R. L. Powell Animal Improvement Programs Laboratory Agricultural Research Service, USDA, Beltsville, MD Historical perspectives on genetic fitness research ADSA Pioneer
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (2)R. L. Powell Fitness (Dictionary.com) The state or condition for being fit; suitability or appropriateness Good health or physical condition The extent to which an organism is adapted to or able to produce offspring in a particular environment
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (3)R. L. Powell Common understanding of fitness traits Nonproduction Functional But what makes a dairy cow more fit and functional than production? We may strain the dictionary definition, but we know what we mean
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (4)R. L. Powell Conformation or type Anecdotal observations for eons What “we” thought cow should look like Linear scoring began around 1980 Promoted research on real value of type traits
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (5)R. L. Powell Longevity Justification for type emphasis Direct observation Indicator traits
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (6)R. L. Powell Somatic cell/mastitis SCS is convenient trait for selection for reduced mastitis Clear importance and relatively ready acceptance of research Like yield, obvious milking-to-milking impact on income (profit)
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (7)R. L. Powell Fertility Should we have foreseen problems? Some natural selection Tribolium pupa weight study (1976) Negative response in family size “Eventual extinction … by generation 16”
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (8)R. L. Powell Calving ease Giving birth is most traumatic time in a cow’s life Can minimize negatives by reducing calvings or by mating plan Better yet, reduce frequency of bad genes (daughter calving ease)
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (9)R. L. Powell Genetic evaluations TraitYear Yield1935 Final score type1964 Calving ease1978 Linear type1980—83 Productive life1994 Somatic cell score1994 Daughter pregnancy rate2003 Stillbirths2006
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (10)R. L. Powell Indexes Consider all traits with a single number Vital with so many traits Needs to be appropriate for market Needs to be “reasonably” accurate Many correlated traits complicate process
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (11)R. L. Powell History of USDA indexes TraitsYear Milk, fat Protein, solids-not fat Productive life, somatic cell score Type composites Daughter pregnancy rate,2003 calving ease + Stillbirths2006
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (12)R. L. Powell Deleterious genes Mulefoot Bovine leukocyte adhesion deficiency (BLAD) Uridine monophosphate synthase deficiency (DUMPS) Complex vertebral malformation (CVM) Weaver Limber leg Rectovaginal constriction (RVC)
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (13)R. L. Powell Learning from history Obsession with production Low heritability vs. no heritability High economic value Large variation Breed for yield, cull for function We got what we asked for
ADSA-ASAS 2006 Joint Annual Meeting (14)R. L. Powell Learning from history (cont.) Beware of pendulum swinging too far back Theoretically, index weights based on research correct index optimum progress