ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/12 2010 ALMA Operations and the European ALMA Regional Centre interaction with and support to the users Paola.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
National Radio Astronomy Observatory June 13/14, 2005 EVLA Phase II Proposal Review EVLA Phase II Computing Development Bryan Butler (EVLA System Engineer.
Advertisements

Stepan Potiyenko ISS Sr.SW Developer.
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array Expanded Very Large Array Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope Very Long Baseline Array.
CSV Plan status Robert Laing ESO Science IPT. 2 Recent changes Complete rewrite to take account of rebaselining and revised delivery schedule Proposal.
ALMA TACand the proposal process Lister Staveley-Smith Member, ALMA Review Panel.
AOP version E Science Operations For the ASAC meeting March 9-10, 2010 Lars-Ake Nyman 1.
Lecture 13 Revision IMS Systems Analysis and Design.
APPLICATION DEVELOPMENT BY SYED ADNAN ALI.
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array Expanded Very Large Array Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope Very Long Baseline Array.
Introduction to Systems Analysis and Design
Contact Scientist Workflow Scott Schnee Dec 19, 2011.
The North America ALMA Science Center (NAASC) John Hibbard NA ARC Manager (NRAO/NAASC) National Research Council Canada ESO ALMA Community Meeting, Garching,
2008 Decmeber 5 ALMA-JT Science Meeting 1 ALMA Project News Koh-Ichiro Morita ALMAJ Project Scientist.
User Committee, Garching April ALMA Operations interaction with and support to the users Paola Andreani.
October 2005ALMA Cost Review1 Atacama Large Millimeter Array Science IPT Review Bilateral Project Scientists: Al Wootten, (Lead) Tom Wilson, (Deputy) Ryohei.
ALMA Proposal Preparation and Submission Eelco van Kampen European ALMA Regional Centre (ESO, Garching) Thanks to Liz Humphrys, Andy Biggs and Paola Andreani.
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array Expanded Very Large Array Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope Very Long Baseline Array.
C. ChandlerEVLA Advisory Committee Meeting September 6-7, Scientific Commissioning Plan Claire Chandler.
CXC Implementing 2007 NRC Portals of the Universe Report Chandra X-ray Center Recommended Best Practices Roger Brissenden and Belinda Wilkes 25 April 2012.
Communication in the ARC network The cornerstone of the network “Communication in the ARC network”, ARC network review, January 14-15, 2015, ESO-Garching.
Hunt for Molecules, Paris, 2005-Sep-20 Software Development for ALMA Robert LUCAS IRAM Grenoble France.
Framework for Compliance, Verification, and Non-Conformance George Angeli LSST All-Hands Meeting Bremerton August 17, 2015.
Principal Investigators: W. Wild (Instrumentation R&D) M. Hogerheijde (Allegro) M. Hogerheijde (Allegro) NOVA-3 Proposal Advancing Submillimeter Astronomy.
ALMA Proposal Preparation and Submission Liz Humphreys European ALMA Regional Centre ESO, Garching Thanks to Andy Biggs, Paola Andreani, Eelco van Kampen.
EVLA Early Science: Shared Risk Observing EVLA Advisory Committee Meeting, March 19-20, 2009 Claire Chandler Deputy AD for Science, NM Ops.
ALMA Operations and the North American ALMA Science Center Al Wootten NRAO.
1 ANASAC Meeting – May 20, 2015 ALMA Pipeline Brian Glendenning (for Jeff Kern)
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array Expanded Very Large Array Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope Very Long Baseline Array Tools for the ALMA.
EA ARC Ken Tatematsu East-Asian ARC Manager. ARC organization Difference between ARCS: NA: concentrated in Charlottesville Europe: distributed in different.
06/10/2006IRAM Interferometry School1 ARC node at IRAM F.Gueth – IRAM Grenoble.
Department of Administration (ADM). Accountant 1 - SCO/EXE/ Accountant 2 - SCO/EXE/ Accountant 3 - SCO/EXE/ Contracts/Proc 1 - SCO/EXE/
