Addressing Nature’s Water Needs The science, policy & politics of environmental flows Tony Maas Senior Policy Advisor WWF-Canada.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Sustaining Regional Partnerships for Conservation: Sharing the Future Joshua N. Collins San Francisco Estuary Institute
Advertisements

The Role of Government in Reducing the Impacts of Agriculture on Water Quality Trilateral Workshop on Water Quality Banff, Alberta October 22 nd to 24.
Marmot Creek Research Basin 50 th Anniversary Workshop March , 2013 John Diiwu Forest Management Branch Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource.
Status of Instream Flow Science in the Southeastern US Mary M. Davis, Ph.D., Technical Advisor Southern Instream Flow Network.
Alberta’s Strategy for Sustainability presented to Prairie Water Policy Symposium Beverly Yee, Assistant Deputy Minister Alberta Environment September.
© Mark Godfrey Brian Richter, Director Global Freshwater Program © Insert Image Credit Environmental Flows for People and Nature.
Trends, Obstacles, and Opportunities Affecting Instream Flow Issues by Tom Annear, Wyoming Game & Fish Department Nina Burkardt, U. S. Geological Survey.
Recommendations to Inform Development of a Climate Change Adaptation Strategy for the Lake Watershed Climate Change Adaptation Strategy for the Lake Simcoe.
Ramsar Convention on Wetlands ( Ramsar Convention on Wetlands ( Convention on Wetlands “The conservation and wise use of.
National Freshwater Ecosystem Priority Areas Project (NFEPA)
Sharing Benefits of Transboundary Waters through Cooperation David Grey The World Bank International Conference on Freshwater Bonn, 2001.
Towards a Human Dimensions Research Agenda for Parks and Protected Areas R.J. Payne & Norm McIntyre School of Outdoor Recreation, Parks & Tourism Lakehead.
Cedar River Instream Flow Management Balancing Certainty and Flexibility.
CSES Vision & Strategies by Edward L. Miles Bloedel Professor of Marine Studies and Public Affairs Adjunct Professor of Fisheries Senior Fellow & Co-Director.
Global public policy network on water management Water as a Cross-cutting Issue for CSD17 gppn.
Risk and Resilience: A Canadian Perspective on Climate Change Adaptation Donald S. Lemmen, PhD Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Directorate Natural.
1 Prairie Water Partnerships in Governance Prairie Water Policy Symposium International Institute for Sustainable Development September 2005, Winnipeg,
International Workshop on Institutional Capacity Development in Transboundary Basins, November 2008, Bonn, Germany Governance and Institutional Arrangements.
Problem Definition Exercise. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service General Summary Responses from ½ of those surveyed (n=14/31) Broad and narrow in scope Narrow.
1 Applying Sustainability Science Ian Lowe. 2 “Our present course is unsustainable - postponing action is no longer an option” - GEO 2000 [UNEP 1999]
Carolinas Integrated Sciences & Assessments (CISA) Work to Support NIDIS July 31 st – August 1 st, 2012 Wilmington, NC.
Introduction to the Session 6 - Theme 4 – on “Water Resources Management and Governance”
Thinking Like a Watershed - Ecological governance concepts, trends and applications A presentation by Oliver M. Brandes, Associate Director POLIS Project.
Welcome Global Water Trends Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (2005) Water withdrawals from rivers and lakes doubled since 1960; most water use (70% worldwide)
Knowledge on HIA IN CAMBODIA Constructing a Caring and Sharing Community Roles of HIA 4-6 October 2012 Bangkok.
SWRR on the Potomac Rhonda Kranz and John Wells Sustainable Water Resources Roundtable April 25, 2006 Measuring the Sustainability of Water Management.
Environmental flows in IWRM Mike Acreman. IWRM goals Economically efficient water use Assessments of supplies, sound allocation, efficient technologies.
The West Coast Governors’ Agreement on Ocean Health Jessica Hamilton Keys Natural Resources Policy Advisor Oregon Governor Ted Kulongoski Hydrographic.
Integrating environmental flows into water management to reduce social vulnerability - Learning from NeWater research in the lower Amudarya River Basin.
Small-scale fishing communities and climate change: A human rights perspective Chandrika Sharma International Collective in Support of Fishworkers Oceans.
A Decade of Working Together on Conservation & Sustainable Use of Canada’s Natural Assets CBS endorsed by FPT Ministers in April 1996 Federal, provincial,
Minnesota Water 2005 John R. Wells Minnesota Environmental Quality Board & Sustainable Water Resources Roundtable October 26, 2005 Measuring the Sustainability.
Who We Are What I Do Great Lakes Commission. Great Lakes Basin.
Alberta’s strategy for sustainability APEGGA February 17, 2004.
Kinge of Dremes MLIS Government Information Sources.
PP 4.1: IWRM Planning Framework. 2 Module Objective and Scope Participants acquire knowledge of the Principles of Good Basin Planning and can apply the.
Environmental & Recreational Impacts of Irrigation John Hayes.
Mohamed Bakarr Senior Environmental Specialist GEF Familiarization Seminar Washington, DC January 17 – 19, 2012 GEF Strategies, Activities and Accomplishment:
Implementation of critical studies necessary to promote better planning and efficient management of hydropower projects in an Int’l River Basin context.
Healthy Waters Magdalena River Basin Working Together towards Whole-River Solutions.
Prescribing Flows for the Potomac River Ecosystem: Six Recommendations Brian Richter The Nature Conservancy.
WISKI for Hydrologic Assessment Michael Seneka Water Policy Branch Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development.
WWF Greater Mekong Programme InVEST Seminar – April 2012 Ecosystem Services in the Greater Mekong Subregion.
Climate Change at Fisheries and Oceans Canada P olicy Framework Georges Lambert, Director, Strategic Planning, Policy Sector Northwest Atlantic Ocean Climate.
Setting Goals for Stream “Health:” The Next Generation of Watershed Plans? The Waterlands Group San Francisco Estuary Institute Aquatic Science Center.
Integrating Water Supply Management And Ecological Flow Requirements Mark P. Smith and Colin Apse The Nature Conservancy Richard M. Vogel and Stacey Archfield.
Sustainability Science in North America: towards ICSS 2012 ”Knowledge to Action for Sustainability” James Buizer Science Policy Advisor to the President,
Knowledge and research needs for wetlands and lakes IWRM presentation 18 November 2008 Johan Schutten Senior Wetland Ecologist SEPA.
Journey of Watershed Approach in India B. Pradhan Department of Land Resources Ministry of Rural Development Govt. of India B. Pradhan Department of Land.
2/19/ Fish Out of Water? Inter-sectoral Conflicts, Trade-offs and Synergies in Freshwater Resource and Coastal Zone Management.
Deerin Babb-Brott, Director National Ocean Council Office National Boating Federation 2013 Annual Meeting.
INTRODUCTION TO INTEGRATED WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT Module 1 Session 1.3: What is Integrated Water Resources Management?
Small-scale Fishers: Realizing Rights and Performing Duties Sebastian Mathew International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (ICSF) ASEAN/SEAFDEC/SIDA.
FLOWING FOREVER WWF-INDIA June 8, 2012
Lake Management in Alberta. Lake Issues ~2500 lakes in total with 800 fish-bearing lakes in Alberta Many lakes have changed due to Watershed alteration.
WWF and The Coca-Cola Company Partnership Overview April 2014.
 Has “Sustainability” Transformed Localized Models of Water Governance?
Improving Canadian Capacity for Predicting the Impacts of Natural and Human Disturbances on Boreal Water Resources Canadian Aquatic Laboratory for Interdiscplinary.
Investing in Ocean Health Presentation to Ocean Protection Council (February 2016) Sara Aminzadeh, Executive Director, California Coastkeeper Alliance.
WWF is working to embed environmental flow protection in BC’s New Water Sustainability Act Linda Nowlan WWF-Canada Vancouver, BC Environmental Flow Law.
Scarcity and BC’s Water Future – The Evolution of Western Water Law?
Sustainability and Challenges of the World Marine Fisheries
Erin O’Donnell, Avril Horne, Rebecca Tharme and Dustin Garrick
WATER POLICY And Management in AlabamA
Department of the Interior Northeast Climate Science Center
Hydropower and the WFD: constraint or opportunity?
Native Fish Conservation Areas Partnership Proposal
Angela H Arthington Australian Rivers Institute
16MN056 - Public Hearing August 26 to 29, 2019 Baker Lake, Nunavut
Erin O’Donnell, Avril Horne, Rebecca Tharme and Dustin Garrick
Presentation transcript:

Addressing Nature’s Water Needs The science, policy & politics of environmental flows Tony Maas Senior Policy Advisor WWF-Canada

“for any ecosystem function to be sustained, freshwater provides the foundation for the processes involved: a foundation that has largely been neglected in the past.” Falkenmark, 2003

Environmental Flows “the quantity, timing, and quality of water flows required to sustain freshwater and estuarine ecosystems and the human livelihoods and well-being that depend on these ecosystems.” Brisbane Declaration on Environmental Flows ©Garth Lenz/WWF-Canada

Renewable Water Supply Adapted from Postel, 2003 Understanding the problem Human Water Footprint Nature’s Water Needs Sustainability Boundary

Voice from the past: “Canadians have tended to undervalue instream uses in water management decisions....” (Federal Water Policy, 1987) years later Generally, decisions to expand cities... apportion water supplies…are made on a project-specific basis... Ecological instream flow needs and lake levels are often ignored or underestimated.” (Schindler & Donahue, 2006)

Evidence of Neglect Over-allocation Fish in the mud Canada dammed? 849 large; >10,000 total Hydropower resurgence Water-Energy nexus Socio-economic impacts Watershed equity WWF Living Planet Report 2006

Changing science Flow as “master variable” Magnitude, frequency, timing, duration, rate of change As many as 207 methodologies….it’s complex. Minimum thresholds Natural flow regime

A Governance Problem “It actually boils down to a value judgment of what we want our world to look like.” ( Instream Flow Council) So who decides and how?

Policy Federal No ‘national’ statement or policy on environmental flows Federal mechanisms - Fisheries Act, Migratory Birds Convention Act, SARA Provinces Ontario PTTW – increased attention to eco-needs Low Water Response –local drought response Alberta - Water for Life WCOs – protection of aquatic environment Conservation holdbacks – 10% on licence trade Crown reservations

Politics – the ‘buts’ Federal Limited action – jurisdictional wrangling Provinces Science  policy Reactive responses Discretionary decision-making Big question – How to say ‘stop’…who says it?

Strategies for success Send in the scientists Assessing environmental flows Setting limits through proactive planning Integrating science and policy Flexible institutional arrangements Adapting to climate change, new knowledge Progress on the ground Focus on priority places Protect Canada’s remaining free flowing rivers

Thank you