Is there a demand for green offices in Central and Eastern Europe? Gunther Maier, Michal Gluszak, Andrej Adamuscin, Kateryna Kurylchyk.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Now You See It, Now You Don’t: Why Do Real Estate Agents Withhold Available Houses from Black Customers? Jan Ondrich Stephen L. Ross John Yinger.
Advertisements

Sustainability and the Dynamics of Green Building Nils Kok UC Berkeley Maastricht University John M. Quigley UC Berkeley Piet Eichholtz Maastricht University.
Voluntary Green Building Certification: Economic Decision or Following the Trend? A Spatial Approach Yueming Lucy Qiu Ashutosh Tiwari Arizona State University.
1) Introduction Prior to the Exxon Valdez oil spill, the estimation of passive use value, was an area of economic research not well known. However, based.
The Multiple Regression Model Prepared by Vera Tabakova, East Carolina University.
Class 17: Tuesday, Nov. 9 Another example of interpreting multiple regression coefficients Steps in multiple regression analysis and example analysis Omitted.
Understanding Factors Affecting Consumer Purchase Decisions for Functional Foods By Ratapol Teratanavat Dr. Neal H. Hooker Presented at the IFT Meeting,
June 2011, ERES Eindhoven Piet Eichholtz Maastricht University Sustainable Buildings: Performance, Users, Investors.
Brad Johnson THESIS PRESENTATION BARRIERS TO CERTIFICATION FOR LEED REGISTERED PROJECTS.
Valuation 9: Contingent Choice Contingent Choice Modelling and its variants Some econometrics Application to green product choice.
Stat 217 – Day 25 Regression. Last Time - ANOVA When?  Comparing 2 or means (one categorical and one quantitative variable) Research question  Null.
Regression Chapter 10 Understandable Statistics Ninth Edition By Brase and Brase Prepared by Yixun Shi Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania.
Stat 112: Lecture 9 Notes Homework 3: Due next Thursday
15. Stated Preference Experiments. Panel Data Repeated Choice Situations Typically RP/SP constructions (experimental) Accommodating “panel data” Multinomial.
The Value of Green Buildings New Evidence from the United Kingdom Andrea Chegut Maastricht University Finance Department
MANAGERIAL ECONOMICS 12th Edition
The Impact of Energy Performance Certificates on the Rental and Capital Values of Commercial Property Assets: Some Preliminary Evidence from the UK Franz.
Chapter 3 Common Stock: Return, Growth, and Risk By Cheng Few Lee Joseph Finnerty John Lee Alice C Lee Donald Wort.
Studium Generale, October Piet Eichholtz Maastricht University Sustainable Buildings: Performance, Users, Investors.
ETH Zürich - Annika Feige, CCRS at the University of Zurich - Markus Gaebel ERES 2012, On the sustainability of the Swiss residential real estate.
LOCATION, LOCATION, GREEN. A SPATIAL ANALYSIS OF GREEN BUILDINGS IN EUROPE? Gunther Maier Research Institute for spatial and Real Estate Economics Vienna.
Do Sydney tenants pay energy efficient office premiums? Jeremy Gabe & Michael RehmJuly 2013.
Turun kauppakorkeakoulu  Turku School of Economics HOW IMPORTANT IS BUILDING ENERGY EFFICIENCY IN MARKETS WITH COLD WINTERS? PRICING AND LIQUIDITY EVIDENCE.
Regression and Correlation Methods Judy Zhong Ph.D.
PENSION REFORM EXPERIENCES IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Agnieszka Chlon-Dominczak Ministry of Economy, Labour and Social Policy, Poland Kiev, May 28th,
CENTRE FOR INNOVATION, RESEARCH AND COMPETENCE IN THE LEARNING ECONOMY Session 2: Basic techniques for innovation data analysis. Part I: Statistical inferences.
Impact of Olympic Games on Housing Markets: Empirical Evidences from Beijing, China Mei Wang & Helen Bao Department of Land Economy University of Cambridge.
MEASURING DWELLING PRICE CHANGES IN POLAND WITH THE APPLICATION OF THE HEDONIC METHOD.
An analysis and evaluation of the effects of lease terms on effective commercial rents in Frankfurt, Germany Gero Grunenberg, John Moohan and Paul Royston.
The Economic Value of Ecosystem Conservation in Japan: Reduction of elicitation effect by Bid Effect Function Mitsuyasu YABE Kyushu University.
Chapter 10 CBA and valuation1 CHAPTER 10 Cost-Benefit Analysis and Valuation.
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Chapter 13 The Market Approach to Value.
Enhanced Annuities, Individual Underwriting, and Adverse Selection August 6, Enhanced Annuities, Individual Underwriting, and Adverse Selection.