The ALMA Software and Release Management Ruben Soto Software Operations Group & Release Manager Joint ALMA Observatory.
High-Level Organization ALMA Board AUI NRAO North American ARC Manager North American ALMA Regional Centre AMACASAC Joint ALMA Observatory ALMA Director.
1 SPSRB Decision Brief on Declaring a Product Operational Instructions / Guidance This template will be used by NESDIS personnel to recommend to the SPSRB.
ALMA Software B.E. Glendenning (NRAO). 2 ALMA “High Frequency VLA” in Chile Presently a European/North American Project –Japan is almost certainly joining.
Designing Experiments T. Venturi Istituto di Radioastronomia, Bologna, INAF ERIS, Manchester, 9 September 2005.
CRISP & SKA WP19 Status. Overview Staffing SKA Preconstruction phase Tiered Data Delivery Infrastructure Prototype deployment.
Scheduling Blocks: a generic description Andy Biggs (ESO, Garching)
MWA Operations Management Plan (OMP, v. 3) Ron Remillard (MIT); MWA Project Meeting, June 6, 2011.
NRAO Users Committee Meeting May 20-21, National Radio Astronomy Observatory NRAO Users Committee Meeting – May 20-21, 2008 ALMA Operations Chris.
Lessons learned from cm-wave interferometry Interferometry analysis is less straightforward than single aperture analysis. Astronomers need ‘support’.
EVLA Software Bryan Butler. 2007May22EVLA SAGE Meeting2 Requirements and Goals of EVLA Software Maximize scientific throughput of the instrument At a.
The North American ALMA Science Center Interim Director, Paul A. van den Bout.
The North American ALMA Science Center North America’s ALMA Regional Center The North American ALMA Science Center acts as the gateway to ALMA for North.
Response to ASAC Report of May 2004 Response to ASAC The Atacama Large Millimeter Array Tom Wilson and Al Wootten Science IPT.
ALMA Week, 2004 March 3-5, in Garmisch, Germany ALMA Operations Plan: Progress Report Darrel Emerson (NRAO) David Silva (ESO) JAO Operations Group
2007Sep06 EAC Butler - Software Overview 1 Software Overview Bryan Butler.
Observing Modes from a Software viewpoint Robert Lucas and Philippe Salomé (SSR)
SAGE meeting Socorro, May 22-23, 2007 EVLA Science Operations: the Array Science Center Claire Chandler NRAO/Socorro.
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array Expanded Very Large Array Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope Very Long Baseline Array Data Processing Progress.
Introduction to EVLA Software Bryan Butler. 2006Dec05/06EVLA M&C Transition Software CDR2 EVLA Computing (Terse) History The original EVLA Phase I proposal.
ADMIT: ALMA Data Mining Toolkit  Developed by University of Maryland, University of Illinois, and NRAO (PI: L. Mundy)  Goal: First-view science data.
ALMA and the Call for Early Science The Atacama Large (Sub)Millimeter Array (ALMA) is now under construction on the Chajnantor plain of the Chilean Andes.
UlvestadEVLA Advisory Committee Meeting September 6-7, Future EVLA Operations Jim Ulvestad.
Atacama Large Millimeter/ submillimeter Array - ALMA ASAC Charges For Oct 31 ASAC Report to ALMA Board Al Wootten JAO Interim Project Scientist.
ALMA Town Meeting Introduction K. Y. Lo Director of NRAO.
Frazer OwenNSF EVLA Mid-Project Review May 11-12, Transition to EVLA
Charlottesville, November ALMA CSV Update Alison Peck Current status.
Jim UlvestadEVLA Advisory Committee Meeting May 8-9, EVLA Operations Jim Ulvestad Array Science Center Concept Requirements Staffing and Cost Plans.
DCA WP3 Report Support to take-up and implementation of the VObs framework Christophe Arviset (ESA-VO) Paolo Padovani (ESO) Christophe Arviset (ESA),
The North America ALMA Science Center
ALMA Software Scheduling subsystem Planning for cycle5 onwards
The CSIRO ASKAP Science Data Archive Progress and Plans
NRAO VLA Archive Survey
Software Configuration Management
Click to add title Planning for LSST Verification George Angeli LSST All Hands Meeting Tucson August 15, 2016.
Observatory Science Operations
EVLA Operations Jim Ulvestad
Observatory Science Operations
Presentation transcript:

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ ALMA Operations and the European ALMA Regional Centre interaction with and support to the users Paola Andreani

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Meaning of ALMA Operations and the Joint ALMA Observatory

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Science Operations Astronomer ’ s perspective Principles: Non-experts should be able to use ALMA  Dynamic scheduler to match observing conditions  Reliable and consistent calibration  Data public in timely fashion

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Paola Andreani Operation Support Facility (OSF) ALMA Operations Sites in Chile 60 MB/s (peak) 6 MB/s (average) Antenna Operations Site (AOS) Santiago Central Office (SCO) array scheduling + operations quick-look, maintenance and repair issues of calls PRC process SB checks pipeline data reduction quality assessment Population of the archive

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ High-level concepts for Science Operations Observations only in service observing mode with flexible (dynamic) scheduling. Observations 24h/day interrupted by maintenance periods. All observations executed in the form of scheduling blocks (SBs). Default output: reliable images, calibrated according to the calibration plan. The Joint ALMA Observatory (JAO) is responsible for the data product quality. All science and calibration raw data are captured and archived. as in the ALMA Operations Plan

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ *Tokyo *Garching *Cvlle *Santiago *ALMA site ALMA Science Operations sites OSF, Santiago and the ARCs

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ ALMA Director Department of Computing Department of Engineering Department of Administration ARCs (NA, EU, EA ) Safety Executives (NA, EU, EA) HREPO Department of Science Operations Joint ALMA Observatory (JAO) ALMA is operated by the JAO. The ALMA Regional Centres (ARCs) form an integral part of JAO operations.

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The Regional centres

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ ALMA Operations: Three ALMA Regional Centres - ARCs Joint ALMA Observatory NA ARCEU ARC (ESO) EA ARC NAOJ “Satellite” EU ARCs NAASC ARCs provide user interface, archive, software tools data delivery Astronomers on duty Enhanced User Services Enhanced services are needed to provide advanced user support, algorithm development, student programs, EPO, grants DSO provides: Array operations Scheduling of projects Execution of observations Data quality assurance and trend analysis Calibration plan maintenance Delivery of data to the archives Archive operations Pipeline operations

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The ARCs and their relation to the JAO

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Work flow of ALMA Operations

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Getting ALMA time

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The User Portal: single sign-on Access to helpdesk, data archive and project tracker

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Observers’ affiliation identified in User Portal profile Eligible Affiliations Preferred ARC for support NA EU EA Chile Non-ALMA member X X X X X X X X (checkbox; i.e. multiple selections allowed) (radio button; i.e. only single selection allowed)

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Getting ALMA time  Joint ALMA Observatory issues calls for proposals Register on the ALMA web page Prepare a proposal with the ALMA Observing Tool user can contact their ARC node for assistance  European ARC provides documentation  ALMA Observatory (with ARCs help) coordinates refereeing process  Program Review Committee ranks proposals  Executives approval Phase I MAKE A PROPOSAL! Scientific case Instrument setup: frequency rms S/N source extension spatial resolution

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ ALMA sensitivity calculator Estimate observing time Customize number of antennas Vary conditions

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ the ALMA software shall offer an easy to use interface to any user and should not assume detailed knowledge of millimetre astronomy and of the ALMA hardware Project Structure Panel Editors Panel Template Panel Feedback Panel Overview Panel The ALMA observing tool

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Getting ALMA time  Phase I: Proposals are submitted using ALMA Observing Tool  Phase II: Successful PIs submit observing programme using the Observing Tool  Preparation of the scheduling blocks  European ARC helps with observation planning and validates observing schedule Phase II

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The ALMA observing tool More details on Wednesday

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ If you need help: helpdesk

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The helpdesk Contacts with the users done through the helpdesk. i.e. need face-to-face support? Use the Helpdesk.

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ JAO ARCs PS Phase 1 Project PRC PS Phase 2 Technical feasibility Scheduling JAO Medium Term Queue Long Term Queue Archive ALMA DATA FLOW Blocks

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Assessing data quality

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Assessing Data Quality (Quality Assurance) Objective: Assess impact of ill-effects during data taking and reduction. Accept if impact is within specified ranges for all parameters. Assumption: Quality of data can be described by sets of single parameters. Joint effects of these parameters are second-order effects. ALMA Approach: Breakdown of QA into broad steps that mimic data flow. –Data Taking:QA0 (SB-level) & QA1 (Observatory Tasks) –Data Reduction:QA2 (Science Pipeline) –Post Data Reduction:QA3 (Feedback from users)

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Deals with rapidly-varying calibration/quality parameters that have to be measured within the Science SBs (or sequences of SBs) Done by AoDs in semi-real time Based on QuickLook outputs, both displays/alarms and the Calibration Summary files. At the end of an SB or a sequence of SB repeats, the AoD will assess QA0 and decide whether the SBs are satisfactory. If so, it will force a state transition in Project Tracker from “Suspended” to “Fully Observed”. The AoD will also make a comment (in Project Tracker) to justify this, or make other comments. Otherwise, it is set to “Broken” and from there it can be reinstated into the queue for re-observing Assessing Data Quality (Q0)

