Additional Statistical Investigations A paired t-test was performed to evaluate whether a perceptual learning process occurs between the initial baseline.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Complex Experimental Designs
Advertisements

Randomized Complete Block and Repeated Measures (Each Subject Receives Each Treatment) Designs KNNL – Chapters 21,
Multiple Analysis of Variance – MANOVA
Analysis of variance (ANOVA)-the General Linear Model (GLM)
Introduction Although an industry-standard lecture aid, PowerPoint has received little systematic controlled research. 1 A recent, well-controlled study.
Introduction Although an industry-standard lecture aid, PowerPoint has received little systematic controlled research. 1 A recent, well-controlled study.
Comparison of Spatial and Temporal Discrimination Performance across Various Difficulty Levels J.E. THROPP, J.L. SZALMA, & P.A. HANCOCK Department of Psychology.
Lab3: writing up results and ANOVAs with within and between factors 1.
Analysis of variance (ANOVA)-the General Linear Model (GLM)
Abstract Cognitive control processes reduce the effects of irrelevant or misleading information on performance. We report a study suggesting that effective.
The Effects of Increased Cognitive Demands on the Written Discourse Ability of Young Adolescents Ashleigh Elaine Zumwalt Eastern Illinois University.
Basic Logic of Experimentation The design of an Internally valid experimental procedure requires us to: Form Equivalent Groups Treat Groups Identically.
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN Random assignment Who gets assigned to what? How does it work What are limits to its efficacy?
Today Concepts underlying inferential statistics
Summary of Quantitative Analysis Neuman and Robson Ch. 11
Chapter 9 Experimental Research Gay, Mills, and Airasian
CORRELATIO NAL RESEARCH METHOD. The researcher wanted to determine if there is a significant relationship between the nursing personnel characteristics.
Slide 1 Testing Multivariate Assumptions The multivariate statistical techniques which we will cover in this class require one or more the following assumptions.
Smith/Davis (c) 2005 Prentice Hall Chapter Eight Correlation and Prediction PowerPoint Presentation created by Dr. Susan R. Burns Morningside College.
Two-Way Analysis of Variance STAT E-150 Statistical Methods.
LEARNING PROGRAMME Hypothesis testing Intermediate Training in Quantitative Analysis Bangkok November 2007.
Context and the Relationship Between Social Anxiety and Urge to Drink Tracey A. Garcia & Lindsay S. Ham Florida International University Introduction 
APPENDIX B Data Preparation and Univariate Statistics How are computer used in data collection and analysis? How are collected data prepared for statistical.
Using Empirical Article Analyses to Assess Students Learning of Psychology Research Methods Sarah Richardson, Michael Schiel, Kaetlyn Graham, & Allen Keniston.
Understanding Statistics
Chapter 11 HYPOTHESIS TESTING USING THE ONE-WAY ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE.
Hypothesis Testing Using the Two-Sample t-Test
B AD 6243: Applied Univariate Statistics Repeated Measures ANOVA Professor Laku Chidambaram Price College of Business University of Oklahoma.
Instrument One instructional (INS) slide and three masking (MSK) slides provided directions for 4 test slides that each contained 3 lists of 3 color words.
Ethnic Identity among Mexican American Adolescents: The Role of Maternal Cultural Values and Parenting Practices 1 Miriam M. Martinez, 1 Gustavo Carlo,
Hypothesis testing Intermediate Food Security Analysis Training Rome, July 2010.
Understanding Action Verbs- Embodied Verbal Semantics Approach Pavan Kumar Srungaram M.Phil Cognitive Science (09CCHL02) Supervisor: Prof. Bapi.
1 of 29 Department of Cognitive Science Adv. Experimental Methods & Statistics PSYC 4310 / COGS 6310 Mixed Model ANOVA Michael J. Kalsher PSYC 4310/6310.
ITEC6310 Research Methods in Information Technology Instructor: Prof. Z. Yang Course Website: c6310.htm Office:
Chapter 13 - ANOVA. ANOVA Be able to explain in general terms and using an example what a one-way ANOVA is (370). Know the purpose of the one-way ANOVA.
Experimental Design and Statistics. Scientific Method
Experimental Research Methods in Language Learning
Introduction Disordered eating continues to be a significant health concern for college women. Recent research shows it is on the rise among men. Media.
11/23/2015Slide 1 Using a combination of tables and plots from SPSS plus spreadsheets from Excel, we will show the linkage between correlation and linear.
September 18-19, 2006 – Denver, Colorado Sponsored by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Conducting and interpreting multivariate analyses.
Experimental Research Methods in Language Learning Chapter 10 Inferential Statistics.
