Prioritization Marc (presenting) Lina (facilitating) Roger, Frank, James, Penny, Rob, Franklin, Daniel, Grace A., Grace W., Ruth, Willy, Zo, Adriana, Harison,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Process – Resource Evaluation Design and perform a set of geographically based resource assessments Develop a methodology for prioritizing land according.
Advertisements

Status of Instream Flow Science in the Southeastern US Mary M. Davis, Ph.D., Technical Advisor Southern Instream Flow Network.
Incorporating Climate Change Adaptation into INRMPs: Case Study Detachment Fallbrook Dawn M. Lawson SPAWAR SSC Pacific Carolyn Enquist NPN Rob Wolf TDI.
Spiny bush (south) KBAs Prioritization Center for Biodiversity Consevation Conservation International Madagascar.
Key Biodiversity Areas Process Overview Center for Biodiversity Conservation Conservation International Madagascar.
LIVERPOOL’S ECOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK Jane Hayward – Liverpool City Council.
Biodiversity: Who cares?. Which is more diverse? A B.
Landscape Level Conservation Planning for prioritizing conservation action in Mozambique Bruno Nhancale, PhD Conservation Science workshop, 21 st April.
Key Biodiversity Areas: review and lessons learned workshop Five years of Key Biodiversity Areas Churchill Hotel, Washington DC 25 July 2006.
The Discovery Corridor Concept and its Applicability January 13/14, 2004 workshop St. Andrews Biological Station, St. Andrews, N.B.
Simon linke robert. l. pressey robert c. bailey richard h. norris the ecology centre university of queensland australia
Environment Sustainability : The Case for Papua New Guinea (PNG) Theresa Kamau Kas Program Director - Manus.
Future Research NeedsWorld Heritage and Climate Change World Heritage and Climate Change - Future Research Needs Bastian Bomhard World Heritage Officer.
Strengthening Marine Protected Areas to
Purposes of protected areas protect focal sp. / spp. –umbrella species protect biodiversity (spp. richness, endemism) protect large, functioning ecosystems.
Unit 8-Environmental Science Chapter 6.3-Biodiversity
10/10/2011 United Nations Environment Programme World Conservation Monitoring Centre PARCC West Africa Protected Areas Resilient to Climate Change in West.
Overview of existing marine assessments in Europe (North East Atlantic, Baltic Sea, Mediterranean and Black Seas) Frédéric Brochier UNESCO/IOC Consultant.
Biodiversity and Climate Change : considerations for development planning United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity.
US FOREST SERVICE REGIONAL ROUNDTABLE Planning Rule Revision Photographer: Bill Lea.
Review of the KBA process in Indo-Burma First iteration of KBAs identified by BirdLife International in collaboration with the Bird Society of Thailand,
National Reserve System and non-marine aquatic ecosystems Presented by: Tim Bond Science Coordinator National Reserve System Section.
Measuring Habitat and Biodiversity Outcomes Sara Vickerman and Frank Casey September 26, 2013 Defenders of Wildlife.
MANTADIA- ZAHAMENA. Deforestation across elevation  Between 1974 and 1994: around 90% of forest
TEEB Training Session 1: Conceptual Frameworks. TEEB Training A summary of some of the various different frameworks for assessing and valuing ecosystems.
1 SURF to Biodiversity 2020 Maria Tiefenbach Environment Agency Austria.
Presented by James Atherton (Conservation Outcomes Manager) KBA Review and Lessons Learned Workshop Washington DC July 25-28, 2006 Presented by James Atherton.
Presented by James Atherton (Conservation Outcomes Manager, CI Pacific Islands Program) KBA Review and Lessons Learned Workshop Washington DC July 25-28,
Survey Priorities Discussion Group Participants: Wang Hao, Cristiano, Megan, Wiggy, Curtis, Simon, Henni, Kristen, Naamal, Matt, Lisa, Leeanne, Tom L.
Bioregionalisation of the Southern Ocean – conservation applications & data needs Susie Grant British Antarctic Survey
Managing the Natura 2000 network: state of play, challenges and opportunities.
Engaging Partners: Challenges and Recommendations Working Group Members: Ruth, Franklin, Grace, Philip, Romy, Jatna, Bruce, Jess, Zoo, Cristiano, Naamal,
Conception for lands of high natural value – international agreements.
Characterization, Inventory and Monitoring of trends in indigenous livestock Dr. E. D. Ilatsia D. N. Kamiti 23-Oct-15Animal Breeding and Genomics Group1.
KBA Conservation Network Wanglang Nature Reserve, June 5-8, 2007.
High Conservation Values Forests of the European North of Russia Approaches to conservation and sustainable use Workshop Syktyvkar, 1 st April 2009
Overview of the KBA Process : A report card for Melanesia Insert representative image or map here Outcome definition for CI Melanesia through Moore- funded.
KBA meeting, Washington DC, July 2006 How much does the KBA process cost? Estimatives for the Brazilian KBA CI-Brazil.
Monitoring for Conservation Planning and Management Elizabeth Kennedy Conservation International 5-8 June 2007 Intervention Monitoring Exchange, Wang Lang.
CURRENT TOPICS Ms. Burakiewicz Conservation. Vocabulary Aquatic Biodiversity Conservation Coral Reef Ecosystem Extinction Endangered Forest Genetic variation.
Ecology - Conservation F Chapter 55 ~ Conservation Biology.
Conservation planning strategies at the landscape scale.
The current state-of-play – protected areas Existing protected areas are not sufficiently comprehensive or adequate to achieve conservation targets. The.
USAID Biodiversity Code Biodiversity Conservation in Agriculture Symposium Punta Cana, Dominican Republic May 31 - June 2, 2006.
and Landuse Change! Existing Landuse Possible Futures Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3 Possible Futures Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3 Projected Landuse.
Science requirements for implementing EBM Rob Stephenson DFO, St. Andrews Biological Station.
Discussion session on freshwater KBAs: a message to the Freshwater Institutional Team Monday afternoon Curtis, Willy, Joel, Henni, Frank, Luciano, Harison,
Identifying Species Targets at the Landscape/ Seascape Scale.
Global Symposium Round Table Session – 23 rd June, 2006 Status & trends in Madagascar’s biodiversity Zo Lalaina Rakotobe Conservation International.
Delineation Break-out Group A Wednesday, 26 th July 2006 Key Biodiversity Areas: review and lessons learned workshop James Atherton, Jerome Spaggiari,
A world where biodiversity counts Matt Walpole UNEP-WCMC Cambridge, UK.
What is biodiversity? 5.1 Biodiversity  Biodiversity is the variety of life in an area that is determined by the number of different species in that.
Measuring Conservation Outcomes for Biodiversity: Name Date Location An overview on monitoring the status of biodiversity and the Outcome Monitoring Program.
C ONSERVATION I NTERNATIONAL First Advisory Committee Meeting February 21, 2007 Regional Program Division (RPD) People, Protected Areas, and Conservation.
2017 EEA report “Climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction in Europe - Synergies for the knowledge base and policies” Rob Swart, Koen Kramer,
Key Biodiversity Areas: review and lessons learned workshop agenda development Setting the agenda for a meeting on five years of Key Biodiversity Areas.
CEPF Strategic Funding Direction 3 Meeting: 28 th June, 2006 Outcomes Monitoring: Status & trends in biodiversity Establishing standard regional monitoring.
Issues arising in KBA delineation 1) How do we delineate KBAs in a vast area of contiguous habitat when the area teems with threatened and irreplaceable.
Cost of KBA process Jessica D., Liza D., Joel G, Jaime GM, Frank H., David K., Francois M., Ricardo M., Yves P., José Vicente R., Jatna S., Romy T., Sebastian.
Key Biodiversity Areas: review and lessons learned workshop Aims and scope Churchill Hotel, Washington DC 25 July 2006.
Biology Chapter 5 Biological Diversity & Conservation.
Biodiversity and Climate Change United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity.
SRS Climate Change Project Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation Management Options.
An Examination of the Adequacy of South African Protected Areas Legislation in the Face of Climate Change Presented to the 8 th Colloquium of the IUCN.
Biological Diversity and Conservation
Mawdsley et al 2008 Kimberlee Ott ATOC 5000 April 10, 2017
Conversations on Climate with First Nations Communities in BC
Conception for lands of high natural value – international agreements
Conception for lands of high natural value – international agreements
Management of farmland in Natura 2000 Ideas for a first outline
Presentation transcript:

Prioritization Marc (presenting) Lina (facilitating) Roger, Frank, James, Penny, Rob, Franklin, Daniel, Grace A., Grace W., Ruth, Willy, Zo, Adriana, Harison, Luciano, Jerome, Russ

Objective  Review prioritization methods proposed in the guidelines manual and other methods tested to date, and discuss the challenges facing these  Develop a more comprehensive process for testing methods for the prioritization of conservation action among KBAs Ran out of time!

Process 1)Presentations on what has been done to date, and how, and key issues, from the Pacific, Philippines, and Madagascar 2)Update from CABS on current thinking 3)Wrote out issues 4)Classified issues 5)Discussed each class of issues

Framework for prioritization: objective is to minimize extinction 1)Biodiversity value: species vulnerability plus site irreplaceability 2)Then site vulnerability 3)Cost and opportunity High site vulnerability will increase priority for highly irreplaceable sites, but decrease priority for sites of low irreplaceability We focused on prioritization within regions (hotspots/high-biodiversity wilderness areas)

A couple of other considerations for biological value 1)Size of site because of the contribution of this to viability (NB: this may be captured in irreplaceability?) 2)Size of site because of contribution to ecological processes important for other KBAs 3)Taxonomic distinctiveness

Three sets of “issues” 1)Site vulnerability – current and future 2)Cost 3)Opportiunity

Site vulnerability Comprises: Impacts on KBAs Direct drivers Indirect drivers Site vulnerability: both current (this can be measured) and future (by determining relationships between current threat and drivers, this can be modeled; only necessary if non-linear relationship with current threat) Plus we pended consideration of aquatic specific threats (pollution, changes in hydrology)

Site vulnerability: impacts in KBAs GlobalRegional Habitat conversion X ExtractionX InvasivesX Drought & fireX

Site vulnerability: direct drivers GlobalRegional Population density, change, migration X InfrastructureX AccessibilityX

Site vulnerability: indirect drivers GlobalRegional GovernanceX Peace/warX Commodity prices X Climate changeX

Costs 1)Acquisition costs 2)Management costs These can be estimates using Bruner et al. type work using GNP, purchasing parity power, and site size 3) Opportunity costs (land suitability analysis, a la Brandon et al.)

Opportunity Checklist of non-extractive values (ecosystem services, carbon, hydrological, etc) This would be combined with extractive values (opportunity cost) to provide an overall estimate of opportunity + opportunity cost

What about existing conservation efforts and land tenure? Data are compiled as part of the KBA identification process These then guide actions in each sites E.g., if site is a protected area and a high priority, then site is a priority for continuing management If site is not a protected area but is a high priority, site is a priority for a new PA or other safeguard