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Assessing Data Quality (Q0)

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Assessing Data Quality (Q1) Deals with slowly varying parameters (>1 week) of the performance of the array that will be tackled by semi-periodic “Observatory Task” observations. Measured by AoDs Based on different reduction packages at this point but expected to converge to TelCal and CASA tasks

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Assessing Data Quality (Q2) Issues detected during the data reduction process and in the final product (image datacube) mainly issues of consistency of calibrations within a given set of SB repeats, and sets observed with different arrays and/or configurations done with CASA scripts that will measure the parameters on the final products and (AQUA tool) searches of the logs output by the Science Pipeline Some of the parameters are more abstract and will be evaluated with a mixture of metrics (example, Imaging Quality) Will be done at the SCO by PMG & DMG Astronomers and Fellows/Data Analysts

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Assessing Data Quality (Q3) Issues missed by all the other QA assessments represent deeper problems not been detected in tests of some specific observing modes, set-ups, etc QA3 is all-encompassing, but most of calibration and processing problems should be picked up at QA2 PIs will report the problems to their ARCs for evaluation If a problem is present, the ARCs will report the problem to DSO for resolution Depending on the steps required for resolution, it may require re-reduction of some of the data

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Getting ALMA data

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Getting ALMA data  Queue based dynamic scheduling  Programs are composed of min scheduling blocks  Raw data pass through multi-tiered quality assurance  Combination of on-site duty astronomer, ARC staff, and automated checks  Data proceeds to pipeline and archiving  Data available from ARC (ESO) maximum within ~2 weeks (quicker for small programmes)  Pipeline products (images and calibrated u-v data), raw data, off-line data processing software made available to PIs  Expert hands-on data reduction help from ARC nodes staff provided on request, helpdesk always available

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Main ALMA Archive ALMA Regional Centre North America ALMA Regional Centre Europe ALMA Regional Centre Japan/Asia ALMA Science Archive ALMA Frontend Archive Archive nodes at the OSF, SCO and the ARCs ARC archive nodes delivered, commissioned and activated as soon as possible after SCO archive. During science operations ARC nodes are synchronized with the central archive through internet (small data sets) or via physical media. OSF connected to SCO via high-bandwidth. It MUST be always possible to operate ALMA even if the internet link does not work The ALMA archives and data distribution

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Data Available for download and/or on media Available data: –Raw UV visibilities –Calibration & flagging tables –Casapy reduction scripts –Imaging products (calibrated cubes & reference images) –Source visibilities with calibration & flagging applied

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Data reduction

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Offline Data Processing Download CASA & CASA documentation/guides/use cases –Interface: JAO & ARC webs –Actors: JAO & ARCs, assembling & posting material Attend CASA tutorial –Interface & Actors: ARCs, including nodes Ask questions –Interface: helpdesk –Actor: ARCs Visit an ARC node for face-to-face support –Interface & Actors: ARCs, including nodes

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ suite of C++ application libraries packaged through a Python scripting interface extensively tested C.A.S.A.: Common Astronomy Software Applications Primary goals: supporting the data post-processing needs of the next generation of radio astronomical telescopes such as ALMA and EVLA projects The ALMA offline reduction package (CASA) CASA session on Wednesday

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Simulating the data

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ protoplanet

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ In one command, CASA generates o uv data (with thermal noise if desired) o a dirty and cleaned image. o a diagnostic window including your input the simulated image

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ In one command, CASA generates o uv data (with thermal noise if desired) o a dirty and cleaned image. o a diagnostic window including your input the simulated image the difference uv coverage and dirty beam or PSF

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Proto-planetary disk (band 9) Skymodel Early Science Full Array (30 mins) (10 mins) E. Van Kampen

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ M51-type galaxy (band 9) Skymodel ES (30 min) ES (4h) Full 2 km array (30 min) Full 2 km array (4h) Full 6 km array (4h) More details on Wednesday

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The ALMA Regional Centres The European ARC

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ A Guide to the European ARC