The effects of working memory load on negative priming in an N-back task Ewald Neumann Brain-Inspired Cognitive Systems (BICS) July, 2010.
MethodIntroductionResults Discussion Factors Affecting Psychosocial Functioning in Serious Mental Illness and Implications for Treatment Jason E. Vogler,
Playground Settings and the Impact of Recess on Classroom Attention Christine Peterson, B.A., M.S.E. Psychology Department Human Development Center University.
Emily C. Prosser, Valerie L. VanTussi, Jaime R. Barth, & Blaine F. Peden, Ph.D. Psychology Department at the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire Women’s.
Chapter 10 The t Test for Two Independent Samples
T tests comparing two means t tests comparing two means.
Handout Twelve: Design & Analysis of Covariance
Copyright c 2001 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.1 Chapter 11 Testing for Differences Differences betweens groups or categories of the independent variable.
Kin 304 Inferential Statistics Probability Level for Acceptance Type I and II Errors One and Two-Tailed tests Critical value of the test statistic “Statistics.
Handout Six: Sample Size, Effect Size, Power, and Assumptions of ANOVA EPSE 592 Experimental Designs and Analysis in Educational Research Instructor: Dr.
© 2006 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. 1 Chapter 11 Testing for Differences Differences betweens groups or categories of the independent.
More repeated measures. More on sphericity With our previous between groups Anova we had the assumption of homogeneity of variance With repeated measures.
HYPOTHESIS TESTING FOR DIFFERENCES BETWEEN MEANS AND BETWEEN PROPORTIONS.
Processing Faces with Emotional Expressions: Negative Faces Cause Greater Stroop Interference for Young and Older Adults Gabrielle Osborne 1, Deborah Burke.
Parental, Temperament, & Peer Influences on Disordered Eating Symptoms Kaija M. Muhich, Alyssa Collura, Jessica Hick and Jennifer J. Muehlenkamp Psychology.
1 of 29 Department of Cognitive Science Adv. Experimental Methods & Statistics PSYC 4310 / COGS 6310 Mixed Model ANOVA Michael J. Kalsher PSYC 4310 Advanced.
Approaches to quantitative data analysis Lara Traeger, PhD Methods in Supportive Oncology Research.
Educational Research Inferential Statistics Chapter th Chapter 12- 8th Gay and Airasian.
Who’s Cheating Who? Perceptions of Infidelity Across Gender and Sexual Orientation Holly M. Albers and Madeline G. Dugolenski University of Wisconsin,
Psychology research methods– Analysis Portfolio Taylor Rodgers B
Norming Study Mechanisms of Emotion Regulation: The Role of Attentional Control Lindsey R. Wallace, M. A. & Elisabeth J. Ploran, Ph.D. Department of Psychology,
Acknowledgements Introduction Results Methods Conclusions
Confidence Intervals.
Friendship Quality as a Moderator
Introduction Results Hypotheses Discussion Method
The involvement of visual and verbal representations in a quantitative and a qualitative visual change detection task. Laura Jenkins, and Dr Colin Hamilton.
Kin 304 Inferential Statistics
Introduction to SAS Essentials Mastering SAS for Data Analytics
Presentation transcript:

Additional Statistical Investigations A paired t-test was performed to evaluate whether a perceptual learning process occurs between the initial baseline of reading Leet words (list 2) and the resulting baseline (list 5). The results indicate that the resulting baseline of reading Leet words was significantly faster than the initial baseline, t(37) = 15.61, p <.000. An Investigation of the Stroop Task Effect Using an Orthographic Variation of the 3/\/9|$|-| 14/\/9(_)493 (English Language) Kaetlyn Graham, Michael Schiel, Blaine Peden, Allen Keniston Psychology Department - University of Wisconsin – Eau Claire Introduction A perceptual learning process will occur between the baseline of reading Leet words. The interference effect for reading incongruent color words will be greater for those participants most familiar with Leet words. ACT scores will demonstrate a negative relationship with the time it takes to read the Leet words and identify colors. Participants 38 undergraduate students from the University of Wisconsin – Eau Claire took part in the study. All of the participants were native speakers of English. The mean age for the participant pool was 23. Materials Eight color words in medium difficulty Leet Speak were selected to be used in this experiment – orange, red, pink, green, blue, purple, gray, and brown. Methods Procedure Using M.Powerpoint, subjects were instructed to audibly report either the color of a given Leet word, or the Leet word. Slides include:  Two baselines – Identifying colors (XXX slides, labeled as BIC) and another was for reading Leet speak presented in black font (BRL).  