|Date 19-06-2013 Market failure Market failure in the Amsterdam office investment market Henk J. Brouwer 1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter 6 Office & Industrial Property. Major Topics Real Estate Principles for the New Economy: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Office Property.
Advertisements

State Housing Needs 1. Housing Needs and Community Economic Vitality are Intertwined Economic conditions drive housing need and demand. Unaddressed housing.
Chapter 2 What drives Real Estate Markets?
Chapter 1 The Nature of Real Estate and Real Estate Markets Real Estate FIN 331.
Alain Bertaud Urbanist Module 1: Introduction and the Context The role of, government, urban planners and markets.
Understanding the Concept of Present Value
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Chapter 5 Residential Market Analysis.
Introduction and the Context The Use and value of Urban Planning.
Prime versus Secondary Real Estate – No guts No glory Taking Calculated Risks Berry, JN 1 ; Lim, LC 1 ; and Sieracki, KA 2 1 University of Ulster, Built.
Executive Summary 1 Market Overview 2 Demand Analysis 3 Supply Analysis 4 Site Analysis 5 Conclusion 6 MARKET ANALYSIS.
UNDERSTANDING THE DUTCH MARKET FOR INDUSTRIAL AREAS with System Dynamics Modeling ERES conference Eindhoven 2011 Session: Market Research, Analysis and.
CONCEPTS of VALUE. FACTORS OF VALUE UTILITY –THE ABILITY OF A PRODUCT TO SATISFY HUMAN WANTS. RELATES TO THE DAMAND SIDE OF THE MARKET. SCARCITY –THE.
© University of Reading 2006www.reading.ac. uk June 1, 2015 Can Australia build a way out of its affordability problems? Lessons from the UK Geoffrey Meen.
Presentation Valuation Methodology in Russia Chris Dryden Regional Valuations Director.
1 A closer look at property investment returns July 2010.
© Henley Business School 2008www.henley.reading.ac.uk Real Estate & Planning Property Markets and Urban Development: A Case Study of Central Area Office.
Chapter 6 Risk and Term Structure of Interest Rates.
Chapter 10 Market Efficiency.
Basic Tools of Finance Finance is the field that studies how people make decisions regarding the allocation of resources over time and the handling of.
Immigration as a Supply Side Policy.
Baltic Real Estate Markets‘ Dynamics Dr. Ieva Kvedaravičienė, MRICS ISM University of Management and Economics 1.
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Chapter 11 Introduction to Investment Concepts.
Agglomeration Economies & Global Cities: the case of London, New York & relativity Lynne Michael London ERES Conference Istanbul June
Supply and Demand in the Space Market
The Housing Market. Content Housing market Regional differences in house prices Changes in pattern of housing tenure Market failure and government intervention.
Understanding Real Estate Markets Chapter 8. Market The mechanism through which goods and services are traded between market participants.
Basics of Valuation By Norm Miller, PhD. Introduction  Value as a concept is theoretical in nature  PRICE is usually factual in nature  Value by nature.
Yield Curves and Term Structure Theory. Yield curve The plot of yield on bonds of the same credit quality and liquidity against maturity is called a yield.
Growth of the Economy And Cyclical Instability
Last Study Topics What Is A Corporation? - All large and medium-sized businesses are organized as corporations. The Role of The Financial Manager - Capital.
Future Direction of the Property Market in Hong Kong & Macau Nicholas Brooke, FRICS FHKIS Chairman, Professional Property Services 5 June 2007.
1 Chapter 10 Equity Valuation Tools Portfolio Construction, Management, & Protection, 5e, Robert A. Strong Copyright ©2009 by South-Western, a division.
Property Particulars BUCHAREST REAL ESTATE MARKET.
1 RESEARCH PAPER: DUTCH RESIDENTIAL INVESTMENTS IN EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE.
