Nonlinear Dynamics of Vortices in 2D Keplerian Disks: High Resolution Numerical Simulations.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
P.W. Terry K.W. Smith University of Wisconsin-Madison Outline
Advertisements

3D Vortices in Stratified, Rotating, Shearing Protoplanetary Disks April 8, I PAM Workshop I: Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics Philip Marcus – UC Berkeley.
Proto-Planetary Disk and Planetary Formation
Wayne Schubert, Gabriel Williams, Richard Taft, Chris Slocum and Alex Gonzalez Dept. of Atmospheric Science Workshop on Tropical Dynamics and the MJO January.
Methanol maser polarization in W3(OH) Lisa Harvey-Smith Collaborators: Vlemmings, Cohen, Soria-Ruiz Joint Institute for VLBI in Europe.
Simulations of the core/SOL transition of a tokamak plasma Frederic Schwander,Ph. Ghendrih, Y. Sarazin IRFM/CEA Cadarache G. Ciraolo, E. Serre, L. Isoardi,
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks Phil Armitage Colorado.
Hurricanes and climate ATOC 4720 class22. Hurricanes Hurricanes intense rotational storm that develop in regions of very warm SST (typhoons in western.
Geostrophic Adjustment Recall winds adjust to mass for scales larger than L R and mass adjust to wind for scales smaller than L R. In mid-latitude squall.
Extrasolar Planets More that 500 extrasolar planets have been discovered In 46 planetary systems through radial velocity surveys, transit observations,
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks Phil Armitage Colorado.
The formation of stars and planets Day 3, Topic 1: Viscous accretion disks Lecture by: C.P. Dullemond.
Max P. Katz, Wayne G. Roberge, & Glenn E. Ciolek Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Department of Physics, Applied Physics and Astronomy.
Gravity Current Flow past a Circular Cylinder: Forces, Wall Shear Stresses and Implications for Scour E. Gonzalez-Juez and E. Meiburg (UCSB) T. Tokyay.
Ge/Ay133 How do small dust grains grow in protoplanetary disks?
Inertial particles in self- similar random flows Jérémie Bec CNRS, Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur, Nice Massimo Cencini Rafaela Hillerbrand.
An introduction to the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) Chia-chi Wang Dept. Atmospheric Sciences Chinese Culture University Acknowledgment: Prof.
Baroclinic Instability in the Denmark Strait Overflow and how it applies the material learned in this GFD course Emily Harrison James Mueller December.
Ge/Ay133 What effects do 1-10 M Earth cores & Jovian planets have on the surrounding disk? Or, … Migration & Gaps.
The Nature of Turbulence in Protoplanetary Disks Jeremy Goodman Princeton University “Astrophysics of Planetary Systems” Harvard.
Planet Driven Disk Evolution Roman Rafikov IAS. Outline Introduction - Planet-disk interaction - Basics of the density wave theory Density waves as drivers.
Intermittent Transport and Relaxation Oscillations of Nonlinear Reduced Models for Fusion Plasmas S. Hamaguchi, 1 K. Takeda, 2 A. Bierwage, 2 S. Tsurimaki,
The General Circulation of the Atmosphere Tapio Schneider.
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks
1 Hantao Ji Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory Experimentalist Laboratory astrophysics –Reconnection, angular momentum transport, dynamo effect… –Center.
Ge/Ay133 What effects do 1-10 M Earth cores have on the surrounding disk? Today = Gaps Wednesday = Migration (included here)
The Formation of Uranus and Neptune (and intermediate-mass planets) R. Helled Tel-Aviv University 1 Dec
Chalmers University of Technology The L-H transition on EAST Jan Weiland and C.S. Liu Chalmers University of Technoloy and EURATOM_VR Association, S
Type I Migration with Stochastic Torques Fred C. Adams & Anthony M. Bloch University of Michigan Fred C. Adams & Anthony M. Bloch University of Michigan.
F.M.H. Cheung School of Physics, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks Phil Armitage Colorado.
Kinetic Effects on the Linear and Nonlinear Stability Properties of Field- Reversed Configurations E. V. Belova PPPL 2003 APS DPP Meeting, October 2003.
Radiation Hydrodynamic simulations of super-Eddington Accretion Flows super-Eddington Accretion Flows Radiation Hydrodynamic simulations of super-Eddington.