Facing the Crisis: Housing Choices and Housing Demand in Poland Michal Gluszak 16 th ERES Conference June, Stockholm.
Green Building Councils: Policy Instrument Or Fashion? Gunther Maier, WU Wien Sabine Sedlacek, MODUL University.
From Green Buildings to a Sustain- able Real Estate Industry – Assess- ing five years of ÖGNI Gunther Maier, Sabine Sedlacek, Philipp Kaufmann.
Empirical Methods for Microeconomic Applications University of Lugano, Switzerland May 27-31, 2013 William Greene Department of Economics Stern School.
Session Outline Differentiation and Positioning Market Segmentation
Estimating Demand Functions Chapter Objectives of Demand Estimation to determine the relative influence of demand factors to forecast future demand.
CHAPTER 14 MULTIPLE REGRESSION
1 Process Analysis and Design Cost Accounting and Profitability Analysis.
Floating Point (a brief look) We need a way to represent –numbers with fractions, e.g., –very small numbers, e.g., –very large numbers,
On visible choice set and scope sensitivity: - Dealing with the impact of study design on the scope sensitivity Improving the Practice of Benefit Transfer:
ERES 2010 Arch. Simone Spreafico Engagement Director, Investment, Engagement Director, Investment, Advisory & Valuation Division Advisory & Valuation Division.
28. JetBlue Airways. 1. Background: As a small and low cost airline, JetBlue has been one of successful small airline companies. Its operating strategy.
1/54: Topic 5.1 – Modeling Stated Preference Data Microeconometric Modeling William Greene Stern School of Business New York University New York NY USA.
Engineering Economic Analysis Canadian Edition
The Annual Meeting of the RSAI – The Israeli Branch, Tel-Aviv University, January 10, 2010 Development and estimation of a semi- compensatory residential.
The differential effects of energy-efficient technology adoption and energy policies: A research note Brad Mills & Joachim Schleich February 2010.
Managerial Economics Demand Estimation & Forecasting.
Determinants for the take-up of energy efficient household appliances in Germany Joachim Schleich (Co-Author: Bradford F. Mills) Fraunhofer ISI.
Real Estate Market Efficiency: A Survey of Literature Gunther Maier, Shanaka Herath Research Institute for Spatial and Real Estate Economics.
Objectives 2.1Scatterplots  Scatterplots  Explanatory and response variables  Interpreting scatterplots  Outliers Adapted from authors’ slides © 2012.
Mannheim Research Institute for the Economics of Aging SHARE Data Cleaning Stephanie Stuck MEA Vienna November 5/6 th.
1 Objectives and Strategy. 2 Product Life Cycle ODI Dell FedEx Jones Blair AA.
Forecasting Chapter 9. Copyright © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall Define Forecast.
MM271 Introduction to Marketing Topic 4 Identifying Market Segments & Targets.
Objectives Be able to define the three steps of target marketing: market segmentation, target marketing, and market positioning. Understand the major.
Estimating Potential Demand for Electric Vehicles (EVs) Michael K. Hidrue and George R. Parsons Camp Resources XVII Wrightsville Beach, NC June 24-25,
1 The Decomposition of a House Price index into Land and Structures Components: A Hedonic Regression Approach by W. Erwin Diewert, Jan de Haan and Rens.
Factors influencing commercial buildings to obtain green certificates in New York: Building characteristics and opposite-principal-agent problem Yueming.
Universität Stuttgart | Institut für Bauökonomie | Dipl.-Ing. Maike Buttler Doctoral Session - ERES Conference - June 2009 CASBEE since 2001 DGNB since.
Chap 6 Further Inference in the Multiple Regression Model
Rents as incentive for saving energy: an empirical analysis for Austria Gunther Maier, Philipp Kaufmann, Andreas Oberhuber.
Behaviour Change to achieve Greener Homes through Market Transformation Stephen Garland The Scottish Government.
Robert Goettling, Principal, The Bloom Organization LLC Curtis Bernstein, Managing Director of Valuation & Transaction Services, Altegra Health October.
Demand Estimation & Forecasting. Direct Methods of Demand Estimation Consumer interviews – Range from stopping shoppers to speak with them to administering.
Market Research Techniques Sustainable Small Acreage Farming and Ranching Cinda Williams, UI Extension 2005.
A Spatial Analysis of the Central London Office Market
Jorn van de Wetering, Franz Fuerst, Peter Wyatt
Presentation transcript:

Is there a demand for green offices in Central and Eastern Europe? Gunther Maier, Michal Gluszak, Andrej Adamuscin, Kateryna Kurylchyk

Content Introduction The current project team Conceptual background Interviews Survey instrument First results

Introduction  Green Building movement in Central and Eastern Europe  Green Building Councils in almost all CEE countries  Various strategies, various certification schemes  Internationally active developers and consultants got involved  What is the value of green building certificates in the CEE market?  Very few certified buildings  Limited information on transactions  Need to do a contingent valuation study

The Research Team  Currently: Cracow (Poland) and Vienna (Austria)  Planned: Kiev (Ukraine) and Bratislava (Slovakia)  Michal Gluszak, Malgorzata Zieba, University of Economics, Cracow  Gunther Maier, Kateryna Kurylchyk, WU Vienna  Sabine Sedlacek, Modul University, Vienna  Andrej Adamuscin, TU Bratislava

Conceptual Background  Evidence for a positive effect of Green Building certificates on values and rents  Eichholtz, Kok & Quigley (2010) (US; LEED and Energy Star): effective rent premium + 7%, sales price premium +16%; the label by itself has a positive value above the implied energy savings.  Fuerst & McAllister (2011) (US; LEED and Energy Star): rent premium +5% (LEED) and 4% (Energy Star); sales price premium +25% (LEED), +26% (Energy Star)  Wiley, Benefield & Johnson (2010) (US; LEED and Energy Star): rent premium +7% to +17%; higher occupancy by 10% to 18%; selling premium per sqft $30 (Energy Star) to $130 (LEED).

Conceptual Background  Positive image of Green Buildings  Addae-Dapaah, Hiang & Shi (2009) (Singapore, survey of occupants): No effect of awareness and appreciation of green benefits beyond cost savings and higher building values. Benefits are very uncertain.  Hypotheses:  Green building certificates have a significant positive effect on rents and sales prices.  In less developed markets (CEE) awareness will be low

Conceptual Background  Method of choice  Hedonic price estimation with certificate as explanatory variable  Problem:  Too few green buildings yet in CEE markets; very limited information on rents and transactions  Solution:  Expert interviews  Contingent valuation survey

Survey instrument  Survey of companies who have moved to new office space within the last 2 years  Goal: identify the WTP (implicit price) for green building certificate  Strategy: contingent valuation  Compare current office space with a similar hypothetical alternative – which one would you have chosen?  Analysis by use of a conditional logit model

Survey (start page)