There were 12 slides total in the PowerPoint in the order of BIC BRL, CIC (congruent condition, identifying colors, list 3), IIC (incongruent condition, identifying colors, list 4), RRL (resulting baseline reading Leet speak), RIC (resulting baseline identifying colors). Participant’s were able to read the Leet words after only one trial, indicating that possibly 1) an extremely effective and powerful generalization process was operating after that trial or 2) participants continued to learn Leet speak via perceptual learning during the congruent and incongruent color identification conditions. Stroop-induced interference is not greater for those participants most familiar with Leet words. These results are contrapositive to the results of the pilot study. A reason for this could be that fewer people were familiar with Leet speak in the current study than in the pilot study. Future research should more fully sample the range of Leet speak familiarity among participants. Evocation of multiple responses between identifying colors and reading Leet may actually prevent interference, requiring participants to alternate rapidly between identifying color and reading Leet speak. We expected that participants with higher ACT scores would have faster response times for reading Leet words and identifying colors. The pilot study demonstrated that ACT negatively correlated with response time taken for BRL and for BIC, but only when the congruent condition was before baseline. This study did not replicate the pilot study results. Overall, exploring the Stroop effect using Leet speak has given us the opportunity to explore the cognitive mechanisms underlying the Stroop effect. These include the influence of perceptual learning, the nature of interactions between cognitive dimensions, and the effects of previous experience on responding to complex stimuli. A 2 x 6 repeated measures ANCOVA was conducted to investigate whether there is a main effect of familiarity (between-subjects) and if there is an interaction effect with congruency condition [within-subjects; levels – congruent (list 3), incongruent (list4)], while controlling for a known covariant – ACT. There was not a main effect for familiarity, F(1, 28) =.54, p =.71, and no interaction effect with the congruency condition F(4, 28) =.44, p =.78. When conducting a regular 2 x 6 ANOVA, the only significant main effect was the congruency condition, F(5, 32) = 8.06, p =.008. However, after conducting the ANCOVA to account for ACT, this main effect for congruency was completely wiped out, F(1, 28) =.01, p =.93. Listrp 1 BIC BRL RRL RIC Stroop (1932) originally contemplated the effects that two cognitive dimensions have on each other when presented as a compound stimulus. Two cognitive dimensions compiled to investigate interference within this study include: 1)the process of generalization that occurs when presented with physically similar stimuli to English letters which are composed of numbers and symbols also known as Leet speak. 2) Identification of colors, which has long been known as a cognitive process which evocates multiple cognitive responses (Peterson et al, 1925). An exploratory pilot study indicated that the Stroop interference was reproduced by Leet words. Additionally, there was a significant change in times from the baseline of reading Leet speak (BRL) to the resulting baseline (RRL). This study seeks to replicate these results, and proposes that between the two baseline conditions, a perceptual learning experience occurs. A one way between subjects ANOVA for the pilot study suggested that familiarity did not have a relationship with the amount of interference experienced between congruent and incongruent conditions. This study seeks to re-evaluate and replicate that self-reported exposure rating (familiarity with Leet Speak) will be an indicator of how much interference is experienced. Fluid intelligence is a concept that refers to the capacity to which individuals are able to logically solve problems and identify patterns or relationships in novel situations (Catell, 1971). The novelty problem presented to participants in this study is generalizing Leet words to English words. Standardized tests such as the ACT are thought to be a loose measure of fluid intelligence. Therefore, this study investigates the extent of the relationship between ACT and the time it takes for participants audibly report the generalization of Leet words to English words. Hypothesis 1 Perceptual Learning Between BRL Hypothesis 2 Familiarity as a Predictor of Interference Hypothesis 3 ACT as a Predictor for BRL & BCI Discussion Hypotheses Method Green + = Green 9Я33/\/ + = 9Я33/\/ An error bar graph to the right indicates the strong significant interference that was replicated by this study, but was wiped out when ACT was taken into account as a covariant. Prior to statistical analyses, preliminary data screening indicated that the list 5 scores were right skewed (skewedness = 3.2, shown as tan colored histogram to the right) as compared to the other list scores which ranged from.20 – In order to fix the departure from normality, a natural log transformation of the scores were used for analyses as replacement. The resulting skewedness for list 5 scores was reduced to 1.61, shown as the green histogram to the right. Additionally, the Levene test for homogeneity of variance was used to determine whether there were any serious violations of the homogeneity of variance assumption across groups (for analyses of hypothesis 2) and no significant value was observed: F(3, 32) =.71, p =.55. Acknowledgements: We would like to extend our outmost thanks for the extraordinary guidance and wise words provided by both Allen Keniston and Blaine Peden. Additionally, thanks to ORSP for funding of this poster. References (see handout) : Although ACT was a covariant that completely wiped out all variance accounted for the congruent conditions, Pearson bivariate correlations did not produce any significant relationships among the lists. Results