Forming and Feeding Super-massive Black Holes in the Young Universe Wolfgang J. Duschl Institut für Theoretische Astrophysik Universität Heidelberg.
Flow Vorticity and Rotation in Peripheral HIC Dujuan Wang CBCOS, Wuhan, 11/05/2014 University of Bergen, Norway.
AS 4002 Star Formation & Plasma Astrophysics Supercritical clouds Rapid contraction. Fragmentation into subregions –Also supercritical if size R ≥ clump.
Alternative derivation of Sverdrup Relation Construct vorticity equation from geostrophic balance (1) (2)  Integrating over the whole ocean depth, we.
Large scale magnetic fields and Dynamo theory Roman Shcherbakov, Turbulence Discussion Group 14 Apr 2008.
11 Role of Non-resonant Modes in Zonal Flows and Intrinsic Rotation Generation Role of Non-resonant Modes in Zonal Flows and Intrinsic Rotation Generation.
BGU WISAP Spectral and Algebraic Instabilities in Thin Keplerian Disks: I – Linear Theory Edward Liverts Michael Mond Yuri Shtemler.
1 S. Davis, April 2004 A Beta-Viscosity Model for the Evolving Solar Nebula Sanford S Davis Workshop on Modeling the Structure, Chemistry, and Appearance.
Direct simulation of planetary and stellar dynamos II. Future challenges (maintenance of differential rotation) Gary A Glatzmaier University of California,
Initial Stages of Planet Formation in Protoplanetary Disks:
Examining Vortex Rossby Wave (VRW) dispersion relations with numerical experiments Ting-Chi Wu MPO673 Vortex Dynamics Project final report 2011/04/28.
Masahiro Machida (Kyoto Univ.) Shu-ichiro Inutsuka (Kyoto Univ.), Tomoaki Matsumoto (Hosei Univ.) Outflow jet first coreprotostar v~5 km/s v~50 km/s 360.
Numerical study of flow instability between two cylinders in 2D case V. V. Denisenko Institute for Aided Design RAS.
Gas-kineitc MHD Numerical Scheme and Its Applications to Solar Magneto-convection Tian Chunlin Beijing 2010.Dec.3.
Outflows from YSOs and Angular Momentum Transfer National Astronomical Observatory (NAOJ) Kohji Tomisaka.
The Solar Interior NSO Solar Physics Summer School Tamara Rogers, HAO June 14, 2007
Planetesimal dynamics in self-gravitating discs Giuseppe Lodato IoA - Cambridge.
Model and Data Hierarchies for Simulating and Understanding Climate Marco A. Giorgetta Demands on next generation dynamical solvers.
Turbulent Convection and Anomalous Cross-Field Transport in Mirror Plasmas V.P. Pastukhov and N.V. Chudin.
21st IAEA Fusion Energy Conf. Chengdu, China, Oct.16-21, /17 Gyrokinetic Theory and Simulation of Zonal Flows and Turbulence in Helical Systems T.-H.
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks Phil Armitage Colorado.
ANGULAR MOMENTUM TRANSPORT BY MAGNETOHYDRODYNAMIC TURBULENCE Gordon Ogilvie University of Cambridge TACHOCLINE DYNAMICS
1.Fundamental equations and concepts 2.Balanced flow and vortex motion 3.Waves 4.Instabilities 5.Nonlinear phenomena An Introduction to Geophysical Fluid.
A resolution of the magnetic braking catastrophe during the second collapse cc2yso UWO, May 17, 2010 – Wolf Dapp Wolf B. Dapp & Shantanu Basu.
Matthew J. Hoffman CEAFM/Burgers Symposium May 8, 2009 Johns Hopkins University Courtesy NOAA/AVHRR Courtesy NASA Earth Observatory.
T HE VORTICAL MECHANISM OF GENERATION & COLLIMATION OF THE ASTROPHYSICAL JETS M.G. A BRAHAMYAN Yerevan State University, Armenia.
Simulation of a self-propelled wake with small excess momentum in a stratified fluid Matthew de Stadler and Sutanu Sarkar University of California San.
Geostrophic adjustment
Convective instability of a decelerating relativistic shell: an origin of magnetic fields in the early afterglow phase? Amir Levinson, Tel Aviv University.
Spectral and Algebraic Instabilities in Thin Keplerian Disks: I – Linear Theory Edward Liverts Michael Mond Yuri Shtemler.
Dynamo action & MHD turbulence (in the ISM, hopefully…)
A Pulsational Mechanism for Producing Keplerian Disks around Rapidly Rotating Stars Steven R. Cranmer Harvard-Smithsonian CfA.
Planetesimal formation in self-gravitating accretion discs
Ge/Ay133 What effects do 1-10 MEarth cores
Geostrophic adjustment
Dust Flow in Disks in the presence of Embedded Planets
Rossby wave Instability in pp-discs
Presentation transcript:

Nonlinear Dynamics of Vortices in 2D Keplerian Disks: High Resolution Numerical Simulations

 Vortices in Protoplanetary Disks  Problem Parameters  Numerical Setup  Nonlinear Adjustment threshold, stability, adjustment time-scales resolution study, structure/spatial-scales, Pot. vorticity and density adjustments  Generation of Waves – Nonlin. Development  Summary  Open Issues

Vortices in Protoplanetary Disks Protoplanetary Disk: pressure supported { gas + dust + particles } Planet formation: Early stages – need for planetesimals Keplerian differential rotation – strong shear flow Long-lived vortices can promote the formation of planetesimals (von Weizacker 1944, Adams & Watkins 1995) Importance of the vorticity: Nonlinear dynamics

Vortices in Protoplanetary Disks Previous contributions: Bracco et al. 1998,1999 (incompress. Dust trapping) Godon & Livio 1999a,b,c (2D compress. Global, 128x128) Chavanis 2000 (dust capturing) Davis 2000,2002 (2D compress. Global,125x300) Johansen et al (dust in anticylones, local) Barranco & Marcus 2005 (3D spectral, local) Bodo et al (2D global. Linear waves)  High resolution global compressible 2D Numerical simulations of the small scale nonlinear vortex structures

Vortices in Protoplanetary Disks  Stability of anticyclonic vortices Detailed Quantitative Description  Development Time  Developed Vortex Size  Developed Vortex Structure  Wave Generation Aspects  Numerical Requirements

Problem Parameters: time-scales  Linear Perturbations: T(SD) ~ 1/  SD T(shear) ~ 4/3  0 -1 T(R)* ~ 1/  R Vortex dynamics: T(R)* >> T(shear) > T(SD)  Nonlinear Perturbations: T(nonlin) ~ (nonlinear adjustment / num. simulations) Vortex dynamics T(R)** >> T(nonlin.) > T(shear,SD) T(R)** > T(R)*

Problem Parameters: spatial-scales H – disk thickness r – disk radius at vortex L – vortex length-scale L R – Rossby length-scale L < L R :{T non /2  } (  0 L/r) 1/2 << 1 Thin disk model:H/r << 1 2D Perturbations: L > H Vortex in disk:L < L R L > H:L > C S /  0 L R >H: C S < r / (T non /2  ) 2 = r / N 2 ;

Numerical Setup PLUTO Polar grid – radially stretched Angular momentum conservation form; FARGO Outflow boundary conditions radially Resolution: (N R x N   N R = f(N ,R in R out )

Numerical Setup

Initial Conditions Circular vortex: a=b Elliptic vortex: a/b = q (aspect ratio)

Nonlinear Adjustment Transition from the initial unbalanced to the final nonlinear self-sustained configuration Initial Imbalance (amount of nonlinearity,  ) Spatial Scale (initial vortex size, a) Adjustment time (Resolution, Cs) long-lived self-sustained anticyclonic vortex nonlinear balance configuration

Threshold Value Amplitude of initial vortex - two nonlinear thresholds: 1.Linear case:  < Weakly nonlinear case, not sufficient for direct adjustment 0.1 <  < Strongly nonlinear case, direct adjustment to single vortex 0.25 < 

eps = 0.2 a = 0.1 res: (2000x733)

eps = 0.5 a = 0.1 res: (2000x733)

Vortex Stability  =0.5 a=0.1 res: (2000x733)

Vortex Stability  =0.5 a=0.1 res: (2000x733)

Adjustment Time Depends on the initial imbalance: a= revolutions a=0.14 revolutions a=0.26 revolutions Does not depends on the wave speed Cs = 10 -1,10 -2

Resolution Study 2000x x x1559

Vortex Structure Potential vorticity gradient is steepening, decreasing in size. Size of the final vortex: Cs =10 -2 a > 0.02 A ~ 0.02 Double core vortex structure: Adjustment of the potential vorticity (4) Adjustment of the mass (12) Different adjustment times scales?

Adjustment of Potential Vorticity

Double Core Vortex

Wave Generation and Development: SHOCKS? Parameters Cs = 10e-2 Eps = 0.5 Scale= x1559 Domain: [ ]

Wave Generation and Development: SHOCKS?

Summary Stability Long lived anticyclonic vortices: stability 80+ revolutions Initial amplitude threshold values: 0.1,0.25 Nonlinear Adjustment Depends on the initial scale, not on the SD wave speed Adjustment time: Pot. Vort. – 4 revolutions (steepening) Density – 15 revolutions (double core) Size of the final vortex decreases to certain value if initial vortex is oversized (0.02) Waves evolve into shocks (?) Requirements on the minimal resolution for global simulations

Open Issues Shocks? Do they dissipate faster then vortices? Momentum transport by waves/shocks Azimuthal diffusion – dense ring. Numerical? Slow drifting of the vortex. Numerical? (v2=1.003, rev:50)