Comparing Political Systems. Why Compare? “Without comparisons to make, the mind does not know how to proceed.” Tocqueville “Man is by nature a social.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter 2 Comparing Political Systems. How we Study Politics Describe Describe Predict Predict Explain Explain A. Description Conceptual Framework – set.
Advertisements

Introduction to Theories of Public Policy
Political Culture and Political Socialization
Sovereignty, Authority, & Power BY: GRANT LANGFORD, RYAN JOHNSTON, & TAYLOR ZITO.
Week 2: Major Worldviews January 10, 2007
Dynamics of Comparison Comparing Political Systems.
Lecture 5. Political Culture and Political Socialization
Constitution and Bill of Rights Test Review
Government, Politics, and the Policymaking Process.
Industrialized Democracies An overview. Political system Inputs –types: support & demands –channels: interest groups and parties Decision making –institutions.
COMPARING THE POLITICAL SYSTEM THROUGH SYSTEMS THEORY
Introducing Government in America
Introduction to Comparative Politics
Introducing Comparative Politics
Chapter 1: Principles of Government Section 1
Objectives Define government and the basic powers every government holds. Describe the four defining characteristics of a state. Identify four theories.
Comparing Political Systems
Introduction Politics and government matter.
Introducing Government in America Chapter 1. Pearson Education, Inc., Longman © 2008 Introduction Politics and government matter. Americans are apathetic.
Chapter 1 Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman. Edwards, Wattenberg, and Lineberry Government in America: People, Politics, and.
Goal – to understand why we use comparative analysis in political science, to understand the methods of comparison available and the methods we will use.
Government and Public Policy
Public Administration Politics not politics What is the connection? Politics sets the tasks for administration. but should not manipulate it’s offices.
The Theory & Practice of Government Powers Module 3.7: Tools of Bureaucracy.
1 Chapter 1 Government and the State How is government defined? What are the basic powers that every government holds? What are the four defining characteristics.
Project Citizen and Public Policy We the People… Project Citizen Center for Civic Education.
Government and the State Standard USG – 1: The student will demonstrate an understanding of foundational political theory, concepts, and application.
Theories of Democratic Government. Power and Authority.
Chapter 2: Comparing Political Systems By: Alyssa Wright Ashley Smith Matthew Jacob.
Teaching to the Standard in Science Education By: Jennifer Grzelak & Bonnie Middleton.
Comparative Government. Reasons to Study Comparative Government Countries are actors in a continuously unfolding play Comparative Government and Politics.
Comparing Political Systems. Why Compare To develop perspective on the mix of constants and variability which characterize the world’s governments and.
Comparing Political Systems
Chapter 1 The Comparative Study of Politics Comparative Politics: Structures and Choices 2e By Lowell Barrington.
Comparative Politics: Domestic Responses to Global Challenges, Seventh Edition by Charles Hauss Chapter 1: Seeking New Lands, Seeing With New Eyes.
Chapter 1: Seeking New Lands, Seeing with New Eyes.
Chapter 2 “Comparing Political Systems” Comparison is the scientific study of politics Theories are developed on political processes.
INTRODUCTION TO ADMINISTRATIVE LAW. 1.Administrative law is being taught in many institutions of higher education as well as in numeorus special institutes.
Interest Articulation
Chapter Two Comparing Political Systems Copyright © 2012, 2010, 2008 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
POL 221: Introduction to Comparative Politics Instructor: Dr. Gang Guo
Introducing Government in America Chapter 1. Updated Statistics Voter Turnout
- The concept of political culture provides a new name for one of the oldest subject of concern in political science. - Political culture as a concept.
UNIT I The Comparative Method Politics and government matter.  Why? Americans are apathetic about politics and government.  Why? American youth are.
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman. Introducing Government in America Chapter 1 Edwards, Wattenberg, and Lineberry Government.
IR 306 Foreign Policy Analysis
Unit 1- Conceptual Introduction to Comparative Government and Politics Lesson 1- Purpose and Methods of Comparison and Classification.
College of Education School of Continuing and Distance Education 2014/2015 – 2016/2017 POLI 112 POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS Sessions 7 – The Executive and Judiciary.
Why do we Compare We compare to Learn –The only way to understand our political system is to compare it with others. Go to Roskin, read the box on Page.
Interest Articulation
Introduction to Theories of Public Policy
American Politics and Government
Management in the Marketplace
Chapter 1 Vocabulary Review
Chapter 1 Vocabulary Review
Political Systems.
Political Systems.
Interest Articulation
Comparing Political Systems Structures and Functions
Management in the Marketplace
SCOPE AND SOURCES OF LEGAL RESEARCH
The Public Policy Process
Comparing Political Systems
Political Culture and Political Socialization
Comparing Political Systems
System Approach for Comparative Public Administration
Chapter 13 Building Evidence-Based Family Policy:
Public Policy.
Comparing Political Systems
Presentation transcript:

Comparing Political Systems

Why Compare? “Without comparisons to make, the mind does not know how to proceed.” Tocqueville “Man is by nature a social animal; an individual who is unsocial naturally and not accidentally is either beneath our notice or more than human. Society is something that precedes the individual. Anyone who either cannot lead the common life or is so self- sufficient as not to need to, and therefore does not partake of society, is either a beast or a god.” Aristotle, Politics Methodological core of the scientific study of politics Contemporary political scientists Try to explain differences between the processes and performances of political systems

How We Compare First stage in the study of politics is description. To describe it we need a set of concepts that are clearly defined and well understood. Conceptual framework Easier this set of concepts is to understand and the more generally it can be applied, the more helpful it is to the study of politics.