Return, Income, Value and Capitalization Learning objectives: –Understand the meaning of investment decision making. –Understand the role of the appraisal.
Financial Liberalisation In New Zealand The Impact on Savings and Investment Phillip Mellor.
Global Research and Consulting European Investment Briefing Presented by: Michael Haddock, Director, EMEA Research & Consulting 05/10/2010.
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Real Estate QUIZMASTER DefinitionsAnalyticalNumericalMiscellaneousPotpourri.
Fair Value Measurement By: Associate Professor Dr. GholamReza Zandi
Chapter 12 Jones, Investments: Analysis and Management
Chapter 12: Sales Comparison Approach. The Sales Comparison Approach is Useful When:  An active market exists  Comparable sale are highly similar to.
CHAPTER 4 INTEREST RATES. Copyright© 2003 John Wiley and Sons, Inc. What are Interest Rates? Cost of borrowing or the return on lending Price of money.
European Real Estate Society Annual Conference Vienna 2013 The City of London Office Bias by Stephen Lee Cass Business School, City University London.
NH Legislature: NH Real Estate Update January 2010 Russ Thibeault Applied Economic Research Research Support Provided By:
Chapter 9 - Cost of Capital Concept of the Cost of Capital Computing a Firm’s Cost of Capital Cost of Individual Sources of Capital Optimal Capital Structure.
The Theory of Capital Markets Rational Expectations and Efficient Markets.
©2014 OnCourse Learning. All Rights Reserved. CHAPTER 1 Chapter 1 Real Estate Space and Asset Markets SLIDE 1.
Understanding Real Estate Markets Regional and Community Analysis Community Growth Patterns Neighborhoods Housing markets Commercial and Industrial markets.
Chapter 15 McGraw-Hill/IrwinCopyright © 2010 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
©2014 OnCourse Learning. All Rights Reserved. CHAPTER 6 Chapter 6 Real Estate Market Analysis SLIDE 1.
Investment Analysis One Lincoln Street Molly Ekerdt Debmalya Guha Laurie Tamis.
. Chapter Ten Lessons from capital market history Copyright  2011 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd PPTs to accompany Fundamentals of Corporate Finance 5e,
For Investment Professionals Only The importance of looking at real returns Presented by Fiona Barwick Director of Regional Research Mondrian Investment.
The Nature of Real Estate and Real Estate Markets Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Specialty Asset Concentrations Understanding the Whole Picture 1.
BARTRAM & COCHRAN Real Estate Math for Attorneys Marc Louargand, Ph.D., CRE ®, FRICS & Maura Cochran, CRE ®
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Real Estate QUIZMASTER DefinitionsAnalyticalNumericalThe.
LEARN ABOUT THE PROCESSES OF SAVING AND INVESTING YOUR MONEY AND SOUND FINANCIAL PLANING Savings and Investment Planning.
Lecture 2 Capital Markets, EMH & Valuation Investment Analysis.
CHAPTER 4 BOND PRICES, BOND YIELDS, AND INTEREST RATE RISK.
Chapter 10 Market Efficiency.
Chapter 8 Understanding Real Estate Markets. Chapter 8  Real Estate Space Market  Real Estate Asset Market  Market Analysis.
© Farebrother All rights reserved. Farebrother CORFAC International affiliate for the United Kingdom.
Why is there positive interest? Why is the interest rate > zero?
Efficiency frontier and matching process on the labor market: Evidence from Tunisia Imed DRINE United Nations University World Institute for Development.
Aggregate Supply What is aggregate supply? Short run aggregate supply
Facts about Business in Stockholm Content  Economy  Business Sector  Workforce and Population  Infrastructure In this publication the Stockholm.
Alternative Investments
Commercial Real Estate Why the is in More Demand?.
Ways to Monetize From a Commercial Real Estate Property
Presentation transcript:

|Date Market failure Market failure in the Amsterdam office investment market Henk J. Brouwer 1

|Date The problem (1) ›Market failure is a situation when free markets fail to allocate scarce resources efficiently ›This is the case in the Amsterdam office market: ›High long-term office vacancy rates ›In many suburban areas 25% or even more ›Construction of new offices continues 2

|Date The problem (2) ›Money is invested in new offices, while existing offices do not yield expected returns ›Clearly waste of capital ›Hypothesis: market failure related to lack of efficiency in the office investment market ›We will try to substantiate this hypothesis 3

|Date The problem (3) ›KPMG (47,000 m2) 4

|Date Efficiency (1) ›Market failure is a fact, inefficient investment market most probable explanation ›Efficiency of markets refers to how rapidly information is reflected in prices ›Real estate is a long-term investment, so analysis of the future is important 5

|Date Efficiency (2) ›Rational investors will use their knowledge of the property market, the wider economy and the best available theories of how the two function and interrelate (Ball et al, 1998) ›Actual market situation should result in adjustment of common expectations ›This is not readily visible in investment market ›So, investment market is not fully efficient 6

|Date Recent history (1) ›Strong employment growth in Amsterdam region in ›During ‘Golden Years’ ( ) more new employment was created than in the preceding twenty years 7

|Date Recent history (2) ›Office construction boom from ›In 1999/2000 construction of more than 1m m2 of new offices started ›Overall, in five years ( ) a third added to the office stock 8

|Date Recent history (3) ›In 1999, actual availability of office space close to zero ›In 2001, it was believed that high demand for offices was structural ›Risk of insufficient capacity for office construction ›Rezoning from mixed use to office park ›Planning studies for underused land announced 9

|Date Recent history (4) ›Today, overall vacancy 20% ›In many suburban areas over 25% ›Structural vacancy is persistent, in spite of removals and transformation ›However, vacancy concentrated in older offices (i.e. offices that have been used before) 10

|Date Vacancy

|Date Vacancy (2) ›Following the end of the ‘Golden Years’ and completion of offices started in 1999/2000, vacancy soared › In complete divergence of markets of newly built and older offices 12

|Date Vacancy (3) ›Supply of new offices triggered demand ›Net take-up much lower than gross demand: from 2000 to 2010, net take-up of offices was only 15% of gross demand ›Demand for new offices results in vacancy of older properties 13

|Date The consequences (1) ›Partition of the market into primary and secondary segments ›Primary market fully marketable ›Secondary market often difficult to let on conventional terms ›Offices can move to secondary segment after only five to ten years 14

|Date The consequences (2) ›Major adjustment of reasonable expectations necessary ›In 1999/2000/2001: strong demand for offices, low vacancy rate, shortages more probable than oversupply ›Recently: many offices will be in primary market for 5-10 years and then move to secondary market with lower rents and higher vacancy rates 15

|Date The consequences (3) 16

|Date The consequences (4) ›The space market is efficient, as the market segmentation is being reflected in rents ›Pronounced adjustment in rental difference between new and older offices from 2004 to 2008 ›Difference not yet sufficient to create equivalence 17

|Date Expectations ›Trends, as analysed before, can continue: strong preferences for new buildings, high supply elasticity ›Are reasonable expectations, based on current trends, included in investment yields? ›Difficult to know exactly ›We have no more than a summary of the trends on the investment market (figures from JLL) 18

|Date Office yields

|Date Analysis of yields (1) ›When should adjustment of expectations have taken place? ›It is more than simple information ›Understanding of market processes necessary ›Market participants have to appreciate underlying process, resulting in market segmentation 20

|Date Analysis of yields (2) ›Split of market as shown by diverging vacancy rates and prices takes place between 2004 and 2008 ›Yields record low in 2006 and 2007 in line with comparable cities ›Yields in Amsterdam start to remain higher as from

|Date Analysis of yields (3) ›Yield difference with Munich and Stockholm lowest in 2006/2007: 45 bps ›Rising to 75 bps in 2010 and even 115 bps in 2012 ›Tentative conclusion: investment markets adjust to changed conditions, but with several years delay 22

|Date Explanation (1) ›German investors major buyers on Dutch office market ›They were the first to spot opportunities in Amsterdam after 1994 ›Since 1995, they account for 35% of office investments in The Netherlands ›Estimated market share in Amsterdam area 50% 23

|Date Explanation (2) ›German funds invest on behalf of multitude of small private investors ›Ultimate investor lacks insight in markets ›Funds feel pressure to invest ›Geltner, Miller et al (2007): duress can result in market inefficiency 24

|Date Explanation (3) ›Alternative analysis in recent report by CBRE: high vacancy rates in peripheral submarkets are common in other cities as well ›However, this argument fails to consider that in Amsterdam peripheral areas with high supply elasticity account for 75% of the market 25

|Date Explanation (4) ›Vacancy rates 26 RegionCBDHighest submarket Munich 2.1%16% Stockholm 4.6%12.8% Brussels 6.9%28.6% Amsterdam 7.2%28.6% Hamburg 8.1%16.4% Frankfurt11.9%35.8%

|Date Conclusion ›Market failure is a fact: waste of capital in office market ›Lack of efficiency in office investment market is plausible ›More research into market processes is important ›Other points of interest: location patterns and supply elasticity 27