FACULTY OF MEDICINE The use of Cochrane breast cancer reviews by guideline developers and Cochrane (public) users Cochrane Breast Cancer Group, NHMRC Clinical.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

The Cochrane Library. What is The Cochrane Library? The Cochrane Library offers high-quality evidence for health care decision making

Advertisements

UK Clinical Research Network (UKCRN) UK Clinical Research Network Maxine Stead PhD UKCRN Assistant Director – Clinical Trials.

WoSCAN CPD GROUP CRITICAL APPRAISAL RESOURCE GUIDE JULY 2007.

Research article structure: Where can reporting guidelines help? Iveta Simera The EQUATOR Network workshop.

©American Society of Clinical Oncology All rights reserved - American.

Prioritisation workshop: how can we meet the Strategy to 2020 target and what does it mean for individual review groups? DAVID TOVEY, RUTH FOXLEE AND SERA.

An introduction to the Cancer Learning website An initiative of Cancer Australia.

Building the Digital Infrastructure for Vermont’s Learning Health System ONC HIT Policy Committee Testimony September 14, 2011 Hunt Blair, Deputy Commissioner.

The Cochrane Library Via Wiley InterScience Or OVID Evidence-Based Medical Reviews Angela Murrell Outreach and Instruction Librarian

Finding the Best Evidence Literature for Evidence Based Health Care.

Participation Requirements for a Guideline Panel PGIN Representative.

Living with and beyond treatment for cancer – the challenge for secondary care Nigel Acheson Medical Director Peninsula Cancer Network.

European collaboration to identify reports of controlled trials in general and specialized health care journals published in Western Europe Gerd Antes.

Accessing Sources Of Evidence For Practice Introduction To Databases Karen Smith Department of Health Sciences University of York.

Nursing Research Council © 2008 ABC’s of EBP Easy Exchanges in Evidence Based Practice Education Session IV: February 2008.

NCCN and NCCN Clinical Practice Guidelines in Oncology™

Diabetes Programme Progress Report Dr Charles Gostling, Joint Diabetes Clinical Director October 2013.

American Medical Association Journals include: JAMA (journal of the American Medical Association.), Archives of surgery, Archives of ophthalmology and.

Mary S. McCabe Survivorship Care Planning. National Directions Focus on recurrence Increasing expectations by patients and families Identification of.

Research in the Health Sciences Kerry Sullivan, MLIS Health Sciences Librarian February 2010.

Critical Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines

How to Overcome Barriers and Develop Collaborative Guidelines Amir Qaseem, MD, PhD, MHA, FACP Chair, Guidelines International Network Director, Clinical.

The Bahrain Branch of the UK Cochrane Centre In Collaboration with Reyada Training & Management Consultancy, Dubai-UAE Cochrane Collaboration and Systematic.

PICOT (PATIENT-INTERVENTION- COMPARISON-OUTCOME-TIME) EBP-----FNP Tips for Literature Review and Research Proposal.

Evidence based nursing practice resources By Dr. Hanan Said Ali.

Implementing a Provincial Cancer Performance Measurement Program in Saskatchewan, Canada 4 th International Cancer Control Congress November 2011 Riaz.

BREAST HEALTH GLOBAL INITIATIVE(BHGI) SUPPORTIVE CARE GUIDELINES& THEIR ROLE IN ADVOCACY : The Uganda Experience Gertrude Nakigudde Patient Advocate Uganda.

THE COCHRANE LIBRARY ON WILEY INTERSCIENCE. Presentation Agenda Brief introduction of Evidence-Based Medicine theories The Cochrane Collaboration – origins,

Peggy Cruse and Shandra Protzko Library & Knowledge Services, National Jewish Health COLLABORATING TO PRODUCE SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS 1.

Norwegian electronic health library ICOLC Philadelphia, March 2006 Kjell Tjensvoll, Norwegian Knowledge Centre for the Health Services.

Delivering Knowledge for Health Self-Management and Rehabilitation MKN: Overview October 2008.