Political Systems: Environment and Interdependence To utilize a structural-functional systems framework to compare political systems we need to discuss three general concepts: A. System: suggests an object having interdependent parts, acting within a setting or an environment B. Structure C. Function Political system: a set of institutions and agencies concerned with formulating and implementing the collective goals of a society or of groups within it

Governments Governments are the policymaking parts of political systems. Decisions of governments are normally backed up by legitimate coercion; obedience may be compelled. political system A political system exists in both an international environment and a domestic environment. A system receives inputs from these environments. International International Exchanges among countries may vary in many ways: small to great. Interdependence has increased enormously in the last decades. ( Globalization) Domestic Domestic Economic and social systems Political culture of its citizens

Structures: Structures: parliaments, bureaucracies, administrative agencies, and courts. Structures perform functions, which in turn enable the government to formulate, implement, and enforce its policies. Policiesagencies Policies reflect the goals; the agencies provide the means. Six types of political structures: Six types of political structures: political parties interest groups Legislatures Executives Bureaucracies courts. They are: Formal organizations engaged in political activities. Some structures, such as ruling military councils or governing royal families, are found in only a few countries. Similar structures may have very different functions across political systems. Ex: China and Britain

Political Systems: Structures and Functions Process functions Process functions: distinctive activities necessary for policy to be made and implemented in any kind of political system Interest articulation Interest articulation Involves individuals and groups expressing their needs and demands Interest aggregation Interest aggregation Combines different demands into policy proposals backed by significant political resources Policymaking Policymaking Decides which policy proposals are to become authoritative rules Policy implementation Policy implementation Carries out and enforces public policies; policy adjudication settles disputes about their application

Political Systems: Structures and Functions Three additional functions are fundamentally important which are not directly involved in making and implementing public policy :SocializationRecruitmentCommunication SYSTEM functions These are SYSTEM functions. They determine whether or not the system will be maintained or changed.

Political socialization Political socialization: involves families, schools, communications media, churches, and all the various political structures that develop, reinforce and transform the political culture, the attitudes of political significance in the society. Political recruitment Political recruitment: refers to the selection of people for political activity and government offices. Political communication Political communication: refers to the flow of information through the society and through the various structures that make up the political system.

Outputs: Outputs: the implementations of the political process. Substantive impacts on the society, the economy, and the culture. Regulation of behavior; extraction of resources; distribution of benefits and services. Reflect the way the policies interact with the domestic and international environments Example of structures and functions in Russia before and after the breakdown of communist rule in the Soviet Union. Approach: Approach: structural functional comparison Allows us to examine how the same functions are performed in different countries, or in the same country at two different points in time

Political Systems: Structures and Functions Process functions Process functions are performed by political structures. The structural-functional approach stresses two points: 1. In different countries, the same structure may perform different functions. 2. While a particular institution may have a special relationship to a particular function, institutions often do not have a monopoly on any one function. Ex: Presidents and governors may share in the policy- making function (veto powers), as do the higher courts (judicial review).

What do the differences in structure and function do for the interests, needs, and aspirations of people? policy level This is the policy level of the political system. policy performance We call the outputs of a political system (its extractions, distributions, regulations, and symbolic acts) its policy performance. Example: Input: American spending on education; more than any other people in the world. Output: U.S. children perform less well in subjects such as mathematics than do children in some other countries that spend substantially less. Outcome of public policy is never wholly in the hands of the people and their leaders. Evaluation: Assessing performance and outcomes

How We Explain describe explain Once we describe politics with the help of a conceptual framework, we then must explain it. Identifying the relationships between political phenomena. Ideally we want to put many political relationships in causal terms. Theories are statements about causal relationships between general classes of events. Ex: What causes democracy, war, or welfare policies? Scientific theories are always tentative; always subject to modification or falsification as our knowledge improves. Theories need to be testable. Good theory holds up after many trials. Good theory holds up after many trials.

Comparative analysis is a powerful and versatile tool. Enhances our ability to: Describe and understand political processes and change in a country by offering concepts and reference points from a broader perspective Also stimulates us to form general theories of political relationships Encourages and enables us to test our political theories by confronting them with the experience of many institutions and settings. Adapted from: Almond, Powell, Dalton & Strøm Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Longman © 2008