Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Really beginning the Upanishads.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Asian Philosophy Lecture 1.
Advertisements

Asian Philosophy Lecture 4. Two Trends in Indian Philosophy Indian philosophy is dominated by two trends. Naturalism / Materialism: There is no soul and.
Introduction to Hinduism Hinduism is the religion of the majority of people in India and Nepal. It also exists among significant populations outside of.
Discovering HOPE in the midst of evil SUFFERING AND THE HIDDENNESS OF GOD.
Today’s Lecture Concluding the Upanishads Beginning the Gita.
John 18:37-38 WHAT IS TRUTH? The Truth About Reality is Knowable The Opposite of True is False The Truth Matters.
Today’s Lecture A clip from The Matrix Concluding the Upanishads.
. WHY IS IT IMPORTANT? Deuteronomy 29:29 ( KJV ) 29 The secret things belong unto the LORD our God: but those things which are revealed belong unto.
Hope you had a happy holiday. Welcome back. Today’s Lecture Admin stuff Buddhism continued: The Four Noble Truths.
Today’s Lecture Admin stuff More basic Buddhist philosophy –The three characteristics of samsaric existence, –The three root evils, –Interdependent Arising.
Definitions – John Dewey
The Problem of Knowledge. What new information would cause you to be less certain? So when we say “I’m certain that…” what are we saying? 3 things you.
Sabine Mendes Lima Moura Issues in Research Methodology PUC – November 2014.
Nature of the Upani  adic Compositions. The principal texts within the Upani  ads are dialogues between teachers and their disciples The subject: the.
CHAPTER FIVE: THE SOURCES OF KNOWLEDGE P H I L O S O P H Y A Text with Readings ELEVENTH EDITION M A N U E L V E L A S Q U E Z.
Today’s Lecture In-class quiz Administrative stuff Preliminary comments about the saddarshanas Some preliminary comments about Samkhya-Yoga A very brief.
Today’s Lecture Some (I hope) final administrative comments Concluding the preliminary comments Orientation for Hinduism The Rig Veda and Vedic Hinduism.
Kyle Burke and Kyle Mann Upanishads. What are The Upanishads? The Upanishads are a series of philosophical works in the Hindu religion. There are over.
Today’s Lecture Your Koller Text Beginning Vedic Hinduism.
HINDUISM PRACTICE QUIZ. HINDUISM HISTORY The Vedic people who spoke Sanskrit and came to dominate the Indus Valley called themselves … 1.Conquerors 2.Norsemen.
Introduction to Hinduism Hinduism is the religion of the majority of people in India and Nepal. It also exists among significant populations outside of.
Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff The Bhagavad Gita: Subsequent chapters.
Title: Hinduism. Three devas- Brahma, Vishnu, Siva -are particularly influential. Some believe in thousands; others worship only one as the true manifestation.
The Indian Subcontinent
Today’s Lecture DON’T FORGET TO VOTE! Concluding the Upanishads.
Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Preliminary comments about Vedanta Advaita Vedanta Vishishtadvaita Vedanta.
Today’s Lecture Seventh in-class quiz (it begins again) Admin stuff More basic Buddhist philosophy –Concluding Interdependent Arising –Rebirth without.
Today’s Lecture Admin stuff Buddhism continued: The Four ‘Noble Truths’
Critical Thinking Dialogue Education 2009 THIS CD HAS BEEN PRODUCED FOR TEACHERS TO USE IN THE CLASSROOM. IT IS A CONDITION OF THE USE OF THIS CD THAT.
Today’s Lecture Eighth in-class quiz The Prajnaparamita Tradition: The Heart Sutra.
Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Concluding Vedanta: Vishishtadvaita Vedanta; Dvaita Vedanta.
Today’s Lecture Any questions about the assignments? Continuing the Gita.
LOGIC AND ONTOLOGY Both logic and ontology are important areas of philosophy covering large, diverse, and active research projects. These two areas overlap.
What led to the development of Hinduism?. Aryan society became more complex… Society divided into groups Society divided into groups Based on occupation.
Ancient India and China Section 2 Three devas- Brahma, Vishnu, Siva -are particularly influential. Some believe in thousands; others worship only one as.
Welcome Back! Please have a writing utensil and paper for notes (inside a notebook is fine)
Mormons do not feel threatened by science. They are not enemies of the rational world. They are not creationist. On human conduct, they tend to stress.
Today’s Lecture Any questions about the assignments? Continuing the Gita.
Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Continuing the Upanishads.
Vedas. “Veda” – Sankrit for “wisdom” or “knowledge stem from oral tradition – rishis written down when ??? 2000 BCE?
Hinduism. The History of Hinduism Hinduism The term Hindu was traditionally used by outsiders to describe the people of South Asia, now it has come to.
Ways of Studying Religion. The Academic Study of Religion - Assumptions - One religion is neither better nor worse than another religion; they are simply.
CHAPTER SIX: TRUTH P H I L O S O P H Y A Text with Readings ELEVENTH EDITION M A N U E L V E L A S Q U E Z.
PHIL/RS 335 Divine Nature Pt. 2: Divine Omniscience.
A brief summary of the ancient practice By: Aileen Kunewa India Center.
I NDIAN R ELIGIONS Chapter 5: Sections 2-3. I NDIAN S OCIETY D IVIDED The Varnas – social divisions in the Aryan society Brahmins – priests; highest.
An Introduction to Indian Philosophy
THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE The nature of knowledge. Knowledge  What is it?  A “Thick Concept”?  How is it different from belief?
Knowledge LO: To understand the distinction between three different types of knowledge. To learn some basic epistemological distinctions. To understand.
Origins of Hinduism The Big Idea Hinduism, the largest religion in India today, developed out of ancient Indian beliefs and practices. Main Ideas Indian.
Bertrand Russell ( ) From The Problems of Philosophy (1912)  Truth & Falsehood  Knowledge, Error, & Probable Opinion  The Limits of Philosophical.
Today’s Lecture Preliminary comments on epistemology Epistemology and our knowledge of the external world - some preliminary considerations. René Descartes.
Two central questions What does it mean to talk of, or believe in, God? –Is talk about God talk about something that exists independently of us? Or a way.
Imagination. What is imagination? It may seem at first sight that human thought is utterly unbounded: it not only escapes all human power and authority.
Today’s Lecture Admin stuff Ninth in-class quiz (it’s almost over) A brief comment on Yogacara and store consciousness.
The philosophy of Ayn Rand…. Objectivism Ayn Rand is quoted as saying, “I had to originate a philosophical framework of my own, because my basic view.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Research and Development Research Approach Research Methodology Research Objectives Engr. Hassan Mehmood Khan.
Seeing the Father John 14:5-11.
What is Philosophy?.
Primary Eastern Religions
Hinduism "When you hear about the Self,
Hinduism & Buddhism.
Ludwig Wittgenstein EARLY: PICTURE THEORY LATER: LANGUAGE GAMES.
Hinduism "When you hear about the Self,
Hinduism.
Hinduism A Brief Introduction.
A Text with Readings TENTH EDITION M A N U E L V E L A S Q U E Z
Introduction to Epistemology
Debate issues Sabine Mendes Lima Moura Issues in Research Methodology
Hinduism "When you hear about the Self,
Presentation transcript:

Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Really beginning the Upanishads

Administrative stuff The Bookstore assures me that the new order of Koller texts has arrived. I have graded the quizzes. I owe you an apology for the appearance of your submissions. I was caught in the rain yesterday and discovered, after the fact, that my bag is not very water-proof. The discoloration of your submissions is the result of a rain soaked inter- campus mail envelope … though it may look like something else. Good job on this first quiz.

Upanishads and the Vedas Remember that the Upanishads consist of reflections on that which underlies, or underpins, Vedic religious thought and practice (including Vedic sacrificial ritual) (Koller, Asian Philosophies, pp.5, 19-20). The principal Upanishads (i.e. the early Upanishads) are often viewed as the end (vedanta) of the Vedas (a ‘cap’ as it were on the Aranyakas [or Forest Treatises], which are, in turn, a ‘cap’ on the Brahmanas [or Commentaries]).

Note for future reference A number of scholars point to the emergence of the Upanishads as the beginnings of a move away from the traditional Vedic Religion. The early (or principal) Upanishads, it is believed, were being formulated at or around the same time as an adoption of a hierarchical stratification of Indian society based upon the Varnas. The Varnadharma, as it is now known, does not stand alone, however. Along with an adoption of this social hierarchy we find the emergence of doctrines concerning rebirth and karma. Why might a social hierarchy and the doctrines of rebirth and karma arise together? Think along the lines of ‘getting one’s just desert’ and being reborn.

Note for future reference Some of these same scholars see this move away from the traditional Vedic Religion as a revival (of sorts) of some of the pre-Aryan/non-Aryan traditions. (More details on the Varnadharma, rebirth and karma to come). Think of the references to Aryan culture as references to, at the very least, the emergence of a culture hitherto not dominant in the North-West sub- continent in and around 1500 B.C.E.

