Meaningful Surface Analysis Dr. Charles A. Doswell III Doswell Scientific Consulting – Norman, Oklahoma Lubbock Severe Weather Conference Lubbock, Texas.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Section 12.4 – Weather Analysis and Prediction
Advertisements

Mid-Latitude Cyclones: Vertical Structure
SO441 Synoptic Meteorology Fronts Lesson 8: Weeks Courtesy: Lyndon State College.
The HPC Surface Desk M. Sean Ryan NOAA/NCEP/Hydrometeorological Prediction Center 1.
Midlatitude cyclones. Identify and describe the North American air masses that influence the weather patterns for Lexington Differentiate between frontal.
Thunderstorm Ingredients ©Oklahoma Climatological Survey EarthStorm 2009.
Warm Season Frontogenesis Forcing Applications and Implications for Convective Initiation (or Failure) Dan Miller Science and Operations Officer NWS/WFO.
Airmasses and fronts. Review of last lecture Tropical cyclone structure: 3 major components, rotation direction of inflow and outflow, location of maximum.
An Overview of Environmental Conditions and Forecast Implications of the 3 May 1999 Tornado Outbreak Richard L. Thompson and Roger Edwards Presentation.
Weather.
Chapter 6 test review Weather.
Extratropical Synoptic-Scale Processes and Severe Convection John Monteverdi Doswell, C.A. III, and L.F. Bosart, 2001: Extratropical synoptic-scale processes.
THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN LARGE- SCALE AND MESOSCALE CONTRIBUTION TO SEVERE CONVECTION: A CASE STUDY EXAMPLE Paper by Charles A. Doswell III Powerpoint by.
Weather and Climate. Vocabulary *weather *climate *evaporation *condensation *precipitation *runoff *clouds *air pressure *temperature *wind *density.
2.6 Synoptic Factors Associated with Severe Convection Subsections: 2.6a Topographic Influences 2.6b Solenoidal Circulations over Simple Terrain 2.6c Monsoons.
Fronts and Temperature Advection Weather Discussion: 26 February, 2008.
ATMO 251 Special Thanks to Dr. Russ Schumacher who originally developed these slides for a guest lecture. Fronts and Frontogenesis.
Weather Weather is the state or condition of the atmosphere at a particular location for a short period of time. Different weather is created by changes.
Chapter 9 – Air Masses and Fronts. Theme of Chapter 9: Air Masses are Important! Air mass – a large region of air (thousands of square miles) having similar.
Air Masses and Fronts – II. Brief review An air mass is a large body of air whose properties of temperature and humidity are fairly similar in any horizontal.
Weather Map Analysis Lab 7. Can include: Frontal lines Barometric pressure Isolines Temperature Frontal zones Frontal air.
Wednesday, November 16th Attendance Attendance Go over Unit Test 3 Go over Unit Test 3 Make-up work and/or weather dvd Make-up work and/or weather dvd.
SC.912.E.7.5 Predict future weather conditions based on present observations and conceptual models and recognize limitations and uncertainties of such.
Characteristics of Northeast Winter Snow Storms Dr. Jay Shafer Dec 8, 2011 Lyndon State College Satellites, Weather, and Climate.
Fronts 4 different types: 1. Cold front 2. Warm front 3. Stationary
AOSS 401, Fall 2006 Lecture 19 October 26, 2007 Richard B. Rood (Room 2525, SRB) Derek Posselt (Room 2517D, SRB)
Forecasting the Weather 3/24/14
Review for Final Exam. Final Exam Tuesday December 17 th, 5pm-7:30pm Room CC301 (this room) 25% of final grade Combination of quick general questions.
Weather forecasting began in the mid 1800’s when basic tools, like the thermometer and barometer, were invented Global Weather Reporting Weather observations.
Fronts and Frontogenesis
The Tricellular Circulation is highly dynamic, varying with the seasons and bringing the Polar front back and forth across the USA. RANGE OF THE POLAR.
* The relative measure of the amount of water vapor in the air * Psychrometer – measures the humidity * Water vapor affects the density of the air. * Cold.
Composite Analysis of Environmental Conditions Favorable for Significant Tornadoes across Eastern Kansas Joshua M. Boustead, and Barbara E. Mayes NOAA/NWS.
1 Air masses, Fronts, & Cyclones Extratropical Cyclone –Cyclone not in the tropics –Also known as Frontal Lows Frontal Cyclones Wave Cyclones Frontal Waves.
Fire Weather: Winds.
Weather Variables and Forecasting Modified from National Weather Service
AOS 100: Weather and Climate Instructor: Nick Bassill Class TA: Courtney Obergfell.
ATS-113 Seven Day Snowfall Totals. Fronts Arise because different air masses don’t mix readily –When two air masses come in contact, they retain their.
Air pressure questions.
* Weather maps are used to show current weather conditions in an effort to predict future weather conditions. * You need to know what each symbol means.
The 1925 Tri-State Tornado What If It Happened Today? Pat Spoden NOAA/NWS WFO Paducah, Kentucky John Hart NOAA/NWS Storm Prediction Center Norman, Oklahoma.
Forecasted 700 hPa Low (Blizzard of 2006) The RUC was saying “watch out.” This model is becoming a great short range model for East coast snowstorms (courtesy.
Fronts and Air Masses. Air Masses & Fronts Air Mass = large body of air whose temperature and moisture is similar at a given height (can cover thousands.
Air Masses. Definition Large body of air having similar temperature and moisture Air masses extend several miles up and cover lots of “ground” There can.
Conditions for Convection The Ingredients Method.
Fronts How to identify fronts on a weather map?
Severe Thunderstorm Summary METR 361. The Pre-storm Environment On the Surface map, look for: On the Surface map, look for: 1.Warm air, T > 50 F 2.High.
ATS/ESS 452: Synoptic Meteorology Friday 08 January 2016 Review Material Overview of Maps Equations of Motion Advection Continuity.
Mid-Latitude Cyclones
Air Masses & Fronts.
Variations in the details of cold frontal passages as revealed by mesonetwork data Chuck Doswell Doswell Scientific Consulting - Norman, OK 14 th Cyclone.
The Course of Synoptic Meteorology
Doswell Scientific Consulting - Norman, OK
Instability Baroclinic instability (needs vertical shear,
Weather Maps Weather Maps.
Weather Lesson Seven Air Masses and Fronts.
Weather – Air Mass extremely large body of air with similar characteristics of temperature and moisture. Forms when air stagnates for long periods of.
Air Masses and Fronts.
Weather and Climate.
A 3-D grasp on fronts and frontal movements and cyclones
What direction do high and low pressure systems spin
Fronts.
The Myth of the Leading Edge
Lower Tropospheric Frontogenesis
Teacher Page Weather Fronts Science 8th Grade.
PRECIPITATION.
Fronts.
Weather Forecasting.
Forecasting the Weather
Forecast Verification time!
Presentation transcript:

Meaningful Surface Analysis Dr. Charles A. Doswell III Doswell Scientific Consulting – Norman, Oklahoma Lubbock Severe Weather Conference Lubbock, Texas – 17 February 2010

What does meaningful mean? Helps with the diagnosis of the current weather situation Critical to a scientific understanding Forecast = diagnosis + trend Formal: Q is a forecast quantity

Surface analysis The industry standard:

The standard analysis The “Norwegian School” Conceptual model of an extratropical cyclone (ETC) – low pressure Polar Front model was an essential element – Cold fronts, warm fronts, occluded fronts – Definition of a front: a 1 st order discontinuity in density – The line on a map - on the warm side of a baroclinic zone (large thermal gradient)

Dropping isotherm analysis … [surface temperature] is often neither representative nor conservative. It is not representative because of many local or orographic influences, and it is not conservative on account of the preponderance of nonadiabatic irreversible processes in the air closest to the earth’s surface. Petterssen (1940) – Weather Analysis and Forecasting

Evolution of this concept Secondary characteristics – Cyclonic wind shift across a front – A “kink” in the isobars Airmass boundaries – Drylines – moisture discontinuities – Outflow boundaries – Land/sea breeze fronts – Others: gravity waves, density currents, etc. Weakly baroclinic troughs in the pressure field

Uncertainty in frontal analysis Uccellini et al. (1992 AMS Bull.)

An ensemble of analyses … It may be inevitable … but good or bad? – Standard isobars + fronts – Isotherms and isodrosotherms – Pressure changes Consensus is right most of the time – why? – Diversity of plausible ideas is valuable Low probability, high-impact event potential – Analysis and forecasting as a team activity

What tells you the most?

Surface analysis and severe weather A simplified version … Ingredients for severe convective weather: – Deep moist convection … ingredients: Moisture Instability (conditionally unstable lapse rates) Lift – Supercell-based severe convective weather Vertical wind shear – Non-supercellular severe convective weather ?? } CAPE

Manually-analyzed surface features Boundaries – Fronts (baroclinic, by definition) – Drylines (baroclinity is a function of time of day) – Windshifts (weakly baroclinic) – Other … sea breeze fronts, gravity waves, etc. Thermal features (  is preferred) Moisture ( r is preferred) Pressure changes (effects on surface wind)

Diagnosis of features Diagnosis – interpretation of data in terms of physical processes Bad diagnosis usually  bad short-term forecast Use of all available information Any interpretation of the data is necessarily provisional … the best you can do at the time Recognition of bad data

Maddox’s Requirements for Making a Short-Term Forecast 1.An accurate diagnosis, including continuous monitoring, of the current situation 2.An extensive physical understanding of the phenomena occurring, including any anticipated developments

Triple points … Ingredients: Moisture, Instability, Lift, Vertical wind shear

Objective analysis aids What’s the purpose of manual analysis? What do you obtain from machine analysis? – Many variables of interest aren’t easily produced for hand analysis (divergence, vorticity, etc.) Keep the notion of ingredients in mind, though – Machine analysis is consistent (reproducible) – Fast and requires no personal effort at all Something of a 2-edged sword

Case example: 22 May 2008

 e versus dewpoint

T / T d versus  / r

Indices and parameters Source: SPC

More indices/parameters

… and what happened …

What can sfc diagnosis do for you? Not perfect forecasts! Keeps you connected to the data Forces you to think like a meteorologist, not a technician Pattern recognition Ingredients-based thinking

Principles of team forecasting Don’t bring your ego to the office! – No one is always right and no one is always wrong – Disagreement is fine, but keep it scientific, not personal – No one succeeds when any one of you fails to do a good job Shift change is a critical time – Listen carefully and ask questions, if necessary – Ever inherited a mess from the previous shift? – Ever leave your relief with a mess?

Surface analysis as a briefing tool Surface analysis generally is idiosyncratic Every few hours, and especially just prior to a shift change, a “standard” surface analysis should be created – Record of your diagnosis and how it has evolved – A fast way to illustrate your concept of what is going on – Everyone should agree on its format

Thank you!! – Essays – Publications – Blog link