Survey (page 1)

Survey (page 2)

Survey (page 3, repeated 10 times)

Survey  Generating the hypothetical alternatives  Criteria are sorted in decreasing expected attractiveness (new before old, city center before periphery)  For all criteria except price, operating costs and certificate: For the new alternative, we either stay at the criteria value (40%) or go one step up (30%) or down (30%). When out of bounds, it is set to the boundary value.  For certificates: When certificate: 50% same certificate, 50% no certificate; when “no certificate”: 40% no certificate, LEED, BREEAM and DGNB with 20% each

Survey  Generating the hypothetical alternatives  Sum of characteristics gives a rough measure of attractiveness  Randomly generated price deviations by 0%, 5%, 10%, 15% or 20% up or down  Result centered around zero and shifted by difference in attractiveness  Correction over the experiment:  When only the original option is chosen, the alternative option becomes cheaper  When only the alternative option is chosen, it becomes cheaper

Kiev: clickable map (12 areas)

First results - VIENNA  32 responses  Respondent fixed effects omitted  Few significant coefficients  High Pseudo R- square  Totcost always neg.sign.  Cert_XXX mixed anyLEEDBREEAMDGNBothermultiple const-2.37*-2.42* totcost-0.13*** -0.14***-0.13*** cert_XXX *-1.81** loc_ loc_3-1.38*-1.36*-1.48**-1.41*-1.43**-1.31* loc_4-2.16**-2.26**-2.12**-2.14**-2.16**-2.1** loc_ * transp_ transp_ transp_ transp_ age-0.59*-0.56* * -0.57* type_ type_ type_ qual_ qual_3-2.03***-2.08***-2.01*** -1.83**-2.07*** qual_ LogLike Pseudo R

First results - VIENNA  Value of green building certificate in % cost increase  Outlier BREEAM (negative significant)  Others in a meaningful range (3-9%) anyLEEDBREEAMDGNBothermultiple totcost-0.13*** -0.14***-0.13*** cert_XXX *-1.81** value2,668,60-13,283,1213,805,16

First results Cracow  18 respomdents  Respondent fixed effects omitted anyLEEDBREEAMDGNBothermultiple const-3,37-0,47-0,81-0,98-0,32-0,43 totcost-0,21***-0,22***-0,19***-0,2*** cert_XXX2,72***0,891,67**0,7518,37-0,28*** loc_20,750,50,550,460,440,48 loc_32,21,561,911,661,611,65 loc_4-18,33-16,64-17,2-16,41-16,9-16,19 loc_5-16,2-15,01-15,15-14,46-15,52-14,45 transp_2-1,52*-0,91-1,27-1,14-0,91-1,04 transp_3-4,42***-3,89***-3,56***-3,89***-3,71***-3,77*** transp_438,9236,234,6135,4636,6435,03 age-0,35-1,01-1,04-0,78-0,97-0,98 type_2-1,7-1,44-1,1-1,53*-1,6*-1,39 type_3-4,42**-3,15*-2,21-3,6**-3,2*-3,01* type_4-7,57***-6,13***-5,64***-6,35***-6,11***-5,94*** qual_2-0,74-1,21-1,14-0,81-0,91-1,03 qual_3-1,87*-1,72-1,62-1,38 -1,49 qual_4-1,5-2,52-2,09-2,2-2,23-2,38

anyLEEDBREEAMDGNBothermultiple totcost-0,21-0,22-0,19-0,2 cert_XXX2,720,891,670,7518,37-0,28 Value12,764,028,623,7790,22-1,34

Summary and conclusions  Still very limited information basis – needs to be expanded  Weak support for the thesis that there is demand for green office buildings in CEE (Vienna)  Green building certificate is worth 3-9% higher total cost  Problem BREEAM / multiple?  Surprisingly similar results  Next steps:  More observations for Vienna and Cracow  Implement Kiev and Bratislava  Expand to other cities?