Modeling Preferences of a Group Member Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Understanding Your Habit: Flow Charts & Lists of Routines Farrokh Alemi Ph.D.
Advertisements

Benchmarking Clinicians Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.. Why should it be done? Hiring, promotion, and management decisions Help clinicians improve.
Hospital Information System (HIS) Stakeholder Consultation
Primary and Secondary Data
[edit on Slide Master, Name of Presentation] [DAY, DATE CITY] 1 Leadership Summit Session 1: I Have the Gavel – Now What? January 16, :15 a.m.– 9:45.
Chapter 8 Making Judgments and Decisions P189 Intuitive Predictions Judgment Aids Utility Analysis chapter 8 Makeing Judgments and Decisions 1.
Introduction to Decision Analysis
UNDERSTANDING, PLANNING AND PREPARING FOR THE SCHOOL-WIDE EVALUATION TOOL (SET)
FARROKH ALEMI, PH.D. Measurement of Severity from Claims Data.
Project Management Take a Tour of the Online Course.
Project Execution Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D. Lee Baliton.
Does Project Management Work Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D. Narrated by Lee Baliton.
IBE312: Ch15 Building an IA Team & Ch16 Tools & Software 2013.
Leveraging Technology for Successful Ergonomics Deployments in Municipalities Presented by: Steve Meyers, CIH, CSP EORM Presented by: Steve Meyers, CIH,
Determining System Requirements Classes 9,10. SDLC Project Identification & Selection Project Initiation & Planning Analysis ** Logical Design Physical.
Agenda Chapter 8 – Leaders Manage Meetings
Putting Your Heads Together How To Form and Effectively Run a Study Group.
Preparing for Automation Dr. Dania Bilal IS 582 Spring 2006.
Copyright © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall 4.1.
Understanding and Administering the School- Wide Evaluation Tool (SET)
Planning and Writing Your Documents Chapter 6. Start of the Project Start the project by knowing the software you will write about, but you should try.
EARTO – working group on quality issues – 2 nd session Anneli Karttunen, Quality Manager VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland This presentation.
Interpersonal Communication and Self Management Unit 1 Lesson 8.
VistA Needs Assessment Vendor Selection Role of Information.
Project Initiation Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.. Course on Project Management Project Phases 1. Initiation 2. Planning 3. Execution 4. Controlling 5. Closing.
Westat University of Wisconsin J. Koppich & Associates AIR Synergy Enterprises Tony Milanowski Westat NEFEC/Gilchrist HCM Systems Technical Assistance.
MATCHING SUPPORT TO PROMOTE POSITIVE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG CHILDREN Jennifer Ross, M.Ed. ECE Training Solutions
IS2210: Systems Analysis and Systems Design and Change Twitter:
Vendor Selection Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.. Alemi at Georgetown 2 Objectives Model decision makers preferences Facilitate communication and documentation.
Mass s Tailored to Individuals Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.
University of Sunderland Professionalism and Personal Skills Unit 9 Professionalism and Personal Skills Lecture Data Collection.
1 Course on Quality Change Cycles Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D
Creating Your Dream Home: Construction-to-Permanent Loan Programs EDIT 6170 ePoster Presentation Diane M. Chubb April 27, 2005.