Evidence Based Medicine Meta-analysis and systematic reviews Ross Lawrenson.

Introduction to the Cochrane Ear, Nose and Throat Disorders Group Cochrane Colloquium, Madrid, Spain October 2011.

Core Outcome Domains for Eczema – Results of a Delphi Consensus Project Introduction Eczema is a chronic, relapsing, inflammatory skin disorder that affects.

Janine Margarita R. Dizon, PhD Research Supervisor Center for Health Research and Movement.

TEACH: LEVEL II – CLINICAL POLICIES AND GUIDELINES STREAM TEACH Plenary NYAM August 8 th, 2012 Craig A Umscheid, MD, MSCE, FACP Assistant Professor of.

Prostate Cancer Coalition of NC A statewide collaborative effort by concerned organizations and individuals to support awareness, early detection, and.

The KU Wichita Center for Breast Cancer Survivorship Judy Johnston, MS, RD/LD Research Instructor Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health,

BMH CLINICAL GUIDELINES IN EUROPE. OUTLINE Background to the project Objectives The AGREE Instrument: validation process and results Outcomes.

NICE - in evidence based commissioning Gateshead Council Gillian Mathews, Implementation Consultant - North 9 September 2011.

Cochrane Injuries Group. About the Cochrane Injuries Group What does the CIG do? Who makes up the CIG? What injury prevention research does the CIG do?

1 How to find literature - A very short introduction - How to start smart Students IIC/IID Medical Library, August 2013.

Evaluation, Trials and Studies Coordinating Centre Developing Sight Loss and Vision research questions: a funder’s perspective Anna Tallant Scientific.

Plenary III: There is No Health Without Mental Health.

From the Advanced Search page of the Cochrane Library, we have clicked on the Cochrane Reviews: By Topic hyperlink. This has displayed the Topics for Cochrane.

5 July 2012Ganesha Associates1 Basic Skills for Scientific Research and Publishing. Segment 1. Introduction to the course.

Trusted evidence. Informed decisions. Better health. Cochrane_QuickRefBooklet.indd 114/8/15 5:41 pm.

Research article structure: Where can reporting guidelines help? Iveta Simera The EQUATOR Network workshop 10 October 2012, Freiburg, Germany.

The Bahrain Branch of the UK Cochrane Centre In Collaboration with Reyada Training & Management Consultancy, Dubai-UAE Cochrane Collaboration and Systematic.

From the initial page of the Cochrane Library, we have clicked on the Cochrane Reviews: By Topic hyperlink. This has displayed the Topics for Cochrane.

Evidence Based Practice (EBP) Riphah College of Rehabilitation Sciences(RCRS) Riphah International University Islamabad.

Compliance at the Crossroads: How can the Compliance Profession Move to the Second Generation? A Practical Approach to Integrating Compliance, Risk and.

Date of download: 5/27/2016 From: Treatment of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: A Systematic Review for a National Institutes of Health.

PREPARED BY The New Zealand Cancer Nurse Coordinator Initiative Natalie James National Nurse Lead May 2013.

Automated QA at Breast Cancer Rounds – A process to improve efficiency and quality of patient care Dr. Kathy Rock Breast Cancer Clinical Fellow Rock K,

Sources of systematic reviews Arash Etemadi, MD PhD Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Tehran University of Medical Sciences.

Publication patterns in public involvement: A bibliometric review of the literature on public involvement in health research published between

The efficacy of interventions to improve psychosocial outcomes following surgical treatment for breast cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis Hannah.

Research4Life Programmes: Similarities and Differences!

Professional Development in Psycho-oncology in Ireland-

Systematic Review, Synthesis, & Clinical Practice Guidelines

The publication gap in years for the cumulative percent of cited research papers in the ESMO and the UK overall cancer clinical guidelines, with the difference.

The contribution of research papers by cancer application site on the two sets of cancer clinical practice guidelines, in comparison with the corresponding.

The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) flow chart summarising the process for the identification of eligible studies.

