©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Transmission Planning & Construction “When, Where, How Much and Who Pays” -Comments by Fred.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

The Midwest ISO from a Transmission Owner Perspective.

Advertisements

Regional Transmission Organizations: A Primer

AN INTRODUCTION TO THE MIDWEST ISO By Bill Malcolm Manager-State Regulatory Affairs Pierre, South Dakota June 9, 2006.

BOSTON DALLAS DENVER LOS ANGELES MENLO PARK MONTREAL NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO WASHINGTON Renewables in the Northeast Local Opportunities, National Context.

Queue Reform at the Midwest ISO NARUC February, 2008.

1 Dale Osborn Midwest ISO March 17, 2008 Detroit, Michigan Great Lake Regional Wind Institute Introduction to the Midwest ISO.

Citizens League Electrical Energy: Affordability and Competitive Pricing Working Team Electric Transmission.

Regional Transmission Organizations: The Future of Transmission? Dave Edwards 4/17/2004.

1 Dale Osborn Midwest ISO February 27, Wisconsin Renewable Energy Summit Transmission Expansion Opportunities with Wind Energy.

Electric Utility Basics An overview of the electric industry in New England and the operation of consumer-owned utilities 1.

The Continuing Evolution of U.S. Electricity Markets

Sue Sheridan President and Chief Counsel Coalition for Fair Transmission Policy EEI Transmission and Distribution Conference April 2012 TRANSMISSION PLANNING.

BOSTON CHICAGO DALLAS DENVER LOS ANGELES MENLO PARK MONTREAL NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO WASHINGTON Governors’ Wind Energy Coalition November, 2011 Competitive.

Infrastructure, Regulators and Utilities in the World of RTOs and Electricity Markets Steve Gaw, Commissioner, Missouri Public Service Commission President.

The Potential for Increased Cooperation on Offshore Wind among the Northeast States Warren Leon, Executive Director.

Eastern Wind Integration and Transmission Study

Eastern Wind Integration and Transmission Study Overview January 28 th Webinar Dave Corbus National Wind Technology Center National Renewable Energy Lab.

ISO New England Regional Update Wholesale Electricity Markets & State Energy Policy Seminar Connecticut Business & Industry Association December 14, 2010.

ISO Grid Planning Presentation to CREPC October 1, 2002

The Value of Electric Transmission NASUCA Mid-Year Meeting June 25, 2012.

PJM© PJM Confidential PJM Generation Interconnection Overview Virginia Offshore Wind Conference Virginia Beach June 22, 2011 Paul McGlynn General.

Need for Transmission Investment 2010 Mid-American Regulatory Conference AEP.

EDP Renewables North America Massachusetts Wind Working Group March 15, 2013.

Bruce Edelston President, Energy Policy Group and Executive Director, Coalition for Fair Transmission Policy Restructuring Today Webinar August 8, 2012.

Eagle Crest Energy Company February Page 2 New Hydro: Making it Happen Background on the Eagle Mountain Pumped Storage Project Need for Eagle.

Southwest Renewable Energy Transmission Conference May 21, 2010 Jeff Mechenbier Director Transmission & Distribution Planning and Contracts.

Retail Competition: Managing a Difficult Transition David L. O’Connor Commissioner Massachusetts Division of Energy Resources (DOER) Presentation to National.

The Council of State Governments Eastern Regional Conference Gordon van Welie, President and CEO, ISO New England August 16, 2010 Portland, Maine.

BUILDING THE NEXT ERA OF CLEAN ENERGY 2010 Mid-America Regulatory Conference - Integrating Renewables to the Grid F. Allen Wiley Vice President, Business.

1 Capacity Markets Investment in Generation Capacity Payments October 31, 2005 J. W. Charlton.

Transmission for a 33% RPS Keith E. Casey Vice President Market and Infrastructure Development California ISO The Independent Energy Producers Association.

1 The Costs of Participating in Restructured Wholesale Markets American Public Power Association February 5, 2007 William M. Bateman Robert C. Smith.

RENEWABLE ENERGY MANDATES: HOW DO THEY WORK AND WHO PAYS? Barbara R. Alexander Consumer Affairs Consultant 83 Wedgewood Dr. Winthrop, ME (207)

The New Balance: Environment and Energy Robert Ruddock The Massachusetts Biotechnology Council Law and Policy Committee July 9 th, 2009.

Transmission Planning Informational Workshop Montpelier, VT September 19, 2005 Allocating the Cost of New Transmission in New England Stephen J. Rourke.

Integrating More Renewable Energy in the Grid Bert Garvin Vice President, Regulatory Affairs July 21, 2008 NARUC Summer Meeting July 22, 2008.

1 Clean Line Energy National Association of State Utility Consumer Advocates Charleston SC Annual Meeting June 2012.

California Transmission Planning Group Collaborative approach to State-wide Transmission Planning.

Dale Osborn Midwest ISO October 13, 2008 EE 590 Transmission Planning with Significant Energy Resources.

John Norden, Manager, Renewable Resource Integration ISO New England Inc NASUCA Mid-Year Meeting June 30, 2009 Roadmap to Renewable Integration in.