Managing Staff in Small Business – Lesson Two. RECRUITMENT, SELECTION, EMPLOYMENT ARRANGEMENTS, LEGAL REQUIREMENTS FOR EMPLOYING STAFF.
Participatory Vendor Selection Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.
Introduction to the Course Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.. This course provides a managerial perspective on the effective use of data and information technology.
Multi-Criteria Analysis - preference weighting. Defining weights for criteria Purpose: to express the importance of each criterion relative to other criteria.
Requirements Elicitation. Structured Interview: Purpose is to ask and answer questions concerning the problem being modeled Observation: Observe activities.
June 2003George Mason University1 Needs Assessment Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.
Practical Coach Discussion Session #60. Learning Objectives To understand the value of coaching in a manager’s work To learn how to determine when to.
Screening for Stroke and Cognitive Impairment Chapter 4: How to Administer Cognitive Screening in Stroke.
0 Calculation of Return on Investments Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.
The CAP Self-evaluation Survey Goal: to improve the assessment (the CAP survey is designed for a formative purpose)
THE POSTMORTEM Chapter 10 Introduction to Team Software Process.
Protection Poker James Walden Northern Kentucky University.
Introduction to the Course Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.. This course provides a graduate level managerial perspective on the effective use of data and information.
S ystems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology 1 Decision Analysis Raimo P. Hämäläinen Systems Analysis Laboratory Helsinki University.
How to administer Cognitive Screening?. Setting the Stage 1.The well-seasoned professional can take minutes to complete. Novices may want to allow.
Unit 9: Evaluating a Public Health Surveillance System #1-9-1.
ICME Interdisciplinary Case Management Experience.
 Prepare  Study the agenda  Study the minutes  Prepare for your contributions  Prepare to play a major role  List questions.
Installation and Maintenance of Health IT Systems Unit 8a Troubleshooting; Maintenance and Upgrades; and Interaction with Vendors, Developers, and Users.
Conducting a Needs Analysis
© 2013 by Nelson Education1 Selection III: Interviewing.
So You Think You’ve Made a Change? Developing Indicators and Selecting Measurement Tools Chad Higgins, Ph.D. Allison Nichols, Ed.D.
Project Execution Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.. Course on Project Management Components of Project Execution 1. Completing plans 2. Managing project resources.
SCHOOL-WIDE POSITIVE BEHAVIORAL INTERVENTIONS AND SUPPORT: ADDRESSING THE BEHAVIOR OF ALL STUDENTS Classroom PBIS: Activity Sequence and Offering Choice.
BELL RINGER What would the polynomial equation be if the zeroes were -2, -2, and 4?
Guidelines for Job Interviews
Construction Schedule Management
Manager Checklist: Conduct Constructive Feedback Discussions
Project Initiation Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.
Intermediate Small Business Programs, Part B SBP 202 Lesson 1: Introduction February 2017 Lesson 1: Introduction.
Activity 35 Building in Boomtown
CMGT 445 MASTER Lessons in Excellence--cmgt445master.com.
Chapter 8 Making Judgments and Decisions
Evaluating Data.
Applying Consequences for Lack of Adherence to Rules and Procedures
Peer Support in the Classroom
Consultation with stakeholders & User participation
Presentation transcript:

Modeling Preferences of a Group Member Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.

Alemi at Georgetown 2 Steps in Participatory Vendor Selection 1. Invite stakeholders to participate 2. One-on-one interviews 3. Group meeting 4. Constructing scoring procedures 5. Group Discussion 6. Measuring Vendor performance 7. Documentation

Alemi at Georgetown 3 Steps in Participatory Vendor Selection 1. Invite stakeholders to participate 2. One-on-one interviews 3. Group meeting 4. Constructing scoring procedures 5. Group Discussion 6. Measuring Vendor performance 7. Documentation Focus of this set of slides

Objectives Prepare for the meeting Construct straw models Solicit attributes Describe attribute levels Identify scoring procedure Alemi at Georgetown 4

5 Additive Multi-Attribute Value Model Overall Value = function {V(A 1 )+V(A 2 ) +…+V(A n )} Value on Attribute 1 Value on Attribute 2 Value on Attribute n

Alemi at Georgetown 6 Misleading Numbers Numbers approximate preferences Build behavioral consensus

Steps in Modeling Preferences 1. Introductions 2. Solicit attributes 3. Identify attribute levels 4. Rate attribute levels 5. Assess importance of attributes 6. Evaluate accuracy 7. Discuss next steps Alemi at Georgetown 7

Step 1: Introductions Introduction of the analyst The task Process of vendor selection Introduction of decision maker Alemi at Georgetown 8

9 Step 2: Select Attributes a) Start with tangible examples of EHR that worked well and those that worked poorly b) Ask directly for additional attributes c) Arrange the attributes in a hierarchy Always use the expert's terminology Use prompts that feel most natural Take notes and do not interrupt

Alemi at Georgetown 10 Step 2: Select Attributes a) Start with tangible examples b) Ask directly for additional attributes c) Arrange the attributes in a hierarchy Always use the expert's terminology Use prompts that feel most natural Take notes and do not interrupt

Alemi at Georgetown 11 Step 2: Select Attributes a) Start with tangible examples b) Ask directly for additional attributes c) Arrange the attributes in a hierarchy Always use the expert's terminology Use prompts that feel most natural Take notes and do not interrupt

Alemi at Georgetown 12 Step 2: Select Attributes a) Start with tangible examples b) Ask directly for additional attributes c) Arrange the attributes in a hierarchy Always use the decision maker’s terminology Use prompts that feel most natural Take notes and do not interrupt

Alemi at Georgetown 13 Step 2: Select Attributes a) Start with tangible examples b) Ask directly for additional attributes c) Arrange the attributes in a hierarchy Always use the expert's terminology Use prompts that feel most natural Take notes and do not interrupt

Alemi at Georgetown 14 Step 2: Select Attributes a) Start with tangible examples b) Ask directly for additional attributes c) Arrange the attributes in a hierarchy Always use the expert's terminology Use prompts that feel most natural Take notes and do not interrupt

Alemi at Georgetown 15 Step 2: Select Attributes Example attributes Easy to use Improve one or more business processes Most value for cost Fit with long term business strategy Vendor responsive to practice information needs Strong testimonies from prior users In use by other practice sites Compatible with existing systems

Step 3: Identify Attribute Levels 1. Selecting the best and worst levels 2. Define intermediate levels 3. Fill in the other possible levels Alemi at Georgetown 16

Step 3: Identify Attribute Levels 1. Selecting the best and worst levels 2. Define intermediate levels 3. Fill in the other possible levels Alemi at Georgetown 17 Easiest to use Hardest to use

Step 3: Identify Attribute Levels 1. Selecting the best and worst levels 2. Define intermediate levels 3. Fill in the other possible levels Alemi at Georgetown 18 Less than 2 minutes More than 5 minutes

Step 4: Rate Attribute Levels No cost (open software) $5000/physician $10,000/physician $20,000/physician $30,000/physician $40,000/physician Alemi at Georgetown 19

Step 4: Rate Attribute Levels No cost (open software) $5000/physician $10,000/physician $20,000/physician $30,000/physician $40,000/physician Alemi at Georgetown

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown 21

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown 22 Arrange attributes from least important to most important Assign the least important attribute the value of 10 How many more times the next attribute is more important?

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown 23 ? Impact on business process ? Cost ? Compatibility with current systems

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown 24 1 Impact on business process 2 Cost 3 Compatibility with current systems

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown 25 Impact on business process ? Cost 10 Compatibility with current systems

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown 26 Impact on business process 30 Cost 10 Compatibility with current systems

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown 27 45/85 Impact on business process 30/85 Cost 10/85 Compatibility with current systems

Step 5: Assign Importance of Attributes Alemi at Georgetown Impact on business process 0.35 Cost 0.12 Compatibility with current systems

Step 6: Evaluate Hypothetical Vendors Vendor AVendor BVendor C AttributeWeightLevelRatingLevelRatingLevelRating Ease of use minutes1003 minutes805 minutes0 Cost per MD , , Reputation 0.2 Good0Excellent100Good0 Alemi at Georgetown 29

Alemi at Georgetown 30 Step 7: Next Step Walk through group meeting Answer questions

Take Home Lesson Listen to the Decision Maker