston and R.E. Lipsey (eds.), International and Interarea Comparisons of Income, Output, and Prices, Studies in Income and Wealth, Volume 61, NBER, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. Hill, Robert J. (2001), "Linking Countries and Regions using Chaining Methods and Spanning Trees", prepared for the Joint World Bank-OECD Seminar on Purchasing Power Parities -Recent Advances in Methods and Applications, Washington, D.C., 30th January-2nd February, 2001.

11 The upper bound of the aggregate input price index with two observations A B Factor input 2 Factor input 1 O

....A C BPBP BLBL P ray L ray q1q1 q0q0 Input 2 Upper bound (Laspeyres-type) Lower bound (Paasche-type) Keynes’ method of limits Input 1

13 Extending a bilateral comparison to a multilateral context (Afriat, 1981) A C B Factor input 2 Factor input 1 O

Upper bound (Laspeyres-type) Lower bound (Paasche-type) Input 2 Paasche limit Laspeyres limit P ray L ray Tight bounds....A C BLBL q1q1 q0q0 q2q2 Samuelson-Afriat tight bounds = Input 1

O F E B y 1 y 0 D C Input x 2 Input x 1 A Misallocation within industry reduces productivity

Output y 1 A1 A1 A0A0 Output y 2 Output y 1. Output y 1 Between industry misallocation causes output loss

The inefficiency parameter e t is found in the interval The starting decomposition of the minimum costs are therefore obtained as cost-inefficiency parameter multiplied by observed total costs: Methodology The search for meaningful economic measures simultaneously along the decomposition

18 Laspeyres and Paasche matrices with Afriat’s tight upper and lower bound matrices So that we have the following range of possible values:

Scale elasticity and misallocation effect for every i ≥ j Finding Afriat efficiency index Finding the scale elasticity : where p is the output price and m is the pure profit margin where L and K are respectively the Laspeyres and Paasche indexes

Scale effects on TFP

Decomposing TFP growth where Output index Actual input index = Efficiency input index ∙Afriat efficiency index Scale effect index Technical change index Marginal elasticity of scale Potential gain in TFP level from removal of base-period “within” misallocation

23 Overview II. Measurement problems and proposed solution III. Empirical results I. Defining the productivity problem in Italy VI. Concluding remarks

24

25

26

27

28

29

30 Figure 11. Average growth rates of TFP, TC, and output loss due to misallocation, (% p.a.)

31 Overview II. Measurement problems and proposed solution III. Empirical results I. Defining the productivity problem in Italy VI. Concluding remarks

32 In Italy, an underinvestment in human capital and other intangibles coupled with low rewards for high skilled labour had been part of misallocation of resources with a consistent output loss. In intercountry comparisons, Italy appears to lag behind in productivity levels and growth rates notwithstanding its rich endowment of tangible assets. A growth strategy based on the acceleration of investments in intangibles and particularly in human capital through education and professional skills seems the most appropriate solution of the Italian productivity problem. Concluding remarks