Upanishads The term ‘upanishad’ comes from the words: sad – ‘to sit’; upa – ‘near’; ni – ‘down’ (John Grimes A Concise Dictionary of Indian Philosophy. (Albany, NY: State University of New York Press), p.329). This implies that the teaching requires a disciple – guru relationship … something you won’t find in this class (or in a class environment in general). These texts, then, can be understood as containing secret teaching. This means that there are at least two layers to the text: a surface meaning and a deeper meaning that requires the direction of a guru (or teacher).

Upanishads – the questions Two questions inform much of the discussion in the Upanishads: (1) What is the underlying fundamental essence, nature or ground of objects or events in the world (or ‘outer reality’)? (2) What is the underlying fundamental essence, nature or ground of the self (or ‘inner reality’)? (Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.20.) How might we relate these questions related? Think of it this way: I’m in your outer world, but I have an ‘inner world’ (in which you are in my outer world).

Upanishads – the questions It gets even more interesting. In deep meditation, Hindu practitioners often claim that they move beyond conceptual thought, beyond the duality of ‘me and that’, or subject and object (see Koller’s discussion on pages of Asian Philosophies). IF such a state exists, and admittedly this is a big ‘if’, then what will be the perception of That Which Is? Will this yield a universal claim about Reality or only one limited or indexed to your own subjective experience? Before you answer, remember that, IF such a state exists, in that state there is no objective-subjective contrast.

Upanishads – underlying theory of knowledge Remember that there are two prominent sources of knowledge for Upanishadic philosophers: (1) Vedic scriptures and (2) meditation (Koller, Asian Philosophies, pp.19-20). To defend their views Upanishadic philosophers tend to point to one or the other of these sources of knowledge (Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.20). You need to distinguish the defense of their views from their explication. In explicating their views, Upanishadic philosophers use stories, myth and common experience.

Upanishads – underlying theory of knowledge In evaluating the overall epistemic value of claims made in Upanishadic philosophy you need to give some thought to the evaluation of scriptural authority and meditation, AS WELL AS the form this evaluation will take regarding either putative source of knowledge. What is it for a body of scriptures to be rightly regarded as authoritative? Are there objective criteria (or criteria that will survive philosophical criticism) for infallibility?

Upanishads – underlying theory of knowledge Do note Koller’s comments (on page 20 of your Asian Philosophies) that at least one accepted formal criterion of testing the truth of putative claims of knowledge, accepted by the Upanishadic philosophers, is whether the claims are internally consistent/coherent.

Upanishads – underlying theory of knowledge We can look for internal inconsistencies or even coherence with known truths, but even if such inquiries yield results that make us disposed to trust some of the relevant scriptural passages, it may be the case that matters lying outside of verifiable fact or truth are falsely presented within the relevant texts.

Upanishads – underlying theory of knowledge Can we think of prima facie (or initial) reasons to think that meditation may well be a source of knowledge? Think of introspection or memory, and the contexts in which we think they may yield true beliefs.

Upanishads – underlying theory of knowledge With either source of knowledge we tend to think that such matters as careful attentiveness, critical self-awareness, and a measured degree of skepticism (a recognition that we may be wrong) should be present when making knowledge claims. But careful attentiveness and critical self-awareness are virtues to be also cultivated by practitioners of meditation. Only when these virtues are properly cultivated are our observations during meditation to enjoy a (to-be-specified) degree of epistemic value.

Upanishads – underlying theory of knowledge Two worries about regarding meditation as a source of knowledge: (i) It is not infallible and (ii) may not yield ‘unique knowledge’ (or knowledge that can only be gained through the relevant meditation technique), unlike, say, perception or reason. Re (i): Neither introspection nor memory are infallible. Indeed both are open to manipulation and distortion (think of false consciousness or false memory). Re (ii): It is not clear that memory yields knowledge only to be gained through that ‘faculty’.

Upanishads - Brahman as all-embracing reference The word ‘brahman’ was originally used to talk about (the power underlying) a Vedic prayer (as contained in the Rig Veda) or spell (as contained in the Atharva Veda). Its meaning undergoes a change when it is used to speak of (the power underlying) all the utterances contained in Vedic Ritual or in the Vedas. The change to such an emphasis corresponds to the change in direction of Vedic religion mentioned before AND a growing concern to understand the causal connection between language/word/sound and success in Vedic ritual (Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.20).