Flow chart of the used methodology adapted from Moher et al

ASCO/NCODA Oral Chemotherapy Dispensing Standards Initiative

Gender representation of board members in all international societies (reference year: 2016). Gender representation of board members in all international.

How to organize a journal club?

Ovid User Training -Medline-

Presentation transcript:

FACULTY OF MEDICINE The use of Cochrane breast cancer reviews by guideline developers and Cochrane (public) users Cochrane Breast Cancer Group, NHMRC Clinical Trials Centre ML Willson, D O’Connell, A Goodwin, N Wilcken

Setting the scene ›A scoping exercise ›Increasing volume of trial data available (Bastian et al, PLoS Medicine 2010) ›Utility of systematic reviews: -can guide treatment decisions -part of the research evidence component of clinical practice guidelines ›Aim: -assess Cochrane review usage by clinical guidelines and our readers 2

Cochrane Breast Cancer Group: producers of Cochrane (systematic) Reviews ›Established in 1996 ›Search for evidence, evaluate its quality and publish results as Cochrane Reviews ›Published in an online database and available via The Cochrane Library ›Reviews known to be methodologically rigorous ›Over 88 Protocols, Reviews and Titles ›Sometimes integrated into clinical practice guidelines 3

Cochrane Breast Cancer Group: Review portfolio 4 ›Topics are decided upon by an international, multidisciplinary Editorial Board

Cochrane Breast Cancer Group: metrics ›Publishers provided a short list of 8 ‘most cited’ + top 10 ‘most accessed ’ ›13 of the 18 ‘most cited/accessed’ Review topics covered: -Prevention, early detection, familial breast cancer, allied health (ie exercise), psychosocial care, complementary therapy, lymphoedema ›5 of the 18 covered treatments -Chemo- and targeted therapy, radiation and surgery 5

Specific aims 1.Assess the uptake of Cochrane breast cancer Reviews in clinical practice guidelines 2.Compare ‘most cited/accessed’ Reviews to those used in guidelines 6

Methods: guideline selection & basic metrics ›Selected 7 key clinical guideline developers or consensus panels: 1.Advanced Breast Cancer Consensus (ABC1) 2.American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) 3.Cancer Australia (CA) 4.Central European Cooperative Oncology Group (CECOG) 5.European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) 6.National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) 7.Scottish Intercollegiate Guideline Network (SIGN) ›Published from 2001 to March 2014 ›For each guideline, recorded: 1.Number and title of Cochrane Review citations 2.Scope of guideline ›Categorised Cochrane Review usage for each guideline developer ›Compared Reviews in guidelines to ‘most cited/accessed’ Reviews 7

Results: no. and scope of guidelines ›28 guidelines included, published July 2001 to July

Results: Cochrane Review usage 9

Results: Cochrane Review usage over time 10 Cumulative no. of guidelines + Cochrane Reviews in guidelines

Results: most cited/accessed in guidelines 11

Results: summary 1.An increase in Cochrane review uptake in guidelines over time -Variation in Cochrane review citations by guideline developers 2.An overlap with Reviews used in guidelines and ‘most cited/accessed’ Reviews -10 of 18 ‘most cited/accessed’ Reviews were used once or more than once 3.Slight disconnect -8 of 18 ‘most cited/accessed’ Reviews were not used -i.e. peripheral topics 12

Limits, discussion, future implications ›A preliminary assessment; small sample (n=28) ›Room to improve communications with guideline developers about upcoming guideline topics ›Identified some gaps in our Topics list that will need to be addressed ›‘Most cited/read’ reviews tended to be on peripheral topics (e.g. exercise) ›Results provide a useful baseline for monitoring the use of our Cochrane reviews 13

Acknowledgements ›A/Prof Nicholas Wilcken (Joint Co-ordinating Editor) ›Dr Annabel Goodwin (Joint Co-ordinating Editor) ›Prof Dianne O’Connell (Statistical Editor) ›Cochrane Breast Cancer Group funders: -National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) -National Breast Cancer Foundation (Australia) ›Supported by: -NHMRC Clinical Trials Centre, University of Sydney 14

Backup slides