1 NAUSCA Summer Meeting Boston June 30, 3009 David W. Hadley Vice President State Regulatory Relations Midwest ISO.

FERC Staff’s Report on Demand Response and Advanced Metering.

Eastern Wind Integration and Transmission Study David Corbus - Project Manager Matt Schuerger (Consultant) National Wind Technology Center NREL Golden,

Bob Cupit Manager, Energy Facility Permitting Minnesota Public Utilities Commission.

Bringing Energy Forward LS Power Presentation to the Organization of PJM States, Inc. 11 th Annual Meeting Sharon K. Segner, Vice President October 2015.

1 Rate Impact Task Force’s Updated Results for it’s Report to the SPP Regional State Committee January 24, 2011.

1 Integrating Wind Energy into the Electric Grid Wind Power Forum October 26, 2011 Brian Conroy, Electric System Engineering Central Maine Power Company.

Lessons Learned from Existing RTOs John Moore January WCEA Meeting January 7 th, 2016.

Energy Markets at the Crossroads Illinois State University Institute for Regulatory Policy Studies 12 December 2002 Springfield, Illinois Vito Stagliano.

Multi-State Clean Energy RFP 1 To explore whether a multi-state procurement might attract larger-scale projects and transmission than single state procurements.

Click to edit master title style The Regional Energy Challenge for ACEC/NHDOT April 7, 2016.

SPP.org 1. Regional and Inter-Regional Planning Update Entergy Transmission Summit July 29, 2008 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans, Louisiana.

1 Progress of Market Integration in North America W. Scott Miller, III Executive Director, Market Applications PJM Interconnection, L.L.C.

Future 2 Soft Constraints Transfer Limit Hardening By the NEEM-TX Subteam SSC Meeting June 6, 2011.

Alliance Update Illinois Commerce Commission Electric Policy Committee July 10, 2001.

Restructuring Roundtable June 12, 2009 Dave Boguslawski Vice President – Transmission Strategy & Operations Northeast Utilities.

Wind Development in an Evolving Power Market

New England’s Growing Thirst for Renewables East Coast Energy Connection 2016 Patrick Woodcock Director, Maine Energy Office.

Patrick Smith, Vice President

First Wind Northeast Transmission Overview

Transmission As Enabler

Clair Moeller Mid-Continent ISO

Panel II - Future of Competitive Transmission in the PJM Footprint December 1, 2016 Chip Richardson – PPL Electric Utilities.

New England Economic Partnership James Daly Vice President Energy Supply Energy Market Perspectives Reliable Energy, Competitive Prices and.

The Role of Hydro-Québec in New England Electric Markets The New England Electricity Restructuring Roundtable June 14, 2013 Stephen Molodetz, Vice.

Creating Benefits for New England: Putting the Pieces Together

Gordon van Welie, President & Chief Executive Officer

Current New Hampshire Cost-Effectiveness Test

Offshore Wind Transmission Prepared for PJM Roundtable

Creating Benefits for New England: Putting the Pieces Together

Presentation transcript:

©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Transmission Planning & Construction “When, Where, How Much and Who Pays” -Comments by Fred Plett, -Utility Analyst

Page 2 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 Joint Coordinated System Plan Midwest ISO, TVA, SPP, PJM, MAPP, NYISO, and ISO-NE 20% wind scenario Transmission Dakotas to the Northeast $80 Billion 2024 Benefit – Cost Ratio of 1.0!! If wind projects get built Transmission cost may be 3-4 times higher!

Page 3 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 Testimony in Favor ITC Holdings, Inc - Green Power Express Energy Futures Coalition - JCSP studies, 3-1 BC Ratio FERC Chair Wellinghoff Subcommittee on Energy & Environment The Future of the Grid: Proposals for Reforming National Transmission Policy

Page 4 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 New England Transmission Renewables in Northern NH and ME Northern New England View Economic Development Opportunity Socialized Rate-Based Transmission Costs Massachusetts View “Build it and they will come” not Desirable Giant Generator Interconnect Generator Responsible Costs Certain, Benefits Not

Page 5 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 Hydro-Québec TransÉnergie, NU and NSTAR HVDC Model Des Cantons, Québec - NH US portion built by NU and NSTAR Cost of Service Recovery from HQ US Hydropower Sale to include Transmission Cost 25 Year Transmission, Purchase Agreements All – In Cost Must Be Competitive!

Page 6 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 Local vs. Midwest 100 – 250 Miles vs. 1,800 Miles! Same Discussions - Who Pays, Who Benefits Costs Certain, Benefits Conditional – But Costs Likely Lower Locally

Page 7 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 Distances

Page 8 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 Discussion Requirements Bottom Up Planning Stakeholder Input and Acceptance Proven Benefit Cost Ratio Purchase Power Agreements Performance Warranties All-In Costs must Benefit Consumers!

Page 9 ©2009 Office of Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley Fred Plett Presentation to NASUCA June 30, 2009 Project Cost Control Helps Ensure Positive Benefit Cost Ratios Projects get built, may go into formula rates (non-Merchant projects) Should FERC be more aggressive in Prudence Reviews?