Will cattle ranching continue to drive deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon? Paulo Barreto Senior Researcher at IMAZON
15% deforested up to 2009
Pastureland ocupies 75% of the area deforested
Will cattle ranching continue to drive deforestation? Predominant trends Critical uncertainties ????? Scenarios
What has driven deforestation?
Policies to occupy the Amazon Infrastructure Colonization projects Subsidized rural credit Tax breaks
Demand for agricultural commodities stimulated deforestation
What has made Brazil more effective against deforestation?
Reduction of leniency with crimes < 5% of the value of fines collected
Drought in Amazon ,000 people affected
EE ~40% of Brazilian Emissions of Greenhouse gases Less than 1% of GDP
Market risk 2006 – soy moratorium Biofuels and indirect deforestation
New measures against deforestation in 2008 Illegal operations Credit restriction Embargo of areas illegally deforested Buyers of products from embargoed areas liable to penalties Increased confiscation
Confiscation of 3,000 cattle inside protected area June 2008 Auctioned after two months
Deforestation declined despite the increase of soy and cattle prices
Will cattle ranching continue to drive deforestation? Predominant trends Growing demand for food Demand for environmental protection Socioeconomic impacts of the application of environmental laws Pressure for economic growth. Critical uncertainties Reduction of legal forest protection? Support for the implementation of laws? Size of the clandestine beef market? Scenarios Low deforestation Medium deforestation High deforestation
Low deforestation scenario Low deforestation No reduction of legal protection Enforcement of environmental laws Support for the implementation of law Beef industry demanding deforestation-free cattle Ranchers organize to overcome barriers to the implementation of the law.
Medium deforestation scenario Medium deforestation. No significant reduction of legal protection Enforcement of environmental laws No support for the implementation of law Beef industry buys from legal deforestation. Clandestine industry buys from ilegal deforestation. Small landholders free to deforest illegally.
High deforestation scenario High deforestation. Reduction of legal protection Enforcement of environmental laws No support for the implementation of law Beef industry buys from legal deforestation. Clandestine industry buys from ilegal deforestation. Small landholders free to deforest illegally.
Low deforestation scenario Low deforestation No reduction of legal protection. Enforcement of environmental laws Support for the implementation of law Beef industry demanding deforestation-free cattle Ranchers organize to overcome barriers to the implementation of the law. REDD