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The European ARC Core functions –Scientific support: Proposal & observation preparation user support –Archive Operations: host a copy, data delivery –Astronomer on duty at OSF –Science community activity –User support: f2f help Non-core functions Data reduction –Advanced pipeline –Extended archive support –Support for special projects –Science community activity: training, schools, workshops ESO: ARC Department ARC nodes ESO ARC + nodes ARC nodes ALMA simulators

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The role of the central node ESO) Participation to Commissioning Science Verification (2years) Support the European users from proposal preparations to data delivery through the helpdesk Validation of the Scheduling Blocks Help in the technical assessment of the proposals Provide help to the proposal handling team Host and maintain a complete mirror of the ALMA archive Delivered pipelined, calibrated data Provide duties at the OSF during observations Manage the ARC nodes 46

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The ESO ARC staff ARC Astronomers: Scientific user support (proposal, SB, OSF duties, technical assessment, proposal handling) Help in managing the nodes ARC Astronomers: Scientific user support (proposal, SB, OSF duties, technical assessment, proposal handling) Help in managing the nodes ARC scientists Helpdesk, SW testing and implementation, SW feedback, archive queries ARC scientists Helpdesk, SW testing and implementation, SW feedback, archive queries Archive operations (system administration, data delivery, database) 7 astronomers 5 scientists 5 contractors

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The role of the ARC nodes Provide one to one user support (proposal, SBs preparation, data reduction, archive research) Participate in the helpdesk Scientific community development New software and techniques Advanced data reduction Public relations and outreach

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ The ARC nodes: staff Bonn-Bochum-Cologne, Germany (F. Bertoldi) Current staff: Bonn: 2 staff astronomers (part-time 25-50%), 1 postdoc, IT support; Cologne: 4 staff astronomers (part time 5-10%); Bochum: 3 staff astronomers (part time 30%) + 2 COFUND Fellows Bologna, Italy, (J. Brand) Current staff: 5 staff astronomers (part-time), 3 postdocs, 1 technician, IT support, 1 staff position advertised + 1 COFUND Fellow Onsala, Denmark, Sweden, Finland (J. Conway) Current staff: 1 staff astronomers (at 30%), 1 astronomer + 1 SW engineer, maybe 1 more position IRAM, Grenoble, France, Spain, Germany (F. Gueth) Current staff: 5 IRAM staff share the task ALMA/PdB support (10-50 %) 1 postdoc, + 3 SW engineer + 1 COFUND Fellows Leiden, The Netherlands, (M. Hogerheijde) Current staff: 2 staff astronomers (part-time) + 2 postdocs, + 1 COFUND Fellow Manchester, United Kingdom (T. Muxlow) Current staff: 4 staff astronomers (10-50%), 1 staff 100%, + 1 COFUND Fellow Ondřejov, Czech Republic (M. Karlický) Current staff: 4 staff astronomers (10-50%), 1 SW engineer, IT support, 2 postdoc

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ User support and helpdesk ARC nodes: f2f support, helpdesk, SW feedback, community activity

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ the EU ARC High-frequency observing Wide-field and high-dynamic-range imaging Molecular spectroscopy, catalogues, models Polarimetry Astrometry Multi-frequency synthesis Array combination imaging Solar physics Allegro Allegro (NL) IRAM/UK/ IRAM/UK/NL DE/CZ/ DE/CZ/NL IRAM/UK/ IRAM/UK/DE/I Nordic/UK/ Nordic/UK/DE Nordic/UKNordic/UK CZCZ UKUK

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Current Timeline Start of CSV (Commissioning and Science Verification): Jan 2010 (3 antennas at the AOS) ESDP (Early Science Decision Point): Nov 2010 (Board meeting) –Mirror Archives in place –ALMA User Portal activated –ALMA Helpdesk activated Deadline for proposals (2011 Q2) –PRC review procedure initiated Deadline for PRC final ranking (Autumn 2011) –Preparation of SBs Start Early Science: Autumn 2011 –Take and deliver data Inauguration: September 2012 –More than 50 fully equipped antennas Baseline ALMA Construction Complete 2013 by the Call for Proposals (Q1 2011) by the Call for Proposals (Q1 2011)

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Early Science Operations Start Science Operations before the ALMA construction finishes Minimum requirements for Early Science Goals for Early Science Early Science Operations: two cycles (0 & 1) –Cycle 0: 8 months scheduling period –Cycle 1: One year scheduling period –Time shared with commissioning. At most 33% of available time will be dedicated to ES observations.

ALMA Early Science, IRAM Grenoble 29/11-1/ Questions?Questions?